Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey all,

I recently purchased St. Anselm's [i]Proslogion[/i] after seeing the work referenced in the encyclical [i]Fides et ratio[/i] ([url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_14091998_fides-et-ratio_en.html"]LINK[/url]; #14). I really had some trouble because it's a bit complicated for my little mind, even though it is fabulously written.

Anselm lays out what is referred to as the "[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontological_argument"]ontological argument[/url]." If you've never even heard of it, the wikipedia article does a pretty good job of explaining the basics (I didn't read the whole thing).

I'm questioning one of the assumptions Anselm makes at the beginning of his argument. He says "God is the greatest possible being and thus possesses all perfections." (paraphrased?).

From a christian perspective, a Catholic perspective, a scientist's perspective or a sceptics perspective, why can this assumption be made? Why must God be the bestest thing ever?

I didn't get too far into the proslogion as I was hung up on the initial assumption, but if somebody wants to take a shot at giving me a cool analogy for some other troublesome aspect of the work, I would be much obliged.

Justified Saint
Posted

Some would say that Anslem has already made a mistake in assuming that God is a being, but that is a different matter. I think such "ontological arguments" are pretty silly myself.

Pope Benedict has a rather scathing critique of St. Anslem's theory of atonement in his [i]Introduction to Christianity[/i]. Perhaps some saints lose their lustre over the years. :)

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1009635' date='Jun 20 2006, 10:49 PM']
Some would say that Anslem has already made a mistake in assuming that God is a being, but that is a different matter. I think such "ontological arguments" are pretty silly myself.

Pope Benedict has a rather scathing critique of St. Anslem's theory of atonement in his [i]Introduction to Christianity[/i]. Perhaps some saints lose their lustre over the years. :)
[/quote]
Wait'll Jeff sees this. muahahaha

phatcatholic
Posted

someone let him know. i can't wait........

Justified Saint
Posted

Was it something I said? :unsure:

phatcatholic
Posted

oh, no, no, its just that jeff knows anselm well, so we look forward to his insight :thumbsup:

ThyWillBeDone
Posted

Yeah, Jeff gave me some good resources when I wrote a paper on the Argument for my Metaphysics class at the seminary. I am sure he will have a lenghty response when he finds this thread.
God Bless

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

hahaha, ok ok, I'm here. And I would have to actually read the Holy Father's analysis of atonement theory, but my guess is that he is treating the legalistic perversion of Anselm's theory that came later. To criticise Anselmian atonement theory for later interpretation would be like criticizing Thomas Aquinas for the poor aristotelians of later centuries. And no, Anselm does not lose his lustre over time ;)

Now the first critical point to make is that the above paraphrase that "God is the greatest possible being and thus possesses all perfections" is a paraphrase that lacks a critical aspect of Anselm's articulation of the argument.

God is defined as "that than which nothing greater can be conceived" and this formulation is crucial for the argument's success or failure.

Now uriel, to answer your question, you have to understand that there is a difference between making an assumption and defining a term. All St. Anselm is doing is explaining what is meant by the term God, he is not assuming that God exists. Think of it like this: I can define what a "circle" is (a figure in which all points are equidistant from a center point) without ever claiming that this circle exists. [i]Then[/i] I can check to see if a circle exists in reality. In the same way, Anselm is defining the term "God" as "that than which nothing greater can be conceived" and then he is trying to figure out if this idea can be found in reality.

Now, if you wanted to "define" a circle as something other than "a figure in which all points are equidistant from a center point" no one could stop you, but every time you talked with someone about circles, you would be talking past each other. In the same way, if you want to define "God" as something other than "that than which nothing greater can be conceived" you are free to do so, but then you and St. Anselm will be talking past each other too. If we are going to talk about God, we need to know that we both mean the same thing when we say the word "God." All that Anselm is doing is explicitly saying what he means by the term "God" - not an assumption, just a definition.

Also, I am more than happy to invite anyone (not just Justified Saint) who finds the ontological argument to be "silly" to discuss it with me. To get the engine started, I propose that the only thing "silly" about it are the Thomistic and Kantian attempts to refute it. :P:

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Justified Saint
Posted (edited)

Jeff,

I have no pretensions of being able to flesh out a critique and/or explication of Anselm and his works; I submit that my "silly" remark stems from a deep-rooted prejudice and suspicion of "proofs for the existence of God." To try to prove the existence of God seems about as pointless and naive as Descartes trying to doubt his own existence. I agree with Kant that one must act as if God exists without being able to prove his existence.

