Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Ratzinger Contra Anselm


Recommended Posts

Justified Saint
Posted (edited)

Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, [i]Introduction to Christianity[/i] (San Fransico: Ignatius Press, 2004), 230-234:

Ratzinger begins this section (Christology and the Doctrine of Redemption) with a lament of sorts: that christology and soteriology, in the historical development of the church, have “visibly parted company.” It is unclear whether he attributes this separation between the work and person of Jesus as caused by Anselm's theory of redemption, or if Anselm's treatise is simply an effect and example of a larger phenomena.

Ratzinger now proceeds to summarize Anselm's theory and provide a critique, presumably in service of his larger aim to reunite what has been driven apart (i.e. the inseparability of the work and person of Jesus). He remarks that the “classical” version of the satisfaction theory is not without “one-sideness,” but he seems to make clear that he is considering the theory in its “vulgarized” form which appears “cruelly mechanical and less and less feasible.”

“Anselm of Canterbury had been concerned to deduce the work of Christ by a train of necessary reasons ([i]rationibus necesssariis[/i]) and thus to show irrefutably that this work [i]had[/i] to happen in the precise way in which it in fact did.”

Ratzinger then claims to be summarizing the “main lines of [Anselm's] argument.” His presentation thus centers around the infinite debt that man incurs by sinning against God, the infinite Being. This entails a violation of rights which must be restored. However, while man can “offend infintely...he cannot produce an infinite reparation.”

“Anselm moves on to the figure of Christ. His answer runs thus: God himself removes the injustice; not (as he could have done) by simple amnesty, which cannot after all overcome from inside what has happened, but through another expedient: the infinite Being himself becomes man and then as a man – who belongs to the race of the offenders yet possesses the power, denied to man, of infinite reparation – makes the required expiation. Thus the redemption takes place entirely through grace and at the same time entirely as restoration of the right. Anselm thought he had thereby given a compelling answer to the difficult question of 'Cur Deus homo?', the wherefore of the Incarnation and the Cross.”

He next notes the decisiveness this theory has had on the rest of Christian consciousness since Anselm and that it has largely been taken for granted that Christ had to die on the cross. Ratzinger then affirms the basic truths behind this theory that seem rather biblical. He adds “And who could fail to see that thus in the schematization of the 'satisfaction' theory the breath of the biblical idea of election remains clear, the idea that makes election, not a privilege of the elected, but the call to live for others?”

He continues, “But even if all this is admitted, it cannot be denied, on the other hand, that the perfectly logical divine-[i]cum[/i]-human legal system erected by Anselm distorts the perspectives and with its rigid logic can make the image of God appear in a sinister light.”

Ratzinger concludes by reaffirming the need to not divorce the work of Jesus from the person of Jesus, a divorce which we would be led to believe is the net effect of Anselm's theory.

Edited by Justified Saint
Justified Saint
Posted

Some inital reactions:

It is important to note that Ratzinger, as a student of hermeneutics, does not make the "intentional fallacy", though I think Jeff in another thread has. In other words, the distinction between what Anselm "actually meant/intended" and how he has been (mis)interpreted is either a false distinction or mostly irrelevant (or both). Ratzinger's ability to even speak of a "classical" and "vulgarized" version of Anselm already suggests his understanding of the fallacy for these immediately indicate the historicity of interpretation. Thus even the "vulgar" Anselm is still Anselm's "answer" and "system."

That said, I believe Jeff's sentiments expressed elsewhere are largely true, the pope is addressing a certain, popular way in which Anselm has been interpreted, though it leaves much wonder at how a better, perhaps more consistent interpretation could yield such polar opposites. Ratzinger seems to leave little hope for a reconstructed Anselm, but perhaps this is only because it remained outside of the concern of his present work.

Did Ratzinger miss something? Could Anselm himself be the cure for the satisfaction theory and the division of Jesus?

