Fides_et_Ratio Posted July 17, 2006 Posted July 17, 2006 The Pope and the Bishops in communion with him.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 17, 2006 Posted July 17, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1025824' date='Jul 17 2006, 12:05 AM'] What about the case of Pope Honorius? Maybe I butchered the spelling on his name...anyway, wasn't that a so-called "close call" as far as infallability is concerned? Just curious if there is a double standard, here. [/quote] That's a totally different kind of thing. This discussion was about the infallible status of a particular teaching, not on the apologetics of infallibility. But maybe I just don't understand the point you're trying to make. In what way exactly is there a double standard here? And if you want my opinion, I think it is pathetic that the "big gun" of the anti-papists, the sort of "killer argument" always seems to be about Pope Honorius. The reason I think this is pathetic is because it's just a really superficial argument (and they're clearly wrong). If that's the best they've got then they've got nothing. Besides the fact that Honorius' letters to Sergius don't constitute official papal teaching (a point which alone destroys any claim against infallibility) the whole controversy is a matter of semantics and I think if one really examines the situation Honorius was never heterodox in the first place. His statement is taken out of context and presumed to be an expression of monothelitism but I think this is an incorrect reading of Honorius and his intent, and the true understanding of his statement, is in fact orthodox.
phatcatholic Posted July 18, 2006 Posted July 18, 2006 on pope honorius: [b]--[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=3301"]Guilty Only of Failure to Teach[/url] --[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0104fea4.asp"]Rebutting James White's Rebuttal on Pope Honorius[/url] --[url="http://www.mwt.net/~lnpalm/honrius1.htm"]The Supposed Fall of Honorius and His Condemnation[/url] --[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1994/9409fea2.asp"]The Truth about Pope Honorius[/url] --[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07452b.htm"]Pope Honorius I[/url][/b] on usury: [b]--[url="http://frcoulter.com/presentations/usury/summary.html"]Usury: Error, Change, or Development?[/url] --[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1997/9709fea3.asp"]The Red Herring of Usury[/url] --[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/THEOLOGY/FRNOONAN.HTM"]A Response to John T. Noonan, Jr. Concerning the Development of Catholic Moral Doctrine[/url] --[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15235c.htm"]Usury[/url][/b]
jswranch Posted July 19, 2006 Author Posted July 19, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1025825' date='Jul 17 2006, 12:06 AM'] A few items of note: 1. My priest was fairly insistent that the contraception ban is not infallible. Can you give me/link me to a single statement that debates his belief? 2. With all your statements on sententia communis and other levels of truth, where does the ban and ban reversal of usury fall into this topic? 3. What is the difference between de fide, dogma, and ex cathedra? 4. Question on LG 25: What is the significance of the verse MT 13:52 as footnote 164?[/quote] Bump
Ziggamafu Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1026037' date='Jul 17 2006, 11:03 AM'] That's a totally different kind of thing. This discussion was about the infallible status of a particular teaching, not on the apologetics of infallibility. But maybe I just don't understand the point you're trying to make. In what way exactly is there a double standard here? And if you want my opinion, I think it is pathetic that the "big gun" of the anti-papists, the sort of "killer argument" always seems to be about Pope Honorius. The reason I think this is pathetic is because it's just a really superficial argument (and they're clearly wrong). If that's the best they've got then they've got nothing. Besides the fact that Honorius' letters to Sergius don't constitute official papal teaching (a point which alone destroys any claim against infallibility) the whole controversy is a matter of semantics and I think if one really examines the situation Honorius was never heterodox in the first place. His statement is taken out of context and presumed to be an expression of monothelitism but I think this is an incorrect reading of Honorius and his intent, and the true understanding of his statement, is in fact orthodox. [/quote] I agree. I remember reading Gary Wills while I was in the process of discovering the truth of Catholicism. He brought up councils that contradicted each other, the shifting position of the Church on slavery, Honorius, etc. Even then I would look at the situations he brought up and see that they didn't meet the requirements for infallibility - or they were clearly misinterpreted. However, I do believe that the (so to speak) "fallible" side of the Church can misinterpret the infallible side. That is to say, we're all still merely human and need dogma to clarify and re-clarify things...I bet most Catholics 1,000 years ago would have balked if you told them that one day the Church would realize that the infallible teaching of "no salvation outside the Catholic Church" would come to be understood as "no salvation outside the mystical Body of Christ". Maybe I'm wrong, but it seems to me that this is what the nature and purpose of dogma / infallibility are all about...progressive conservatisim. Not a Church who bends toward secular culture or the demands of