Also, that Benedict may have been addressing later interpretations of Anselm's atonement theory is possible, though he does not necessarily phrase it as such for he makes his critique in continual reference to Anselm (of course the pope, as a good student of hermenutics, knows that the difference between what Anslem "really means" and how he has been interpreted is largely irrelevant).

Edited by Justified Saint
Guest JeffCR07
Posted

I take no offense at the "silly" remark, so no need to apologize, I very much enjoy discussions of this nature.

Now with regards to Kant, I have to be wary. Are you actually familiar with the Kantian thesis? Even if Kant did not formulate it as such, the logical result of his delimitation of the noumenal realm is that God cannot even be an object of [i]thought[/i] and, as what cannot be thought cannot be believed, Kant, whether he realized it or not, ultimately leaves no room at all for Faith. The argumentation of his Second and Third Antinomies leads to this conclusion, since unlike Space and Time in the Second, God is not one of the Forms of Intuition.

In my opinion, proofs of God have their value, but that value is not to be found in its power of persuasion. I tend to think that believe in God entails not simply an intellectual recognition of valid argument, but also an assent of will. As such, an atheist can most certainly rationally discuss whether God exists with a theist, and can even acknowledge that the theist's arguments are good one, without necessarily being lead to believe in God. My roomate and I have had many such discussions and this notion has borne itself out for me in experience.

Also, it should be pointed out that the difference between what someone says and how it is interpreted is "irrelevant" only from a pastoral standpoint which is, necessarily, immanently practical. However, to say that the distinction is irrelevant on the whole is to make a grevious mistake. Indeed, if this mistake had been made in the middle ages, Thomas Aquinas would never have adopted aristotelianism in the first place and all of Catholic philosophy would be drastically different than it is today.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Justified Saint
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1010290' date='Jun 22 2006, 04:50 AM']
I take no offense at the "silly" remark, so no need to apologize, I very much enjoy discussions of this nature.

Now with regards to Kant, I have to be wary. Are you actually familiar with the Kantian thesis? Even if Kant did not formulate it as such, the logical result of his delimitation of the noumenal realm is that God cannot even be an object of [i]thought[/i] and, as what cannot be thought cannot be believed, Kant, whether he realized it or not, ultimately leaves no room at all for Faith. The argumentation of his Second and Third Antinomies leads to this conclusion, since unlike Space and Time in the Second, God is not one of the Forms of Intuition.

In my opinion, proofs of God have their value, but that value is not to be found in its power of persuasion. I tend to think that believe in God entails not simply an intellectual recognition of valid argument, but also an assent of will. As such, an atheist can most certainly rationally discuss whether God exists with a theist, and can even acknowledge that the theist's arguments are good one, without necessarily being lead to believe in God. My roomate and I have had many such discussions and this notion has borne itself out for me in experience.

Also, it should be pointed out that the difference between what someone says and how it is interpreted is "irrelevant" only from a pastoral standpoint which is, necessarily, immanently practical. However, to say that the distinction is irrelevant on the whole is to make a grevious mistake. Indeed, if this mistake had been made in the middle ages, Thomas Aquinas would never have adopted aristotelianism in the first place and all of Catholic philosophy would be drastically different than it is today.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff
[/quote]

I am familiar with the Kantian thesis as its interpretation has been taught to me -- surely there is nobody who is a Kant expert (is this not a contradiction in itself?) and truly if there every was a breakdown in the distinction between was is "really meant" and how it is interpreted it must be with Kant!

I have understood Kant to say that man must assume the existence of freedom, the immortality of the soul, and God as the most complete ideals of the noumenal world and having the most regulatory effect on the phenomenal world -- ideas which can never be proven but must be assumed. Whatever this logically entails ultimately is irrelevant to my thinking since I don't subscribe to Kant's neo-platonism and the rest of his system.

I don't deny that proofs for the existence of God may have their value, but when they are conceived in a kind of scientific and rationalistic rigor, I find them to be nearly blasphemous. One can have God-talk without first having to proof the existence of God, just as one can have man-talk without proving his own existence.

Posted

These boards are so prone to hijacking it leads me to insanity.

