Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Ok let me preface this by saying this thread does not have to do anything with my other post. when i was an Athiest i was on the extreme end of sucidal, but i could never bring myself to do it. i thought of it as a cowards way out, but i would have constant fantasies about it like 24/7 to the point where i would dream about death (ya my life sucked that bad). after reading some of my old stuff here is the question i thought it would be good to ask. have you ever had a fantasy about death or sucide and more importantly what kept you going so you didn't do it?

Posted

[size=1][color="FF6699"]I have thought about it, but not in the same way other people have.
I have always wondered why I was so afraid of suicide, to even dream about doing it scared me.
But I do know why people would think it is such a saving grace...
Depression is a disorder. So people with that type of disorder cant think straight anymore.
It is unatural, I think, to want to die.

I have always seen it as dark and scary.
So MOW....

I dunno.
Its not a cool thing...
[/color][/size]

TridentineMotoX
Posted

I've never wanted to die. I'm scared of dieing, scared of God. I like my freinds and my family, I wish it would never change. :ohno:

Posted

I too was an atheist at one point (8th through mid 9th grade, I'm going into 11th now) or rather, a "Lestatist" as I found it enjoyable to compare myself to Anne Rice's Lestat character in the Vampire Chronicles. I was also overweight, self-concious, and severely depressed. I was a self-mutilator and considered suicide on more than one occasion. It's a terrible and frightening thing. Two things happened that stopped me from finally getting fed up with my life and ending it. The first was that I met the love of my life and current boyfriend of a year and four months as next Sunday. The second, was that with my boyfriend's encouragement, I began to study Wicca and continue to this day, which has given me a great deal of joy. And now it's even better, as we have agreed to study one another's faiths...which is why I'm here. :D

Pontifite 7 of 10
Posted

Congrates on converting! You converts ROCK! I haven't considered suicide... exept one time because I didn't want to do homework, but I wasn't serious not like you guys.

God the Father
Posted

[quote name='Pontifite 7 of 10' post='1020625' date='Jul 9 2006, 05:43 PM']
I haven't considered suicide... exept one time because I didn't want to do homework,
[/quote]

We should found a support group.

Proud2BCatholic139
Posted

I beleive my faith saved me from suicidal thoughts.

Posted

[quote name='Lahecil' post='1020603' date='Jul 9 2006, 02:51 PM']
I too was an atheist at one point (8th through mid 9th grade, I'm going into 11th now) or rather, a "Lestatist" as I found it enjoyable to compare myself to Anne Rice's Lestat character in the Vampire Chronicles. I was also overweight, self-concious, and severely depressed. I was a self-mutilator and considered suicide on more than one occasion. It's a terrible and frightening thing. Two things happened that stopped me from finally getting fed up with my life and ending it. The first was that I met the love of my life and current boyfriend of a year and four months as next Sunday. The second, was that with my boyfriend's encouragement, I began to study Wicca and continue to this day, which has given me a great deal of joy. And now it's even better, as we have agreed to study one another's faiths...which is why I'm here. :D
[/quote]I also had a facination with vampires and actually knows quite a bit about demonology. i was never a cutter though i did scar myself (a phoenix) though thank God it it has faded so you cant see it. but i did other things, i had my tongue pierced, and I pierced my own ears and my labret. i have sense removed them though my ears will never close (i pierced with a 10 gauge). i don't relate the two things though (piercing and sucide), my motivation to live was only that i didnt want to be seen as a coward. I loved my piercings and would still wear them (except my labret) but i feel its something i need to leave behind.


