Dave Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 (edited) I first posted this in the Debate Table, but then I began to think maybe I should've posted it here instead, as there's more of a chance of people responding. [quote]Anyone care to comment on this excerpt from a sermon given by the previous pastor of my parish? He basically says secular music of any and every kind is evil. [quote] Let’s focus on one of those gateways: the sense of hearing. Back in the 8th century, St. Bede the Venerable had this to say: “He who listens to evil tales, to licentious songs, to calumny or detraction, opens his ears and makes them the gate through which death enters the soul. That calumny, detraction, and evil tales existed in the 8th century probably surprises no one. But when it comes to licentious songs, we usually think of our own times rather than those of St. Bede some 1300 years ago. We think of Rock ‘n’ Roll and any number of its species: e.g., hard rock, punk, funk, grunge, gothic, heavy metal, rap, and new wave. The problems: sometimes the lyrics are bad (e.g., Imagine); sometimes the music is disordered but the lyrics are good (e.g., Christian rock); other times, both the lyrics and music are disordered (rap: degrades women) What do we mean by “bad” lyrics or disordered music? First, here’s what we don’t mean: By “bad” we don’t mean that the music is not attractive. On the contrary, rock musicians often do have a talent for melody: (Beatles, Led Zepelin (hypnotic), Billy Joel, Alabama, Yes, Rush, Doobie Brothers, Jethro Tull). Nor by “bad” do we mean cheap or superficial, vulgar or unrefined. To be sure, Rock ‘n’ Roll is cheap, superficial, often vulgar, and always unrefined—at least in comparison to Gregorian Chant, Palestrina, Vivaldi, Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, Chopin, Brahms, Mendelssohn, Mahler, Liszt, Bruckner, Debussy, Prokofiev, Gottchalk, Lecuona, Cervantes, and many others. Nevertheless, it’s no sin to be unrefined. Rock ‘n’ Roll in general is bad because it encourages the young and impressionable to feel good about rebellion against authority (esp. against parents); it lures listeners into the trap of illicit sexual activity. Worse still, a lot of rock music exposes the listener to the world of drugs, witchcraft and the occult. Other songs promote nihilism, a sense of despair, even suicide. That being the case, I don’t think I am being unfair to Rock ‘n’ Roll when I say that it opposes the True, the Good, and the Beautiful; that it does little to edify the soul and draw it closer to God. Now, a lot of young people always justify their musical tastes by saying something like this: “I don’t listen to the lyrics. I just like the beat.” (Imagine an early Christian going to the Roman Circus, saying, Don’t worry, St. Paul, I don’t clap when the Christians get ripped apart by the lions; I just love the excitement and frenzy of the crowd, the action.) The music is a vehicle for the words. Listen to the music long enough and you will begin to be formed not only by the music, but also by the ideas contained in the lyrics. (Nazi Germany). But even if the lyrics were wholesome, one should also consider the influence of the music itself. As I said earlier, it’s possible to have a decent piece of music and lousy lyrics (e.g., Imagine). But it’s also possible to have objectively bad music, regardless whether the lyrics are good or bad. In other words, music is not simply a matter of taste. . . How to determine the moral quality of music. Melody: idea, intellect. Harmony: pleasing order, makes chaos more revolting. Rhythm: energy, drive of music: it gives it motion, life. When used in the service of melody and harmony, you hardly notice it. But when rhythm becomes predominant in a piece, it stirs the passions. As to which passions, that may depend on the context: battlefield or nightclub. Music is disordered if it encourages the passions to rule over the reason, to act chaotically. Now, Rock ‘n’ Roll, at least in its earliest stages, was recognized to be just that kind of music. At least Alan Freed, the man who coined the term R&R back in 1954 and brought this form of music to the mainstream market, made the connection. Or so it would seem, considering his choice of terms. What R&R meant originally [was to have sex -- it was a popular slang phrase in the black community]. If it is true that R&R promotes rebellion, sexual immorality, violence against women, suicide, then it is not unreasonable to conclude that R&R promotes the agenda of Satan. If R&R promotes Satan’s agenda, then it’s fair to say that R&R (by and large) is diabolical. I realize this may seem shocking to many of you, even outrageous. In reply, all I can say is, don’t expect the devil to appear to you in person. The devil is far more subtle than that. He’ll take us out through our senses, through our flesh. So take St. Paul’s words to heart: “Be not deceived: God is not mocked. For what things a man shall sow, those also shall he reap. For he that soweth in his flesh, from the flesh also shall he reap corruption."[/quote] While I agree that some types of music are indeed bad and should be avoided ("gangsta" rap, a lot of -- maybe even most -- heavy metal, etc.), now I'm hearing the argument that rock music in general promotes evil things and that it's rhythm, melody, harmony, etc. result in negativity. Who wants to help me out here?[/quote] Edited June 16, 2006 by Dave
