Laudate_Dominum Posted July 14, 2006 Posted July 14, 2006 I've been having some questions along the way as I create my little Star Wars vs. Star Trek game. I hope that someone around here is an expert on Star Trek and/or Star Wars. Here are a few questions for starters: 1. What was the maximum inventory of photon torpedoes that the Enterprise-E could handle? 2. What about for Intrepid class star ships? 3. If that's the maximum inventory what was normal? 4. Did the Enterprise-E still have photon torpedoes in spite of the quantum torpedo upgrade? If so, what were the inventory levels on these weapons? 5. Do pulse phaser cannons (USS Defiant) have a limit on how much they can fire or can pure energy weapons like conventional phasers fire infinitely so long as the ship has power? 6. What kind of limits do the various classes of Klingon and Romulan disruptor cannons have? 7. How do different disruptor weapons compare in terms of damage and stuff? And how does this aspect of the storyline fare with the star trek universe: One of the main problems with the storyline of the game is obviously the fact that Star Trek takes place several centuries in the future and in our galaxy, whereas Star Wars takes place a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away. The way the game deals with this problem is by setting the game in a scenario in which the Borg have established an invasion platform at the edge of the Alpha Quadrant and are preparing a full scale invasion of the quadrant. Aware of this the Federation, the Klingon Empire, the Romulan Empire and others have put together a massive fleet with which to engage the Borg. What the allies don't realize is that the Borg have managed to synthesize and stabilize the Omega Molecule and have created a prototype weapon which they intend to use to create a vast rupture in subspace with which to eliminate the resistance force in one stroke. The problem is that the Romulans have secretly developed a technology using extremely high energy plasma torpedoes that generate a strong chroniton field, the idea being that this will allow the torpedoes to penetrate the Borg's shields and that the Borg will not be able to adapt to the technology. When the alpha quadrant fleet advances to engage the Borg fleet in combat the Borg deploys its secret weapon which would effectively create a region of many thousands of light years in which warp travel would be impossible but the Borg's transwarp capability would still be effective. Besides protected their invasion platform from any possible attacks this would make the federation, klingon and romulan fleets merely sitting ducks (assuming any of their ships even survive the weapons effects). But as we know advanced Romulan plasma torpedoes are designed for warp speeds (federation photon torpedoes can sustain warp speeds if fired while the ship is in warp, but can't produce their own warp fields) and the Romulans detected the unknown Borg weapon en route and decided to deploy a batch of their chroniton enhances torpedoes in order to intercept the Borg weapon. The Borg weapon was of course shielded and equipped with its own defensive capabilities but they had not anticipated this new weapon of the Romulans, which was in a state of temporal flux and effectively cloaked and able to pass through Borg shields, the Romulan weapon impacted the omega molecule weapon and the result was the creation of a quantum singularity of unprecedented proportions. The weapon was designed to create a specific sort of rupture in subspace, but the way in which the omega molecule reacted with the super high energy chroniton field of the Romulan weapon created also a temporal anomaly. In fact, the extremely unanticipated result was a rift in the space time continuum which is essentially a gateway between that region of the alpha quadrant in that point in time and a region of another galaxy far, far away in a point in time long ago. Anyway, cheers.
DAF Posted July 15, 2006 Posted July 15, 2006 (edited) 1) [url="http://www.sttff.net/sovereign.html"]Enterprise E[/url] - it can take 150 stransphasic torpedoes and 275 quantum torpedoes. 425 total. However, [url="http://www.goth.net/~vamp/ncc1701e.htm"]this one[/url] says it can take way more, w/ 600 quantum torpedoes, and 500 photon torpedoes. You can sort it out, I have no idea. 2) [url="http://www.sttff.net/intrepid.html"]Intrepid[/url] - This one says 38 quantum torpedoes 3) (By inventory I assume you mean armaments?) I would think they always had it full up, but I'm not a trekkie, I wouldn't know. 4)It would appear that way, and I don't know. I can't find anything about that. Sorry. 5) [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weapons_of_Star_Trek#Phasers"]Phasers[/url] - This one says that a pulse phaser canon requires a small energy bank, which is powered by a 4.2 gig. generator. I don't know if the generator operates autonomously from the ship, however. I'm sure you can answer the other two by wiki-ing klingon and romulan disruptor canons and such. Hope I was of some help, and if I wasn't, you've still got some good reading material. Edited July 15, 2006 by DAF
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 15, 2006 Author Posted July 15, 2006 sweeeeeeeet!! thanks DAF, that helps a ton.
