Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Studying Scientology


Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

Outside of Wikipedia and a Rolling Stones article I have no idea where to turn to learn about Scientology. Could someone point me in the right direction?

Posted (edited)

Hi Hughey,

you could try this link on Beliefnet.com. I hope it works...

[url="http://www.beliefnet.com/index/index_10042.asp"]Scientology on Beliefnet.com[/url]

Edited by KatS
Posted (edited)

Funny, I just looked this up a couple of weeks ago

I would recommend trying to read Dianetics ( :blink: ) and the Church of Scientology published a book called "What Is Scientology" (I haven't read that one yet). Neither of these is going to get into the really weird stuff like the aliens, etc., but they do get into engrams, reactive memory, and other pseudo-psychobabble.

The official site is www.scientology.org

Other sites to check out.

[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology[/url] (obviously, this is the wikipedia entry on Scientology. While wikipedia isn’t always the most reliable source, this series of entries appears to be a fairly extensive and more-or-less objective presentation on Scientology and related issues. It is well documented and cited, so you might be able to find some useful books and articles from the endnotes.)

www.xenu.net (Operation Clambake, This is the most popular/extensive anti-Scientology website. Written and maintained by an atheist in Norway, it has a lot of information and some documents that are not generally available to the public.)

Rick Ross has some great background articles:
[url="http://www.rickross.com/groups/scientology.html"]http://www.rickross.com/groups/scientology.html[/url]

A friend of mine especially recommends the Penthouse interview with Hubbard's son:
[url="http://rickross.com/reference/scientology/scien269.html"]http://rickross.com/reference/scientology/scien269.html[/url]

Other anti-Scientology websites which include information on Scientology, news about Scientology, lists of celebrity Scientologists, and stories from former Scientologists:

www.scientology-lies.com
www.scientology-kills.com

Edited by p0lar_bear
franciscanheart
Posted
:blink: that was fast... thanks! ^_^
Posted

that Penthouse interview is a little scary.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I recall reading parts of their "catechism" on their website one time.

Posted (edited)

That was probably the book "What is Scientology?" It can be accessed online at [url="http://www.whatisscientology.org"]www.whatisscientology.org [/url]

Edited by p0lar_bear
Posted

You can say that again!

"He told me and a lot of other people that the way to make a million was to start a religion."

This is a big contrast to our Lord, who spent most of His life - no, He was poor ALL His life - impoverished and dependent on the help and hospitality of his followers.

phatcatholic
Posted

here are a couple short articles on scientology from the "Dragnet" section of a couple issues of [i]This Rock[/i]:

[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1990/9010drag.asp"][b][i]This Rock[/i]: Dragnet[/b][/url] (1990)[list]Scientologists are a clever lot. Whatever else you may think of them, give them credit for marketing savvy. The Church of Scientology has been placing a full-color insert (16 oversized pages) in newspapers such as the Los Angeles Times, and the insert is attractive and has been noticed. It praises Scientology and its founder, L. Ron Hubbard.

The insert asks if there is a solution to today's woes, particularly drugs, stress, and violence. "YES: SCIENTOLOGY IS THE SOLUTION." For proof, just look at the bar chart to see what Scientology can do for you. "Made me much happier": 64 percent. "Enabled me to help others better": 80 percent. "Improved my life": 89 percent. Above the chart are photographs of a smiling young couple, a pair of middle-aged joggers (also smiling), a junior executive being congratulated by his colleagues (all smiling), and a performing artist (not smiling).

What does Scientology do and teach? "The Church provides individual counseling called auditing. . . . Scientology auditing takes up areas of a person's life that he is having trouble with or that he is confused about and relieves the upset and trauma associated with them, restoring happiness and lost abilities. . . . Auditing is the only workable solution which allows one to reach full spiritual freedom."

The auditing process uses what's called an E-Meter. "The E-Meter does not diagnose or cure anything, but is a religious artifact used by Scientology ministers to assist in locating specifically what to address in auditing. It is the only instrument that can accurately measure thought."

