N/A Gone Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 [quote]Anyway, I'm not even sure myself but here goes... Mostly, I'm Catholic. I believe in honesty, charity and being ethical. I'm opposed to things like promiscuity and destruction of religious landmarks and materials. However, I agree with a lot of what Martin Luther preached and there are a few things about Catholicism that I don't like. Papal primacy: I think the papacy is important but it's got too big of an ego. A few concerns of mine surrounding the papacy are -The notion of papal infallability: The Pope is a mortal. -The notion that the Pope is God's link to the world: The Pope is elected by men, often as a result of behind-the-scenes dealings. -The Pope's word is definitive: It is the most important in terms of doctrine but most important doesn't mean the only important one. -The Pope is more important than a king: Historically, Catholics have believed that all of the great dynasties were chosen by God. Again, the Pope is chosen by men - cardinals, but still men. -Excommunication and interdict: A mortal man has no right to condemn another to damnation. The role of priests: I think priests should guide and instruct, not command. They should teach, not force religion upon anyone who'll listen. The overwhelming majority of the time, you should go to them, not the other way around. Religion being taught in Catholic schools: I went to seven years of religion class and as a result, renounced my confirmation. I studied European history for a couple years and fell back in love with the religion. People can't hope to emulate Jesus so why ask it of them? Teach them about Him, sure, but then also teach them about past heroes who've acted in line with Catholicism and whose deeds are more easily attainable. In my opinion, "Strongbow was a good Christian and he saved the Anglo-Normans" works much better than "Jesus was a good Christian (well, I guess) and he was executed". The Catholic church as a political entity: The pope has never been king of anything and never will be. The clergy have never had much secular authority and they never will. They should just keep themselves out of what isn't their business. I don't mean to undermine the importance of the papacy, the priesthood or especially Jesus but I think the Catholic church is too single-minded. Looking at something from a different persepctive never hurts. I have a Presbyterian father and a Catholic mother so I've seen different perspectives, as I'm sure you have too in all your religious studies. That's also not everything and it's probably not too coherent but it's 1:35AM and I worked/transited 10 hours yesterday (today if you don't like acknowledging the change of a day).[/quote] This guy is a good guy, I have spoke to him before, but his arguments are interesting...maybe this can start some talk.. thoughts?
Cow of Shame Posted June 22, 2006 Posted June 22, 2006 [quote]The Catholic church as a political entity: The pope has never been king of anything and never will be. The clergy have never had much secular authority and they never will. They should just keep themselves out of what isn't their business.[/quote] What about the pope & clergy? What does that have to do with the price of figs in Norway? Does this person truly see no connection between morality & politics? I mean, if he's talking about taxes, then yeah, I don't see clergy really taking a stand on the rate of sales tax....but in general, don't you kinda want your politicians to be upright, honest, MORAL individuals?
