skellmeyer Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 (edited) Everyone seems to think World War III has started. Newt Gingrich, President Bush, Sean Hannity – the opinions are coming fast and furious. Unfortunately, the assertion seems to be more bombast than substance. While the conflict against Wahabbi Islam and its variants span the globe, it is not at all clear that it approaches anything like a world war. World Wars I and II saw the institution of the draft and/or the mobilization of millions of men in dozens of countries on several continents. The smallest battles in these wars injured or killed hundreds, the big battles saw tens of thousands of casualties. In both wars, huge sections of major cities were either seriously damaged or entirely destroyed. In both wars, governments nearly succeeded in destroying entire populations: in World War I, the Turks committed genocide against the Armenians, in World War II, Germany committed genocide against gypsies, Jews and Catholics. Both wars resulted in the functional disappearance of empires (Austria-Hungarian and Britain’s empire, respectively). In both world wars, the economies of the combatants were so fully engaged in producing war material and maintaining men in the field that strict rationing was enforced on the entire civilian population of virtually every participating country. It is important to remember that the designation “world war” is a purely 20th-century phenomenon. The Napoleanic Wars, for instance, were certainly fought at various locations around the world (including the Pacific) and certainly involved the whole of Europe, the northern coasts of Africa, the Middle-East and Asia. Those wars mobilized millions of men and involved the destruction of significant urban areas Despite this, Napolean is not considered to have started a “world war.” Similarly, we can point to various times in Britain’s history where she was simultaneously involved in several wars to maintain a world-wide empire (the American Revolution, for instance, was but one brush-fire in a much larger series of British conflicts), but she is not considered to have started a “world war” either. So, does the current conflict rise to the level of “world war”? It’s hard to see how it would. Certainly one can point to armed conflict in at least a dozen countries around the world, but that’s about the strongest argument that can be made. Muslims are not fully mobilized for war, nor is a significant percentage of Muslim men involved in armed conflict. Even the most successful Islamic assault, September 11th, had less than two dozen enemy combatants directly involved. Most of the incidents involve groups much smaller than one dozen. The “battles”, if one wishes to call the various terrorist incidents by this name, are not particularly deadly. In most cases (September 11 being an unusual exception), casualties do not even reach a thousand injured, in fact, they generally don’t get much above one hundred or so. There is no war-time rationing. Indeed, quite the opposite is the case. Apart from the two occasions where American forces actually invaded a country (Afghanistan and Iraq), there have been no serious pitched battles between combatants. Instead, the terrorists have inflicted a level of violence much more similar to that inflicted by mob-run gangs who fought each other and police during Prohibition. Cities are not razed, most are left entirely untouched. Even September 11 involved the total destruction of less than a dozen buildings in New York City, an urban area that contains hundreds of thousands of commercial buildings. Most attacks consist of train bombings or individual suicide bombers, barely noticeable events on the military violence scale. Islamic terrorists seem to be set up much more along the lines of organized criminal gangs than they are armies. Indeed, given the level of intra-Muslim violence, it is not unreasonable to draw comparisons between gang warfare and the current level of Islamic violence. In short, if this is World War III, then world wars are definitely getting pretty wimpy. [b]About the Writer:[/b] Steve Kellmeyer is a nationally recognized author and lecturer who integrates today's headlines with the Catholic Faith. His work is available through [url="http://www.bridegroompress.com"]http://www.bridegroompress.com[/url]. He can be contacted at skellmeyer@bridegroompress.com. Edited July 19, 2006 by skellmeyer
skellmeyer Posted July 19, 2006 Author Posted July 19, 2006 Hey, don't blame me. Someone from phatmass asked me to post some of my stuff here, so I did. If you don't want it, I won't bother.
Birgitta Noel Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 Jamie! Be nice. This isn't ! Steve is just sharing his opinion
Era Might Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 I don't think WW3 has "started", but I think it is brewing. The conditions are very similar to WW2. Hitler drew up "Case White" and began preparations to invade Poland in 1939. The malicious intent of Iran is eerily similar, with Hezbollah in Iran today explicitly welcoming a third world war. Before WW2, of course, there was a lot of diplomatic activity between Germany, Austria, England, the United States, and Russia, with the infamous meeting in Munich and the sacrifice of Czechoslovakia. We see the same kind of roundtable right now, with Israel, Iran, North Korea, Russia, England, and Palestine. Pray, pray, pray.
Jaime Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 [quote name='skellmeyer' post='1027111' date='Jul 18 2006, 08:36 PM'] Hey, don't blame me. Someone from phatmass asked me to post some of my stuff here, so I did. If you don't want it, I won't bother. [/quote] I have no problems with the article. Its the writer's note at the end that I thought was superflous and self serving.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1027125' date='Jul 18 2006, 08:28 PM'] I have no problems with the article. Its the writer's note at the end that I thought was superflous and self serving. [/quote] [img]http://www.galapagosinc.com/images/thelook.gif[/img]
Ash Wednesday Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 I can understand Jamie's irritation. That last paragraph does have a real spam vibe to it. Spam vibes aside, what difference does it make if this doesn't fit the description of a "world war"? Does that somehow make it "not as serious"? As far as I'm concerned, there is no "wimpy" or "strong" in war. It's not a flippin' hurricane for people to categorize in strength. It's still WAR.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 (edited) I asked Steve to come to PM because his books are awesome and I knew he used to post in the past. Welcome! Edited July 20, 2006 by thedude
Jaime Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 Nobody has a problem with Steve posting here. In fact I think it would be great if he posted more often. However the premise of his article (in my opinion) is flawed. If you only want to define what is a world war by examining the previous world wars at their most intense, then yes this is wimpy. But the start of both world wars were hardly auspicious or dramatic. The trigger point for WWI was an assasination. While WWII's start was a bit grander, (the invasion of a country), it was also a chain reaction. No one at the time called Hitlers invasion "WWII" but it was definitely the start of it. That is not dissimilar to what is happening now. If we get aggressive with North Korea,what will China's reaction be? If we get aggressive with Iran, what will be the reaction of Russia? If the war in the Israel escalates, what is going to be the US's reaction? While the war in Iraq did not make us popular around the world, Saddam had no allies to rely upon. Neither did the Taliban in Afghanistan. However we can't say the same for the political powderkegs that are lit now. Iran, North Korea and Israel all have powerful friends.