[quote name='Proud2BCatholic139' post='1020777' date='Jul 9 2006, 08:14 PM']
I beleive my faith saved me from suicidal thoughts.
[/quote]
Almost, Its not quite your Faith as their are good solid Catholics who have suicidal thoughts but its Grace that has saved you from all things.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Suicide is a bad permanent answer to a temporary problem. Life does change, so such a permanent
solution is not advisable.
Tomorrow or even next week CAN be a better life, if you want it to be.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1020824' date='Jul 9 2006, 10:02 PM']
Suicide is a bad permanent answer to a temporary problem. Life does change, so such a permanent
solution is not advisable.
Tomorrow or even next week CAN be a better life, if you want it to be.
[/quote]
If it were only that true... we all have our crosses to carry, i experienced what is refered to as the dark night of the soul. i was raised protestant but given many graces by God, for example the church i was in did not believe in the real presence yet i did. i would also pray for 3 to 4 hours at a time and held many (what i have now discovered to be) Catholic ideas that my church did not teach. my dark night lasted a very very long time and i dispaired not because i wanted to but because there was no one to show me another way. but as for your comment on a permanent answer to a temporary question i heard something once that i think is fitting.

a therapist surveyed 100 survivors who jumped form the golden gate bridge one third of the way down they all came to the conclusions that all the problems in their lives, everyone really wasnt that bad, and they could ALL be fix, except one: they had jumped from a bridge and were plumiting to their death.

Posted

[quote name='pyranima' post='1020508' date='Jul 9 2006, 11:18 AM']
Ok let me preface this by saying this thread does not have to do anything with my other post. when i was an Athiest i was on the extreme end of sucidal, but i could never bring myself to do it. i thought of it as a cowards way out, but i would have constant fantasies about it like 24/7 to the point where i would dream about death (ya my life sucked that bad). after reading some of my old stuff here is the question i thought it would be good to ask. have you ever had a fantasy about death or sucide and more importantly what kept you going so you didn't do it?
[/quote]

I've never had this problum. I've never had the scent of death constantly re-accuring in my mind or haunting my dreams and thoughts. I've never had a hate for life, or my own life. I've never feared death, I've feared judgement yes, but don't we all? Faith, Hope, and Charity. 3 key things we need. Hope is one, hope that we won't be condemned. Yes we will with mortal sins and no repentance, but hope as in, with the right intentions and sincere effort to save your soul and to please God, that in his infiniate mercy He WILL save you. So, Faith, as I see you have already abtained, which is excellent :) and charity which speaks for itself. I've never feared death, I've always seen death as a sweet accurance. It's your passage to the 'afterlife' it's the only way to get to the other side. I would never say I hate this life, but I would say that I feel very cooped up, on this sinful earth, I think it's natural for me to have a yearning to get out of this earth and be ultimatly united with our Lord for all eternity. omg. I'm going like REALLY far with this, anyways, all I wanted to say was I can't apply to this because I've never had that look on life, I've always desired death yes, but not in that point of view. I think it's natural to see this world infected with evil, but there is still God in all, and that is the hope that keeps us going. That we will be with Him in heaven one day.

[quote name='pyranima' post='1020817' date='Jul 9 2006, 10:50 PM']
I also had a facination with vampires and actually knows quite a bit about demonology. i was never a cutter though i did scar myself (a phoenix) though thank God it it has faded so you cant see it. but i did other things, i had my tongue pierced, and I pierced my own ears and my labret. i have sense removed them though my ears will never close (i pierced with a 10 gauge). i don't relate the two things though (piercing and sucide), my motivation to live was only that i didnt want to be seen as a coward. I loved my piercings and would still wear them (except my labret) but i feel its something i need to leave behind.
Almost, Its not quite your Faith as their are good solid Catholics who have suicidal thoughts but its Grace that has saved you from all things.
[/quote]


grace comes with faith.

Posted

you mean Faith comes with Grace. its always Grace first then Faith and works.

Life is hard to desire when you have no hope.

Posted

thats it, people don't have faith, or hope. Without faith, you can't have hope. Because God is our hope. God made us so we can be happy with Him in heaven, and for us to know, love, and serve Him. That is our purpouse, that is our being. But while we are here we make reparation for our sins and the sins of others. By living here, you have to have faith or everything, every experience is going to felt bitterly, and all hope is lost. So many people ask themselves, "What is the point in my excistance?" because they have no faith. Thus they have no hope. I have hope, I know our excistance, but naturally I wish to end this earth. Not in the way some people want to die.