phatcatholic Posted June 22, 2006 Posted June 22, 2006 personally, i don't find his critique all that interesting. "ignorant" comes to mind, but certainly not "interesting".... [quote]Anyway, I'm not even sure myself but here goes... Mostly, I'm Catholic.[/quote] well, either you are or you aren't. there's no "via media", as much as the anglicans would have us think otherwise.... [quote]Papal primacy: I think the papacy is important but it's got too big of an ego. [/quote] none of what he will go on to list as the egotistical features of the Church actually have anything to do with the "ego" of the papacy at all. why? b/c the pope merits [i]none[/i] of the privileges he enjoys. it has nothing to do w/ him as a person, or his qualifications. for one, there have been many dastardly popes, yet the Church still believes they had the power to speak infallibly. even more important is the fact that infallibility is a charism of the Holy Spirit, a gift, and one that no man deserves. his primacy comes from the primacy of Peter, which also has nothing to do with him. so, the "ego" charge is rather ridiculous. now, i acknowledge full well that some popes saw it as a source of pride to be the pope and they abused the position they were in, but surely there is something wrong about making blanket statements about the entire papacy based on the sins of a few. in the light of JPII's pontificate, how could anyone say the papacy has "too big of an ego"? [quote]A few concerns of mine surrounding the papacy are -The notion of papal infallability: The Pope is a mortal. [/quote] big deal. mortality does not preclude infallibility when it comes [i][b]as a gift outside yourself[/b][/i]. the gospel writers were mortal men too, yet surely he believes that they wrote inspired scripture (and inspiration is a much greater work of the Spirit than infallibility is). [quote]-The notion that the Pope is God's link to the world: The Pope is elected by men, often as a result of behind-the-scenes dealings.[/quote] big deal. God can't use men to appoint his representative? do i really need to point out all the times He has done that in the span of salvation history? He used the 11 to appoint Mathias (Acts 1). [quote]-The Pope's word is definitive: It is the most important in terms of doctrine but most important doesn't mean the only important one. [/quote] sure, everyone has something "important" to say, but if we don't have someone who has the final word then we have no rule of faith with which to determine what is true. we've all seen what happens when that scenario plays itself out (how many denominations are we up to?). personally, i don't find it too appealing, and i don't think its what Jesus had in mind when he prayed for unity in his Church like that shared by he and the Father. to be continued.........
phatcatholic Posted June 22, 2006 Posted June 22, 2006 [quote]-The Pope is more important than a king: Historically, Catholics have believed that all of the great dynasties were chosen by God. Again, the Pope is chosen by men - cardinals, but still men. [/quote] more important than a king? what is he talking about? does this guy really know what it's like to be a Catholic? its not like slavery under some iron-fisted dictator who is always imposing his will on the lowly masses. instead, being Catholic means living your life in confidence of what is true and bolstered by inumerable graces. its wonderful, liberating even, to be a Catholic. i wish more protestants understood that. [quote]-Excommunication and interdict: A mortal man has no right to condemn another to damnation.[/quote] well, for one, excommunication is not a condemnation to hell. it is a formal separation from the Church and a plea to return. no one is forever put out. there is always the hope of reconciliation, and it is in that hope that excommunications are given in the first place. also, being "mortal" has nothing to do with it. Jesus instructed us to excommunicate those who do not listen to the Church, and Paul speaks of it often (see [url="http://bible.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?new=1&word=1+Cor.+5%3A3-5%3B+16%3A22%3B+1+Tim.+1%3A20%3B+Gal+1%3A8%3B+Matt+18%3A17§ion=0&version=rsv&language=en"][b]these verses[/b][/url]). [quote]The role of priests: I think priests should guide and instruct, not command. They should teach, not force religion upon anyone who'll listen. The overwhelming majority of the time, you should go to them, not the other way around.[/quote] i too agree that religion should be forced upon no one. that is not the nature of the priesthood, and a priest is not expected to do such a thing. what he is describing here is not something inherent to the priesthood. instead, it sounds to me like the mistakes of a few that he is generalizing as representative of the whole. that said, does he have any idea what happens when a church has a pastor that doesn't command? you have a church filled with chaos, where every member believes and does whatever the hell he wants, even when it is blatantly contradictory to right belief and action. perhaps the priest is supposed to just stand by and let that happen? [quote]Religion being taught in Catholic schools: I went to seven years of religion class and as a result, renounced my confirmation. I studied European history for a couple years and fell back in love with the religion.