prose Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 I am in a different camp. I don't believe rock music promotes evil things any more than classical music does. I think that anywhere Satan can get his grubby claws into something and make it his is where the problem lies. I think rock music can be EXTREMELY uplifting. I can think of more than a few Christian rock bands that have helped me through hard times through their music. [quote]Music is disordered if it encourages the passions to rule over the reason, to act chaotically[/quote] I don't believe that all rock and roll does that. I also didn't get the impression that is what the priest was saying either. I think that he was saying that we, as Catholic christians need to be more aware of what we are hearing and what we are letting infiltrate into our everyday lives. I think he is insinuating that we need to be more vigilant about what we allow to bring us pleasure.
philothea Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 And I worked so long on my reply... maybe some kind mod can move it over here.
prose Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 Here it is... Phil's response: [quote] Anyone care to comment on this excerpt from a sermon given by the previous pastor of my parish? He basically says secular music of any and every kind is evil. While I agree that some types of music are indeed bad and should be avoided ("gangsta" rap, a lot of -- maybe even most -- heavy metal, etc.), now I'm hearing the argument that rock music in general promotes evil things and that it's rhythm, melody, harmony, etc. result in negativity. Who wants to help me out here?[/quote] I think your previous pastor is commenting on a culture of which he is ignorant, which... well, it makes people look stupid when they do that, and leads to a lot of false alarms and bizarre conclusions. [quote] But when it comes to licentious songs, we usually think of our own times rather than those of St. Bede some 1300 years ago.[/quote] Only people who don't know anything about history... or human nature. As far as I know, every culture has music. I bet the rowdy hunter or warrior types in every culture all have naughty songs too. I bet all teens everywhere experiment with new, shocking innovations. [quote] The problems: sometimes the lyrics are bad (e.g., Imagine); sometimes the music is disordered but the lyrics are good (e.g., Christian rock); other times, both the lyrics and music are disordered (rap: degrades women)[/quote] And.... sometimes the music and the lyrics are both good? Maybe? Sometimes even neutral or harmless, I bet! [quote] To be sure, Rock ‘n’ Roll is cheap, superficial, often vulgar, and always unrefined—at least in comparison to Gregorian Chant, Palestrina, Vivaldi, Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, Chopin, Brahms, Mendelssohn, Mahler, Liszt, Bruckner, Debussy, Prokofiev, Gottchalk, Lecuona, Cervantes, and many others. Nevertheless, it’s no sin to be unrefined.[/quote] Ooh, nice bias here. Actually, the creation of modern popular music takes vast amounts of work, technical skill, and engineering. "Unrefined" its not. It's so refined often the performers can't reproduce the released songs in a live performance anymore. "Informal" is the word he's looking for. Superficial and vulgar are in the ears of the listener. Cheap? Well, if I can get the iTune... [quote] Rock ‘n’ Roll in general is bad because it encourages the young and impressionable to feel good about rebellion against authority (esp. against parents); it lures listeners into the trap of illicit sexual activity.[/quote] Was this sermon given 50 years ago? Back then, he might have a point. Nowadays the parents are unlikely to be bastions of morality. (They listened to all that carp decades ago.) The last parental rebellion song I noticed dealt with "I don't want to be a superficial money-grubber like you..." Definitely, some of the pop and hip-hop "club" type songs are all about sex... but that whole culture is messed up. The song lyrics are just a symptom, and anyone with any kind of decent upbringing is either going to be unaffected by, or dislike, that stuff. [quote] Worse still, a lot of rock music exposes the listener to the world of drugs, witchcraft and the occult. Other songs promote nihilism, a sense of despair, even suicide. That being the case, I don’t think I am being unfair to Rock ‘n’ Roll when I say that it opposes the True, the Good, and the Beautiful; that it does little to edify the soul and draw it closer to God.