Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Dear Church Scholars,

I picked up this book at the library. The cover reads, "What Jesus Meant - Gary Wills: Author Of-Why I Am A Catholic". Halfway through the book, I'm wondering, "why are you Catholic"?!

1) Priests-
He says the Greek word for priest, "'. . . 'hiereus' is not used of any Christian the four gospels or the Pauline letters. . . When the term 'priesthood' finally occurs, in the pseudo-Petrine letters it refers to the whole Christian community, (1Pet 2.5, 2.9). The only Christian priest mentioned in the New Testament is Jesus himself, who is called that in only one place, the Letter to the Hebrews, where it is said that he is the last priest, who makes other priesthood obsolete (Heb 7.28, 9.12, 10.12)."

2) Bishops and Popes-
"Peter is clearly the leading member of the twelve. But he, like all other apostles or disciples, is not a priest, much less a bishop. There were no bishops in his lifetime, and none in Rome till the second century (as the letters of Ignatius of Antioch prove)."

Unfortunately, he doesn't cite references here, and I have no idea what he's referring to.

He continues, ". . . linage guaranteed by papal elections, supposedly guided by the Holy Spirit--a line in which bribery, intimidation, and imperial influence were often the deciding factors. In this famous succession, the papacy was often bought, and once sold for money (by Benedict X). Popes were for a long time appointed by various temporal rulers, Popes were heretical (Liberius, Honorius), they waged wars, they ran governments (with their full compliment of armies, spies and torturers), and they granted indulgences for those killing heretics (the Albigensians) or infidels."

Thanx in advance,
-Jeff

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

moving to transmundane lane

thessalonian
Posted

Not a greek expert so I will leave that to others.


[quote]He continues, ". . . linage guaranteed by papal elections, supposedly guided by the Holy Spirit--a line in which bribery, intimidation, and imperial influence were often the deciding factors. In this famous succession, the papacy was often bought, and once sold for money (by Benedict X). Popes were for a long time appointed by various temporal rulers, Popes were heretical (Liberius, Honorius), they waged wars, they ran governments (with their full compliment of armies, spies and torturers), and they granted indulgences for those killing heretics (the Albigensians) or infidels."[/quote]

Well first of all if a Pope were a heretic it wouldn't matter as long as he did not perpetrate the heresy to the whole Church. That is the only way his heresy could be a violation of infallibility. However, having said that his examples of Liberius and Honorius are poor ones. Honorious's statement is ambigous and non-committal and is in a private letter. It is not strickly speaking heretical.

As for Liberius, he is accused of accepting Arianism. Funny thing is noone has his words that prove it. It is only noted that he was eventually allowed to return to Rome after a time by Constantinious who exiled him. The inuendo is that he approved Arianism but noone has such a statement by him. Further no statement was presented by either Constantinious or the Arians. It is highly doudtful that one ever existed. Even if it did, it would have been signed under duress and would have been invalid.

I don't know the Benedict X situation so I will see what others say. But if we expect a perfect history in the passage then we will think that men were capable of protecting the Church and it's teachings. Many times the Church was protected in spite of the very sinful men that held the office and the circumstances under which they came to power. They were not perfect and sinless. That is not what infallible means. It only means the Church is guarded against error on matters of faith and morals.


Hope that is of help.

Posted

The book sounds very strange. It's titled "Why I AM a Catholic?" Ooookay...

Yeah, anyway it sounds like he has no understanding of the basic principles of the Papacy (like the difference between infallability and impeccability, for one), and the rest of his arguments are all hear-say. Throw the book away, or buy it from the library and burn it.

Posted

Why was this topic moved? It hasn't been answered here.

Posted

In Acts of the Apostles are references to presbyters (aka elder aka bishop aka episkopos) words that are often used interchangeably . . .

the first council in Jerusalem

Acts 15:2, the Christians at Antioch charge Paul and Barnabas to go to Jerusalem "to the apostles and presbyters."
Acts 15:6 The apostles and the presbyters met together
Acts 15:22 Then the apostles and presbyters, in agreement with the whole church, . . .
Acts 15:23 This is the letter delivered by them: "The apostles and the presbyters, your brothers, to the brothers in Antioch, Syria, and Cilicia of Gentile origin: greetings.

phatcatholic has an entire section of the directory devoted to apostolic succession

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/3"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/3[/url]

from which you may find this helpful: [url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0107bt.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0107bt.asp[/url]

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

I would suggest throwing the book in the trash. Wills isn't very good, and his "history" is questionable at best. It is true that the Scriptures do not refer to the apostles as "hiereus" but "presbyter" and "deacon" is used, as is, later "episkopos." Moreover, he is clearly making an anachronistic fallacy. He is arguing that because a later terminological distinction was not applied at an earlier time, the meaning behind the term was not present either. But this is clearly not true. The fact is that the hierarchy developed organically into specific roles over time, but that doesn't mean that there was no notion of hierarchy.

In a sense, Will's argument is almost a [i]reductio ad absurdum[/i] against itself, and is exceedingly reminiscent of more non-traditional protestant argumentation. In an attempt to deny the legitimacy of the clergy, they look to history. But in the past 500 years, a hierarchical clergy is painfully obvious. So, they move further back in history, lets try 1000 years. carp, still a hierarchical clergy. 1500 years? Oh no, its still there. What about in the fourth, and third centuries after Christ? Sweet mercy, that darn clergy is still there. Lets go back further! How bout the first and second centuries after Christ?