That aside, I am so happy that you answered my question in such a simple way. I see that not only is this a good way to work, thanks to you analogy, but that if you're going to try to prove their's a God, you might as well make him really hard to prove (ie the best). Now I can go back to reading the proslogion :lol_roll:

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1010662' date='Jun 22 2006, 04:54 PM']
I don't deny that proofs for the existence of God may have their value, but when they are conceived in a kind of scientific and rationalistic rigor, I find them to be nearly blasphemous. One can have God-talk without first having to proof the existence of God, just as one can have man-talk without proving his own existence.
[/quote]

My perspective on attempting to "prove God" is this:

I'm an engineering student. There is no stinkin' way I would be here typing in letters which are sent through a complex system of electrical impulses to a data-center in someplace I've never been to and then other folks reading it if their wasn't a God. Don't get me started on trees :) ! I can think critically :shock: ! Un-flippin' believable.

Where you run into trouble with this simple approach is "there's a creator, now what." In the definition of the creator, you're able to learn of his nature and this revalation of his nature can lead to a reasoned faith in Catholocism in place of say islam. We both believe in a creator, but from what I know that has slightly different implications.

Justified Saint
Posted

uriel, sorry If I have anything to derail this thread, it was not intended :)

In any event, your point is well taken. However, I am quite confident, as I think I indicated in my above post, that God-talk is quite possible and necessary even without existence proofs. I don't think one needs a series of rational postulates to proceed from before they can start talking about the nature and "being" of God. For God is self-revealing and this is exactly why I think existence proofs have a kind of backwardness that borders not only on blasphemy, but also arrogance and pedantry.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

Justified Saint, I agree with you that we can speak about God without having proved his existence. All that I am saying is that talking and debating about His Existence is just as valid a philosophical endevour as talking and debating about His Nature.

Also, on an erudite sidenote: I would personally be careful about calling Kant or his system "Neo-Platonic." I know you meant it loosely, but when it comes to ontology and metaphysics there is a gap between the two systems that is so vast as to render them practically diametrically opposed. In Neo-Platonism, it is the true Noumenal (the true "thing in itself") that is the ultimate real - i.e. the Forms, and we can never have true knowledge of the world of sense experience. The Kantian metaphysic and epistemology, on the other hand, renders the "thing in itself" unknowable and claims that true philsophic and scientific knowledge can [i]only[/i] be found in the world of sense experience (and, to some extent, in the human reason).

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1010799' date='Jun 22 2006, 10:13 PM']
In any event, your point is well taken. However, I am quite confident, as I think I indicated in my above post, that God-talk is quite possible and necessary even without existence proofs. I don't think one needs a series of rational postulates to proceed from before they can start talking about the nature and "being" of God. For God is self-revealing and this is exactly why I think existence proofs have a kind of backwardness that borders not only on blasphemy, but also arrogance and pedantry.
[/quote]I agree with you that we shouldn't approach "God-talk" as a scientific undertaking because that misses the whole real, and important dimension of spirituality.

The proslogion is actually from exactly the perspective you're talking about. It's someone with faith trying to seek God in a truer and more deep way. This is kinda where I find myself in relation to the faith, so it works out nicely.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I can scarce think of a major philosopher since Anselm's time who has not written something about this argument. Whether or not you believe it is true, one must at least admit that it is very compelling and interesting.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

On a related note:
[quote][b]The First Vatican Council (Canon 2.1):[/b]
If anyone says that the one, true God, our creator and lord, cannot be known with certainty

- from the things that have been made,
- by the natural light of human reason:

let him be anathema.[/quote]

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1011648' date='Jun 24 2006, 03:02 PM']
I can scarce think of a major philosopher since Anselm's time who has not written something about this argument. Whether or not you believe it is true, one must at least admit that it is very compelling and interesting.
[/quote]

gosh jeepers, thats true! Plus, its just so much darn-tootin [i]fun[/i]

Justified Saint
Posted

Jeff,

In regards to Kantism and Neo-Platonism, I only meant that they are both similarly conceived idealisms even if their conclusions are poles apart. I suspect it is exactly their different conclusions that makes Kant such a radical turn in Western philosophy.

thedude,

What would we do without those anathemas!

It is worth noting, however, that there are different degrees of certainty and epistemic certainties are certainly not is what is being reffered to in the canon.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

I'm with you there ;) :D:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...