Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

The film has garnered extremely negative reviews. "Meandering." "Boring." "Confusing." "Egotistical." "Audience punishment." "Astonishingly irritating."

These reviews are so patently false as to be incoherant.

The film was astonishingly beautiful, intensely moving. My heart leapt in my chest, weeping stuck in my throat. The audience erupted into applause at the end.

I have never been to a movie where anyone bothered to applaud at the end. Ever.

Lady in the Water resonated with me so deeply, so brilliantly, that I was speechless upon leaving the theatre. I honestly felt like a better person at the end. I mean, sweet Jesus, I felt LIKE A BETTER PERSON.

The picture is all about purpose in existence and an extraordinary world just to the left, just around the corner of the ordinary one. From the most unexpected places come strength and will to serve, yes, to serve even in the most ridiculous manner, to come together and live out their purposed lives in the most meaningful of places -- the mundane ones. In an apartment complex in Philadelphia with a pool, there came a delicate and beautiful story, a drama in their lives, guided by fate or God. The story is ultimately and deliberately vocational, centered, absolutely centered on the premise that we are all called to a particular service, at a particular time, for a particular good -- to give ourselves even if we can't understand what's going on.

The movie is profoundly spiritual, profoundly purposed, and skillfully executed. I cannot praise it enough, and I pray -- yes, I pray -- that this movie will attain the recognition it deserves.

melporcristo
Posted

it was good. I just felt I needed to talk about it after wards in order to figure out whether I liked it.
But yes, my friends who I saw it with loved it.
I just got scared by the monster thing

Posted

I enjoyed it...

Wasn't Shyamalan's best - but he did NOT disappoint!

Awesome review, Seatbelt...

Posted

The National Catholic Register reviewer abhorred it. I don't always agree with his reviews though....

Posted

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='1031120' date='Jul 26 2006, 08:59 AM']
The National Catholic Register reviewer abhorred it. I don't always agree with his reviews though....
[/quote]


Too bad, I thought it was well worth the money. My girlfriend liked it too.

Birgitta Noel
Posted

The CatholiCity monthy message had this to say

[quote]Oh, the new M. Night Shyamalan movie, Lady in the Water, is
simply terrible, and is definitely not for little kids, even
though it it being advertised as a "fairy tale."[/quote]


:idontknow:

DemonSlayer
Posted

I'll probably watch it.

Posted (edited)

Just came back from seeing it, and omg it's really good!!

I honestly am surprised at the reviews, they seriously underestimated this film. Totally unique plot dealing with issues we just don't see anymore. Too often films are depressing and carry some kind of pessimistic undertone, this movie was the exact opposite.

I'm also quite surprised to hear Catholics speaking down on it seeing it is overflowing with Christian symbolism...did you guys know Shamylan is a Christian?! Heck I didn't know that until just now! Figured it odd for a Hindu to be playing with so many Christian elements anyway :)

So down with the haters and two thumbs up for Shamy! :P:

Edited by mortify
melporcristo
Posted

Yes- M. Night was even taught by Sisters at a Catholic school who still wore their habits

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

i know my brother and sister saw it and really enjoyed it.

TheOliverOrder88
Posted

So M. Night is a Christian? I am so glad to hear that. I realize alot of his films involve fate and it is really inspiring to see a successful Christian film-maker in Hollywood.

I enjoyed Lady in the Water a whole lot. His style is so apparent in all of his films.

DemonSlayer
Posted

I think I read somewhere around when Signs was released that he was a Hindu.

Posted

I heard from my brother's sister's uncle's cousin's roommate that he was an Evangelical Jewish Buddhist? :idontknow:

melporcristo
Posted

[quote name='inDEED' post='1036154' date='Aug 2 2006, 04:39 AM']
I heard from my brother's sister's uncle's cousin's roommate that he was an Evangelical Jewish Buddhist? :idontknow:
[/quote]

wow. I'll have to check where I read that he went to Catholic school too ... but I read in Time when Signs came out that his parents were Hindu.
Crazy.

Decentfilms.org has an interesting perspective of the movie too ... they didn't love it or hate it.

sarcasmguy126
Posted

I still haven't seen the village (heard it had a disappointing end, but it still wanted to rent it)

i'll probably rent this on dvd too...

Posted

Looking past the ending, The Village is still a better overall than Signs.

Posted

[quote name='sarcasmguy126' post='1039954' date='Aug 8 2006, 07:11 PM']
I still haven't seen the village (heard it had a disappointing end, but it still wanted to rent it)

i'll probably rent this on dvd too...
[/quote]


I loved the ending and all love all his movies.

I saw Lady in the Water last night... and to tell you truth I don't exactly know yet how I feel about it.....

It's hard to explain my emotions from the movie



hah.

Miss Cat Ballou
Posted

I love all of M Night Shyamalan's films. I also recently saw Lady in the Water. It wasn't his style, nor one of his best, but I still loved it! It had a lot of Christian symbolizm... I don't know why these good Catholic magazines gave it bad ratings. Then again, they also gave Lord of the Rings bad ratings, and those were amaizing films. I have a hunch this might be his last... or that he might be winding down in the film making business. Just a hunch.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...