Chica_Catolica Posted June 18, 2006 Posted June 18, 2006 I know that this has probably been asked before, but either I wasn't paying attention or it was before my phatmass days. Anyway, a friend of mine sent me an email, and what I've written to her hasn't helped clear it up, so I'm hoping that someone else has a better explanation. Here's the part of the email I'm talking about: "i mean, i know that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are all one and not three separate beings, but i guess i have trouble with the Father and Son part. it says that God sent His only Son, which makes it sound like two separates. and Jesus prays to God, on specific occasion the night before His crucifixion and then during it. that seems to me like two separates as well. so i just struggle with that bit. cuz if Jesus is God, why would He pray to God as if God were separate from Him? so i dunno. that's what i'm struggling with regarding the Trinity. i know they're all one being, they're all God, but it's hard for my brain to grasp." If anyone has anything to offer, I appreciate it!
ReinnieR Posted June 18, 2006 Posted June 18, 2006 [quote name='Chica_Catolica' post='1007660' date='Jun 18 2006, 05:53 AM'] I know that this has probably been asked before, but either I wasn't paying attention or it was before my phatmass days. Anyway, a friend of mine sent me an email, and what I've written to her hasn't helped clear it up, so I'm hoping that someone else has a better explanation. Here's the part of the email I'm talking about: "i mean, i know that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are all one and not three separate beings, but i guess i have trouble with the Father and Son part. it says that God sent His only Son, which makes it sound like two separates. and Jesus prays to God, on specific occasion the night before His crucifixion and then during it. that seems to me like two separates as well. so i just struggle with that bit. cuz if Jesus is God, why would He pray to God as if God were separate from Him? so i dunno. that's what i'm struggling with regarding the Trinity. i know they're all one being, they're all God, but it's hard for my brain to grasp." If anyone has anything to offer, I appreciate it! [/quote] it's because God is beyond human comprehension. how is it possible that Jesus is one in being with the father? we don't know. why do we believe because of faith [quote name='phatcatholic' post='1005321' date='Jun 13 2006, 10:53 PM'] we all struggle with the mysteries of Christianity. it is only "by grace through faith" (Eph 2:8) that we are able to believe in the Incarnation and in the divinity of Christ. so, we should not be so quick to judge them as "stupid" or "ridiculous." note also that, as Catholics, we stand on the shoulders of giants. they do not have the benefit of 2,000 years of Tradition, like we do. [/quote]
Quietfire Posted June 18, 2006 Posted June 18, 2006 As far as Jesus praying to the Father in the Garden and on the Cross... and basically the question is...."How can God pray to God?" Well, first off...Jesus has two natures. One completely devine. One completely human. When I say completely, I do mean completely. There is nothing lacking in either nature. He is man complete. Everything man can do, he can do. All the emotions, all the abilities and so forth. He is God complete. Everything God can do, he can do. After all, the Trinity is not 3 Gods, but One God in three persons. The very nature of God exists in all three persons of the Trinity, not in 3 parts but completely full in three persons. Each person possesses the Devine nature completely. Jesus in the garden and on the cross is, in fact, praying to the Father, in his complete human nature. As humans we all know that there is One who created us, and that is that nature of Jesus who is praying. He is not praying to Himself, his human nature is praying to the very God who created him. Gee, I hope I explained that correctly. If not, someone help me out. I know what Im trying to say, but Im not sure if its sounding right.
mortify Posted June 19, 2006 Posted June 19, 2006 Peace Chica, Its because God is three Persons, and these three Persons are truly distinct from one another [u]in relation to eachother[/u]. Meaning, they are not distinct in terms of essence, like the Father is something different from the Son. They are distinct in the sense that the Son proceeds from the Father, where as the Father does not proceed. Am I making sense? I don't know what you mean by separate, but they are separate in the sense that the Son was on the Cross and not the Father. Only the Son felt the agonies associated with the Crucifixion. So since God is known in Three Persons, the Person of Christ can pray to the Person of the Father. Now one may ask, if the Son is God why would He need to pray to the Father? With this we have to remember that Christ took on the role of a servant. He closed His eyes, so to speak but was not blind. He certainly had the ability to fulfill His prayers but chose not to, why? Because He embodied humility, came to serve the Father, and served as a model for us all. "In your relationships with one another, have the same attitude of mind Christ Jesus had: 6 Who, being in very nature [a] God, did not consider equality with God something to be used to his own advantage; 7 rather, he made himself nothing by taking the very nature [b] of a servant, being made in human likeness. 8 And being found in appearance as a human being, he humbled himself by becoming obedient to death— even death on a cross! 9 Therefore God exalted him to the highest place and gave him the name that is above every name, 10 that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, 11 and every tongue acknowledge that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father. (Philippians 2:5-11)
chris Posted June 19, 2006 Posted June 19, 2006 [quote]Well, first off...Jesus has two natures. One completely devine. One completely human. When I say completely, I do mean completely. There is nothing lacking in either nature. [/quote] Exactly, in the Nicean Creed which is spoken in Mass it says that Christ was fully God and Fully man. So there was a human aspect also in Garden of Gethsemene. God is beyond our recognition. Beyond any and all logic. The only way he has made himself known to us is through Christ, The Church, and the Holy Gospels. The crux of the whole matter is exactly what ReinnieR said...Faith.