Posted

My money's on Ratzinger. :)

Posted

Poor Anselm, first he his 'deconstructed' by Aquinas in the proofs for God. Now he is being critiqued by BXVI. Our theology is designed to be built upon.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

First and foremost, I would like to thank Justified Saint for the time and work he has put into this. My response to his previous post was rather short and crude and, rather than responding in kind, he has charitably given his best effort to clarify. So I want to say thank you, JS.

Now, with regards to content: Justified Saint has done a very good job pointing out that the Holy Father is mainly criticizing the vulgarized form of atonement theory, which is a criticism that (in my humble opinion) St. Anselm would have readily agreed with. Moreover, then Cardinal Ratzinger's remark concerning the "one-sidedness" of the "classical" or actual Anselmian argument is not without some truth. In large part Anselm's [i]argument[/i] focuses on the concept of debt, satisfaction, and atonement, and, if one chooses to focus exclusively on the argument without reference to his conclusion, it would most certainly (and truly) appear one-sided.

However, as I said before, a deeper analysis of Anselm's solution to the problem of atonement offers us a way out of this "one-sidedness" and, in my mind, actually does in fact accomplish the reconciliation of Christology and Soteriology desired by the Holy Father, because for Anselm, atonement is not found in Christ's act of dying, but rather, atonement is to be found in the [i]person[/i] of Christ, or, in his life. What man "owes" to God is nothing more than his own happiness: an upright will in perfect communion with God. This upright man is the person of Jesus Christ. For Anselm's theory, Christ's death on the cross is significant because it is the crowning act of obedience. In the crucifixion, Christ showed that his will was upright and obedient from start to finish, and that not even death on a cross could cause him to forsake his upright will. What many people miss with regards to Anselm's theory is that Christ's crucifixion is not, [i]qualitatively[/i], a more redeeming act than, say, the act of preaching the Sermon on the Mount. For Anselm, we find our redemption in every single moment of Christ's life, not in one particular action, because what is "owed" to God is not a particular action, but a way of life - a life in communion with Him. The crucifixion is the final act in that saving life, but it is the [i]life[/i] that is of primary importance for St. Anselm. Thus, I think that we could gain much from adopting a more pure Anselmian understanding of Soteriology, precisely because, when it is properly understood, it is intricately tied to Christology.

Just as a final comment, I would like to respond to the accusation of commiting the intentional fallacy. If there was, in fact, one way that Anselm has been "interpreted" over the years, then the accusation would be perfectly valid. However, this is not the case, since there are, and have been for a number of years, conflicting depictions of Anselm. There is the proto-Thomist Anselm, according to which his soteriology acts as a precurser to (and looks forward towards) the soteriology of Aquinas. There is the Augustinian Anselm, according to which Anselm's soteriology is firmly in line with the Augustinian tradition, and was, in fact, continued upon and built upon by St. Bonaventure, Duns Scotus, and the Franciscan School. There is the Innovative-Anselm, according to which the Anselmian soteriology marks a radical break from tradition and the ECF; and, finally, there is the proto-Calvanist Anselm (the "vulgarized" Anselm above) according to which Anselm's soteriology marks the shift of emphasis towards the legalist interpretation.

In light of the fact that there are numerous different interpretations, and there is not, nor has there historically ever been, "one interpretation" of Anselm's thought, it is quite impossible to commit the intentional fallacy. If I have committed any fallacies, my mistake has been in assuming a degree of knowledge and familiarity with Anselm's thought that simply cannot be expected on an online message board, and for that, I humbly apologize.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Guest JeffCR07
Posted (edited)

PS, I really enjoy these discussions, Justified Saint, and I hope I'm not coming off as too pompous or all-knowing. I'm constantly writing argumentative-style papers for school, and its hard for me to get out of that way of writing. But you should know that I really respect you and enjoy these discussions, even if we are on "opposite sides" (if we even are?).

Also, to everyone who might be reading this discussion (if anyone actually is) I hope I made it sufficiently clear in my above post that I do not think there is much of a "Ratzinger Contra Anselm" at all.