The E-Meter looks not unlike a young child's toy airplane cockpit. It's made of plastic and has fold-out legs so it can stand before you at a sharp angle. On the face are several knobs, three digital read-outs, and a needle indicator. To make it work, you sit with an auditor, who watches the indicators while you clasp two metal cylinders which look suspiciously like tin cans. You're asked questions, and the cylinders pick up certain signals from your body. These are displayed on the E-Meter and guide the auditor in counseling you.

Auditing can be great fun, apparently. (A photograph shows a man and women sitting across from one another. She's making notes about what the E-Meter says. He's holding the cylinders and laughing.) Auditing also can be expensive--very expensive.

To reach "clear," the state in which your problems have been identified and removed, requires a lengthy series of auditing sessions, some of which are grotesquely expensive. It's not uncommon to hear about Scientologists who have mortgaged their homes and spent tens of thousands of dollars on auditing sessions. The deeper they get into debt, the less reason they have to leave Scientology. After all, they've made such a giant investment.

The principles (or, depending on your point of view, gimmicks) of Scientology were "discovered" by the late L. Ron Hubbard, who outlined them in Dianetics. You've probably seen the television ads for the book, which is claimed to be a best seller--which is true, but there's a twist to the story.

Non-Scientologists don't seem to buy Dianetics. Those few who do buy it don't seem to read it. Most of the purchasers are Scientologists assigned to visit book stores regularly. Their marching orders: buy, buy, buy. Some Scientologists have closets full of Dianetics. Some purchase every copy a book store has.

How are the books getting onto the shelves in the first place? Through sweetheart deals with the book stores. Most publishers give retailers a 40 percent discount off the list price. From this the stores pay their overhead and make their profit. The Church of Scientology gives a far steeper discount, and it "guarantees" sales. (The book stores don't have to worry about "returns," unsold copies.)

This means a fantastic profit for the stores, which, in the industry custom, then report that Dianetics is moving fast. This means Dianetics gets listed on the all-time best-seller lists. And that, in a roundabout way, is how Scientology is "proved" to be true.

After all, the book wouldn't be selling out if the public weren't interested in Scientology, right? And people wouldn't be interested in Scientology unless it were true, right?

Many folks think that makes sense--but not as many as the Church of Scientology would like you to think. No matter how slick its promotional pieces or how ubiquitous its books, the Church of Scientology has few members.

Here is what it claims: "In just over 35 years, the Church of Scientology has grown from one church in the United States to over 700 churches, missions, and groups in more than 65 countries around the world. As the fastest growing religion in the world, it has millions of members on six continents."

This claim is undercut two ways. The insert in the Los Angeles Times lists Scientology churches--41 in the United States, others in Canada, the United Kingdom, even in Zimbabwe and South Africa. In all, 72 churches. But are all of these really churches? The one in San Diego is in an office building downtown. Presumably others are mere storefronts. Perhaps these are what Scientology terms "missions" or "groups." No matter how you add up the floor space, you can't squeeze "millions" of Scientologists into these places.

There's another reason to think the claim of millions of members is advertising puffery. The insert claims that last year 10 million hours of auditing were given. If there are just one million Scientologists in the world, that would be an average of ten hours of auditing for each.

But auditing is the sacrament of Scientology. Without auditing, Scientology ceases. Does it make sense to say each Scientologist spends only ten hours a year auditing? No, especially when you factor in that many of them spend thousands of dollars yearly for auditing sessions.

Assume a modest 200 hours yearly spent in auditing. That works out to 50,000 Scientologists. And if the figure of 10 million auditing hours is inflated (which it probably is, considering the Church's book store scam), then there are even fewer Scientologists.

Is Scientology dangerous? Not as dangerous as some think. It's too silly to be really dangerous. (E-Meters look like toy surprises you'd expect to find in super-giant-sized boxes of Cracker Jacks.) The Church has been in trouble with the IRS, which says it really isn't a church at all. Be that as it may, Scientology is known only because it advertises itself and its founder, not because the masses are streaming into it.

Scientology attracts a certain crowd: mainly young, professional, on the way up the corporate ladder--people who admit they have problems but who seek the solution in technology, not faith. A disproportionate number of Scientologists are avid science fiction fans. (Hubbard wrote science fiction stories--we mean other than Dianetics.)