The fact is, in order to "find" a point in the Church's history in which there isn't any clear cut hierarchy, they have to go back to a time in which the Church was so small that one person was both "bishop" and "priest," and even then there is still the beginnings of a hierarchy (c.f. the apostles laying hands on the first deacons in Acts).

Allow me to make an abortion analogy. This is clearly a human, so we can't kill him/her. Well what if we look back a couple years? Nope, still clearly human. carp, lets go back further. Nuh uh, still human. Wow, lets go back all the way to the beginning. Yes! [i]Now[/i] it doesn't look like its human!

The fact that the embryo hasn't had time to develop to [i]look[/i] like a human doesn't mean it isn't human in nature. Similarly, just because the primitive, primitive Church (pre-writing of the Gospels) didn't have a fully developed hierarchy doesn't mean that the Church isn't hierarchical in nature. It simply means that it hadn't been given enough time to develop the hierarchy that is natural to it.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1043571' date='Aug 14 2006, 10:39 AM']The fact is, in order to "find" a point in the Church's history in which there isn't any clear cut hierarchy, they have to go back to a time in which the Church was so small that one person was both "bishop" and "priest," and even then there is still the beginnings of a hierarchy (c.f. the apostles laying hands on the first deacons in Acts).[/quote]

You could go back to Jesus' earthly ministry and simply note that Peter, James, and John were present for several miracles that the other disciples did not get to witness (at least two, the healing of Jairus' daughter and the Transfiguration).

When I hear stories about the sinfulness of past bishops and popes, it only strengthens my belief that God is clearly watching out for His Church. A man-made institution wouldn't have survived the many years (and generations, in some cases) of infamously careless leadership that the Catholic Church has endured.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

oops... Internet hiccupped on me.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1043571' date='Aug 14 2006, 12:39 PM']
It is true that the Scriptures do not refer to the apostles as "hiereus" but "presbyter" and "deacon" is used, as is, later "episkopos." Moreover, he is clearly making an anachronistic fallacy. He is arguing that because a later terminological distinction was not applied at an earlier time, the meaning behind the term was not present either.
[/quote]

An element of his argument, (that I didn't include in the original post), was that the Greek word for priest WAS used for his persecutors.

I think we can stick a fork in part two of Wills argument regarding Bishops and Popes. However, I still don't feel we've addressed part one regarding Priests.

Anymore ideas on that, anyone . . .?

So you don't have to scroll-up . . .

the Greek word for priest, "'. . . 'hiereus' is not used of any Christian the four gospels or the Pauline letters. . . When the term 'priesthood' finally occurs, in the pseudo-Petrine letters it refers to the whole Christian community, (1Pet 2.5, 2.9). The only Christian priest mentioned in the New Testament is Jesus himself, who is called that in only one place, the Letter to the Hebrews, where it is said that he is the last priest, who makes other priesthood obsolete (Heb 7.28, 9.12, 10.12)."

Edited by Jeff
Posted

I'm not a scholar, but I do hope to help.
[quote name='Jeff' post='1053970' date='Aug 30 2006, 09:18 PM']
An element of his argument, (that I didn't include in the original post), was that the Greek word for priest WAS used for his persecutors.

. . . When the term 'priesthood' finally occurs, in the pseudo-Petrine letters it refers to the whole Christian community, (1Pet 2.5, 2.9). [/quote]
Yes, we are all priests. What you may be searching for is whether a ministerial priesthood exists. Start a new topic for that one. (cant help with greek as it is not my area).

[quote]The only Christian priest mentioned in the New Testament is Jesus himself, who is called that in only one place, the Letter to the Hebrews, where it is said that he is the last priest, who makes other priesthood obsolete (Heb 7.28, 9.12, 10.12)."[/quote]
Whoa... not sure this conclusion of Jesus being last [u]and only priest [/u] is scriptural. He is the last and only highpriest. His order or priesthood has priests.

A more correct qoute would read, "he is the last [u]priest[/u]priesthood, who makes other [color="#3333FF"]previous[/color] priesthood[color="#3333FF"]s[/color] obsolete."


First, Heb 7 discusses the priesthood of Aaron, priesthood of Melchiz'edek, priesthood of Levit'ical and priesthood of Jesus. Aaron, Melchiz'edek and the Levites were not the only priests in their 'order.'
All the OT priesthoods passed away. The priesthood of Jesus will reign forever as Heb7:21b shows:
"Thou art a priest for ever, after the order of Melchiz'edek."
Verse 28 refers to Jesus as perfect highpriest and says nothng about the only priest.

Second, Heb 9:12 is about Christ serving as an priest sacrificing himself vice goats and calves. It says nothing about Jesus being the only priest.

Third, Heb 10:12 is about Christ offering a single sacrifice for sins once for all time. It says nothing about Jesus being the only priest.

More importantly, don't forget 1Pt2 that proves a priesthood of Christ does exist, not just Jesus priest alone.

In conclusion, if you want to profess that "the priesthood of Jesus is now the only priesthood in existance, which He serves a highpriest and all other priesthoods are obsolete with the New Covenant," you are correct. However, if you profess that Jesus is not only the great highpriest, but also the only priest in the world today, you err in scripture and truth.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...