Maria Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 In my understanding, priests aren't able to marry (though married men can be ordained): it's not just a discipline. However, laicized priests, who are still priests, are able to marry, which would suggest that it's along the lines of a discipline, not an impossibility. Anybody know?
the_rev Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 It's only a practice correct. But it is a very good disipline. A priest has an undivdied heart for the Church. For in scripture it said, "A man can not serve two masters" How can a priest serve both God, the Church, and his wife/family. A priest has many more tasks than an ordinary pastor. A priest says daily mass, he hears confession, etc. He has so much more than a common married pastor in a non denominational church. I believe celibacy is a gift for our priests. For your question, it is only a discipline not a doctrine. In the Lord, Ed
Era Might Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 Priests can theoretically marry, although they have never been allowed to. It was always married men ordained to the Priesthood. But, I'm sure there were exceptions in Church history, such as a widowed Priest with very young children.
Aloysius Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 I'm not so sure. I always thought it had to do with the nature of the two sacraments. You cannot enter matrimony after ordination; ordination is an exclusive marriage to the Church. now, I never understood laicized priests getting married anyway. seems to me like they're given permission to ignore a solemn vow they made to God. it's like a divorce and re-marriage. anyone know the history on this? have laicized priests always been able to get married just like that and be considered good members of the Catholic community? I've never felt like they are at all in good standing. there were never any formal exceptions to this ordering. once through a mistake I believe a particular diocese was letting priests get married but they put a stop to that within a couple decades (sometime during the middle ages I believe) so that's an ant of a mistake in a molehill of consistency. if it is a teaching, which I've always thought it to be, it would enjoy infallibility as being taught with consistency through the ordinary universal magisterium, since there have never been any exceptions allowed by the Magisterium.
Era Might Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 If ordination were an "exclusive" marriage to the Church, then no married man could be ordained. Marriage after ordination would be more common for Deacons, at least in the West. If a Priest were to go and get married on his own (like Archbishop Milingo), then his marriage would be invalid, of course, because ordination is an obvious impediment to marriage. But that is because it remains ecclesial discipline. There is nothing intrinsic to the Sacraments of Marriage or Holy Orders that would make it impossible to enjoy both at the same time. Diocesan Priests do not take vows of celibacy, they make promises to remain obedient to the discipline of the Church. Religious Priests do take vows of celibacy. The Church has the authority to dispense a man from a vow and a promise; as long as he is validly laicized, there is no sin or disobedience to his previous state, which has been dispensed by the Church herself.
the_rev Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 My question is, we are baptized as "priest, prophet and king" what is meant by priest? In the Lord, Ed
Aloysius Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1025168' date='Jul 15 2006, 09:32 PM'] If ordination were an "exclusive" marriage to the Church, then no married man could be ordained. Marriage after ordination would be more common for Deacons, at least in the West. If a Priest were to go and get married on his own (like Archbishop Milingo), then his marriage would be invalid, of course, because ordination is an obvious impediment to marriage. But that is because it remains ecclesial discipline. There is nothing intrinsic to the Sacraments of Marriage or Holy Orders that would make it impossible to enjoy both at the same time. Diocesan Priests do not take vows of celibacy, they make promises to remain obedient to the discipline of the Church. Religious Priests do take vows of celibacy. The Church has the authority to dispense a man from a vow and a promise; as long as he is validly laicized, there is no sin or disobedience to his previous state, which has been dispensed by the Church herself. [/quote] exlusive as in once you're ordained there can be no more. I very much quesiton that this does not relate doctrinally to the nature of these sacraments, especially considering the universality and consistency with which it has been held for 2000 yrs. at the very least I would assert that the sacrament of ordination excludes the men who receive it from receiving the sacrament of marriage while they remain priests; and that this is not discipline but doctrine relating to the nature of the sacrament of ordination. a man may bring a wife he had already married along with him in marrying the Church, but once one is a husband of the Church as it were he may take no more brides. Here's where I see this firm doctrinal stance: any potential wife for an already ordained priest is a daughter of the Church. once the priest becomes married to the Church, those women call him 'father', they are his spiritual children. as such I see him just as doctrinally unfit to marry them as any man is doctrinally unfit to marry their own daughter. bringing a woman who you have already married with you when 'marrying' Mother Church is another story, she is already your wife before you ever became a spiritual father. if it's not an issue of the nature of the sacrament of ordination, it is an issue of the nature of the priesthood. either way I assert that it is doctrinal, and taught infallibly by the ordinary universal magisterium. again, any history behind laicized priests? I always have had an icky feeling about them. but I suppose when they are laicized, though they remain a priest forever, they are taken down from the position of spiritual father and as such could get married. this would mean that it is more a doctrine about the nature of the priesthood than about the sacrament of ordination like I previously thought.
CrossCuT Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 [size=1][color="FF6699"]A priest being married bothers me. I dont like that. [/color][/size]
the_rev Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 [quote] A priest being married bothers me. I dont like that. [/quote] I hear you!
