Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

avemaria40
Posted

A few questions on romance:

How can you tell the difference between infatuation and the genuine article?

What is your advice if it ends up long distance?

How does attraction play into love?


What's it like to date someone who doesn't share your Catholic Faith?


Thank you :)

Posted

It is best, if you are younger then 18 or 20 to just leave it as infatuation. When it is the real thing, you will not have to ask that question, you will know it. So slow down and just enjoy the friendship.
Long distance relationships are tough very tough. Again, why be so serious? If you are young enjoy this time. Don't get tied down too early in your life.
Attraction to the person is one of the first steps in falling in love. Whether it be their physical looks or that they make you laugh.
I say date whom ever you want. When you get closer to the marrying age that may come into the picture. I have dated out of my faith, and it really mattered little. It is nice to share your faith with others, and share your beliefs. Religion is a very personal issue, and many people practice no faith. It just was not a problem to me if I really liked the person. Before you marry you really need to iron alot of the issues out. I know that many on this board will disagree with me on this issue, but that is ok. I am only giving my opinion!

brendan1104
Posted

Remember, the most important thing in a relationship is authentic, true love. :)

Posted

[quote name='avemaria40' post='1015321' date='Jun 30 2006, 10:18 PM']How can you tell the difference between infatuation and the genuine article?[/quote]
There's no answer to this question that I could classify as exclusive to either infatuation nor to the "genuine aticle." It's really all about discernment, and trying not to get caught up in all the feelings that make up infatuation and precede real love. Time is the only indicator really...get to know that person, and I mean really get to know them, and if you still have the same feelings afterwards, I thik that's worth pursuing.


[quote name='avemaria40' post='1015321' date='Jun 30 2006, 10:18 PM']What is your advice if it ends up long distance?[/quote]
Patience, trust, and understanding. You need all three of those in order to be able to maintain a long distance relationship. They're not easy. And the longer you're in it, the harder it gets. You have to be willing to make sacrifices. But they do work.


[quote name='avemaria40' post='1015321' date='Jun 30 2006, 10:18 PM']How does attraction play into love?[/quote]
Sometimes attractions comes first. Sometimes it's the result of the love you have for that person. Sometimes it's both, and your attraction simply grows stronger as you love that person more and more. But don't think that attraction and love can't be separated. Attraction does not neccesarily equal love, nor does love neccesarily equal attraction. It's definitely a blessing to be attracted to the one you love...as well as a burden (chastity becomes more difficult the stronger the attraction).


[quote name='avemaria40' post='1015321' date='Jun 30 2006, 10:18 PM']What's it like to date someone who doesn't share your Catholic Faith?[/quote]
I have never dated someone who wasn't at least nominally Catholic. My impression is that it's not advisable to date someone who doesn't share your faith. If you're as into your faith as I am, it becomes difficult to find things in common when you don't share that. That said, don't date someone not of your faith if you think you can convert him. Missionary dating is a big N-O. it doesn't foster emotional growth and only serves to cause tension. If he happens to convert because of you, wonderful! But going into a relationship with that mindset is not conducive to a healthy relationship.


Hope that helped :idontknow:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

A few questions on romance:

How can you tell the difference between infatuation and the genuine article?

[color="#6666CC"]Time is the first indication. Infatuations don't last, and are usually more related to what you need, than who the other person actually is. Love is surprising. Infatuation is getting lost in the other, love is facing forward in the same direction.[/color]

What is your advice if it ends up long distance?
[color="#6633FF"]Pray about it, because unless you are already marrried, it can be very difficult.[/color]

How does attraction play into love?
[color="#6666CC"]You don't just decide to love an attractive person, rather a person becomes attractive to you because you love them.[/color]
What's it like to date someone who doesn't share your Catholic Faith?
Thank you :)

[color="#3333FF"]It depends.[/color]
[color="#6666CC"]For me at this point, I am more interested in a man's character and heart than if he is catholic. When I was young, it was more important that I marry a catholic.[/color]

Posted

Right now I admire girl because of her innocense. She shared with me some things in her life she has never done, in my opinion she has done nothing really in her sixteen years that is really sinful.

I see her as a person who can help me grow closer to God. We're establishing a friendship, we're going ot the movies, to mass, and being witnesses of the faith to others. She also encouraged me to enter the college seminary when I was doubting if i should enter right away. We have a relationship based on friendship. If God doesn't want me to be a pries I will know, and if she's still available she might be the one.