[/quote] this guy is repeatedly making the mistake of assuming that his negative experience with Catholicism is representative of the entire Catholic Church. believe it or not, just b/c [i]he[/i] lost his faith doesn't mean that Catholic schools are such that they just naturally cause [i]all [/i] Catholics to lose their faith. that's just silly. it is a good and noble thing to want to educate one's children in the ways of the faith. we are negligent as parents if we don't do this. also, i wonder how much of his falling away can actually be attributed to the school he went to, but maybe that's off topic.... [quote] People can't hope to emulate Jesus so why ask it of them? Teach them about Him, sure, but then also teach them about past heroes who've acted in line with Catholicism and whose deeds are more easily attainable. In my opinion, "Strongbow was a good Christian and he saved the Anglo-Normans" works much better than "Jesus was a good Christian (well, I guess) and he was executed". [/quote] this guy has allowed himself to be utterly scandalized by his negative experiences with the Church, and all of his arguments come not from any rational, logical, or educated basis, but primarily from this negative experience. so, all you really have to do is show him how unfair it is to keep generalizing. he's doing it here too. just b/c he feels like he can't hope to emulate Jesus, that doesn't mean that we shouldn't hope to or ask people to, or that other people don't in fact emulate Jesus every day. plus, the Church does in fact teach "past heroes." they're called the saints, and we venerate them for a reason. [quote]The Catholic church as a political entity: The pope has never been king of anything and never will be. The clergy have never had much secular authority and they never will. They should just keep themselves out of what isn't their business.[/quote] for someone interested in European history, he sure knows little about the history of the Church and its relationship throughout the years w/ those very European nations. [i]he[/i] should "keep himself out" of what he knows little about, but i digress......the point is that, in the past, the hierarchy in the Church did in fact enjoy an element of secular power, but we learned (perhaps the hard way) that a priest has quite a bit of trouble living out his vocation when he is consumed by such pursuits. its not even really an issue now, which makes me wonder why he's even bringing this up. perhaps his beef is more w/ how the Church used to be than w/ how She currently is. as for the current "secular" or "kingly" status of the pope, he is in fact the political head of the Vatican, but it is necessary for him to be thus. the Pope is the head of the Church. he needs a place from where he can run the affairs of the Church w/o being hindered by kings or political parties. surely your friend would grant the pope that much. [quote]I don't mean to undermine the importance of the papacy, the priesthood or especially Jesus but I think the Catholic church is too single-minded. Looking at something from a different persepctive never hurts. I have a Presbyterian father and a Catholic mother so I've seen different perspectives, as I'm sure you have too in all your religious studies. That's also not everything and it's probably not too coherent but it's 1:35AM and I worked/transited 10 hours yesterday (today if you don't like acknowledging the change of a day).[/quote] for some reason, whenever one is convicted in his position, he is "single-minded." or, when he refuses to contradict what is true, he is "single-minded." there is plenty of room for multiple views and theological expression. but, the truth can never be contradicted, or watered-down, or subjected to a majority vote or to whatever the vogue philosophy happens to be. i hope that helps..............sorry it was so............i dunno............antagonistic? pax christi, phatcatholic
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 22, 2006 Posted June 22, 2006 [quote name='Myles Domini' post='1010255' date='Jun 21 2006, 11:30 PM'] Thumbsup for Phatcatholic [/quote] I raise my whiskey glass for phatty
N/A Gone Posted June 22, 2006 Author Posted June 22, 2006 Myles, Phatty and L_D and I all in one room... shed a tear, I shed a tear...
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 22, 2006 Posted June 22, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1010262' date='Jun 21 2006, 11:49 PM'] Myles, Phatty and L_D and I all in one room... shed a tear, I shed a tear... [/quote] I love you guys *sappy guy moment* hey, we're like a Catholic nerd support group. heheh just teasin
jswranch Posted June 22, 2006 Posted June 22, 2006 [quote]People can't hope to emulate Jesus so why ask it of them? Teach them about Him, sure, but then also teach them about past heroes who've acted in line with Catholicism and whose deeds are more easily attainable.[/quote] Can this man say this about Francis, Therese etc. To cite Kreeft, saints are a religion's great selling point. Your buddy might benefit from 'lives of the saints.'
