jswranch Posted July 22, 2006 Posted July 22, 2006 No. Bull, encyclical, letter.. etc. are types of pronouncements/communication. However, they can be.
fearundercontrol Posted July 22, 2006 Posted July 22, 2006 (edited) Here are the qualifications for something to be [i]ex cathedra[/i]: □ The pope has to speak as pastor and teacher of all the faithful with the full weight of his supreme apostolic authority ¨ This is known either by the formulation (he says it) or by the circumstances □ The pope must have the intention to decide definitively (finally) a teaching of faith ¨ Without this intention made clear, it is not a complete dogmatic definition [i]ex cathedra[/i] Hope that helps. Edited July 22, 2006 by fearundercontrol
jswranch Posted July 23, 2006 Posted July 23, 2006 [quote name='fearundercontrol' post='1028882' date='Jul 22 2006, 01:53 PM'] Here are the qualifications for something to be [i]ex cathedra[/i]: □ The pope has to speak as pastor and teacher of all the faithful with the full weight of his supreme apostolic authority ¨ This is known either by the formulation (he says it) or by the circumstances □ The pope must have the intention to decide definitively (finally) a teaching of faith ¨ Without this intention made clear, it is not a complete dogmatic definition [i]ex cathedra[/i] Hope that helps. [/quote] Amen. And as a side note, a teaching need not be pronounced ex cathedra IOT to be infallible or binding.
fearundercontrol Posted July 24, 2006 Posted July 24, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1029547' date='Jul 23 2006, 03:31 PM'] And as a side note, a teaching need not be pronounced ex cathedra IOT to be infallible or binding. [/quote] Yeah. That got my class pretty confused lol.
thessalonian Posted July 24, 2006 Posted July 24, 2006 I prefer to focus on papal primacy. Infallibility is really a little used doctrine in the positive sense (as explained above). The Assumption and Immaculate Conception are arguabley the only two times the dogma has been applied since Vatican I when the dogma of infallibility was declared (though it has always applied throughout the history of the Church, even though not dogmatically declared, and there is evidence of this as well). There are only around 20 infallible statements by Popes. By the way even in a dogmatic encyclical, only the statement defining and binding the dogma is infallible. Not the whole encyclical. In the negative sense it must be remembered that the dogma by the power of the Holy Spirit prevents popes from making errant statements binding on the whole Church as well. In that sense I think perhaps every Pope has used it.
fearundercontrol Posted July 24, 2006 Posted July 24, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1029835' date='Jul 24 2006, 08:01 AM'] In the negative sense it must be remembered that the dogma by the power of the Holy Spirit prevents popes from making errant statements binding on the whole Church as well. [/quote] Yup. That's why the Church doesn't have an official statement on predestination. I don't remember who they were, but two popes in a row tried to make a declaration or whatever on it, but they both died like the day before they were planning on making the announcement. The following pope decided not to say anything on it.
thessalonian Posted July 25, 2006 Posted July 25, 2006 (edited) Your not giving the whole story it seems. [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/SCRIPTUR/PREDESTI.TXT"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/SCRIPTUR/PREDESTI.TXT[/url] It appears Leo XI was between them but I don't see anything that says he was going to make any kind of a declaration on predestination. Further Paul V did not just throw his hands up on the matter. The Church does not have to make a ruling and predestination is a very complex matter. There are statements in the catechism however. Edited July 25, 2006 by thessalonian
fearundercontrol Posted July 25, 2006 Posted July 25, 2006 Sorry I don't have the best memory. I was trying to recount what one of my profs told my class and I very well could have screwed up the "two in a row" part. I just know there were two of them. And I know that the Church doesn't have to make a declaration/ruling/whatever. And it is a really complex matter.
jswranch Posted July 30, 2006 Posted July 30, 2006 Since you mentioned predestination: Can I correctly say The Blessed Virgin Mary was predestined to remain sinless?
thessalonian Posted July 31, 2006 Posted July 31, 2006 (edited) [quote name='jswranch' post='1034076' date='Jul 29 2006, 11:41 PM'] Since you mentioned predestination: Can I correctly say The Blessed Virgin Mary was predestined to remain sinless? [/quote] Yes. Once again though, not in a robotic way, apart from her will or apart from grace on the reverse side of the same coin. Edited July 31, 2006 by thessalonian
jswranch Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1034853' date='Jul 31 2006, 02:12 PM'] Yes. Once again though, not in a robotic way, apart from her will or apart from grace on the reverse side of the same coin. [/quote] Wheew, glad to see i am learning something. I can state she was predstined, but how does predstination work while the person still has free will? Can you send me a link to a simple explanation to these aparent discrepancy?
Guest JeffCR07 Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I'd suggest reading St. Anselm's [i]De Concordia Praescientiae et Praedestinationis et Gratiae Dei cum Libero Arbitrio[/i] (or just "De Concordia" for short). It deals with questions of reconciling divine foreknowledge, predestination, and human free will.
thessalonian Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 The link I gave above is somewhat helpful to the question. [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/SCRIPTUR/PREDESTI.TXT"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/SCRIPTUR/PREDESTI.TXT[/url] "To solve this problem we must notice that although a man by the movement of free will can neither merit nor obtain divine grace, yet he can block himself from receiving it. ...But they alone are deprived of grace who set up in themselves an impediment to grace, just as, when the sun shines on the world, he deserves blame who shuts his eyes...."" Keeping in mind that the Church does not teach predestination to damnaition and says that God gives all men the grace sufficient for their salvation, I think the concept of free will, creating an impediment is right on. Paul's words in romans when he says "the good that I would do I do not, while the evil that I would not do, I do.". I think many times when we sin, we do not do so because of our will which is weaker than the flesh. Free will is molded by God against sin but when we give in to see by that will, then we are in danger of damnation. Not by a predestination by God but by resistance to his desire for us to be with him for all eternity. "God desires all men to be saved and come to a knowledge of the truth". We must therefore assume he makes salvation available to all, knowing that some will resist by their will. In the end of course the balance and solution between grace and free will will remain somewhat of a mystery as it is beyond our comprehension how it all works together I think. I've not read Anslem but I usually take Jeff's advice. He's a straight shooter. Therefore I think I will look Anselm up myself. Blessings
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now