modernism but a Church who understands herself more clearly with every passing generation. Our understanding of the teaching on contraception might change, but the teaching itself will not. This is why the efforts of liberals and dissident Catholics are so pathetic and fruitless. Such efforts toward change would be far more effective if they played by the rules of Catholic theology. It is hard for liberals to understand that the Church is conservative by her nature. It is hard for conservatives to understand that the Church is progressive by her nature. Just like Protestants must realize that if there is to be any Christian unity such unity must be on Catholic grounds, so liberals must realize that if there is to be any progressive understanding of Church teaching such progression must be on conservative grounds. In other words, no femminist "progress" can result in priestesses and no sexual "progress" can result in toleration of the contraceptive mentality. The teaching that it is gravely immoral to prevent life by use of artificial contraceptives will never change. This is the conservative ground upon which any "progressive" understanding must stand. So yes, I think the ban is infallible.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1027227' date='Jul 19 2006, 09:58 AM'] I agree. I remember reading Gary Wills while I was in the process of discovering the truth of Catholicism. He brought up councils that contradicted each other, the shifting position of the Church on slavery, Honorius, etc. Even then I would look at the situations he brought up and see that they didn't meet the requirements for infallibility - or they were clearly misinterpreted. However, I do believe that the (so to speak) "fallible" side of the Church can misinterpret the infallible side. That is to say, we're all still merely human and need dogma to clarify and re-clarify things...I bet most Catholics 1,000 years ago would have balked if you told them that one day the Church would realize that the infallible teaching of "no salvation outside the Catholic Church" would come to be understood as "no salvation outside the mystical Body of Christ". Maybe I'm wrong, but it seems to me that this is what the nature and purpose of dogma / infallibility are all about...progressive conservatisim. Not a Church who bends toward secular culture or the demands of modernism but a Church who understands herself more clearly with every passing generation. Our understanding of the teaching on contraception might change, but the teaching itself will not. This is why the efforts of liberals and dissident Catholics are so pathetic and fruitless. Such efforts toward change would be far more effective if they played by the rules of Catholic theology. It is hard for liberals to understand that the Church is conservative by her nature. It is hard for conservatives to understand that the Church is progressive by her nature. Just like Protestants must realize that if there is to be any Christian unity such unity must be on Catholic grounds, so liberals must realize that if there is to be any progressive understanding of Church teaching such progression must be on conservative grounds. In other words, no femminist "progress" can result in priestesses and no sexual "progress" can result in toleration of the contraceptive mentality. The teaching that it is gravely immoral to prevent life by use of artificial contraceptives will never change. This is the conservative ground upon which any "progressive" understanding must stand. So yes, I think the ban is infallible. [/quote] :applause: such a cool smiley
qfnol31 Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 jswranch, There are a couple things to respond to. First, the ban on contraception cannot itself be infallible. However, the teaching that it is intrinsically evil is such. Second, most people cannot give you a link to an official document on the matter. The reason is because it isn't defined or declared by the Extraordinary Magisterium, but by that Magisterium which is Ordinary, Episcopal, Universal. In English? We know it's infallibly taught because it has always been taught as intrinsically evil and the Pope closed the matter in Humanae Vitae, just as Pope John Paul II closed the issue of female ordination in Ordinatio Sacerdotalis in 1994.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1027354' date='Jul 19 2006, 05:20 PM'] jswranch, There are a couple things to respond to. First, the ban on contraception cannot itself be infallible. However, the teaching that it is intrinsically evil is such. Second, most people cannot give you a link to an official document on the matter. The reason is because it isn't defined or declared by the Extraordinary Magisterium, but by that Magisterium which is Ordinary, Episcopal, Universal. In English? We know it's infallibly taught because it has always been taught as intrinsically evil and the Pope closed the matter in Humanae Vitae, just as Pope John Paul II closed the issue of female ordination in Ordinatio Sacerdotalis in 1994. [/quote] :applause:
Aloysius Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 In the other thread, the possibility was admitted that in theory, John Paul II or Paul VI could have taugh fallaciously that either of these things was already infallible, because their statements are not infallible. So to me, this all seems to fall apart there: if things are already infallible teachings then something which cannot be wrong must confirm for us that they are already infallible. If the thing which tells us that they are already infallible can be wrong about that, then we have no certitude.