Mateo el Feo Posted June 22, 2006 Posted June 22, 2006 Phat didn't leave a lot to add (great response!), but here's a little: [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1009991' date='Jun 21 2006, 05:38 PM'](Quoting) People can't hope to emulate Jesus so why ask it of them? Teach them about Him, sure, but then also teach them about past heroes who've acted in line with Catholicism and whose deeds are more easily attainable.[/quote] We Christians "ask" people to emulate Christ, because this is what the Holy Scriptures ask. For example: [quote name='Ephesians 5:1-2']So be imitators of God, as beloved children, and live in love, as Christ loved us and handed himself over for us as a sacrificial offering to God for a fragrant aroma.[/quote] We are made in the image of God, so we are called to be imitators of Him. Catholics can find 2,000 years of saints whose lives are worthy of emulation, but as is so often the case, this is not a question of either/or. For Catholics, it is both/and. Imitate Our Lord or imitate your favorite saint (who was imitating Our Lord).
thessalonian Posted June 22, 2006 Posted June 22, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='1010267' date='Jun 22 2006, 12:57 AM'] i prefer "knights at the round table" [/quote] Me too.
Socrates Posted June 23, 2006 Posted June 23, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1009991' date='Jun 21 2006, 03:38 PM'] This guy is a good guy, I have spoke to him before, but his arguments are interesting...maybe this can start some talk.. thoughts? [/quote] The problem is he really doesn't offer any actual arguments; he just gives a lot of disjointed personal opinions. [quote]Mostly, I'm Catholic. I believe in honesty, charity and being ethical. I'm opposed to things like promiscuity and destruction of religious landmarks and materials. [/quote] These things do not in themselves make one Catholic. There are plenty of pagans and unbelievers who would agree with these things. Not all non-Catholics are crazed, hedonistic satanic people out to destroy all morality and Church property! "Catholic" means agreeing with the dogma taught by the Church, not just being a "good guy." [quote]-The notion of papal infallability: The Pope is a mortal.[/quote]Nobody claimed the pope was immortal. Catholics teach Papal infallibility, not Papal Immortality. (Although the Church does teach that all humans are immortal and will rise from the dead on the Last Day.) [quote]-The notion that the Pope is God's link to the world: The Pope is elected by men, often as a result of behind-the-scenes dealings.[/quote] So? God can use men to elect leaders. Would he only accept Papal authority if Christ descended from the clouds to personally anoint each Pope? [quote]-The Pope's word is definitive: It is the most important in terms of doctrine but most important doesn't mean the only important one.[/quote] This doesn't make sense. If anyone else's "doctrine" contradicts that taught by the Pope, they cannot both be true doctrine. [quote]-The Pope is more important than a king: Historically, Catholics have believed that all of the great dynasties were chosen by God. Again, the Pope is chosen by men - cardinals, but still men.[/quote] Likewise nonsensical. Kings are traditionally determined by hereditary succession. Is he implying Popes should be born into power in the same way? [quote]-Excommunication and interdict: A mortal man has no right to condemn another to damnation.[/quote] "I will give you the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven: Whatever you declare bound on earth shall be considered bound in heaven; whatever you loose on earth shall be considered loosed in heaven." (Matt. 16:19) [quote]The role of priests: I think priests should guide and instruct, not command. They should teach, not force religion upon anyone who'll listen. The overwhelming majority of the time, you should go to them, not the other way around. [/quote] I really haven't seen that many priests running around putting guns to people's head, forcing them to convert. [quote]The Catholic church as a political entity: The pope has never been king of anything and never will be. The clergy have never had much secular authority and they never will. They should just keep themselves out of what isn't their business.[/quote] Keep themselves out of what? Speaking out on moral issues such as abortion? [quote]Religion being taught in Catholic schools: I went to seven years of religion class and as a result, renounced my confirmation. I studied European history for a couple years and fell back in love with the religion. People can't hope to emulate Jesus so why ask it of them? Teach them about Him, sure, but then also teach them about past heroes who've acted in line with Catholicism and whose deeds are more easily attainable. In my opinion, "Strongbow was a good Christian and he saved the Anglo-Normans" works much better than "Jesus was a good Christian (well, I guess) and he was executed"[/quote] What about the saints? And is he saying martyrdom is impossible? [quote]I don't mean to undermine the importance of the papacy, the priesthood or especially Jesus but I think the Catholic church is too single-minded. Looking at something from a different persepctive never hurts. I have a Presbyterian father and a Catholic mother so I've seen different perspectives, as I'm sure you have too in all your religious studies. [/quote] Is he saying the Catholic Church should stop teaching the Catholic Faith and start teaching "other perspectives"? Edited June 23, 2006 by Socrates