KatS Posted June 19, 2006 Posted June 19, 2006 [quote]Exactly, in the Nicean Creed which is spoken in Mass it says that Christ was fully God and Fully man. So there was a human aspect also in Garden of Gethsemene.[/quote] This is why he was so distraught and sweat blood, and he begged his disciples to stay awake with him. I'm unfamiliar with many parts of the Bible and I may need correction, but I also thought that it was his human nature who was suffering so badly, and so that is why Jesus prayed to the Father.
chris Posted June 19, 2006 Posted June 19, 2006 [quote] This is why he was so distraught and sweat blood, and he begged his disciples to stay awake with him. [/quote] He did this because his human side was afraid of dying. But his God side knew why he had come. Remeber the sweat that was as if great drops of blood?
KatS Posted June 19, 2006 Posted June 19, 2006 [quote]He did this because his human side was afraid of dying.[/quote] Yes, exactly. This is what I meant even though I didn't type it out explicitly. I've heard scientists say that under extreme stress a person can sweat blood. This demonstrates just the sheer amount of terror Jesus was experiencing in the Garden of Gethsemene. [quote]Remeber the sweat that was as if great drops of blood?[/quote] Very enlightening point about His drops of blood as a precusor to His crucifixion. However I have hijacked this thread speaking specifically about the Agony in the Garden; I'm certain some more Phatmassers will get the thread back on track!
Quietfire Posted June 19, 2006 Posted June 19, 2006 I also wish to quickly add that Our Lord was carrying the weight of mankind's sins on his shoulders, and went to the cross. Not one of us will ever understand pressure compared to His sacrifice for us.
Seven77 Posted June 20, 2006 Posted June 20, 2006 Chica, all the great responses that everyone gave can be found in the [url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1574557203/sr=8-1/qid=1150837047/ref=pd_bbs_1/102-3137478-2344961?%5Fencoding=UTF8"]Compendium of the Catechism of the Catholic Church[/url] if you want, you can check it out in Spanish right now (im taking a wild guess that you speak Spanish): [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_sp.html"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/compendium_c...ium-ccc_sp.html[/url]
phatcatholic Posted June 20, 2006 Posted June 20, 2006 i wish they had it translated into english....
ReinnieR Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 [quote name='Seven77' post='1009218' date='Jun 20 2006, 03:02 PM'] Chica, all the great responses that everyone gave can be found in the [url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1574557203/sr=8-1/qid=1150837047/ref=pd_bbs_1/102-3137478-2344961?%5Fencoding=UTF8"]Compendium of the Catechism of the Catholic Church[/url] if you want, you can check it out in Spanish right now (im taking a wild guess that you speak Spanish): [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_sp.html"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/compendium_c...ium-ccc_sp.html[/url] [/quote] when i clicked the CCCC amazon link it told me that i had already purchased it on the 30th of March 06 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='1009288' date='Jun 20 2006, 04:39 PM'] i wish they had it translated into english.... [/quote] i know right
phatcatholic Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 [quote name='ReinnieR' post='1009359' date='Jun 20 2006, 08:27 PM'] when i clicked the CCCC amazon link it told me that i had already purchased it on the 30th of March 06 i know right [/quote] ahh well, u should get it here anyway [url="http://www.allcatholicbooks.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=ACB&Product_Code=AG25xw8&Category_Code="]http://www.allcatholicbooks.com/Merchant2/...&Category_Code=[/url]
ReinnieR Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='1009364' date='Jun 20 2006, 07:29 PM'] ahh well, u should get it here anyway [url="http://www.allcatholicbooks.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=ACB&Product_Code=AG25xw8&Category_Code="]http://www.allcatholicbooks.com/Merchant2/...&Category_Code=[/url] [/quote] sorry i already have it
Slave_of_the_Trinity Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 I think the Secret in a sense of the Trinity is that there is a seperation of beings but The Trinity share one Divine Nature bound together by Love! In the Theology of the Body, JP the Great says that the Trinity is a union of Love, The Father is the Giver of Love, while the Son is the One Who recieves that Love being the Beloved of the Father. Since that Love is so Strong it forms a Divine Person, the Love Flowing between the Father and the Son is the Holy Spirit. Now the Mystery of the Trinity goes further... to the very point where God the Creator becomes Man, a mere creature. As it was said before, Christ was indeed 100% percent man and 100% God. Because of this as said before, Christ' humanity was crying out the Father, It's very Creator for assistance and deliverance. This shows in itself that Christ was INDEED 100% man. Because Christ overcame this temptation to quit He has shown us that obviously His Divinity is much stronger that His Humanity. But His Humanity still needed the consolation of reaching out to the Creator. I hope that made sense, it is kinda late so i donno if it did or not.... As deep as this is the Mystery of the Trinity is even more difficult to grasp when God goes further than become a mere creature...when He becomes the Food of His creatures!