I leave it in God's hands. Pray, you shall know.

In Christ,

Ed L.

How can you tell the difference between infatuation and the genuine article?

I'm not really sure.

What is your advice if it ends up long distance?
The girl I speak of lives 25 minutes away from me. What do you classify as long distance? If it is meant to be, God will provide.

How does attraction play into love?
You should be attracted to someone who brings you to Christ and the Church.

Posted (edited)

Dating is a fascinating topic to me. Catholics seem to have all sorts of opinions on it and can't comes to a consensus on it except for the basics (be chaste, don't date for the sake of dating, etc.)

[quote]It is best, if you are younger then 18 or 20 to just leave it as infatuation. When it is the real thing, you will not have to ask that question, you will know it. So slow down and just enjoy the friendship.
Long distance relationships are tough very tough. Again, why be so serious? If you are young enjoy this time. Don't get tied down too early in your life.[/quote]
Since when is dating the opposite of having fun? :idontknow: Since when is anything the opposite of fun based on the fact that it's challenging?

[quote]How can you tell the difference between infatuation and the genuine article?[/quote]
I can't answer that, but I can tell you what won't give you the answer: you emotions. Don't get thrown by your emotions. If anything, use them to your advantage. Some of my most devoted prayer has been the result of intense emotions, both happy and sad. But falling in love is not the point of marriage, and it's very different from the[b] decision [/b] to love somebody. So, you probably won't know if it's the real thing until you've gotten to know the person for a while. Which, incidentally, causes you to fall in love anyway.*

Put another way, falling in love just isn't a huge deal. Finding your future spose is a huge deal.
Put another way, "Happy is a yuppie word."
Put another way, there's more to a good marriage than falling in love.

I'm probably doing a terrible job of explaining this. It's a lot more exciting than I can describe...I'm probably making it just sound all stale and boring!!

[quote]What is your advice if it ends up long distance?[/quote]
Umm, try to get the same wireless company as your significant other? That way you can call each other without using minutes. But do resist the urge to text message. I wish I had a better answer to that one.

[quote]How does attraction play into love?[/quote]
It's important to some extent. You need somebody who makes it obvious that he/she is bearing the image and likeness of God. And you also want somebody to remind you that you are ridiculously attractive. Because you are.
[quote]What's it like to date someone who doesn't share your Catholic Faith?[/quote]
Just be very very careful. Put the well-being of your soul first. You can take a stab at evangi-dating if you want, but again, THAT shouldn't be the point of the relationship. If you think the other person must change for the relationship to work, that's the time to stop the relationship.
[quote]Thank you[/quote]
Your welcome! ;)


*on that note, spend lots of time with Jesus, Mary, Joseph, and some saints. :D:

Edited by XIX
heavenseeker
Posted

[quote name='avemaria40' post='1015321' date='Jun 30 2006, 08:18 PM']
A few questions on romance:

How can you tell the difference between infatuation and the genuine article?

What is your advice if it ends up long distance?

How does attraction play into love?
What's it like to date someone who doesn't share your Catholic Faith?
Thank you :)
[/quote]
i wish i knew but im still a dateles wonder so im no help here.

let_go_let_God
Posted

[quote name='avemaria40' post='1015321' date='Jun 30 2006, 08:18 PM']
A few questions on romance:

How can you tell the difference between infatuation and the genuine article?

What is your advice if it ends up long distance?

How does attraction play into love?

What's it like to date someone who doesn't share your Catholic Faith?
Thank you :)
[/quote]

1) It takes a while to tell the difference between infatuatio and the real deal. I spent a long time infront of the Blessed Sacrament talking to God about my now fiancee before I could even stammer through those three little words. The big thing is to pray and discern, make sure you are following God's will before you act. I realize even in my own life, this is easier said than done.

2) Long distance, hehehe, my fiancee and I are currently 4 hours apart, 2 when I'm at school. It is tough, very tough. Simple things like talking on the phone or simple letters can be misconstrued because the simple contact you have between you and another person isn't exactly there like you are when you are in person. It takes a lot of paitence and trust to have a relationship over a long distance. If you are willing and committed, also leaving a lot of it up to God, I've found, dispite the hardships you can't really go wrong.

