Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

He says that the universe is made of spiritual energy and the physical world that we experience is a projection of spiritual reality. When we realise certain spiritual realities, we personify them as "gods" and worship them. This makes so much more sense than to me than Christian theology, with its mad idea that spiritual and material realities are mixed in us and that the reason everything, even the bad, is sustained is "love".

Christianity has not made me happy. Christianity has brought me nothing but the worst misery I've ever had in my life. I almost killed myself twice over it and now I'm on medication to keep me at a level just above the throes of suicidal depression, and if I miss my medicine by even a few hours I start thinking crazy thoughts. Christianity just imbues me with a sense of my own worthlessness and the awful fact that I will never, ever be able to return the love of a loving God the way I'd like to as long as I live on this earth. There is no purity here. Everything is corrupt, to a greater or lesser extent. You have to take the good with the bad and drink a bitter, bitter cup, if you want any joy out of life. What a miserable existence.

Compare that with paganism. Paganism states that we aren't all in an awful state of corruption. Just a state. Just being. It's all about perspective. It's not pain if it's pleasant, for example. There is no hell. As my friend says, "the Christians saw our Heaven and thought they had seen hell. They don't realise some people just like to live that way. If there is a place without God and full of fire and brimstone, it'll be Heaven for you, as you'll enjoy anything they throw at you." It's not torture if you like it -- all about perspective.

Now let's look at what love is according to Christianity: God dies for us, not because of anything we are, but because of who He is. He "loves" us.

When I meditate on that statement, and isolate the "love" part, I come up with -- nothing. Nothing. I see absolutely no reason why He would do something like this. Apparently the reason is "love". But I can't see love. All I see is a terrifying action that makes no sense at all. Apparently the world is sustained, the good and the bad together, because of love. I see no intelligent reason why I even exist, assuming the Christian God. It's "love". The reasoning behind all the workings of the world is love. But I see nothing; I see nonsense. Love like this is madness. I don't believe it exists. I've tried to have faith. I've tried to HOPE something like this exists. But it makes no sense at all; it doesn't fit in with what I see in the world, it's just not a rational explanation for why I or this corrupted earth exist.

Now let's look at paganism. Is "love" the reason everything exists, the good and the bad? Nope. Everything is one. There is no good. There is no evil. There is only being, and one's perspective of it. Isn't that just a much nicer, neater view than all this "love" nonsense?

It all boils down to, that from the Christian point of view:

Evil should not exist by definition. Evil does exist. Going from those two observations, I and this whole universe should not exist. But we do, and the reason is "love". Love is this mystical undefinable thing that answers all the "why?" questions I have, like this one.

Unfortunately, love is not rational and there's a much, much better explanation for why I exist than it.

Posted

Ok, I don't know how well I'll be able to respond to everything you said, but I can respond to one part.

[quote]Paganism states that we aren't all in an awful state of corruption.[/quote]

Catholicism also does not state we are all in an awful state of corruption. Our nature is inherently good, but wounded. We are inherently good. When God created the rest of the world he said it was good. When he created humans he said it was VERY good. Don't ever think that all humans are in an awful state of corruption, it's not true! Yes, we are certainly imperfect, but there is MUCH good within us.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Just because something is easier to believe doesn't make it more correct.

Christianity is true and is founded on truth. Anyone who calls a spiritual reality "god" is using faulty theology. Who created the spiritual reality? If there are more than one of these, then wouldn't they be likely to conflict? Who said that there were more than one.

We as Catholics believe that we can know God exists from human reason alone. We know that we come to know Him through physical realities. Yet we proclaim that He is one spiritual reality, uncreated. It is not possible for there to be more than one. The source must be one, it must be simple, not complex.

Posted (edited)

Just because you believe in paganism does not mean that you are immune from pain in this world because you believe it so or "that is your heaven". Persepectives are one thing, Truth is another.

The worst misery in your life? Christianity being the cause of that? Pagan or not, misery comes from life itself. To dwell on thoughts on unworthiness can cause one to despair.