N/A Gone Posted June 23, 2006 Author Posted June 23, 2006 He wrote me back.... [quote]Are you then implying that what men do is because of God's will and shouldn't be questioned upon that basis? If so, that sounds like something from the Byzantine Empire. (i.e. "But God wanted me to kill my dad! That's the only way I could've become the king!") I think the Pope is more of a Prime Minister figure than an overlord of sorts. I like Stephen Harper yet I don't take everything he says to be true, much the same as with a pope. Ratzinger referred to rock music as "a vehicle of the devil" but I listened to some on my ride home from work. I'm referring to the past clashes where a pope has attempted to make a king obey him (Innocent III/Philip II, Boniface VIII/Philip IV, various papal and Holy Roman/Habsburg clashes). A pope has no authority to tell a secular leader how to do anything. The secular leaders of the past Catholic states (Holy Roman Empire, Kingdom of England prior to Henry VIII, Kingdom of France, Kingsom of Poland, Kingdom of Spain, Habsburg Empire) didn't let the papacy tell them how to run their kingsoms and rightfully so. The claim of the papacy over the Holy Roman throne, for instance, ws very presumptuous and inappropriate. Chaos or free thought? I have a lot of respect for the heavily established Protestant sects (Lutheran, Anglican, Presbyterian). I don't hear quarrels between the members in them either. I don't think a Protestant would kill someone and then justify it on the basis of there being no religious authority to tell him/her otherwise. I could use myself as a case study but instead, how about you just go look at all the slutty girls at the local Catholic school? Something must not be getting through. Have you ever sinned? I'm guessing yes. Jesus was divine and we are mortal. An oval can't just be a circle. Saints come about because they got along with the papacy. A lot of it's a big political game and that's what I hate. There have been past instances of papal votes being swayed with money (I'm thinking late medieval here, help me out). Then the pope basically chooses the saints. Then there are the people who have deserved so much recognition within the churches and don't get it. Philip Augustus, for instance, had a tremendous impact upon Catholicism's hold in Western Europe and he made its dominant force a strictly Catholic one. Richard I actually managed to hold a less violent Crusade! However, since they both had fallouts with the pope... Let's see... England: rocky relationship ending in a big, nasty (yet I suppose understandable) divorce France: placed under interdict during the reign of its great ruler Holy Roman Empire: the pope claimed supremacy over it, which was totally inappropriate Austria-Hungary: since the Habsburgs held the Holy Roman throne, the papacy interefered with them for a while too Poland: they didn't really communicate much but ironically, that worked in the Poles' favour (i.e. never held an inquisition, never crusaded) Over the Papal States and the Vatican, of course. It's not directly an issue now but neither is the Russian Empire, and many of the defining characteristics of the Tsars are evident in current Russia. (Sorry to use the Tsars as an example, seeing as they were in a sense the ultimate enemies of Catholicism) Institutions are built upon principles that don't really go away and interferene is one that tends to apply to the papacy. The idea of someone telling me how to live my life doesn't appeal to me because I feel that I can be a good, moral person without having to perpetually fear being smitten by celestial wrath if I make a mistake. [/quote] this guy is a good guy, not like my Fundi friend Dr. J, he is using a private message function, and not making loud noise on a thread. I wish I could simply answer him cause he seems to have the intention of knowing truth
Mateo el Feo Posted June 24, 2006 Posted June 24, 2006 He seems to be focused on the temporal affairs of the Catholic Church, not really its teachings. Anyway, I couldn't give an intelligent response to his many citations, but I think a good book recommendation would be: [url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0761516042/sr=8-10/qid=1151118917/ref=pd_bbs_10/104-0250935-4160735?%5Fencoding=UTF8"]Triumph : The Power and the Glory of the Catholic Church (link)[/url] by H. W. Crocker III. It is an informative (and entertaining) history of the Catholic Church.