Era Might Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1025254' date='Jul 16 2006, 12:18 AM']exlusive as in once you're ordained there can be no more. I very much quesiton that this does not relate doctrinally to the nature of these sacraments, especially considering the universality and consistency with which it has been held for 2000 yrs. at the very least I would assert that the sacrament of ordination excludes the men who receive it from receiving the sacrament of marriage while they remain priests; and that this is not discipline but doctrine relating to the nature of the sacrament of ordination. a man may bring a wife he had already married along with him in marrying the Church, but once one is a husband of the Church as it were he may take no more brides. Here's where I see this firm doctrinal stance: any potential wife for an already ordained priest is a daughter of the Church. once the priest becomes married to the Church, those women call him 'father', they are his spiritual children. as such I see him just as doctrinally unfit to marry them as any man is doctrinally unfit to marry their own daughter. bringing a woman who you have already married with you when 'marrying' Mother Church is another story, she is already your wife before you ever became a spiritual father. if it's not an issue of the nature of the sacrament of ordination, it is an issue of the nature of the priesthood. either way I assert that it is doctrinal, and taught infallibly by the ordinary universal magisterium. again, any history behind laicized priests? I always have had an icky feeling about them. but I suppose when they are laicized, though they remain a priest forever, they are taken down from the position of spiritual father and as such could get married. this would mean that it is more a doctrine about the nature of the priesthood than about the sacrament of ordination like I previously thought. [/quote] First, nothing you are saying has been "held as doctrine for 2000 years". The Church has never taught that the Sacrament of Holy Orders, of its very nature, makes it impossible to receive the Sacrament of Holy Matrimony. If you are going to argue that she does teach this, I'll have to ask for documentation. The image of Priest as husband of the Church is just that, an image. In the West, the theology of the Priesthood is centered around this image in a very exclusive way; hence, universal celibacy. But it remains an image, a theological tradition. When you take this image too literally, then you are forced to condemn the theological tradition of the East, which admits married men to the Priesthood. If being "married to the Church" means it's not only an image, but a juridical marriage, then a married man who is ordained becomes a polygamist. But the Church doesn't understand the image in this literal sense. What you are doing is taking a theological image, setting it in stone, and establishing it as doctrine. But you can't do that. The theology of a particular Church is a way to see and live the faith, but it is not the faith itself. The Latin theology of the Priesthood is not the only way to see the mystery, and the Roman Church does not pretend to draw doctrinal conclusions from a theological tradition. If you want to say Priests OUGHT not marry after ordination, because it better conveys a particular image of the Priesthood, that's fine. But we have to be clear that there is nothing INTRINSIC to the Sacrament, or the office of Priest, which would prohibit the celebration of Holy Matrimony. Your appeal to the image of Priest as husband and father does not have to be taken so narrowly. The very fact that a married man is admitted to the Priesthood already introduces a mitigation of the image. A man does not juridically marry the Church anymore than he becomes a legal "father" to his parishioners. These are concepts, images, and the Church does not take them literally and apply them as doctrine. As for laicized Priests, there is nothing to feel "icky" about. For whatever reason, whether sin, or a recognition that the Priesthood was not a man's true calling, the Church dispenses him from the clerical state. So long as he continues to serve the Lord, there is no scarlet letter upon him. However, even the marriage of a laicized Priest undercuts your argument. When a man and a woman separate, they remain married, and cannot remarry until one of them dies. If we were to apply the image of "husband" too literally, then a laicized Priest couldn't remarry. Again, though, the Church's discipline of celibacy is meant to highlight a particular image. It does not establish doctrine where there is none to be found. So, to restate what I said originally, there is nothing intrinsic to the Sacrament or the office of Priest that would forbid a theoretical marriage; certainly not Church doctrine. But the discipline of the Church does not permit it, for various reasons.
StMichael Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 In the early church, Priests were allowed to be married. The problem was that they willed Church property to their families. This opened the question that the leaders of the Church must give of themselves 100%. As for ordaining married men. A Catholic married man can not be ordained, but the Church makes exceptions for those coming over from the Angelican practice. The highest level, a non-widowed Catholic can reach is Deacon.
Aloysius Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 unless he goes to an eastern catholic church. married men have been ordained, ordained men have never been married to Era Might: it would be easier to ask for documentation of an EXCEPTION to this, because it is evident that the majority of Church history runs by this and there are no evident breaks from it; something which is held by the whole magisterium everywhere since the beginning of the church which relates to the nature of the priesthood can be considered doctrinally taught be the universal ordinary magisterium I do not see the image of being married to the church as totally binding, but I do believe the priest's spiritual fatherhood is something that is not just an image but an essential reality about the nature of the priesthood. This is where I see the doctrinal line drawn. It is not a doctrine that can be sited anywhere except in the universal consensus of the bishops throughout time which, as described by LG 25, is the infallible ordinary universal magisterium. a laicized priest is removed from the office and, though still holding the indulable mark on his soul, he is no longer the spiritual father of anyone (i suppose), he is moved from service in the head of the body of Christ to service in the laity, which makes him no longer the spiritual father of the children of the Church. also: logic has no power over my icky feelings. i can have icky feelings if I want to! :
qfnol31 Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1025159' date='Jul 15 2006, 07:58 PM'] Priests can theoretically marry, although they have never been allowed to. It was always married men ordained to the Priesthood. But, I'm sure there were exceptions in Church history, such as a widowed Priest with very young children. [/quote]I actually think the practice of marrying was stopped in the Latin Church in the 800s...I mean, our first Priests were obviously married. I read this somewhere (I think on the poster of the Popes).