The folks who are attracted to Scientology seem to consider themselves special, forward-looking, avant garde. Scientology has a certain cachet. It's new, it's fun, and you can spend your way into thinking it works. But don't expect it to be around in a few more decades.
[/list][url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1991/9109ltrs.asp"][b][i]This Rock[/i]: Letters[/b][/url] (1991)[list]I WAS GLAD to see This Rock run a critique of the Scientologists. But don’t underestimate them because their cult is so silly--those guys have lots of money behind them, and they play rough.

Russell Miller’s excellent biography of Scientology’s founder, L. Ron Hubbard: Bare-Faced Messiah, is the book to get, if you can find a copy that the Scientologists haven’t destroyed.

Sandra Miesel
Indianapolis, Indiana
[/list][url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1994/9403drag.asp"][b][i]This Rock[/i]: Dragnet[/b][/url] (1994)[list]Chief among the bizarre doctrines of the "Church" of Scientology is the belief that all human beings are embodied spirits called "Thetans." The goal of the Scientologist is to release his Thetan from the layers of spiritual and psychological crud with which all humanity is covered (analogous in a way to original sin), reaching what is know as the state of "clear."

After reaching clear the Scientologist works toward becoming an "OT"--an "Operating Thetan." Through study and application he moves through different levels of OT, gaining wisdom and prowess with each. This progress does not come cheaply. Scientologists routinely pay tens of thousands of dollars to enroll in OT training sessions. But they say it's worthwhile: Operating Thetans gain new powers, as the "OT Phenomena" section of the Scientologist magazine Advance reveals:

"There's a certain feeling about `being in charge' of the universe when you hike up The Bridge [the hierarchy of OT levels] grade chart. When I'm 20 miles from home on a bike and the rain begins to pour, it's a good feeling to have. Pour, pour. Intend, intend. Drizzle, drizzle. Intend, intend! Drip, drip--dry. I always seem to get clear sky. After all, I found out, I'm really in charge here" ("M.G.," issue 89, 1986).

"I was driving home a day or so after finishing OT III Expanded [one of the middle levels on the OT scale]. I suddenly had an urge to go to the store and get cigarettes. Now I don't smoke, but I got some for my husband. When I walked in the door I just handed him the cigarettes and he said `thanks' and then walked off. He stopped a couple of feet away and said, `How did you know?' My only reply was a smile. This is a wonderful level to operate from" ("C.B.," issue 52, 1978).

We hate to break this to C.B., but it doesn't take thousands of dollars' worth of pseudo-scientific training to determine that a smoker with whom you've been living for years might want some cigarettes.

"I was working on a Hollywood movie set. There were 700 extras and a lot of randomity [sic]. We had been shooting for 72 hours with no sleep and we were running on pure drive to complete the film. About two a.m. one night I was running in the rain across the lot. All of a sudden I heard a screech of tires and looked up and saw the headlights of a truck in my face. People were yelling. In an instant I rolled back time and the truck was three feet back where it had been, and I leapt across to the other side of the driveway. The person standing there said, `Oh, my God! What happened? You were dead!' The driver of the truck was stark white and said, `What did you do? I was right on top of you!' He was completely stunned" ("C.W.," issue 115, 1993).

That's a fascinating talent you have, C.W. When you have a little spare time, would you please "roll back" the Johnstown Flood or maybe the Reformation? By the way, are you aware that your account seems to be a reprint of one from a "C.C.," who wrote in issue 93 in 1987? Perhaps being an OT doesn't help one's memory, eh?