Socrates Posted June 25, 2006 Posted June 25, 2006 (edited) While I don't know your friend here, from these quotes he seems either very ignorant or intellectually dishonest regarding the Catholic Faith. [quote]I think the Pope is more of a Prime Minister figure than an overlord of sorts. I like Stephen Harper yet I don't take everything he says to be true, much the same as with a pope. Ratzinger referred to rock music as "a vehicle of the devil" but I listened to some on my ride home from work.[/quote] He's referring to what "he thinks." He needs to study up on what the Church Fathers and Scripture think on this issue. ([url="http://catholic.com/library/church_papacy.asp"]SOME RESOURCES HERE[/url]) And bringing up Cardinal Ratzinger's views on rock music is a non-sequitor having nothing to do with papal infallibility. He made these statements before he became Pope, and were never intended nor regarded as definitive Church dogma on faith and morals. The Pope only is infallible when speaking ex-cathedra on issues of faith and morals. (And what a future pope says before being elected Pope has no bearing on papal infallibility. Even your friend should realize this.) [quote]I'm referring to the past clashes where a pope has attempted to make a king obey him (Innocent III/Philip II, Boniface VIII/Philip IV, various papal and Holy Roman/Habsburg clashes). A pope has no authority to tell a secular leader how to do anything. The secular leaders of the past Catholic states (Holy Roman Empire, Kingdom of England prior to Henry VIII, Kingdom of France, Kingsom of Poland, Kingdom of Spain, Habsburg Empire) didn't let the papacy tell them how to run their kingsoms and rightfully so. The claim of the papacy over the Holy Roman throne, for instance, ws very presumptuous and inappropriate.[/quote] Your friend needs to get his history straight. Such clashes usually involved the Emperor trying to exert political authority over the Papacy, not vice-versa. And the Pope did indeed give advice to the Catholic leaders of these other countries, not just the HRE. The clashes came about when these rulers acted contrary to the Catholic Church. However, this is all beside the point, as the Pope is only infallible in teaching ex Cathedra on Faith and Morals, not in his political actions. [quote]Chaos or free thought? I have a lot of respect for the heavily established Protestant sects (Lutheran, Anglican, Presbyterian). I don't hear quarrels between the members in them either. I don't think a Protestant would kill someone and then justify it on the basis of there being no religious authority to tell him/her otherwise.[/quote] If your friend thinks members of protestant churches never have quarrels among themselves, he obviously knows very little about protestant churches! The Anglican/Episcopalian battles over gay bishops, and the Presbyterian controversy over changing the names of the Holy Trinity come to mind as two current examples. Protestants have always been fighting among themselves, often over issues more fundamental than those which Catholics fight over. And I have no idea what the remark about killing someone and justifying it refers to. No good Catholic would do such a thing! Protestants have been responsible for their share of blood in history. In Elizabethan England, simply being a Catholic was a capital crime, and many Catholics were martyred for their Faith. And the most massive witchunts were conducted by Protestants. [quote]I could use myself as a case study but instead, how about you just go look at all the slutty girls at the local Catholic school? Something must not be getting through.[/quote] What's the point here? Because Catholics can choose to sin, the Church must be wrong? Many "Catholic" schools nowadays do a piss-poor job of teaching the Catholic Faith, and even in good Catholic schools, people can rebel. And are Catholic school girls really sluttier than girls at other schools, or is this just stereotyping? This is a non-argument. [quote]Have you ever sinned? I'm guessing yes. Jesus was divine and we are mortal. An oval can't just be a circle. [/quote] I have no clue what the point of that statement is. [quote]Saints come about because they got along with the papacy. A lot of it's a big political game and that's what I hate. There have been past instances of papal votes being swayed with money (I'm thinking late medieval here, help me out). Then the pope basically chooses the saints. [/quote] If your friend would actually bother reading the lives of the saints, he would see that they are made saints because they lived lives of exceptional holiness. Many saints lived lives of complete