Slave_of_the_Trinity Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 (edited) i posted it too many times so i have to fill this sry! Edited June 21, 2006 by Slave_of_the_Trinity
Slave_of_the_Trinity Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 (edited) Edited June 21, 2006 by Slave_of_the_Trinity
Mateo el Feo Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 [quote name='Slave_of_the_Trinity' post='1009416' date='Jun 20 2006, 10:00 PM'] I think the Secret in a sense of the Trinity is that there is a seperation of beings but The Trinity share one Divine Nature bound together by Love![/quote]I wanted to make a small comment/correction on your post. The proper term to descibe the distinctions of the members of the Trinity is "persons." Using the phrase "separation of beings" is inappropriate. This is obvious when we look at the Creed, which says that Our Lord is "one in being with the Father."
Mateo el Feo Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 [quote name='Chica_Catolica' post='1007660' date='Jun 18 2006, 06:53 AM'] I know that this has probably been asked before, but either I wasn't paying attention or it was before my phatmass days. Anyway, a friend of mine sent me an email, and what I've written to her hasn't helped clear it up, so I'm hoping that someone else has a better explanation. Here's the part of the email I'm talking about: "i mean, i know that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are all one and not three separate beings, but i guess i have trouble with the Father and Son part. it says that God sent His only Son, which makes it sound like two separates. and Jesus prays to God, on specific occasion the night before His crucifixion and then during it. that seems to me like two separates as well. so i just struggle with that bit. cuz if Jesus is God, why would He pray to God as if God were separate from Him? so i dunno. that's what i'm struggling with regarding the Trinity. i know they're all one being, they're all God, but it's hard for my brain to grasp." If anyone has anything to offer, I appreciate it![/quote] Hola Chica, I think this is such a wonderful topic you bring up. Others have written quite well on the subject, but I wanted to add my two cents. There are plenty of valuable resources for pondering the Trinity, but if your friend says, "it's hard for my brain to grasp," the simple answer to this is: your brain won't grasp this. Though the dogma is not [i]contrary [/i] to reason, it cannot be [i]proven [/i] by reason. It is an article of faith, revealed to us by God. Paraphrasing the Scriptures, "the foolishness of God is higher than the wisdom of man." So, don't worry about a "proof" of the Trinity. I've found that--although God cannot be fully understood--we can use His creation to find parallels that might help us penetrate (just a little) the mystery of the Trinity. For example, your friend comments:[quote]i mean, i know that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are all one and not three separate beings, but i guess i have trouble with the Father and Son part. it says that God sent His only Son, which makes it sound like two separates.[/quote]I would respond to this by finding a parallel to better understand this truth. First, I'll reword the phrase from "God sent His only Son" to "The Son proceeds from the Father." Now, the comparison: a spoken word coming from sound (*). The spoken word and sound are the same "thing," yet we can still understand that the "word proceeds from the sound." In the same way, God's Word (the Son) proceeds from God (the Father). In the case of the word, the "procession" of sound-to-word occurs in an instant. The Son proceeds from the Father in the "instant" of eternity. There are a million more parallels, but I'll just leave it at that. (*) Note: St. Augustine discusses words proceeding from sound in his Confessions, but he was discussing something different ([url="http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/basis/confessions-bod.html#14.3"]see this link for more info[/url]).
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now