[/quote] "A lot of rock music"? Not really. Television is worse. That satanism stuff hasn't been trendy for decades. Christian stuff is hot now! It's rebellious! :upsidedown: [quote] But it’s also possible to have objectively bad music, regardless whether the lyrics are good or bad. In other words, music is not simply a matter of taste. . .[/quote] On what is this based? It sounds like he's making it up. [quote] How to determine the moral quality of music. Melody: idea, intellect. Harmony: pleasing order, makes chaos more revolting. Rhythm: energy, drive of music: it gives it motion, life. When used in the service of melody and harmony, you hardly notice it. But when rhythm becomes predominant in a piece, it stirs the passions. As to which passions, that may depend on the context: battlefield or nightclub.[/quote] Music is disordered if it encourages the passions to rule over the reason, to act chaotically. Hm. By this standard I shouldn't listen to a choir sing Te Deum because it always makes me cry, no matter how much I try to reason myself out of that reaction. I don't see needing to avoid an emotional response is a good reason. Sounds like Aristotle to me, not Jesus. I agree with you, Dave -- some modern music should be avoided. This is true for all modern art forms: some books, some movies, some TV, some games, some websites. The power of music to directly influence emotions is, indeed, something to consider (as is the hypnotic qualitiy of moving images, or the lasting influence of printed words). I have broad musical tastes. I search out and buy lots of new music. I have no trouble finding more good, positive, inspiring songs than I can afford to buy...
Era Might Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 (edited) Film can do everything mentioned in that article, and the Holy See still encourages the use of film, and even has its own list of greatest films. I won't even address his opinions about "rap", because he has no idea what he's talking about. Which is fine, but I'm still gonna laugh. Edited June 16, 2006 by Era Might
Domine ut Videam Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 (edited) Wow........ He should come to our group at school, called Communio. We have praise and worship sessions where we sing some Beatles songs. Let me get a list of the secular songs........ Fire and Rain Help! Hey Jude Let it Be Sweet Home Alabama We Can Work it Out With or Without You You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away Those are just some of them.....but it is about seeing God and praising Him in everything. He wasnts to be a part of our lives. Singing secular songs is actually something that we have picked up from Communion Liberation and GS but i think it is a great idea! -Yours in Christ Lauren Edited June 16, 2006 by Domine ut Videam
journeyman Posted June 17, 2006 Posted June 17, 2006 I heard one non-Catholic theologian argue the badness was due to rock's appeal to the physical senses, so even if the lyrics were good, they were overcome by the beat which sort of ties in with one of the scriptural passages about eschewing the pleasures of the flesh
Era Might Posted June 17, 2006 Posted June 17, 2006 The problem is, that's painting with pretty broad strokes. Stevie Wonder would be considered "Rock n' Roll", but the only thing I feel when I listen to Stevie Wonder is joy. It's like saying "film" displays sin. Well, yah it displays sin, but there's a good way and a bad way to do so, just as there are good and bad ways to affect emotions with music. Gregorian chant sometimes overwhelms me with the power of the chant itself that I don't even think about the words. But that is a good thing.
Loyola Posted June 17, 2006 Posted June 17, 2006 This is a great topic. Five years ago I threw all of my "alternative/rock" CDs away, because I thought that God wouldn't want me to waste my life with them. I kept only my Classical and a very few of my Christian CDs. I have since "rebuilt" my collection. I struggle with this daily. Sometimes I feel I have too much "pleasure" from my material items, and I just want to throw them all away. Most times I enjoy them and just say the heck with it. I really love music, and I can't see myself without a good variety of albums. There is one band though that I will never support or listen to. I will not name them, but they sooo have the devil on their side. It was hard giving them up eventhough I knew something was awry. They made great melodies.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now