Oh, and to jswranch, don't worry about Anselm, his thought is tough enough to stand up to scrutiny. Plus, Aquinas' critique was pretty weak, and if you do everything you possibly can to strengthen it, you end up with a critique of the argument that Anselm would ultimately agree with, and that, in his mind, does not take away from the effectiveness of the argument. :D:

Edited by phatcatholic
Justified Saint
Posted

Jeff,

I would also like to thank you for your patient, charitable response which shows a clear understanding of the topic. I too appreciate these discussions despite the unequal distribution of knowledge on the issue (that is meant as a compliment :)) You don't come off as pompous or all-knowing, though you do come off as erudite and resolute since you know what you are talking about, certainly a good thing by all accounts.

In his book, Ratzinger goes on to flesh out a more complete picture of his attempt to reunite the work and person of Jesus, an attempt that is remarkable on its own and, on your account, doesn't sound too much different from what Anselm was attempting. That is rather interesting and ironic.

As to the intentional fallacy, I did not mean to dwell on it and it seems like a moot point. However, I think you are mistaken in your characterization of it. It seems to me that it is exactly a plurality of interpretations that would make the intentional fallacy that much more tempting. "All of these different versions of the author's work, why don't we just find out what he really meant and settle the matter?" It is a fallacy to appeal to the author's "true" intentions since that either presupposes that the author's intentions are readily apparent or that they should have some special, epistemic status. A vareity of interpretations could just mean that a bunch of thinkers and schools think they know what the author "really intended", or it could not. In any case it is irrelevant since I thought you committed the fallacy by appealing to what Anselm "really intended". The best way to vindicate Anselm isn't to uncover his true intentions, that is biography, but rather to give him a good reading.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1018275' date='Jul 6 2006, 10:10 AM']
Jeff,

I would also like to thank you for your patient, charitable response which shows a clear understanding of the topic. I too appreciate these discussions despite the unequal distribution of knowledge on the issue (that is meant as a compliment :)) You don't come off as pompous or all-knowing, though you do come off as erudite and resolute since you know what you are talking about, certainly a good thing by all accounts.

In his book, Ratzinger goes on to flesh out a more complete picture of his attempt to reunite the work and person of Jesus, an attempt that is remarkable on its own and, on your account, doesn't sound too much different from what Anselm was attempting. That is rather interesting and ironic.

As to the intentional fallacy, I did not mean to dwell on it and it seems like a moot point. However, I think you are mistaken in your characterization of it. It seems to me that it is exactly a plurality of interpretations that would make the intentional fallacy that much more tempting. "All of these different versions of the author's work, why don't we just find out what he really meant and settle the matter?" It is a fallacy to appeal to the author's "true" intentions since that either presupposes that the author's intentions are readily apparent or that they should have some special, epistemic status. A vareity of interpretations could just mean that a bunch of thinkers and schools think they know what the author "really intended", or it could not. In any case it is irrelevant since I thought you committed the fallacy by appealing to what Anselm "really intended". The best way to vindicate Anselm isn't to uncover his true intentions, that is biography, but rather to give him a good reading.
[/quote]

My intent was not to say "this isn't what Anselm said, so problem solved" but rather, to point out that none of these interpretations adequately reflect the subtlety of Anselm's actual thought, which, in fact, provides a deeper, more penetrating, more accurate, and more fulfilling account of soteriology and christology than any of the subsequent interpretations. I was not simply trying to establish the historical Anselm, but also to point out that the historical Anselm has a superior contribution to thought than the common interpretations.