"I was driving across a bridge one day, exterior [as a Thetan separated from his body], maybe 30 feet above my car, when I felt a lot of mass piling up around my body's head. This struck me as rather odd, since it wasn't there a minute ago and I didn't recall putting anything there. I got down around my head, and intending awareness here and there I discovered that there was a being trying to pick up my body. He thought it was up for grabs since he didn't see anyone in it. I got in comm [communication] with him, saw the exact nature of his upset, and handled that exactly with standard tech [application of Scientology]. The mass blew, and the being keyed out. I told him that the name of the technology that freed him was Scientology and advised him to pick up a new body and find out about it. He acknowledged me and left" ("S.S.", issue 89, 1986).
[/list][url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1995/9504drag.asp"][b][i]This Rock[/i]: Dragnet[/b][/url] (1995)[list]We downloaded this "insider's account" of Scientology from an online forum dedicated to exposing the cult. The author is Patrick Jost:

My father was in advertising, and had heavy "show business" connections. I dabbled in the music business when I was doing graduate work at UCLA. A "celebrity" friend of the family had mentioned Scientology to me several times; I had never been interested in the talk of engrams and so on, but I was interested in claims of increased intelligence. I read the standard bio of [L. Ron] Hubbard [founder of Scientology] and decided someone with that background might actually have some useful ideas. As a result, I was "sponsored" (which means I didn't pay for it) for some courses and auditing at the Los Angeles Celebrity Centre.

Well, I kept "advancing" but nothing happened. I mentioned this several times, and was told that by the time I made OT [Operating Thetan], that I'd have an IQ of 200, perfect recall, and so on. Yes, on occasion I "believed" I was getting some results, but would always decide that I wasn't. I was also hearing stories of "powers," but when I asked for details or demonstrations ("you can fly!") they remained stories.

[The studies] describe events in the distant past involving alien beings, space travel, and exploding volcanoes. I started to object to this on scientific grounds. I also have a good background in archaeology and was asking some very pointed questions about geology, biology, linguistics.

At about this point, my "sponsor" started to hint that it was time for me to start to pay for my own auditing; it seems that my "complaining" was reaching some of the higher levels and someone who had initially been perceived as a hot recruit was not working out.

I found out the cost; I didn't have that sort of money, so I approached my father. He said, "Let's investigate . . . what do you know about this man Hubbard?" I showed him the bio, and he found it incredible; he (my father) served with distinction in the Pacific, and just did not accept it. We got copies of Navy records, and sure enough, no command of a corvette squadron, no long list of citations, no mention of serious injuries.

The next step was a P.I., who checked with George Washington University and Princeton. Hubbard flunked out of GWU (or dropped out) and never attended Princeton. We found a reference to a Ph.D. from Sequoia University, which was a degree mill.

I then allowed an electrical engineer to open my E-Meter and take a look. He explained the Wheatstone Bridge circuit to me, and I accepted that there is no correlation between resistance and "mental mass" (whatever that means).

I returned to the Celebrity Centre and had a long talk with my course supervisor. I told her that I had seen no results . . . not personally, not with anyone else. I told her that I now had serious doubts about Hubbard's background as well as the effectiveness of the E-Meter.

She told me (quite sternly) that I should not investigate Scientology. She told me that a "high level OT" could wipe me out with a thought and that the Church did not tolerate "snooping around" and the like. She said that I needed to do "an ethics course" and that it would not cost me anything. She said that if I didn't do the course, I'd be kicked out of Scientology.

Off to ethics. My first encounter was with the "Director of Communications" of the Celebrity Centre, who also seemed to be the receptionist. She told me that she had gained the ability to speak fluent Spanish through auditing. Well, let me tell you, she could not speak fluent Spanish; in fact, apart from a few expressions, she knew nothing about Spanish. She told me that such accusations were "going to get me into trouble" with the Ethics Officer, who was a "powerful" person.

Finally . . . into the inner sanctum of the ethics officer. Th e guy was a little runt who wore glasses, squinted, and chain smoked. He told me that I had to stop asking questions, stop investigating, stop challenging people's claims of abilities, and so on. He wanted me to sign some forms. I refused . . .

Well, Jost didn't last much longer in Scientology. He found out it wasn't a religion, but a scam. Plus, he was scared off by the guys who said, "We'll get you when we have to." Not an endearing attitude.
[/list][url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1995/9506drag.asp"][b][i]This Rock[/i]: Dragnet[/b][/url] (1995)[list]If you want to be sued, do something displeasing to the Church of Scientology, possibly the most litigious church in history. Consider the case of the folks who started an Internet newsgroup (discussion group) called "alt.religion.scientology." About a hundred messages a day are posted about Scientology, most of them from people exposing the church, its doctrines, its finances, and its methodologies. Some former Scientologists are posting what they say are the secret scriptures of the church, and the church's leaders have acknowledged the authenticity of the documents by obtaining a court order confiscating the computer equipment of a former Scientologist who had been uploading the texts. So round one seemed to go to the Scientologists-except that other people have been posting the same material anonymously.

