Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

My bishop tightening rules for marriage


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.coloradocatholicherald.com/display.php?xrc=207"]His Holiness Bishop Sheridan has increased the demands for marriage prep.[/url] His new policy has raised some eyebrows. As consolation, I understand Italy requires a 2 year prep.

Posted

It certainly raises my eyebrows.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

That's pretty cool, so long as the instructors are well educated... and the people are prepared.

photosynthesis
Posted

2 years? I think that's a little nuts if you ask me.

My archdiocese requires engaged couples to notify the parish priest at least one year in advance, and I think that's fine, but 2 years seems realy unnecessary.

I think it has a lot to do with what the purpose of engagement is. Some people think engagement is all about discerning whether or not you're called to marry someone... however, I think it's important to get engaged *after* you've already discerned that. Once you've properly discerned the vocation to marry, it [i]really[/i] shouldn't take more than a year to prepare for marriage, unless you have special circumstances

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' post='1025914' date='Jul 17 2006, 09:06 AM']
2 years? I think that's a little nuts if you ask me.


[/quote]


Might depend on perspective and history. 2 years in a conservative diocese where things are pretty tight with Rome might be a tad long. But, in a liberal hippy diocese that is all but schismatic, it might be what is needed to help bring things back into line.

*DISCLAIMER* No offense intended to the Colorado diocese in question - I have no idea how in line it is... :saint:

*DISCLAIMER for the above disclaimer* A LOT of offense intended for those dioceses that match the description I put forth - shame on you! :topsy:

photosynthesis
Posted

but why would forcing people to delay marriage be good for any diocese? It can't possibly take that long to prepare MOST Catholic couples. I usually associate LONG drawn out engagements with secular couples, who don't think they're "ready" to make a lifelong commitment. They feel like they have to "take a couple years" to "try the relationship out." If a couple is not ready to get married, then why are they even engaged?

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I don't know that it's necessarily claiming the couple is not ready to get married...

But, in today's world where many people decide they want to get married after only 2 months, it seems like a good thing. You need time to get to know the other person.

(BTW... it seems Colorado's is only 1 year... he mentioned that [i]Italy[/i] (he thinks, I haven't heard this) requires 2 years; 2 years seems perhaps a bit excessive to me, but 1 year seems like a good plan)

Mitchell_b55
Posted (edited)

We also have to understand that Europeans work at a different pace than Americans. In a place were from 1 - 4 PM everything is completely shut down and only the restaurants remain open, one can understand that it is the intensified pace of life in America that makes us drop our jaws in awe. One year in America is the equivalent of half a lifetime. I mean, God forbid, I might accidently alose all my stock holdings tomorrow and then I would never be prepared for marriage. Better do it now. I think the biggest problem with time is the fact that people don't like to keep their knickers on that long. Someone with a devout faith would quietly accept it. Why we travel through life without resting or slowing are pace is beyond me. Patience. I spent 3 years preparing before I was baptized into the Church. those who are patient remember every moment of their life with the clarity of a home movie except the emotion is real too.

P.S. I think the American Media has ADD. I mean when was the last time you heard about Osama bin Ladin, or SARS, or West Nile Virus, even the Avian Flu. Huh! I thought that was going to be a big thing. :rolleyes:

Edited by petrus_scholasticus
Posted

I don't see why some of those things should be mandatory. :idontknow: I'm not saying it's bad, it's just that circumstances probably differ from couple to couple.

Posted

The biggest gripe I have witnessed yet comes from our parish Marital Prep leaders. They do lots of evangelization to nominal Catholics who want to get married in our parish. Through working with engaged couples, the leaders work hard at leading them back to the faith. Our leaders complain that couples who would return to the church now will go get married in a non-Cat church once they hear of the 1 year requirement and be gone for good.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

This may seem cold but I am afraid that the way back to a strong Catholic Church is not for the already poorly catechized. Yes we must reach out to them. We need to evangelize them. But the way back to a strong Catholic Church is to build up the family. Right now the family has been assualted from every side until even Catholics don't have a solid foundation for entering in to marriage. I think 2 years is too long but greater preparation in my mind is not a bad thing. The days of cafeteria Catholicism are over. We need quality more than we need quantity. I am for more marriage prep.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

I think they should just do away with engaged encounters and require meeting w/ a holy couple for marriage prep. I don't think it's quite necessary for it to be a year, though.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...