Aloysius Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 there never was a practice of marrying ordained men in any church, latin or eastern. the practice was ordaining married men, there's a difference.
Era Might Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 Aloysius, That something is a continuous discipline of the Church doesn't mean you can take whatever doctrinal conclusions from it that you want. I don't have to prove that there were exceptions, although I could look into it, because it's not relevant. If you can't show where the Church teaches that the Priesthood invalidates any potential marriage, then there is no Church teaching on the matter. If you want to argue that there should be a Church teaching on the matter, you are free to do so. But there is nothing there that any Catholic has to hold as doctrine. And I would be willing to bet any amount that there have been exceptions, that Priests have in fact married after ordination in the history of the Church. As far as I know, this still takes place today on a rare basis among Deacons in the West.
qfnol31 Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1025398' date='Jul 16 2006, 11:27 AM'] there never was a practice of marrying ordained men in any church, latin or eastern. the practice was ordaining married men, there's a difference. [/quote]You are right, but it is still a practice of marrying with a distinction. :[quote name='Era Might' post='1025400' date='Jul 16 2006, 11:32 AM'] Aloysius, That something is a continuous discipline of the Church doesn't mean you can take whatever doctrinal conclusions from it that you want. I don't have to prove that there were exceptions, although I could look into it, because it's not relevant. If you can't show where the Church teaches that the Priesthood invalidates any potential marriage, then there is no Church teaching on the matter. If you want to argue that there should be a Church teaching on the matter, you are free to do so. But there is nothing there that any Catholic has to hold as doctrine. And I would be willing to bet any amount that there have been exceptions, that Priests have in fact married after ordination in the history of the Church. As far as I know, this still takes place today on a rare basis among Deacons in the West. [/quote]Deacons are allowed to remarry if they have a family that needs a mother, otherwise I believe they aren't allowed to. I'm not sure how that would go for a Priest.
Era Might Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 You are erecting a "doctrine" around the idea that a Priest is a spiritual father. But you are arbitrarily taking this image of Priest as "father" too literally. You could also take the image of Priest as "husband" and say a married man who becomes a Priest is a polygamist. But these roles of a Priest are not meant to be taken literally or without due regard for other aspects of Sacramental theology. This is why married men are admitted to the Priesthood, and why a Priest could (in theory) get married. That's not to say Priests SHOULD get married after ordination. But what SHOULD happen and what MUST happen are two different things. It's the difference between theology and doctrine. I meant to add that last post to the previous one, just FYI. [quote name='qfnol31' post='1025405' date='Jul 16 2006, 12:38 PM']Deacons are allowed to remarry if they have a family that needs a mother, otherwise I believe they aren't allowed to. I'm not sure how that would go for a Priest. [/quote] Right. It's not a question of what Church discipline allows or what we think should be the discipline of the Church. It's purely an academic question of theory. Theoretically, there is nothing to exclude a Priest from getting married.
Aloysius Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1025400' date='Jul 16 2006, 12:32 PM'] Aloysius, That something is a continuous discipline of the Church doesn't mean you can take whatever doctrinal conclusions from it that you want. I don't have to prove that there were exceptions, although I could look into it, because it's not relevant. If you can't show where the Church teaches that the Priesthood invalidates any potential marriage, then there is no Church teaching on the matter. If you want to argue that there should be a Church teaching on the matter, you are free to do so. But there is nothing there that any Catholic has to hold as doctrine. And I would be willing to bet any amount that there have been exceptions, that Priests have in fact married after ordination in the history of the Church. As far as I know, this still takes place today on a rare basis among Deacons in the West. [/quote] that something is universally consistently held by all bishops at all times puts it on the level of the ordinary universal magisterium. that the nature of the priesthood is a spiritual fatherhood over the faithful is referenced in the bible and has be universally and consistently held. priests not marrying after becoming priests has been consistently and universally held, only one documented exception which lasted a couple decades in a particular area and was promptly stopped. the doctrine has been universally and consistently held even if not stated in a council or encyclical. Church history attests to this fact, it would be up to you to show the magisterium conding any exceptions at any time to contend against it being part of the universal ordinary magisterium.
Era Might Posted July 16, 2006 Posted July 16, 2006 (edited) Aloysius, You keep saying "the doctrine has been universally held", but THERE IS NO DOCTRINE. You have not cited anything except a discipline of the Church, and from that discipline, you have come to your own doctrinal conclusion. You have not pointed to any teaching of the Church that this discipline means Priests are inherently incapable of marriage. Nobody's denying that Priests are spiritual fathers. Priests are also spiritual husbands. That doesn't mean they can't be actual husbands, or actual fathers. You have erected an arbitrary definition of Priestly roles. Edited July 16, 2006 by Era Might
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now