Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

stbernardLT
Posted

I got pumped up when I heard they had members of Motley Crue, GNR, and Metallica.
Tommy Lee is a good representation of Motley Crue, but Jason Newsted and Gilbey Clarke. Give me a break. That's like having Tito Jackson from the Jackson Five and the sound guy from the Temptations. These guys don't rock, they fell into fame with a band that was already rocking. It's like telling my son I'm going to buy him a horse and I show up with a donkey. There is a bit of a let down.

Posted

But Dave Navarro is in the show!


Nobody rocks like Dave.


Which may be a bit weird for me to say since I can't stand Jane's Addiction.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Yeah, but he's only the host. lol

In either case, I don't really care. The band doesn't really matter so much to me after the show is over, I just LIKE THE SHOW. lol

franciscanheart
Posted
:lol: same here.
DemonSlayer
Posted

How heavy is the band gonna be?

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I don't rightly know, they said it wasn't going to be metal, that it would be rock... if you watch sometimes they show clips of the 3 guys playing together, minus a lead singer, of course. lol I think alot of it depends on ho wheavy the lead singer is, ya know? There's one girl, I think her name was Dana? She was really young compared to the rest of them, and she had a really good voice (I thought), but I just didn't think she could cut it for ROCK. Then there was the creepy woman who sang the Nirvana song, and she was definately rock, but she was also rather dark so she'd probably be quite heavy. Then there was Jenny, the Nickleback girl, who was probably rock, but she was terribly offkey. Lukas, the guy who sang Rebel Yell (the last singer on the first episode) was definately rock, but not super heavy.... Storm, the first woman who sang, was rock, but not a heavy dark rock like the Nirvana lady, and she was awesome.

It comes on again tonight, you should watch and form your own opinion from that, I guess. lol

Posted

Was anyone else turned off by the producer proposing to that one chick? I thought her performance was sub-par. Used her sex appeal more than her voice, IMO.

I'm not seeing a Marty Casey sort of character yet (who I liked best on RS:INXS) buuuut then again, even he wasn't brilliant until a couple episodes in.

Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1018139' date='Jul 6 2006, 06:16 AM']Oh my word, and the woman who sung the Nirvana song... she was creeeepy. lol Not necessarily bad, just very odd, I couldn't really get into it when she was singing.[/quote]totally agree! what a creepy chick

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='ardent1' post='1021647' date='Jul 11 2006, 11:07 AM']
Was anyone else turned off by the producer proposing to that one chick? I thought her performance was sub-par. Used her sex appeal more than her voice, IMO.

I'm not seeing a Marty Casey sort of character yet (who I liked best on RS:INXS) buuuut then again, even he wasn't brilliant until a couple episodes in.
[/quote]


Yeah, that was really dumb I thought.

I really liked Marty, too. When it got to the end I was really hoping he'd win. One of the other things I really liked about him was that he was one of 6 kids... I guess it was sort of a big family bias. lol

Posted

Storm was last night? Dang stupid corporate jetsetting life!!!


Thank goodness for Tivo


Tonight's lineup

or should I say lameup...

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Its on right now. :) (I'm actually typing while I watch and posting when its done lol)

My thoughts, blow by blow so to speak:

Magni (the one from iceland): alot better this time, I think.

Jenny: still didn't like her

Jill (Mini Pam Anderson): still didn't like her either... I actually liked Jenny better, if you can believe it. And what is up with the fluffy skirt thing? The guys didn't like it so much either...

Zayra (marriage proposal girl): Did not like her performance at all tonigt, which is sad becase for some reason I like the idea of her, she LOOKS like she'd have flair and rock pretty well, but she's just not doing it for me. The guys totally put her down, and she dished it right back. MAJOR. lol I feel sorry for the people who missed that bit.

Chris (one of the guys from the bottom 3 last week): alot better than last week, I think, but still not spectacular, I don't think he's got very good range. (Man, the guys are on a roll this week, they weren't joking when they said they went easy on them last week and were going to be more tough on them this time...)

Dilana (creepy woman): sang Johnny Cash. interesting performer, but I still can't get into her performances, she's just too creepy, not as bad as last week, though. She was the first one they told was amazing so far tonight. (The didn't diss Jenny or Magni, but they didn't say they were amazing either.)

Josh (can/t think of anything interesting to say to describe him): sang "arms wide open"... not too shabby.

Phil (the pitchy guy): sang Tonic. I don't like the way he looks when he sings, last week they said they were afraid he didn't have a strong enough stage presence, I think they're right.... but he got alot of compliments, except from Jaon. lol

Storm: sang Cheap Trick. She is my Jordis this season. I think she is so awesome, strong voice, great performer. But Dave dissed her a little. SHAME ON HIM!

Patrice (she was the other chick I liked last week): sang Nirvana, she did well, liked her again. She got alot of compliments.

Lukas (Rebel Yell guy, last singer from last week): Did not like him AT ALL this week. He's got to lose that copper eye shadow, too. He's got a funny hsaped face or something and that just makes him look even weirder. Change it up, man. He got mixed reviews.

Ryan (the philosophy major guy): I didn't care for him last week... he sang The Rolling Stones this week... I think it suited him more than Iris did last week, but I'm still not a fan yet. Adrienne told me he was dirty and needed to take a bath... guess that doesn't say much for his appearance. lol

Dana (the girl I didn't think rocked enough): sang Born to be Wild... not half bad, a little harder this week, but I'm still not cinvinced she can hack it. Tommy totally dissed her, but I thought she was way better than last week.

Toby (australian guy): I thought he was pretty decent last week, not so much this week... I dunno, I didn;t think he was bad, I just didn't dig it so much, maybe it was the song. Definately harder than alot of the other performers. The guys really liked him.

My prediction: Next episode bottom 3: Chris, Zayra, and either Jilll or Phil...

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1022136' date='Jul 11 2006, 08:56 PM']
Storm was last night? Dang stupid corporate jetsetting life!!!
Thank goodness for Tivo
Tonight's lineup

or should I say lameup...
[/quote]

Yeah, thank goodness for Tivo because you just missed it. Its just now going off. lol

Posted

Dave dissed Storm??



I'm sooo conflicted now...

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

He said that he felt like she had bits of Broadway in her performance, that she needed to be herself and not play a character.

Posted

I don't have a TV so I haven't watched (and probably wouldn't watch it anyway :) ) but the creepy girl is from Houston and in the local paper they had a big right up on her today.

I've talked with some who have seen her perform live and they say that in addition to the creepy hard rock side she also has a sensitive, tender side.

Time will tell I guess.

Enjoy the show!

Posted

[img]http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c44/jaime9265/icebabystorm.gif[/img]


Rockstar Supernova 2020

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

That looks nothing like Genevieve. :P:

mariahLVzJP2
Posted

Zayra has the best hair style. her first performance was nuts, but i missed it last night, darn.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1022727' date='Jul 12 2006, 09:11 AM']
That looks nothing like Genevieve. :P:
[/quote]

And another thing... what is wrong with her ears??? lol

Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1022903' date='Jul 12 2006, 11:16 AM']
And another thing... what is wrong with her ears??? lol
[/quote]

That's not nice to make fun of your baby girl!!

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

The elimination show is starting. :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...