Have you read "Theology and Sanity" by Sheed? Read it. Acknowledging God is not about sanctity, but [b]sanity[/b]. You don't have to be "religious" to acknowledge that God does exsist.

God Bless.

Edited by jmjtina
EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

He does not want misery. Don't impose it on yourself. I don't know if your struggle with scrupulosity, but this is helpful to me:
[url="http://mission.liguori.org/newsletters/scrupulosity.htm"]http://mission.liguori.org/newsletters/scrupulosity.htm[/url]

To shed some light on Christ's sacrifice:
His sacrifice was the eventual end to His obedient life. Christ, the New Adam, remained faithful to the Father at all times - this ended in His death. His death was His ultimate act of obedience and broke the slavery of sin for humanity.

Posted

Raphael,

there is one god, who IS spiritual reality.

Our universe is a reflection of him.

The gods we make for ourselves are all personifications of a part of him.

Posted

[quote name='Cathurian' post='1020646' date='Jul 9 2006, 04:08 PM']
He says that the universe is made of spiritual energy and the physical world that we experience is a projection of spiritual reality. When we realise certain spiritual realities, we personify them as "gods" and worship them. This makes so much more sense than to me than Christian theology, with its mad idea that spiritual and material realities are mixed in us and that the reason everything, even the bad, is sustained is "love".

Christianity has not made me happy. Christianity has brought me nothing but the worst misery I've ever had in my life. I almost killed myself twice over it and now I'm on medication to keep me at a level just above the throes of suicidal depression, and if I miss my medicine by even a few hours I start thinking crazy thoughts. Christianity just imbues me with a sense of my own worthlessness and the awful fact that I will never, ever be able to return the love of a loving God the way I'd like to as long as I live on this earth. There is no purity here. Everything is corrupt, to a greater or lesser extent. You have to take the good with the bad and drink a bitter, bitter cup, if you want any joy out of life. What a miserable existence.

Compare that with paganism. Paganism states that we aren't all in an awful state of corruption. Just a state. Just being. It's all about perspective. It's not pain if it's pleasant, for example. There is no hell. As my friend says, "the Christians saw our Heaven and thought they had seen hell. They don't realise some people just like to live that way. If there is a place without God and full of fire and brimstone, it'll be Heaven for you, as you'll enjoy anything they throw at you." It's not torture if you like it -- all about perspective.

Now let's look at what love is according to Christianity: God dies for us, not because of anything we are, but because of who He is. He "loves" us.

When I meditate on that statement, and isolate the "love" part, I come up with -- nothing. Nothing. I see absolutely no reason why He would do something like this. Apparently the reason is "love". But I can't see love. All I see is a terrifying action that makes no sense at all. Apparently the world is sustained, the good and the bad together, because of love. I see no intelligent reason why I even exist, assuming the Christian God. It's "love". The reasoning behind all the workings of the world is love. But I see nothing; I see nonsense. Love like this is madness. I don't believe it exists. I've tried to have faith. I've tried to HOPE something like this exists. But it makes no sense at all; it doesn't fit in with what I see in the world, it's just not a rational explanation for why I or this corrupted earth exist.

Now let's look at paganism. Is "love" the reason everything exists, the good and the bad? Nope. Everything is one. There is no good. There is no evil. There is only being, and one's perspective of it. Isn't that just a much nicer, neater view than all this "love" nonsense?

It all boils down to, that from the Christian point of view:

Evil should not exist by definition. Evil does exist. Going from those two observations, I and this whole universe should not exist. But we do, and the reason is "love". Love is this mystical undefinable thing that answers all the "why?" questions I have, like this one.

Unfortunately, love is not rational and there's a much, much better explanation for why I exist than it.
[/quote]
Well, this whole post makes very little sense, but it seems like just a lot of subjectivity ("what makes me feel good") with little in the way of rational argument.