And don't sell yourself short. Your comments have been both insightful and penetrating, and I think that your questions, more than my snide answers, are what really make these boards, and those that read them, better.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1018210' date='Jul 6 2006, 09:50 AM']
However, as I said before, a deeper analysis of Anselm's solution to the problem of atonement offers us a way out of this "one-sidedness" and, in my mind, actually does in fact accomplish the reconciliation of Christology and Soteriology desired by the Holy Father, because for Anselm, atonement is not found in Christ's act of dying, but rather, atonement is to be found in the [i]person[/i] of Christ, or, in his life. What man "owes" to God is nothing more than his own happiness: an upright will in perfect communion with God. This upright man is the person of Jesus Christ. For Anselm's theory, Christ's death on the cross is significant because it is the crowning act of obedience. In the crucifixion, Christ showed that his will was upright and obedient from start to finish, and that not even death on a cross could cause him to forsake his upright will. What many people miss with regards to Anselm's theory is that Christ's crucifixion is not, [i]qualitatively[/i], a more redeeming act than, say, the act of preaching the Sermon on the Mount. For Anselm, we find our redemption in every single moment of Christ's life, not in one particular action, because what is "owed" to God is not a particular action, but a way of life - a life in communion with Him. The crucifixion is the final act in that saving life, but it is the [i]life[/i] that is of primary importance for St. Anselm. Thus, I think that we could gain much from adopting a more pure Anselmian understanding of Soteriology, precisely because, when it is properly understood, it is intricately tied to Christology.

[/quote]

Wow jeff, its great to see how you (and Anselm) bring everything back together. The free will, the uprightness of will, Christ obedient to the cross. I bet Anselm makes these points somewhere, but sometimes (at least for me) its too easy to get caught up in the little stuff and miss the big picture of how everything fits in together. Outstanding!

phatcatholic
Posted

Jeff.............how did u come to learn so much about Anselm? btw, what school do u go to? what do you plan to do w/ ur degree?

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

Phat, it all started because I took a Contemporary Philosophy class my sophomore year and I focused on a discussion concerning the Ontological Argument. That lead me to actually get a copy of the [i]Prosologion[/i], and then I got his complete works. Since then I've been in email contact off and on with a couple current Anselm scholars, and I've just been doing a lot of reading on my own. If anyone is interested in reading some current Anselmian scholarship, the "Saint Anselm Journal" is good, though in my humble opinion some articles are better than others - Professor Katherine Rogers is particularly good, though I differ with her on some points.

I'll be a senior at Dickinson College (yea, its a secular school) and I'm double majoring in Philosophy and Religion. I'm currently seriously discerning a vocation to the Dominicans (particularly in St. Joseph's Province), so I guess that is what I want to "do" with my degree. I'd like to teach, if that is what God is calling me to do. :D:

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Justified Saint
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1018332' date='Jul 6 2006, 10:45 AM']
My intent was not to say "this isn't what Anselm said, so problem solved" but rather, to point out that none of these interpretations adequately reflect the subtlety of Anselm's actual thought, which, in fact, provides a deeper, more penetrating, more accurate, and more fulfilling account of soteriology and christology than any of the subsequent interpretations. I was not simply trying to establish the historical Anselm, but also to point out that the historical Anselm has a superior contribution to thought than the common interpretations.

And don't sell yourself short. Your comments have been both insightful and penetrating, and I think that your questions, more than my snide answers, are what really make these boards, and those that read them, better.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff
[/quote]

I think we might be operating from different definitions/assumptions. I would say what you are doing is making a good interpretation. But again, let bygones be bygones.

Thank you for the compliment, but your comments are far from snide (even if they may seem a little so at first :))

Speaking of Anselm and the ontological "proof", you may find [url="http://percaritatem.blogspot.com/2006/06/anselm-kant-and-what-to-do-with.html"]this[/url] discussion of particular use/interest. I have been reading some of the comments (particularly the first one is striking), but then it gets a little too analytical for me. :)

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

She gives a pretty straightforward account of Anselm's argument. The person who posted that it is merely a prayer is, in my humble opinion, making the same error that Karl Barth makes, namely, that of anachronism. Anselm wrote before the Thomistic distinction between theology and philosophy. In his mind, and in the Augustinian tradition, theology and philosophy are intertwined precisely because the object under consideration is man in the concrete. Given the fact that these two were not formally distinguished, it is irrelevant that the argument occurs in the context of the prayer. Just as St. Bonaventure can be considered as a philosopher, though he in fact denied the distinction between theology and philosophy, so too with Anselm. The fact that Anselm's argument can be found within an inner dialogue with God only reflects the deep concern that Anselm, as will most Augustinians, had with man in the concrete.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Justified Saint
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1019352' date='Jul 7 2006, 12:07 PM']
She gives a pretty straightforward account of Anselm's argument. The person who posted that it is merely a prayer is, in my humble opinion, making the same error that Karl Barth makes, namely, that of anachronism. Anselm wrote before the Thomistic distinction between theology and philosophy. In his mind, and in the Augustinian tradition, theology and philosophy are intertwined precisely because the object under consideration is man in the concrete. Given the fact that these two were not formally distinguished, it is irrelevant that the argument occurs in the context of the prayer. Just as St. Bonaventure can be considered as a philosopher, though he in fact denied the distinction between theology and philosophy, so too with Anselm. The fact that Anselm's argument can be found within an inner dialogue with God only reflects the deep concern that Anselm, as will most Augustinians, had with man in the concrete.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff
[/quote]