Era Might Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 We do not need an infallible statement on the infallibility of a particular doctrine, because our faith and obedience does not proceed from infallibility, but from the Holy Spirit's guidance of the Church. The Church leads us, for the most part, through her ordinary Magisterium, and that is sufficient. If she feels the need to settle something through extraordinary means, she will do so. You're missing the point that it doesn't matter whether a document is infallible or not. It has no bearing on whether we owe obedience. We no more need to know infallibly that something is infallible than we need to know infallibly that we are in a state of grace (which the Council of Trent says is impossible, except by special revelation).
Aloysius Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 I never said it did. My concern is for the historical and apologetic certitude we can have in this doctrine. We tell people it is very simple to show the Catholic Church wrong... show two infallible statements contradicting each other. The way this is presented leaves ten outs to a flush on the river... where is our certitude here in the infallibility of this? there doesn't have to be certitude in this for our religious assent. but for shouting from the rooftops "this is infallible", there ought to be certitude. if, in theory, john paul ii can be wrong about it already being an infallible doctrine, then there is still no certitude in its infallibility. this would all be solved if the ordinary papal magisterium could not be wrong about what was already infallible according to the ordinary universal magisterium. not that the document of ordinatio sacerdolis would be infallible in any way, but that its declaration that things were already set-in-stone infallible could not be wrong.
Era Might Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 Our certitude is in the Holy Father saying it is definitive, and commanding all Catholics to hold it as definitive. Even if the Ordinary Magisterium were infallible when talking about something infallible, you would still have to prove that the Pope can be infallible at all. You are looking for absolute certitude. We don't have that. We don't need that. Christianity is, by definition, a religion that begins with faith. You can shout from the rooftops that the Church's teaching is infallible; you just can't shout from the rooftops that Ordinatio Sacerdotalis is infallible, because it isn't. Many converts, unfortunately, are mislead into a false idea of Catholic unity that sets up everything as black/white, fallible/infallible. And then when they come into the Church, and they see nuance and discussion and flexibility, their false view of the Church doesn't match up with reality, and they lose heart. The Catholic faith has never been about determining what is "infallible" and what isn't. The Catholic faith is an Apostolic communion which is handed on through the living witness of the episcopate in every generation. Pope John Paul II and Pope Paul VI contributed to that living witness with these respective doctrines. They did not choose to invoke their charism of infallibility, because it wasn't necessary. The authority of the doctrines themselves, and the authority of their ordinary magisterium, was sufficient. The early Church didn't need an infallible Papal statement to tell them that the Gospels were inspired by God; they didn't even need an Ecumenical Council to do so. Why? Because their faith proceeded from their trust in the living preservation of truth in the Church. At the end of the day, a non-Catholic has to answer one question: do you believe in the authority of the Catholic Church? If they do, then the Holy Father's judgement is sufficient, even if it is not infallible in itself. If they don't, then they need to do some more soul searching. Either way, their decision to be Catholic should proceed from faith, not from arbitary judgements on what is and is not infallibly infallible. Ultimately, they still have to rely on their own faith in the infallible interpreter of what is infallible, and they themselves can never be infallible. It all proceeds from faith.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now