3) When asking this, ask yourself, "Do I love this person because of how they look, or because of who they are?" Attraction helps when you are getting to know a person because this is something that initially draws you to that person. However is it how they look that you love, or their personality, actions and just being them? Don't get me wrong how a person looks can play a factor, but sometimes and I've struggled with this, attraction can give the devil a way into temptation.

4) The last one, I can't really answer. Sorry.

5) Your welcome, hope I helped.

God bless-
LGLG

Posted

[quote name='let_go_let_God' post='1015770' date='Jul 1 2006, 02:48 PM']
2) Long distance, hehehe, my fiancee and I are currently 4 hours apart, 2 when I'm at school. It is tough, very tough. Simple things like talking on the phone or simple letters can be misconstrued because the simple contact you have between you and another person isn't exactly there like you are when you are in person. It takes a lot of paitence and trust to have a relationship over a long distance. If you are willing and committed, also leaving a lot of it up to God, I've found, dispite the hardships you can't really go wrong.
[/quote]
Amen :yes: My boyfriend and I live 12+ hours apart. It's hard, but worth it.

Posted

[quote name='avemaria40' post='1015321' date='Jun 30 2006, 09:18 PM']
A few questions on romance:

How can you tell the difference between infatuation and the genuine article?

What is your advice if it ends up long distance?

How does attraction play into love?
What's it like to date someone who doesn't share your Catholic Faith?
Thank you :)
[/quote]
A good priest once said that you can't say you're in love with someone until after about 18 months. Anything before that is just infatuation. In other words, don't rush into thinking yourself in love. Give it time. If it's real love, it will grow.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted (edited)

[quote name='avemaria40' post='1015321' date='Jun 30 2006, 09:18 PM']

What is your advice if it ends up long distance?[/quote]

I dated StColette for 11 months before we met. Distance relationships are tough and you have to be ready for the pain and angst that come with them. They sure are rewarding in the end, though. :)

[quote]How does attraction play into love?[/quote]

Attraction is a drive, like our drive of hunger or anything else. It only points us in a direction toward something we want to have. It's not bad, just like the drive for beauty isn't bad, but you have to evaluate it. In the case of beauty, for instance, you can be attracted to Monet's paintings or you can be attracted to some sort of disturbing modern performance art. You need to look at what you are attracted to and see it's what you're supposed to be attracted to. If it's not, then you probably need to adjust yourself to better appreciate true beauty (the more art reflects God, the more beautiful it is). The same goes for love. Ask yourself what you're attracted to...is it good looks, a good mind, virtue, etc., or is it the way they throw money around wastefully or the way they abuse power, etc.? That's not to say you can't love someone who has certain undesirable traits about them, but you don't want to love someone because of the evil in them, especially since this will make you less likely to want to change that evil into good (which you must try to do, because love desires the salvation of the beloved).

I'm attracted to Jennie because she's smart, makes me laugh, is very pretty, is extremely faithful, and is herself, genuinely herself. There are things that drive me nuts about her (hardly a day goes by that there isn't something that annoys me just a bit), but those aren't enough to make me not love her. My attraction points me toward her. Here's the part where love comes in: I have to decide whether or not to follow that attraction. I have to make the choice, everyday, every moment, whether I will love her or not.

Edited by Raphael
let_go_let_God
Posted

[quote name='azaelia' post='1015786' date='Jul 1 2006, 01:22 PM']
Amen :yes: My boyfriend and I live 12+ hours apart. It's hard, but worth it.
[/quote]

12+ hours :shock: wow, God bless you and your boyfriend.

God bless-
LGLG

Posted

[url=http://www.holyspiritinteractive.net/columns/guests/edwardpsri/lovenresponsibility.asp]good article: Love and Responsibility: Avoiding Fatal Attractions
by Edward P. Sri[/url]

Posted

I do the daisy method.

"He loves me, he loves me not .... etc."


That usually works.

avemaria40
Posted

Thank you so much :) You guys have given me awesome answers. Now, I just need to go to God and see what He wants through this. Again, thank you:)


LOL, I should have tried the daisy method, it would have made it so much simpler :lol_roll: :D:

Posted

What's it like to date someone who doesn't share your Catholic Faith?

Not impossible I think it depends of the situation and the person, I know a couple who the husband converted and now they have a cute little catholic family.
From my experience........ Its one of the hardest things ever.. I came 2 a point where I had to make a choice between God or the guy. Its hard 2 follow god when the person u r with doesnt.

later

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...