And yes, grace does come before faith, but who says it can't come after it? lol.

Posted

uruviel i mean no offense when i say this but you have no clue what your talking about, take away everything you have, a loving family, good friends, food on the table. imagine being told your worthless, imagine being told that you can never be as smart as someone else. know that something is missing inside of you, you dont know what it is or how to fill it but you know something should be there that is not. now go a step further, imagine you have no soul. that is what is missing from inside of you, there is this black pit where your soul should be. Faith Hope and Love, the greatest of these is love. from someone who has been there from someone who has been as low as you can go, hit rock bottom and then fallen through that bottom it is not like you think at all and you are way off. Faith is good, Faith is great, but what people need, what we need is love. before i had Faith i had Hope, not hope of being with God, i didn't even believe in him. at first it was just hope for hopes sake, but before i had hope i had love. it was not me who had love but me who was given love, i was a dry well that had nothing left inside to give i had been used up and emptied out. someone came along to give me life to fill me with love, i realize now that God sent them but at the time i did not see that. you dont know what its like to live in a world without love, a world so dark that even the darkness seems like light. Before you can have faith you must have Hope, and before you can have hope you must have love. Love is the warm blanket that wraps around you, Hope is the joy and comfort that blanket will always be there, and Faith is the ability to believe in that blanket when all the lights go out and you cant see it. but Faith tells you its there. im sorry but until you understand until you truly understand the meaning of what i just said there is no way for you to know. faith is great but it is the last of the theological virtues not the first. before i became a Christian i would have eaten you alive for the comment you just made. Have faith in what? have hope in what? that the world is going to end? good the sooner the better. When you have neither hope nor love you can only exist, you can only be. and there is only one purpose to your existance... to survive. First Love then Hope then Faith, in that order.

Posted

Yes, I do understand where you are coming from, and I understand your order, it makes perfect sense. But I also understand the way I put it, I failed to mention love, I'm sorry. I believe your right in the sense that love comes first, but faith and hope, it's difficult to say what comes next. Because, I believe hope without God is false hope. It's a lie if you have hope for anything but God. God is the center, He is the equalizer, He is everything. Without Him, hope and faith are false. So where do they come in, if you have no God?

And when you say, have faith in what? Have hope in what?
Have faith in God. Have faith in the purpose behind your creation, have faith in everything that makes you, you. Have faith and belief in the True God. Have hope that God will give you the means to obtain salvation. Without hope, with complete doubt in God's mercy, that's wrong. Granted, you can't have them without love as you have stated, but in what order I don't know. When you have hit rock bottum and your nothing but a hollow shell, your body is like a temple of nothing, your body is just a shell. It's hollow, useless, worthless, it's absolutely nothing to anyone, and you have no faith. Well then, you need grace. you need grace. Grace, to give you love, to give you hope, to give you faith. It all starts with grace. It's the light that shimmmers within the darkness, and plants love in our souls. Ok now I'm just rambling.

Posted (edited)

I have in my past pondered and dwelled on the questioin - yes.

Reasons I had not to go through with it;

Fear of Hell.

Always giving it 'one last chance', aka, i never really gave up.

stubborness; I never wanted to admit to others that they had finally had the best of me (they say the best vengeance is living well, i would not say so far that i seeked vengeance because I did not cause 'much' retribution for when I have been wronged. Those few and small retributions I have caused have been repented for)


Those are the three main reasons. that first one is a big one. Even when I most questionned the presence of God in the world and my life that is a fear that remained with me always, and to this day (though it has dimished greatly, especially in the last year - thanks pham!). there is no wrong in fearing hell; in fact i would worry, almost panic for someone who didn't; but make sure to know the difference between fearing hell, and fearing God, and fearing god's judgement.


and I agree with Uruviel; wihtout faith there is only darkness in life.

And I agree with pyranima, faith, on its own, is insufficient.

Love, faith and hope, and the greatest of these three is love. But the fact is you cannot have two of these without the third. the truth is, although love is the greatest of the three, you need ALL THREE.