ilovechrist Posted July 17, 2006 Posted July 17, 2006 Laudate... the game sounds AMAZING. the storyline is crystal clear and is well thought through... i wanna play this game super de duper bad.
ilovechrist Posted July 17, 2006 Posted July 17, 2006 I dont have a Phat Mass account so i am going to use My wonderful friends SN although I still cant figure out how you are going to deal with the Star Wars side of this, i doubt an accident like this would cause the Federation to team up with the romulans and Klingons to fight what would be an impossible merging of the Jedi and Sith, I have other comments, but I will keep the rest of my comments to my self and make sure i have a well thought out pro and con list for you concerning the two parralel Universes.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 17, 2006 Author Posted July 17, 2006 [quote name='ilovechrist' post='1026173' date='Jul 17 2006, 02:06 PM'] I dont have a Phat Mass account so i am going to use My wonderful friends SN although I still cant figure out how you are going to deal with the Star Wars side of this, i doubt an accident like this would cause the Federation to team up with the romulans and Klingons to fight what would be an impossible merging of the Jedi and Sith, I have other comments, but I will keep the rest of my comments to my self and make sure i have a well thought out pro and con list for you concerning the two parralel Universes. [/quote] The alliance of the alpha quadrant forces is pretty loose. And I have not considered a teaming up of the Jedi and Sith. The way I've been going with this so far is more of a free for all. In one mode of the game, campaign mode, you select a particular side to represent (federation, klingons, borg, empire, jedi, etc.) and all the "teams" in the game are sort of doing thier own thing. I envision the Borg invasion platform to be something like the Borg equivalent to the Death Star so I'm hoping to work this into campaign mode in some way that forces a clash between the Borg and the Empire. When the two worlds collide in the game (star wars & star trek) both are in a state of war. The alpha quadrant groups at war with the Borg, and the rebels at war with the empire. When the two scenarios are merged it becomes something like a big intergalactic brawl. Right now the entire game takes place in space and with star ships. If I ever have time I would like to radically expand the game to include interior levels and characters. I think it would be sweet to have individual Jedi, Borg drones, star fleet officers, Darth Vader, Captain Picard, Luke Skywalker, etc. The main problem is that creating a game of this magnitude takes a ton of work. The only level that is far enough along that it is actually playable right now is the level representing the sector which contains the Borg invasion platform. The problem is that it is a virtually impossible level to win. You can warp to that sector, but once you get there you have a fleet of Borg ships that will generally destroy even a galaxy class vessel within 7 seconds. I actually had the most luck using the USS Defiant. The ship is very small but tough, and the size/manueverability make it possible to duck around and evade the Borg ships for a while before you are ultimately destroyed. Only by having serious skills is it even possible to defeat a single Borg cube with a federation star ship, but this sector has about a dozen borg cubes as well as other borg weapons. It would require a large fleet to take out the Borg invasion platform, and currently the game only allows a player to control a single ship at a time. The missions that I've come up with are designed to be playable by a single ship. That is how campaign mode works. You are assigned a mission by star fleet command (assuming you're playing as the federation) and you warp to some sector and carry out the objective. But there is nothing stopping you from warping to any sector you want, so you could warp to the sector that the Borg fleet inhabits and get destroyed real quick. :-) And the way the game works right now (only star fleet mode is playable) is that when you select your side (federation, klingon, borg, empire, etc.) you are given a fleet, and you can change which ship in your fleet you are currently controlling, but once all the ships in your fleet are destroyed you lose the game. And some groups are different. For the federation you control one large star ship at a time, which sometimes includes small shuttle craft that your ship can deploy, but if you were to play as the empire you would control a large star destroyer or frigate, but could also deploy a bunch of tie fighters that you would control as a formation. I need to experiment with it some more and potentially revise things a great deal.