The Church of Scientology sees this as copyright infringement; the posters of the messages see it as exposing a cult. Scientology charges its members thousands of dollars to progress from one level of instruction to another. At each level new "scriptures" are revealed. Many members of the organization have mortgaged their homes to pay for instruction at the higher levels.

The religion was founded nearly fifty years ago by L. Ron Hubbard, a writer of low-quality science fiction novels. The story is that he claimed anyone could found a religion, was challenged to do so, and won the bet.
[/list][url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1997/9712drag.asp"][b][i]This Rock[/i]: Dragnet[/b][/url] (1997)[list]Actor John Travolta told a rally of Scientologists, gathered in Berlin to protest Germany’s tough stance on the group, that there was no excuse for governments to discriminate against religious bodies. Singing and chanting, Scientologists from Germany, the United States, and across Europe joined the U.S.-based organization’s largest demonstration in Germany against what it said was official discrimination against religious minorities. Police said there were up to 3,000 at the protest; Scientology organizers, who had hoped for a crowd of 10,000, put the figure at 6,500.

"Scientology is our religion," Travolta said in a video message taped in Los Angeles. "It has helped us a lot, as it has helped so many others around the world. Actress Anne Archer and singer Isaac Hayes, both of whom are Scientologists, joined the protest march through Berlin to the Brandenburg Gate.

Germany rejects the claim that Scientology is a religion and considers it a business that exploits its members for financial gain, a charge denied by the movement. German authorities also accuse Scientology of depriving its members of freedoms guaranteed under the German Constitution and of using threats to hinder members from leaving—charges the group denies. Scientology was founded in 1954 by the late American science fiction novelist L. Ron Hubbard. Followers are recruited through personality tests and offered expensive courses of "treatment" to solve problems diagnosed in the tests.
[/list]

franciscanheart
Posted

Thanks, phatty. :) Those are great.

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

A religious psychologist of the last century wrote a book on the topic called [u]Varieties of Religious Experience[/u], William James that is. It examines what the title suggests.

There is a chapter devoted to so called "mind cure" religion or "simple optimism." His evaluations of scientology and other similar religions really make them sound so absurd.

I do recommend his work for all serious psychologist.

However, William James is not a catholic, or is his work well completely christian. It is very objective to say the least.

SHALOM

phatcatholic
Posted

cool, thanks for the heads up :thumbsup:

Cow of Shame
Posted

First few levels of Scientology training

[url="http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~dst/Secrets/TR/critique.html"]http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~dst/Secrets/TR/critique.html[/url]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

This is weird

[quote]Horrible Truths for Scientologists

[© Copyright, Roland Rashleigh-Berry, roland.rashleigh-berry@virgin.net 20th November 1998. Permission is granted to everyone to freely host, copy and distribute this document]

Body Thetans

Scientologists have heard about "Thetans", "theta" as well as "theta bodies" perhaps, but they won't have heard the term "Body Thetans", nor will they be able to find it in their Tech dictionaries.

This is because the information is being withheld from them until they reach a secret level in Scientology known as "OT III". On this level, they are told that they are full of the Thetans (or souls) of murdered space-aliens. Roughly 2,500 of them. And they have to talk to them telepathically to make them go away. These aliens were once part of the local galactic confederation of 75 million years ago, ruled over by the evil galactic overlord Xenu (sometimes said as Xemu).