God bless, and keep the faith! (and the love, and the hope)

Edited by Didacus
Posted

thanks didacus, you make good points.

Posted

[quote name='uruviel' post='1022893' date='Jul 12 2006, 09:59 AM']
Yes, I do understand where you are coming from, and I understand your order, it makes perfect sense. But I also understand the way I put it, I failed to mention love, I'm sorry. I believe your right in the sense that love comes first, but faith and hope, it's difficult to say what comes next. Because, I believe hope without God is false hope. It's a lie if you have hope for anything but God. God is the center, He is the equalizer, He is everything. Without Him, hope and faith are false. So where do they come in, if you have no God? [/quote] Hope for hopes sake that is where it comes in. you dont know its God giving you hope and love but it does not mean that he is not. there is a level of self awareness in Faith but that is not true for Love and Hope. for someone who knows and already believes i totally agree with you that there is an active Faith needed. but what about those who have never heard of or can't believe for whatever reason. its not a lie if you have hope for anything but God, if you dont know there is a God then hope for hopes sake is perfectly acceptable. you need to be very careful not to say "Your not Christian so you dont have hope" or "your not Christian you dont have love", that is a very dangerous error and it will push people from the church. it is not that it is a False hope but an incomplete hope, Catholics have the fullness of the Christian Faith but we are not the only Christians. do you get what im saying? you need to not take such a hardline approach though, it is not inline with the Church and it is not helpful to anyone. i refer to my bestfriend as "my own personal Jesus", he was Jesus for me he brought me Jesus not because i asked it he didnt even talk about religion, i knew him for almost a year before i knew he was Catholic. he didnt say "If you dont hope in God then you dont have Hope, if you dont love God then you dont love." instead he met me where i was, if he had said any of those things i would have never spoken to him again. What he knew that i did not was that i was hoping in God and i was Loving God without ever knowing it. Love and Hope do not need a concious act. i am glad you are on fire for God and that you center so much around him, but you need to keep in mind that not everyone is aware of that and not to Shove that FACT down peoples face. it is better to love them in silence first, another words before you ever say 1 word to them about God show them love. that love will grow and lead to both hope and desire. they will desire what you have, they will hope to one day have what you have, and it then that you can bring God to them.
[quote]
And when you say, have faith in what? Have hope in what?
Have faith in God. Have faith in the purpose behind your creation, have faith in everything that makes you, you. Have faith and belief in the True God. Have hope that God will give you the means to obtain salvation. Without hope, with complete doubt in God's mercy, that's wrong. Granted, you can't have them without love as you have stated, but in what order I don't know. When you have hit rock bottum and your nothing but a hollow shell, your body is like a temple of nothing, your body is just a shell. It's hollow, useless, worthless, it's absolutely nothing to anyone, and you have no faith. Well then, you need grace. you need grace. Grace, to give you love, to give you hope, to give you faith. It all starts with grace. It's the light that shimmmers within the darkness, and plants love in our souls. Ok now I'm just rambling.
[/quote]
again you do not understand, this is where you need to step back and take the advice of someone who has been there. you are looking on the outside saying "i know" and im telling you, you think you know. I could not have Faith in God, i could not have Hope in God at the time, you are saying that i needed to believe in something that i did not believe in. no rational mind can make themselves believe what they do not. do you understand what i am saying. God is Good God is Great and God is the center of all things, but... and an important but... if you dont believe in God you can not have hope or Faith in him. FIRST and very FIRST you need love. even if you dont know it is God who is loving you, you need love. even if you do not know it is God you are hoping in you still have hope in God. at first it is hope for hopes sake.

Posted

I've considered it probably twice that I could remember, and not really even for the sake of considering doing it, but more to figure out why people have such morbid fascination with it (and death in genral).

As for dying, when I know I'm in the state of grace I don't really mind thinking I could die at any moment, in fact I sort of welcome the idea (not for death's sake, but for Heaven's sake! Hooray! :kitten: ) But when I'm in a state of mortal sin, I'm almost terrified to get in the car to drive to confession!

