Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

The other day I was in a supermarket and a HS aged cashier (male) was wearing a Rosary around his neck.

In all my life, I have not seen that (other than madonna the harlot).

Any ideas if this is proper or respectful?

brendan1104
Posted

Usually not proper. It shouldn't be used as a necklace.

[quote name='StMichael' post='1023845' date='Jul 13 2006, 06:28 PM']
The other day I was in a supermarket and a HS aged cashier (male) was wearing a Rosary around his neck.

In all my life, I have not seen that (other than madonna the harlot).

Any ideas if this is proper or respectful?
[/quote]

Posted

I've seen it done too. It's good and holy to evangelize so openly I suppose, but I think it's a bit disrespectful.
However, I don't think there's a rule about it.

nawtyeravgjoe
Posted

yeahhh, the rosary isn't a fashion statement.

a lot of people in my high school wear em though =\

Posted

I wouldn't really mind people wearing them if it weren't so apparent that they don't even know how to pray one, or even care to learn. :(

Posted

Hmm, been googling this and I'm seeing that it is outright banned in the UK and the religious never wear it around their necks here in the US.

I'm gonna see if I can't find something that really states if this is acceptable, if it is not, I will make sure I pass that info along to that guy.

geetarplayer
Posted

My Hispanic friend does that. He's thinking about the priesthood, actually. :idontknow:

MissScripture
Posted

I was always taught that it was disrespectful, but never really given a reason. I think mostly because that's not what it's meant for. It's not meant to be a personal adornment.

indescribable
Posted

in Mexico, it's very common to see children with rosaries around their necks. i think it depends on the region one lives in.
i think as a fashion accessory, it's terrible. one of my friends had one on the other day and i asked him over and over again to take it off, but he wouldn't comply. now what do you say to that? he didn't care that i was offended.

Posted

I was reading on the C.F.R. site once that the Brothers call wearing a Rosary around your neck Bronx style, I understand that they give a lot of them away to the homeless, the poor and the streetpeople and that this is where they usually wind up at is around their neck... I dont think it is proper, but I have to believe that having a Rosary on your person whether around your neck or in your pocket is better than no rosary at all.... Although I have never seen anyone do this personally, if I ever did I wouldnt hesitate to compliment them on their Rosary, and then ask them which mysterys they like the best, they will either have an answer for you, or it gives you a great chance to teach someone about the Rosary...

God Bless and Keep
hermit

salveregina
Posted

Rosary as fashion statement is never a good idea.

Rosary as prayer is always a good idea.

Depends on the motivation of the wearer.

God Conquers
Posted

My stance has always been this:

A Rosary must always be used as a Sacramental i.e.: You're praying it, have prayed it recently, or will pray it soon.

If this is the case, put it on your neck, in your pocket, around your wrist, etc. carry it however you need to.

If it's there as ornamentation only... no no no.

melporcristo
Posted
:)
Well, at Franciscan, a lot of us wear rosaries.
In fact, I have mine on right now, which is a rosary made of rope with a scapular on both ends. My good friend made it for me [yes, I have the Scapular blessed & installed].
Many of the Filipino's make the Rosary/Scapulars to wear also.
I don't see anything wrong with this act of devotion since like Hermit said, it's better than not wearing any religious article at all and definately gives us the chance to witness about a true devotion to Our Lady & praying the Rosary.
Posted

[quote name='StMichael' post='1023872' date='Jul 14 2006, 12:17 AM']
Hmm, been googling this and I'm seeing that it is outright banned in the UK[/quote]

:huh: Maybe banned at some schools. Rosaries have been a fashion statement among non-Catholics here for years. So much so that some major secular fashion stores sell plastic rosaries as an accessory (I had a :madrant: about it in a store once). If someone wants a rosary, let them go to a Catholic source and learn what it's about. What upsets me is the new "trend" in removing the cross from them. :(

Rosaries are given out in prisons (usually the glow-in-the dark white rosaries). Some people wear them to show they identify with how Our Lord was treated like a criminal.

I see it as an opportunity to tell people what the rosary is really for and if this brings them closer to conversion then it's great. Hopefully after we explain what they are for, they will try to pray it or at least realise it is not just a necklace.

Posted

[color="#009900"][b]I saw both lay and religious persons at the National Shrine in D.C. wearing rosaries around their necks a la March for Life. I don't see how it's any different than rosary around the wrist/through belt loops if it's done out of devotion, rather than desire to by stylish.[/b][/color]

Posted

[quote name='God Conquers' post='1024045' date='Jul 13 2006, 09:08 PM']
My stance has always been this:

A Rosary must always be used as a Sacramental i.e.: You're praying it, have prayed it recently, or will pray it soon.

If this is the case, put it on your neck, in your pocket, around your wrist, etc. carry it however you need to.

If it's there as ornamentation only... no no no.
[/quote]


Maybe not as an ornamentation on your person, but what about rosaries in car windows? Tons of good Catholics do that and I've never heard anyone saying anything against it. What about little rosary bracelets, or rosaries you hang on your wall? I know the rosary is a sacramental, something that opens you up to more grace when you use it, but where does the line begin and end? If someone wants to wear a rosary as a statement of faith (which you should never underestimate) then what's wrong with it? It's a great conversation starter, and if you get persecuted for the sake of the Name, then more power to you. Saying that a rosary should only be prayed upon and worn for the purpose of being prayed upon later or for the reason of having just prayed upon it and you don't know where else to put it, I don't know, that might be losing opprotunities to share your faith.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='StMichael' post='1023845' date='Jul 13 2006, 04:28 PM']
The other day I was in a supermarket and a HS aged cashier (male) was wearing a Rosary around his neck.

In all my life, I have not seen that (other than madonna the harlot).

Any ideas if this is proper or respectful?
[/quote]


I remember once I woar one around my neck when I was very young my grandma smacked me in the back of my head, told me take that off it's disrespectul to wear it like that. To bad Grandma aint around to talk to your cashier....

Posted

[quote name='misereremi' post='1024101' date='Jul 14 2006, 06:27 AM']
:huh: Maybe banned at some schools. Rosaries have been a fashion statement among non-Catholics here for years. So much so that some major secular fashion stores sell plastic rosaries as an accessory (I had a :madrant: about it in a store once). If someone wants a rosary, let them go to a Catholic source and learn what it's about. What upsets me is the new "trend" in removing the cross from them. :(

Rosaries are given out in prisons (usually the glow-in-the dark white rosaries). Some people wear them to show they identify with how Our Lord was treated like a criminal.

I see it as an opportunity to tell people what the rosary is really for and if this brings them closer to conversion then it's great. Hopefully after we explain what they are for, they will try to pray it or at least realise it is not just a necklace.
[/quote]

Yeah, places like Topshop, River Island and the like. A few years ago I did do this, but I didn't think there was much wrong with doing it, and I felt quite ‘safe’. But upon reading up on it I noticed it was pretty much frowned upon. Also, there were sometimes where I had to cover it up in case of any…altercations shall we say!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...