"Christianity" is not the source of your misery. Many Christians will attest that it brings them not misery, but peace and joy. The only thing making you miserable is yourself. The sooner you face up to this, the better.
But ultimately, how it makes you "feel" is irrelevant. Feelings are subjective. The issue should be, "What is true?"

All this about love not existing is nonsensical. Again, God's love does not depend on your subjective feelings. If you cannot believe in God's love, this says more about you than about God. (And it's a little puzzling to see how a universe without love makes you feel better than one with love.)

If evil does not exist, how do you explain your own misery? Evil is simply the deprivation of a due good. If you are unhappy, it is evidence that you are aware of a deprivation of some good which should be present. Your own statements are self-defeating - "everything's horrible, but there is no good or bad."

[quote]Unfortunately, love is not rational and there's a much, much better explanation for why I exist than it.[/quote]
Which is???

It seems the real appeal of this paganism is simply that you want to live with no moral framework - nothing is right or wrong; do what you please. This nihilism will not in the end bring happiness.

I'm not seeing much real argumentation here - just a lot of self-pity.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

Hi Cathurian,

I first want to let you know that I pray to God that you find healing in the arms of Our Lord. He came to bring Good News to all who would listen. Please trust in Him.

Mateo

On to my post...

I have noticed that neo-paganism--in its many forms--is quite "seeker-friendly." It's basically, believe what you want to believe. I'm OK, you're OK.

Unfortunately, there are times when I'm not OK. Specifically, when I sin against God or my neighbor. While neo-paganism doesn't really have an answer for this, Christianity teaches (along with most other major religions) that "the wages of sin is death."

Neo-pagan evangelists avoid the tough questions of our existence in the hopes that the "warm fuzzy" story is enough to convert. Look at this statement, for example:
[quote]Paganism states that we aren't all in an awful state of corruption. Just a state. Just being. It's all about perspective.[/quote]Aren't things like suicidal tendencies something we should try to overcome?

I read some of your previous posts where you describe demon-possession. I hope you don't blame Christianity for the suffering caused by demons. BTW, satanism teaches exactly as neo-paganism (i.e. we aren't all in an awful state of corruption). I hope this concerns you that demons tried to snatch you away from God by force, so that you might now reject Christianity and embrace what they wish.

If I could throw out a guess, I'd say that some of the pain that Christianity brings you is actually caused by a vice which it teaches you to reject. All the vices that I have had in my life had one thing in common: they sell themselves as great liberators, while--in reality--their purpose is to enslave.

Reading the lives of the saints helped me see that all people deal with these struggles. In particular, St. Augustine's Confessions shows the journey from a philosophy that wrote off sin (Manichæism taught a dualism which blamed an evil spirit for all sinful acts) to the Catholic Faith.

On to the assertions:
1) "there is one god, who IS spiritual reality."
This statement is a little vague. I guess I don't understand the point of the statement. Are you trying to find common ground between Christianity and neo-paganism?

2) "Our universe is a reflection of him."
The universe was made in the image of God? In what way, and by what proof would someone arrive at this conclusion? Is the purpose of this statement to contrast your views with pantheists?

3) "The gods we make for ourselves are all personifications of a part of him."
It seems that if we "make" gods for ourselves, then they cannot be the same as an eternal spirit, whose origin precedes our creative imagination. I'd be more inclined to believe an atheist who would suggest that these many "gods we make for ourselves" were merely our own delusions.

One of the methods that I have used to strengthen my faith after a serious derailment is to nourish myself with some spiritual reading. God always seems to help guide me to the right book. I trust that God will find a way to foster your faith in Him.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Cathurian' post='1021377' date='Jul 10 2006, 06:37 PM']
Raphael,

there is one god, who IS spiritual reality.

Our universe is a reflection of him.

The gods we make for ourselves are all personifications of a part of him.
[/quote]
You would like to settle yourself on worshipping images (reflections) of God, rather than God Himself? Your soul is spiritual, and therefore an image of God; will you worship yourself?

Paganism is man-worship.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...