The galactic confederation supposedly consisted of 22 suns with their 76 inhabited planets. That makes three or four inhabited planets per sun. This fits in with L. Ron Hubbard's view that other planets in our own solar system were inhabited, namely Venus (whose government is monitored by the Fifth Invader Force -- [url="http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/Venusian.ram)"]http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/Venusian.ram)[/url], Mars (inhabited by the earlier Fourth Invader Force -- [url="http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/Mars.ram)"]http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/Mars.ram)[/url] and Jupiter (by people who he said would look like Eskimos -- [url="http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/Jupiter.ram)"]http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/Jupiter.ram)[/url].

These aliens were supposedly similar in appearance to ourselves as we are now. The average populations of these planets was 178 million or 250 million on average (both figures are quoted in the same line on the handwritten OT III document).

This was an overpopulation problem for Xenu. To solve it he called most of the inhabitants of these planets in for income tax inspections where they were instead given injections of a mixture of alcohol and glycol into their lungs to paralyze them. They were then frozen and put on DC-8 identical space-planes and flown across space to planet Earth (then called Teegeeack) [url="http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/DC-8s.ram"]http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/DC-8s.ram[/url]

If the story is to be believed, then this would have happened to about 4 trillion people. The story makes it clear that the actual corpses of people were transported to Earth. Supposing each DC-8 could carry 200 frozen bodies in refrigerated units at a time and the excess population per planet was 100 million, then 500,000 DC-8 space-plane flights would have been required to ship these people to Earth. If the return trip were 6 weeks, as mentioned in the "Assists" lecture in relation to the three weeks from Coltice to Earth, and if this were all achieved in six months, then each planet would have required 125,000 DC-8 space-planes.

When the people arrived on Earth, all 4 trillion of them were stacked around ten or so volcanoes and then nuked. After they were nuked their Thetans (souls) were captured in electronic beams, boxed up and taken to cinemas. There they were shown pictures of what life on Earth should be like and they were also shown false pictures of God and Christ to instill a religious fervor in them that would make them less effective and so easier to control.

The Thetans were frozen, again, in alcohol and glycol - a supposed very effective way for capturing Thetans. The start of these films was unusual in that the first two days of it were taken up with a helicopter about to crash ( [url="http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/Helicopt.ram)"]http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/Helicopt.ram)[/url] After watching these films, which lasted several days, these Thetans clustered together and now inhabit our bodies.

These films supposedly set the scene for the future. The houses, theaters, trains, boats, planes etc. of the late 1950's were supposed to be copies of those at the time of this incident and the same as those shown to the body Thetans in the films. Hence society of the 1950's was a copy of what life was like 75 million years ago. And since these images were implanted in these body Thetans and they were required to act out these scenes, then this was a block to further progress. In inhabiting our bodies, we too inherit these images which then govern our lives. Indeed, we are, in most cases, one of these same body Thetans - it is just that we are the one in charge or the "leader" body thetan or controller.

Scientologists are required to exorcise all these body Thetans if they are to make spiritual progress within their religion. Once gone then they are supposed to regain their own powers. They talk to them telepathically to make them go away. This whole incident, as described, is known as "R6", or "Incident Two". In liberating these body Thetans it is important to get to the first time something like this happened. It is called "getting the basic on the chain of events".

This was not the earliest incident though, since there was supposedly an Incident 4 quadrillion years ago, called Incident One, in which Thetans were confused by a chariot charging at them as well as a cherub blowing a horn before blackness was dumped on them. If these body Thetans are reminded of this then they leave the body readily and with some noise and energy. L. Ron Hubbard described how he readily achieved this on himself ( [url="http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/BTs.ram)"]http://www.xs4all.nl/~xemu/rams/BTs.ram)[/url].

When the body Thetans (or "BTs") leave, they are Clear and are able to operate as Thetans. They have become "Operating Thetans" - a high goal in Scientology. They then supposedly decide to be flowers or butterflies.

The Cracks Appear

On the surface, the above story may seem plausible. However, incisive thinking on these events lead to questions that challenge the validity and accuracy of this story.

1) DC-8 space planes

Each planet would have had to manufacture about 100,000 new DC-8 space planes for this task within, let us say, a six month period. This would have put an enormous strain on the planet's resources. And of course airports would have to have been constructed for this five-fold planned increase in space traffic. With all planets heavily overpopulated, the clearing of buildings to make new airports would have been a very noticeable and unpopular move which would have made the inhabitants curious as to what the new space-planes would have been used for. Rumors would have been rife and this would have led to civil unrest that would have disrupted these developments.