I've only been really afraid to die when I thought that maybe there is no God, or that Allah's got it in for me if I do end up dying, but I don't dwell on those doubts, there's no reason to.

Posted (edited)

[b]I've only been really afraid to die when I thought that maybe there is no God, or that Allah's got it in for me if I do end up dying, but I don't dwell on those doubts, there's no reason to[/b]

your right you shouldn't dwell on those, those are temptations from the devil to have disbelief.

[b]
Hope for hopes sake that is where it comes in. you dont know its God giving you hope and love but it does not mean that he is not. there is a level of self awareness in Faith but that is not true for Love and Hope. for someone who knows and already believes i totally agree with you that there is an active Faith needed. but what about those who have never heard of or can't believe for whatever reason. its not a lie if you have hope for anything but God, if you dont know there is a God then hope for hopes sake is perfectly acceptable. you need to be very careful not to say "Your not Christian so you dont have hope" or "your not Christian you dont have love", that is a very dangerous error and it will push people from the church. it is not that it is a False hope but an incomplete hope, Catholics have the fullness of the Christian Faith but we are not the only Christians. do you get what im saying? you need to not take such a hardline approach though, it is not inline with the Church and it is not helpful to anyone. i refer to my bestfriend as "my own personal Jesus", he was Jesus for me he brought me Jesus not because i asked it he didnt even talk about religion, i knew him for almost a year before i knew he was Catholic. he didnt say "If you dont hope in God then you dont have Hope, if you dont love God then you dont love." instead he met me where i was, if he had said any of those things i would have never spoken to him again. What he knew that i did not was that i was hoping in God and i was Loving God without ever knowing it. Love and Hope do not need a concious act. i am glad you are on fire for God and that you center so much around him, but you need to keep in mind that not everyone is aware of that and not to Shove that FACT down peoples face. it is better to love them in silence first, another words before you ever say 1 word to them about God show them love. that love will grow and lead to both hope and desire. they will desire what you have, they will hope to one day have what you have, and it then that you can bring God to them[/b]

Oh yes I get what your are saying, I'm really sorry that I'm explaining myself so terribly, I wasn't saying that you have to present them with "THE CATHOLIC FAITH IS THE ONE TRUE FAITH" for it turns them away, trust me I know I have baptist friends, lutherin friends, and I know that love comes first. My whole famliy has always had a friend that isn't Catholic, and we're always learning how to turn them towards the church. When you said they will desire to have what you have, I have been exactly there. Trying to lead them to the place where they want what I have. Those who have the ability to change something (if through God of course) has the responsibility to change it. We are nothing, just vessels, just instruments, to help these people. God gives us the grace to present it to them, and His grace works from there. Ok anyways, I respect your knowlege on this matter :)



[b]again you do not understand, this is where you need to step back and take the advice of someone who has been there. you are looking on the outside saying "i know" and im telling you, you think you know. I could not have Faith in God, i could not have Hope in God at the time, you are saying that i needed to believe in something that i did not believe in. no rational mind can make themselves believe what they do not. do you understand what i am saying. God is Good God is Great and God is the center of all things, but... and an important but... if you dont believe in God you can not have hope or Faith in him. FIRST and very FIRST you need love. even if you dont know it is God who is loving you, you need love. even if you do not know it is God you are hoping in you still have hope in God. at first it is hope for hopes sake.[/b]

ok, I want to believe you when you say that I can't know, but I do understand. Maybe I haven't felt it before but I [i]understand[/i]. I wasn't speaking in terms of, the person who has no faith in God has to believe in Him anyway, or have a false hope, (and your right, it's more of an incomplete hope) I never said love did not come first. I was unsure as which, faith or hope comes before the other. I know it all starts with love, it's like the light at the end of the tunnel. And as long as you have that person, or that love whereever it may come from, it will always grow. And hopefully with God's grace, it will grow into hope and faith.

Edited by uruviel

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...