Didacus Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 Things are excallading very fast in the last few weeks (especially this last week). Very grim, very grim. Prayers indeed. And I agree, WWIII or not; who cares! Are people getting less hurt or killed? Is the 'importance' of a war proportional to the amount of lives it destroys? WWII is the only was in human history to have seen battles on all continents.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 [quote name='Didacus' post='1027629' date='Jul 20 2006, 03:56 PM'] WWII is the only was in human history to have seen battles on all continents. [/quote] Was there one on Antarctica?
Didacus Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1027626' date='Jul 20 2006, 01:51 PM'] [snip] That is not dissimilar to what is happening now. If we get aggressive with North Korea,what will China's reaction be? If we get aggressive with Iran, what will be the reaction of Russia? p[snip] [/quote] You sum my thoughts very well hot stuff. the fact is the world is interconnected one to another in a way that if you remove a single piece, the others will fall. Afg. and Iraq where exceptions since they did not have 'powerful friends' to speak of. Iran, Isreal, N.Korea, as you say, are world players. Adn their firends by the way, and nuclear powers. Of particular note about Isreal, is the passionate outlook the world has towards it. Christinaity, Judaism, and Islam all have major religious stakes in that region, and though I despise, even hate to admit it, nothing fuels a passion for war quite like religion does. Israel is not denying, as of today, the possibility of a full scale invasion. NOT GOOD people... not good at all. pray pray pray And remember that whatever happens - stand tall, be strong, be faithful [quote name='thedude' post='1027632' date='Jul 20 2006, 01:58 PM'] Was there one on Antarctica? [/quote] Everyone's a critic. Make that every 'habitated' continent. ok? If WWIII breaks loose, maybe we'll all end up lliving in Antartica.
LSW Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1027626' date='Jul 20 2006, 02:51 PM'] Nobody has a problem with Steve posting here. In fact I think it would be great if he posted more often. However the premise of his article (in my opinion) is flawed. If you only want to define what is a world war by examining the previous world wars at their most intense, then yes this is wimpy. But the start of both world wars were hardly auspicious or dramatic. The trigger point for WWI was an assasination. While WWII's start was a bit grander, (the invasion of a country), it was also a chain reaction. No one at the time called Hitlers invasion "WWII" but it was definitely the start of it. That is not dissimilar to what is happening now. If we get aggressive with North Korea,what will China's reaction be? If we get aggressive with Iran, what will be the reaction of Russia? If the war in the Israel escalates, what is going to be the US's reaction? While the war in Iraq did not make us popular around the world, Saddam had no allies to rely upon. Neither did the Taliban in Afghanistan. However we can't say the same for the political powderkegs that are lit now. Iran, North Korea and Israel all have powerful friends. [/quote]
Pontifite 7 of 10 Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 And N. Korea has a butt-lode of nukes to blow the first country that attacks his friends.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted July 20, 2006 Posted July 20, 2006 [quote name='Didacus' post='1027639' date='Jul 20 2006, 04:04 PM'] Everyone's a critic. Make that every 'habitated' continent. ok? If WWIII breaks loose, maybe we'll all end up lliving in Antartica. [/quote] Not trying to be critical. I used to read a lot about WWII and seriously wondered if there was something I did not know about.
Didacus Posted July 21, 2006 Posted July 21, 2006 [quote name='thedude' post='1027690' date='Jul 20 2006, 03:13 PM'] Not trying to be critical. I used to read a lot about WWII and seriously wondered if there was something I did not know about. [/quote] No sweat dude, its all good. The Germans sent a submarine in the St-Laurent during WWII. It sunk a couple of ships (if I remember right, they where commercial ships). I'll have to search to remember the few battles that occured in South America; they where minor in the overall scale of the war. honestly,m although WWII was fougt on every continent, it has that claim through obscure battles of little overall consequence; few people actually know this and its difficult to even find it in books, I came accross the fact in a foot note myself. I was about 10 years old when I started reading on the first and second world war. I had a certain fascination with destruction. when I was 18, I told my mother I wanted to join the millitary; she started crying! Now that I'm all grown up (at least I think I am), I understand why she was crying. I wouldn't want my son to join the army either. Anyone read the morning's article on the situation in Israel?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted July 21, 2006 Posted July 21, 2006 (edited) [quote name='The Little Way' post='1027112' date='Jul 18 2006, 09:36 PM'] Jamie! Be nice. This isn't ! Steve is just sharing his opinion [/quote] I figured hot stuff was referring to the ad at the bottom. Anyway, I like most of Mr. Kellmeyer's apologetics. Bible Basics is a must have. Oh, and my catechetics advisor says he knows him from Peoria. I'm a bit biased. Edited July 21, 2006 by Raphael
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now