Do you then find the author's distinction between the "scholastic" Anselm and the Augustinian Anselm ill-founded (i.e. The [i]Proslogion[/i] vs The [i]Monologion[/i])?

I didn't see the author's comment as anachronistic since it was correcting an anachronism (i.e. Descartes).

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1019753' date='Jul 7 2006, 11:09 PM']
Do you then find the author's distinction between the "scholastic" Anselm and the Augustinian Anselm ill-founded (i.e. The [i]Proslogion[/i] vs The [i]Monologion[/i])?

I didn't see the author's comment as anachronistic since it was correcting an anachronism (i.e. Descartes).
[/quote]

Not only do I find such a distinction to be "ill-founded" - I find it to be [i]unfounded[/i]. Granted in order to really get into it, we would need to know precisely what the author means by "scholastic" and "Augustinian" but the fact remains that if we are engaging in common-use of such words, there are a great number of Augustinians who were scholastics. Moreover, there was a period of 100-200 years (depending on when you mark the beginning of "scholasticism" in which Augustinians were the [i]only[/i] scholastics. To say that one is either an Augustinian or a Scholastic would certainly come as a shock to Anselm (who can be considered the founder of Scholasticism), along with Hugh of St. Victor, William of Auvergne, Robert Grosseteste, Alexander of Hales, and St. Bonaventure. Scholasticism and Augustinianism are not mutually exclusive schools, and, as such, to make a "distinction" between an Augustinian Anselm and a Scholastic Anselm, is, in my mind, to be unfamiliar with Anselmian thought.

If you will permit me to offer an alternative view (hopefully without sounding too pompous): First, it is my opinion that Anselm can be firmly placed within the Augustinian School. Moreover, I think that Anselm can be considered the great systematizer of Augustine. Anselm is to Augustine as Proclus is to Plotinus. Now, I do think that we can consider Anselm an innovator as well, but this innovation (in my mind) consists only in where he [i]went further[/i] than the thought of Augustine, and not in some sort of contradicting of Augustine. Moreover, the innovative aspects of Anselmian thought are not "scholastic" elements. Rather, Anselm's whole method could be considered "scholastic" or, perhaps, "proto-scholastic."

In essence, Anselm is a scholastic in form and an Augustinian in content, who was also a mind great enough to systematize Augustine's thought and move beyond the letter of what Augustine wrote in order to grasp the conclusions that logically follow.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Oh, and with regards to the [i]Prosologion[/i] vs. the [i]Monologion[/i] as being examples of a "scholastic" vs. an "augustinian" Anselm, I think that the author is confusing Anselmian originality (the [i]Prosologion[/i]) with scholasticism. There is nothing (or at least very little) markedly scholastic in the [i]Prosologion[/i] that is not also present in the [i]Monologion[/i]. It is true that the latter acts as a systematization of Augustinian natural theology (though it too, has a good bit of originality in thought), but the [i]Prosologion[/i] can be seen as simply a systematization of the arguments in the [i]Monologion[/i], so I do not see how you can have a marked change in kind from the one to the other. Is there more orginal thought in the [i]Prosologion[/i]? Yes. Does that place it within a different philosophical "school"? No. Moreover, as I mentioned above, I do not think the "schools" of scholasticism and augustinianism are incompatible to begin with, so I also reject the premise.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...