poverty, and could not have been chosen because they were big donors to the Papacy or anything. That is complete nonsense. Others had fall-outs with the pope (on issues other than dogma). Saint Catherine of Siena comes to mind, who repremanded the Pope for holding office in Avignon. And as saints are canonized usually long after their deaths, and so are almost never canonized by a pope who reigned in their lifetime, this argument is even more absurd. [quote]Then there are the people who have deserved so much recognition within the churches and don't get it. Philip Augustus, for instance, had a tremendous impact upon Catholicism's hold in Western Europe and he made its dominant force a strictly Catholic one. Richard I actually managed to hold a less violent Crusade! However, since they both had fallouts with the pope... [/quote] People are canonized for the personal holiness of their lives, not for political achievement. Not every "good Catholic" is canonized a saint. [quote]Let's see... England: rocky relationship ending in a big, nasty (yet I suppose understandable) divorce France: placed under interdict during the reign of its great ruler Holy Roman Empire: the pope claimed supremacy over it, which was totally inappropriate Austria-Hungary: since the Habsburgs held the Holy Roman throne, the papacy interefered with them for a while too Poland: they didn't really communicate much but ironically, that worked in the Poles' favour (i.e. never held an inquisition, never crusaded) Over the Papal States and the Vatican, of course. It's not directly an issue now but neither is the Russian Empire, and many of the defining characteristics of the Tsars are evident in current Russia. (Sorry to use the Tsars as an example, seeing as they were in a sense the ultimate enemies of Catholicism) Institutions are built upon principles that don't really go away and interferene is one that tends to apply to the papacy.[/quote] More political issues essentially unrelated to papal authority as understood by the Church. [quote]The idea of someone telling me how to live my life doesn't appeal to me because I feel that I can be a good, moral person without having to perpetually fear being smitten by celestial wrath if I make a mistake. [/quote] While I don't personally know your friend, I strongly suspect, this is his real problem with the Church. He doesn't like the Church "telling him how to live his life. " He probably disagrees with the Church on some moral issue/s, and is trying to come up with justifications for why he doesn't have to follow the Church. This is the case with most "fallen-away Catholics." His "arguments" are weak and fallacious, and he does not appear to be honestly seeking the truth. I'd say he needs prayers, and perhaps his real problems with the Church need to be honestly addressed. (Not bogus historical issues concerning medieval kings and such.) Edited June 25, 2006 by Socrates
N/A Gone Posted June 25, 2006 Author Posted June 25, 2006 hmm, this political talk is annoying... --------------------------------------------------------------- [quote]Catholic kingdoms did execute non-Catholics. Protestant kingdoms did execute Catholics. Should religions encourage vengeance for ancient feuds or reconciliation?Read Catholic Church documents from any time in history, and you won't find the voice of a bloodthirsty religion. In fact, the Papal letters that you do find will often criticize Catholic kings who persecute minorities. This happens with regard to Jews, native Americans (non-Christian), and African slaves, to name a few groups.[/quote] It tended to be the other way around. There was a whole event called the Papal Inquisition for one, which was largely a France-based thing. As for persecuting Jews and Africans, it is well documented that Jews co-existed with the Central Europeans very easily and that early Africans were basically not persecuted at all until colonization began (they had extensive trade with the Byzantines before that and Northern/Western Europeans found them interesting, not offensive). While I agree that the Catholic church has generally not been all that bloodthirsty, the letters from Gregory VII to Henry IV say otherwise, as do the ones from Innocent III to Philip Augustus. That's a while back though. More recently, the church made no real outcry about the Holocaust, even when there is evidence of a Catholic cardinal walking with Hitler through a camp and Poles, Hungarians and Croatians (i.e. members of their own church) were being persecuted. I'm not attacking the church here, just pointing out that it's never been perfect. ----------------------------------- oyoy, thoughts?