Another minor point is of the positioning of the rockets engines on the DC-8. If this were to the rear, then it contradicts L. Ron Hubbard's claim that they were identical to DC-8 passenger planes since they do not have rocket outlets at the rear. If, instead, the rockets were placed where the jets were, then as soon as the DC-8 had gotten beyond the atmosphere, it would have started flying around in circles, as the rocket engines would not have been directly in line with the center of gravity of the space-plane.

2) Income Tax Offices

People being called in for income tax inspections would be highly suspicious if their friends were called in, never to be seen again. They would have suspected that something were amiss and would have refused to go, especially after knowing that 100,000 DC-8 space planes with their corresponding airports had been built. For this to be effective, all the visits to the tax offices would have to have been completed in a very short time. A week or less. Let us estimate that there were 10,000 income tax offices on each planet. If 100 million people were to make visits then each office would have to see at least one thousand people per day. This would have caused people to queue and they would have noticed that although people were seen to enter, they were not seen to leave. This would have raised suspicion.

3) Technological Progress

Technology has progressed since the 1950's. If all life is dictated by the films the body Thetans saw, then we would not have developed technology beyond DC-8 planes, for example. We now have supersonic fighter planes and supersonic passenger aircraft as well as Stealth bombers. The technology is far in advance of DC-8s. The same goes for the design of houses, boats, trains, compurters etc. Society on Earth and its technology does not appear to be stuck at any timepoint. Technological progress has continued unabated. This raises a question mark over these films as to whether they were actually shown or, if so, had any effect. In both cases, we should question the usefulness of L. Ron Hubbard's system of dealing with body Thetans.

4) Lack of Archaeological Evidence

There is no evidence of a 250 million population on this planet from 75 million years ago. Indeed, as archaeologists dig down, they find evidence of dinosaurs from this period but no evidence of 1950's type technology. If the story were true then the planet should be covered, down to a certain depth, with the concrete and metal artifacts of the thriving population of this planet of 75 million years ago. It should be possible to unearth remains of 1950's style trains at the level where fossilized skeletons of dinosaurs are found instead. That there exists none of the remains of this supposed civilization suggests that L. Ron Hubbard's view was in error.

Another niggling worry is the volcanoes where the now body thetans were nuked with H-bombs. as listed in the secret handwritten OT III document. Some of the listed volcanoes did not exist 75 million years ago.

5) Easy-to-Clear Body Thetans

Body Thetans are supposedly easy to exteriorize from the body. And as they leave, then so our own powers are supposed to increase. If that were true, then it should be easy for us to leave our bodies as well, since we are the "lead" thetan and are more powerful than the rest.

Even with all the body Thetans gone, people are not able to exteriorize. They may feel dissociated, somewhat, after telepathically talking to 2,500 invisible space-aliens inside them, but this could be a sign of mental fatigue or even deterioration, rather than the emergence of a new mental ability. Also, since the body Thetans were once people like ourselves, you would expect their ambitions to go beyond the inhabiting of flowers and butterflies.

With you as the "lead thetan", you would expect them to show more loyalty and to attempt to get their leaders to exteriorize as well. If they had been close companions for 75 million years then you would expect the friendship and commitment to their fellows to run deeper than to just leave to become a flower or butterfly.

Conclusion

I have just touched upon 5 points which cast doubt on the validity of L. Ron Hubbard's supposed recounting of events of 75 million years ago as well as the veracity of the existence of Body Thetans. I am sure there are many more avenues worthy of exploration. I will leave it to the reader to make their own mental investigations into this alleged chapter of Earth's history. After two years or more of careful thought on this subject, I have personally come to the conclusion that L. Ron Hubbard was largely in error in this matter.

Roland Rashleigh-Berry
[/quote]

phatcatholic
Posted

are people really that stupid? i can see L. Ron Hubbard in his office chair, thinking "i can't believe people are actually buying this carp?"

nothing quite as lucrative as starting your own religion.......

