at0m1c Posted July 22, 2006 Posted July 22, 2006 How is it that animals can have emotions, without having a soul like ours? And if they are under our dominion, why do we have to drag them around or whip them? Why can't we command them to stop and it just happens?
matthew1618 Posted July 22, 2006 Posted July 22, 2006 [quote name='at0m1c' post='1028809' date='Jul 22 2006, 01:14 PM'] How is it that animals can have emotions, without having a soul like ours? And if they are under our dominion, why do we have to drag them around or whip them? Why can't we command them to stop and it just happens? [/quote] They don't have reason, they just go by their insticts.
Norseman82 Posted July 24, 2006 Posted July 24, 2006 Anyone who has ever had a dog or cat knows that you don't train them, they train you!!!
Tindomiel Posted July 25, 2006 Posted July 25, 2006 A guide to Genesis that I was reading basically said that we lost perfect dominion over the animals with the Original Sin. When our original state of grace was lost, we refused to enter in to the Lord's Day out of the sixth day on which we were created with the animals. So our fallen nature is no longer completely unidentifiable with the animals and we can no longer control them perfectly (even if we could we would no longer treat them [i]wisely[/i]). I hope that helps. Humans are still far above animals in the natural heirerarchy, of course, but Sin degrades this state of being. Here's a quote from the Catechism on the subject as well: [quote] Man's dominion over inanimate and other living beings granted by the Creator is not absolute; it is limited by concern for the quality of life of his neighbor, including generations to come; it requires a religious respect for the integrity of creation.[/quote]
Guest JeffCR07 Posted July 25, 2006 Posted July 25, 2006 According to St. Thomas and Aristotle, animals have souls, but they are not immaterial souls capable of subsisting on their own in seperation from the body. Emotions or sensations are not an attribute of the soul considered in its immateriality, but rather, are physical reactions that are made possible by virtue of the fact that the matter of the body is informed with a sensative, or animal, soul. All of that is a long way of saying that the souls of animals are different from ours because our souls have the capacity for abstract reason, which is immaterial, while their souls do not. Everything that an animal can do or feel can be explained by appeal to their biology. Humans are different because our abstract reason transcends matter. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
Tindomiel Posted July 25, 2006 Posted July 25, 2006 [quote name='JeffCR07' post='1030461' date='Jul 25 2006, 09:41 AM'] According to St. Thomas and Aristotle, animals have souls, but they are not immaterial souls capable of subsisting on their own in seperation from the body. Emotions or sensations are not an attribute of the soul considered in its immateriality, but rather, are physical reactions that are made possible by virtue of the fact that the matter of the body is informed with a sensative, or animal, soul. All of that is a long way of saying that the souls of animals are different from ours because our souls have the capacity for abstract reason, which is immaterial, while their souls do not. Everything that an animal can do or feel can be explained by appeal to their biology. Humans are different because our abstract reason transcends matter. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff [/quote] Nice! I love that discussion in Aquinas.
Mitchell_b55 Posted July 26, 2006 Posted July 26, 2006 Just thought I would put in my two cents. Anima, is Latin for breath or soul, make the connection. If it [b]breathes[/b] it has a soul. Animare, to give life to. An [b]Anima[/b]l breathes. Aquinas obviously knows what he is talking about on the matter. Aristotles Thesis on the Soul is titled, De Anima.
batteddy Posted July 28, 2006 Posted July 28, 2006 Yeah, emotions have nothing to do with the soul. They are chemical reaction in the brain, part of our Lower or "sensitive" Appetite. They are the "fleshy passions," anger, desire, sadness, hapiness...etc...
Tindomiel Posted July 28, 2006 Posted July 28, 2006 I would think that these "emotions" as felt by animals would probably be much different than those experienced by humans, because our experience of emotion is so intrinsically tied up with our intellect, our free will (when it comes to responding to the emotion), etc. :thinking: And I don't think happiness could truly be considered alongside anger, desire, sadness, etc, because according to St. Thomas Aquinas and Aristotle happiness is the ultimate end of every human. As Catholics, we know that happiness consists in the Beatific vision. So happiness, then, has to be inseperable from love, free will, and those other attributes with which God created man. Since animals do not share these attributes they can't be happy as we understand the word. Now that I've written all this out, however, I suppose it is possible for animals to be happy in one way, ie by glorifying God through their existence and obedience to Him. Even in this case, however, their happiness would be of a much lower order than that of humans. I suppose this capacity for happiness may be part of what causes the "hierarchy" of created beings.....
Guest JeffCR07 Posted July 28, 2006 Posted July 28, 2006 According to the Aristotelian/Thomistic hypothesis, "happiness" corresponds to the fulfillment of the [i]telos[/i] or the end of a thing. Thus, there is "happiness" for animals, but it is not the same as "happiness" for man. Since happiness corresponds to the successful fulfillment of natural faculties, animal happiness consists in the cultivation and preservation of the animal's physical body. Because man can reason, man's natural happiness involves the cultivation and preservation of both the body and the mind. That is why our happiness takes on, as Tindomiel says, an intellectual aspect. Moreover, it should be pointed out that man has not only a [i]natural[/i] end (as discussed above) but also a [i]supernatural[/i] end, that follows from his being made in the image of God. The fulfillment of this supernatural end is not merely the cultivation and preservation of the mind and body, but rather, it is the perfection of that [i]imago dei[/i] in the soul, and this can only be had through perfect communion with God - the Beatific Vision. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
phatcatholic Posted July 29, 2006 Posted July 29, 2006 jeff....................everything u post is freakin gold, dude. i heart jeff.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted July 31, 2006 Posted July 31, 2006 are you kidding me? compared to all the work you do, my little posts are nothing. You're my hero dude
kateri05 Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 oh no, humility duel.... who will break first? : you guys are both pretty cool, i must say
Ziggamafu Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='1033631' date='Jul 29 2006, 10:02 AM'] jeff....................everything u post is freakin gold, dude. i heart jeff. [/quote] Jeff, I totally agree. Amazing and insightful; I think I've really learned something or been inspired by every serious post of yours. Nick, you are like the work horse or vital cog of phatmass, imho; I've wondered from time to time if you are actually some form of advanced artificial intelligence secretly implanted into phatmass by the Jesuits.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 Naw, nick is more orthodox than the jesuits :
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now