Socrates Posted June 25, 2006 Posted June 25, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1011952' date='Jun 25 2006, 12:04 PM'] hmm, this political talk is annoying... --------------------------------------------------------------- It tended to be the other way around. There was a whole event called the Papal Inquisition for one, which was largely a France-based thing. As for persecuting Jews and Africans, it is well documented that Jews co-existed with the Central Europeans very easily and that early Africans were basically not persecuted at all until colonization began (they had extensive trade with the Byzantines before that and Northern/Western Europeans found them interesting, not offensive). While I agree that the Catholic church has generally not been all that bloodthirsty, the letters from Gregory VII to Henry IV say otherwise, as do the ones from Innocent III to Philip Augustus. That's a while back though. More recently, the church made no real outcry about the Holocaust, even when there is evidence of a Catholic cardinal walking with Hitler through a camp and Poles, Hungarians and Croatians (i.e. members of their own church) were being persecuted. I'm not attacking the church here, just pointing out that it's never been perfect. ----------------------------------- oyoy, thoughts? [/quote] It's really unclear who you're quoting or what you're trying to say here, but the whole thing about the Church being "silent" on the holocaust, or complacent or even supportive of the Nazis is a recent anti-Catholic myth, contrary to the facts of history. Pope Pius XII did speak out against the Nazi holocaust, and was active in harboring and protecting Jews from the Nazis. In fact, many Jewish leaders and Jewish organizations at the time praised the Pope for his actions during the Holocaust. There was no serious criticism of him regarding the Jews until the 1960s. [url="http://www.catholicleague.org/pius/framemain.htm"]HERE'S A GREAT LIST OF RESOURCES ON THIS TOPIC.[/url] Good short article here: [url="http://www.catholicleague.org/pius/piusxii_faqs.html"]Frequently Asked Questions About Pope Pius XII and the Holocaust[/url] Edited June 25, 2006 by Socrates
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 25, 2006 Posted June 25, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='1012050' date='Jun 25 2006, 04:54 PM'] It's really unclear who you're quoting or what you're trying to say here, but the whole thing about the Church being "silent" on the holocaust, or complacent or even supportive of the Nazis is a recent anti-Catholic myth, contrary to the facts of history. Pope Pius XII did speak out against the Nazi holocaust, and was active in harboring and protecting Jews from the Nazis. [url="http://www.catholicleague.org/pius/framemain.htm"]HERE'S A GREAT LIST OF RESOURCES ON THIS TOPIC.[/url] Good short article here: [url="http://www.catholicleague.org/pius/piusxii_faqs.html"]Frequently Asked Questions About Pope Pius XII and the Holocaust[/url] [/quote] :applause:
phatcatholic Posted June 28, 2006 Posted June 28, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='1012050' date='Jun 25 2006, 06:54 PM'] It's really unclear who you're quoting or what you're trying to say here, but the whole thing about the Church being "silent" on the holocaust, or complacent or even supportive of the Nazis is a recent anti-Catholic myth, contrary to the facts of history. Pope Pius XII did speak out against the Nazi holocaust, and was active in harboring and protecting Jews from the Nazis. In fact, many Jewish leaders and Jewish organizations at the time praised the Pope for his actions during the Holocaust. There was no serious criticism of him regarding the Jews until the 1960s. [url="http://www.catholicleague.org/pius/framemain.htm"]HERE'S A GREAT LIST OF RESOURCES ON THIS TOPIC.[/url] Good short article here: [url="http://www.catholicleague.org/pius/piusxii_faqs.html"]Frequently Asked Questions About Pope Pius XII and the Holocaust[/url] [/quote] this one has more articles actually, its the most comprehensive collection of articles on the subject that exists on the internet (note the link to pg. 2 at the very bottom) [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/344"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/344[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now