Church Punk Posted July 18, 2006 Posted July 18, 2006 Well the debate has begun and I have been providing apologetics for this issue. As many of you may know the theology of 7th Day Adventist is based upon the Lords day being Saturday not Sunday as in the Jewish tradition. I have read up on the subject at New Advent (see the link below) as well as other sources and I have even let him have a look at the site to read my source for the explanations I was giving. I now have received a good email from him, by which he poses decent argument backing his case. Can one of you theologians review this for me and provided any help in direction to support the Catholic tradition of Worship on Sunday? [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14335a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14335a.htm[/url] From his last email to me: [quote]The argument for Sunday keeping in the light of the 4th Commandment holds no water. The Bible expressly states that the 7th day is God's holy day because He sanctified it and set it apart for holy use. Genesis 2: 1-3. Further, The Lord's day as mentioned in Revelation 1: 10 is not Sunday, but satruday as seen in what Jesus Himself said in Mark ;:27,28. The sabbath was made for man to use for worship and not man to change it according to his whim and fancy. The early church fathers had no Biblical injunction to change it. They did it to avoid the Jews just as Moslems chose Friday to avoid being identified with the Christian sabbath= Sunday and also the Jewish Sabbath- saturday. God is not a Jew. The Sabbath according to the Bible is not Jewish. The Law was existant long before Abraham into the scene. The Ten Commandments as found in Exodus Ch 20 : 1- 17 is a complete picture of God's will for us. When Jesus said: " if you love me, keep my commandments - John 15: 10. The Father's commdments are holy unto Jesus and us humans. We have no business to tamper with God's law. We need to hear God's word and pay heed to it. James chapter 1: 23-25 is plain in its statement. If Sunday is God's holy day (sic) then why do people go to churhc just for an hour and then go for ball games, watch movies and go picknicking/ The 4th commandment expressly states that we should not do any work, neither anyone working for you. Exodus 20: 8-11. Jesus kept the Sabbath- Luke 4: 16. When He arose on Sunday Luke 24: 1- 6 , He even kept the Sabbath in the grave by resting on that day and even the women who wanted to annoint His body that Good Friday evening did not do it as the Sabbath was coming on. So they rested accoding to the commandment. If Jesus did away with the law as many Christians say today, How come the women kept the Sabbath after He died? Also, Paul the great evangelist, kept and preached to both Jews and Gentiles on the real Sabbath. Acts 13: 42- 43. We do not keep the law to be saved. That is salvation by works. We keep the Law because we are saved by His death on the cross and His blood cleanses us from all sin. The is the Gospel and the good news of salvation. Do not go to human arguments for reasoning, but to God's word that has stood the vissicitudes of time and humna logic.The very first line of your article is plain enough to see that the Sunday keeping arose from Egyptian time keeping in line with their worship of the Sun! We need to worship the Creator, not His creation! Any comments are welcome.[/quote]
Seatbelt Blue Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 [quote name='Church Punk' post='1026962' date='Jul 18 2006, 03:04 PM'] Well the debate has begun and I have been providing apologetics for this issue. As many of you may know the theology of 7th Day Adventist is based upon the Lords day being Saturday not Sunday as in the Jewish tradition. I have read up on the subject at New Advent (see the link below) as well as other sources and I have even let him have a look at the site to read my source for the explanations I was giving. I now have received a good email from him, by which he poses decent argument backing his case. Can one of you theologians review this for me and provided any help in direction to support the Catholic tradition of Worship on Sunday? [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14335a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14335a.htm[/url] From his last email to me: [/quote] I've been wondering about this myself, and I'm not sure if the "binding and loosing" passage is of much help here, because I've been under the impression it applies to halacha, and I'm not sure if the Sabbath observance constitutes halacha. But again, I really have no idea and would also appreciate a good, firm answer.
thessalonian Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 First of all it was hardly on a whim. Jesus arose from the dead on Sunday. The Mass is culminated in our partaking of the Lord's Supper on the day he rose. There is much significance in this that I do not have time to go in to now. Let's start with Acts 13:42. Paul is found in the synagouge preaching to a very large group of people which apparently included both Jews and Gentiles though it is not clear whether they are gentile converts to Judaism as indicated above. It makes no difference. Now what precipitated Paul being at this synagouge on the Sabaath? Well let's go back to v. 14: [14] but they passed on from Perga and came to Antioch of Pisid'ia. And on the sabbath day they went into the synagogue and sat down. [15] After the reading of the law and the prophets, the rulers of the synagogue sent to them, saying, "Brethren, if you have any word of exhortation for the people, say it." Paul comes to Antioch and on the Sabaath he goes where jews are gathered. In the synagouge. It does not say he went there to pray or to worship but what he ends up doing is going there to preach the Gospel. Now I don't doudt that he prayed and worshipped but that was not his mission. He went there to gain converts to Christianity. To preach the Gospel. That is his primary purpose throughout Acts when he enters the synagouges. Nowhere does he go to the synagouges on the Sabaath to find other Christians to fellowship and worship with that I can find. Someone correct me if I am wrong. Where else would you go to get bang for the buck than where a large group of people gather if you want to evangelize? Now these Jews that he preaches to in Acts 13:14 ask him to come back the following Sabaath. It is not Paul's requirement that he come back and worship and preach on the following Sabaath but their wish as Jews who worship on the Sabaath. Paul most assuradely would have come on any day they asked or does your friend think the Word of God can only be preached on the Sabaath? So Paul comes back at their request. Once again he is not meeting Christians but Jews. So what your friend needs to provide is a place in scripture where Paul goes to meet and fellowship and worship with other Christians. There is one such place in Acts 20 where he comes and breaks bread (Lord's Supper) with Christians. It is in Acts 20 but it happens "on the first day of the week". So it is not of much help to him. Secondly I would point you to the book of revelations. John was caught up in his vision on "the Lord's Day". This is known in the early Church on Sunday. If you read Scott Hahn's book, the Lamb's Supper, he shows how the book of revelations parrellel's the Mass. This isn't going to do much for your friend as he won't likely see it. But it should build your faith if you read that book. Once again ask him to show you a place in scripture where Paul meets with Christians on the Sabaath to worship rather than with Jews for the purpose of evangelizing them. Hope this is helpful Thess
Church Punk Posted July 19, 2006 Author Posted July 19, 2006 Thanks a lot Thess. I think that the problem I am have doesnt lie with the Sabbath day. But our whole teaching and understanding of who Jesus is compared to the protestant. When we look at the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, we can note that EVERY Day is the Lords day as it should be, not just one day a week. The Church celebrates in the Lambs Supper Everyday of the week, not just on one day. So the interpetation of scripture play huge in this debate. Thank you for your insite. PAX
thessalonian Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 (edited) Your point is well taken. In fact, the Church these days celebrates the Mass around the clock somewhere in the world. A seeming fullfillment of the following passage which was applied to the Mass by the Early Church Fathers. Mal.1 [11] For from the rising of the sun to its setting my name is great among the nations, and in every place incense is offered to my name, and a pure offering; for my name is great among the nations, says the LORD of hosts. Edited July 19, 2006 by thessalonian
phatcatholic Posted July 21, 2006 Posted July 21, 2006 i'm not very good at this debate, but i have plenty of resources that will help: [b]--[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/572"]Sunday Worship[/url] --[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/200"]The Sabbath Day[/url][/b] peace, phat
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now