God Conquers Posted July 18, 2006 Posted July 18, 2006 That is AWESOME. If you need some Beta testers down the road... I'm in for sure. The story is really sound and good... even though no one would care that much as long as they could blow up Warbirds with XWings.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 19, 2006 Author Posted July 19, 2006 w00t! So far this game has been lacking certain key ships (such as the famous x-wing fighter), well lastnight, to remedy this situation, I decided to finally buck down and create a 3D model of the x-wing to be used in my Star Wars vs Star Trek game. Finally Luke Skywalker can get his butt kicked by the Borg! Here are some screen shots of it (oh, and I will probably improve some of the finer details if I ever have free time): [img]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h119/NoonienSoong_2006/xwing1.jpg[/img] [img]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h119/NoonienSoong_2006/xwing2.jpg[/img] [img]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h119/NoonienSoong_2006/xwing4.jpg[/img] [img]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h119/NoonienSoong_2006/xwing5.jpg[/img] [img]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h119/NoonienSoong_2006/xwing6.jpg[/img] [img]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h119/NoonienSoong_2006/xwing7.jpg[/img] This isn't even remotely to scale (yet), but it's still cool: [img]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h119/NoonienSoong_2006/scene1.jpg[/img]
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 20, 2006 Author Posted July 20, 2006 So this is a really basic question, and possibly dumb, but do X-wing and A-wing fighters have shields? I know that imperial cruisers, star destroyers and frigates have shields, but I can't remember any reference to x-wing shields in the movies. Thanks.
Jaime Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1024628' date='Jul 14 2006, 02:34 PM'] I've been having some questions along the way as I create my little Star Wars vs. Star Trek game. I hope that someone around here is an expert on Star Trek and/or Star Wars. Here are a few questions for starters: 1. What was the maximum inventory of photon torpedoes that the Enterprise-E could handle? 2. What about for Intrepid class star ships? 3. If that's the maximum inventory what was normal? 4. Did the Enterprise-E still have photon torpedoes in spite of the quantum torpedo upgrade? If so, what were the inventory levels on these weapons? 5. Do pulse phaser cannons (USS Defiant) have a limit on how much they can fire or can pure energy weapons like conventional phasers fire infinitely so long as the ship has power? 6. What kind of limits do the various classes of Klingon and Romulan disruptor cannons have? 7. How do different disruptor weapons compare in terms of damage and stuff? And how does this aspect of the storyline fare with the star trek universe: One of the main problems with the storyline of the game is obviously the fact that Star Trek takes place several centuries in the future and in our galaxy, whereas Star Wars takes place a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away. The way the game deals with this problem is by setting the game in a scenario in which the Borg have established an invasion platform at the edge of the Alpha Quadrant and are preparing a full scale invasion of the quadrant. Aware of this the Federation, the Klingon Empire, the Romulan Empire and others have put together a massive fleet with which to engage the Borg. What the allies don't realize is that the Borg have managed to synthesize and stabilize the Omega Molecule and have created a prototype weapon which they intend to use to create a vast rupture in subspace with which to eliminate the resistance force in one stroke. The problem is that the Romulans have secretly developed a technology using extremely high energy plasma torpedoes that generate a strong chroniton field, the idea being that this will allow the torpedoes to penetrate the Borg's shields and that the Borg will not be able to adapt to the technology. When the alpha quadrant fleet advances to engage the Borg fleet in combat the Borg deploys its secret weapon which would effectively create a region of many thousands of light years in which warp travel would be impossible but the Borg's transwarp capability would still be effective. Besides protected their invasion platform from any possible attacks this would make the federation, klingon and romulan fleets merely sitting ducks (assuming any of their ships even survive the weapons effects). But as we know advanced Romulan plasma torpedoes are designed for warp speeds (federation photon torpedoes can sustain warp speeds if fired while the ship is in warp, but can't produce their own warp fields) and the Romulans detected the unknown Borg weapon en route and decided to deploy a batch of their chroniton enhances torpedoes in order to intercept the Borg weapon. The Borg weapon was of course shielded and equipped with its own defensive capabilities but they had not anticipated this new weapon of the Romulans, which was in a state of temporal flux and effectively cloaked and able to pass through Borg shields, the Romulan weapon impacted the omega molecule weapon and the result was the creation of a quantum singularity of unprecedented proportions. The weapon was designed to create a specific sort of rupture in subspace, but the way in which the omega molecule reacted with the super high energy chroniton field of the Romulan weapon created also a temporal anomaly. In fact, the extremely unanticipated result was a rift in the space time continuum which is essentially a gateway between that region of the alpha quadrant in that point in time and a region of another galaxy far, far away in a point in time long ago. Anyway, cheers. [/quote] Ok first, I'm in awe of the line of reasoning here. Truly!! But I have one question How in the world were you able to get a girlfriend?!?!