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1010988' date='Jun 23 2006, 12:07 PM']
are people really that stupid? i can see L. Ron Hubbard in his office chair, thinking "i can't believe people are actually buying this carp?"

nothing quite as lucrative as starting your own religion.......
[/quote]
Yeah, it's weird. I suppose by the time a person gets to OT III they are sufficiently conditioned/brain washed to believe anything.

It just annoys me how these sects who like to brag about being "scientific" (Raelians, Scientologists, etc.) always have these idiotic, absurd and contradictory doctrines.

Another thing that I find interesting, and wouldn't mind learning more about, is the Church of Scientology's participation in the group known as Firephim. Other members of Firephim include the Raelian Movement, the Jehova's Witnesses, Wicca Occidental, the Moonies and the so-called Children of God (aka Family of Love). This Family of Love cult ("hookers for Jesus") is pretty strange, they teach their members to fantasize about Christ whilst having sex with someone or masturbating. If that's not demonic I don't know what is. I just think it's interesting that these groups have a sort of affiliation, it says a lot. Oh, and as I understand it the Church of Scientology essentially leads this organization.

franciscanheart
Posted

It's amazing how insufficient the human mind truly is. Cahtolicism is beautiful in it's limitlessness. The human mind can never grasp the true essence of Catholicism - because, of course, it is rooted in God Himself.

Scientology is odd.

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1010988' date='Jun 23 2006, 02:07 PM']
are people really that stupid? i can see L. Ron Hubbard in his office chair, thinking "i can't believe people are actually buying this carp?"

nothing quite as lucrative as starting your own religion.......
[/quote]


According to L. Ron Jr, he was doing precisely that....


When you read all this stuff, especially when you get to the carp about Xenu, it is laughable and it seems inconceivable that someone would actually believe it, but you have to realize that most Scientologists don't believe in Xenu, they don't even think that Scientology teaches it. Scientology is a mystery "religion," initiates aren't taught the stuff about Xenu and the aliens, they start out just getting the stuff from Dianetics. If you read Dianetics, especially if you don't have a set philosophical anthropology or belief system, it can be rather convincing. L. Ron Hubbard may have been a hack at sci-fi writing, but he didn't do a bad job with Dianetics. A lot of the beginning stuff seems very appealing...psychatric drugs are bad (even people who don't believe this don't like the idea of taking them), our past experiences affect us today (true enough), we can fix ourselves (very appealing), we can live forever (fits what man knows in his heart--that we have immortal souls), our physical ills are caused by psychological problems (can be true in many cases), our psychological problems are not our own fault (again, very appealing), chemicals are harmful (true enough in many cases), etc. They offer people a way to feel better, be smarter, see better, be happier, and even live longer just by talking about your memories and experiences. It's appealing. You want to believe that it's possible.

By the time you start learning the other stuff, you are already in deep...you've spent thousands upon thousands of dollars, all your friends are Scientologists (you're encouraged to avoid spending time with people who are not Scientologists), you've spent years auditing and re-auditing to get to the level of "operating thetan," etc. Plus, you are sometimes threatened. People who leave not only loose their entire support system, they are often blackmailed or intimidated. Their employers or prospective employers are told things that may or may not be true about them and their families. All the dirty little secrets they revealed in "auditing sessions" are either revealed to their wives, family, friends, etc. (or at least the threat is made). Leaving is like leaving a cult or the mob...not easy by any stretch. Scientologists are good at intimidation. By the time you are that far in, you convince yourself to believe it just because believing the unbelievable is better than the alternative.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Bottom line for anyone considering becoming a Scientologist.

They think they (we...the human race...or maybe just them...cause they're so 'enlightened' who knows on that point) come from space aliens.

Not kidding here.

Yeah, I couldnt get past the part where I was supposed to imagine some invisibe smoke like aura thing eminating from my head (my power...or something...dont remember perfectly cause it was years ago) I laughed so hard cause I kept thinking of a Dean Koontz novel that had that same description in .....with aliens too btw!
Dean Koontz's novel was more interesting though.

Kudo's for Koontz.
Hubbard needs to work on his fiction skills

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...