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 20, 2006 Author Posted July 20, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1027651' date='Jul 20 2006, 02:25 PM'] Ok first, I'm in awe of the line of reasoning here. Truly!! But I have one question How in the world were you able to get a girlfriend?!?! [/quote] I was blessed to find the right woman I suppose. She loves star wars!! But she isn't crazy about star trek (or so she says!). I have reason to believe that deep down she's a trekkie.
Jaime Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1027660' date='Jul 20 2006, 03:35 PM'] I was blessed to find the right woman I suppose. She loves star wars!! But she isn't crazy about star trek (or so she says!). I have reason to believe that deep down she's a trekkie. [/quote] Today You are my hero *sniff*
God Conquers Posted July 21, 2006 Posted July 21, 2006 They have deflector shields, but not the complex energy shields that Star Trek ships have. Star Wars will totally win! USE THE FORCE!!!!!!
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 21, 2006 Author Posted July 21, 2006 [quote name='God Conquers' post='1027888' date='Jul 20 2006, 06:54 PM'] Star Wars will totally win! USE THE FORCE!!!!!! [/quote] I'm not sure.. as it is right now the x-wing is about as threatening to a star trek ship as a shuttlecraft.
God Conquers Posted July 21, 2006 Posted July 21, 2006 Some friends of mine were talking about this a while ago... Star Destroyers are something like 6 MILES LONG! They totally dwarf anything Star Trek has! Plas Trek is not used to many small ships (i.e. fighters) and pretty much use only capital ships. Man, I love the concept, I'm just too huge of a Star Wars fan to contemplate their loss. Which could POSSIBLY happen... if Species 486 came into the picture... but that's a no-win for everybody.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 21, 2006 Author Posted July 21, 2006 actually, this guy makes the argument that Star Trek is not even remotely a match for Star Wars: [url="http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Essays/FiveMinutes.html"]http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Essays/FiveMinutes.html[/url] crazy
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 21, 2006 Author Posted July 21, 2006 And according to memory-alpha.org (which I consider to be very solid), a galaxy class star ship is 642 meters is length, an intrepid class vessel is 344 meters long; in contrast an imperial-I class star destroyer is 1,609 meters in length. Not quite six miles (that's actually one mile exactly), but it still dwarfs star fleets ships. I just learned that the executor class star destroyer is 17600 meters in length!!! That's basically eleven miles! It was the imperial flag ship in Darth Vaders time. The eclipse class isn't far behind at 17,500 meters!! [img]http://hangarbay.tripod.com/eclipsessd.jpg[/img] I'm starting to convert.. I think star wars would utterly destroy star trek. And they wouldn't break a sweat doing it if it was a straight fight. Here's the picture with a galaxy class vessel added for comparison: [img]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h119/NoonienSoong_2006/eclipsessd.jpg[/img]
God Conquers Posted July 21, 2006 Posted July 21, 2006 GAH!!! You know, there used to be some "Star Wars vs. Star Trek" videos floating around cyberspace... they were fairly well-done for their time (probaly 6 yrs ago) and were pretty cool and realistic. Some of them also had Babylon 5 I think too. Oh... and the craziest thing really is how many TIE Fighters one of those executor-class Star Destroyers carries... unbelievable amounts. ah... I love Star Wars.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now