Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Important: please read. Especially the moderators/Dust.


Recommended Posts

Lilllabettt
Posted (edited)

[quote name='fearundercontrol' post='1032266' date='Jul 27 2006, 08:10 PM']
Seriously, though, somebody needs to dephishiphy the guy.
[/quote]

New York abstains, courteously. But I concur.

(any scholars of the american revolution here?)

Edited by Lilllabettt
Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' post='1032444' date='Jul 27 2006, 08:04 PM']
I'm sorry if this sounds mean but the first thing that popped into my head was

so there only dumb ones left?
[/quote]
ouch!! :P:

fearundercontrol
Posted

[quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1033112' date='Jul 28 2006, 06:54 PM']
New York abstains, courteously. But I concur.
[/quote]
I don't get it. What's that mean? Does it have something to do with me being from NY? I'm confused. And abstaining from what? :blink:

CatholicCid
Posted

since dust is on, i'll give this a bump

:ninja:

let_go_let_God
Posted

I agree, I support that your phishy title should be removed.

God bless-
LGLG

Lilllabettt
Posted (edited)

[quote name='fearundercontrol' post='1033976' date='Jul 29 2006, 11:48 PM']
I don't get it. What's that mean? Does it have something to do with me being from NY? I'm confused. And abstaining from what? :blink:
[/quote]


Nope, dear, it has nada to do with you.

Ever seen the movie, [i]1776[/i]? I was briefly obsessed with it in junior high. Its all about the Continental Congress, the founding of America, blah blah blah.
Anyway. The Continental Congress voted on lots of things. And every single time anything came up for vote, the representative for New York, Lewis Morris, would always abstain. Because New York was full of Patriots and Loyalists, and they were always fighting about everything, so they never sent him any instructions as to how to vote. So he was always abstaining, even when it came time to ratify the Declaration of Independence. Everyone would get really frustrated him. Like, there goes New York, abstaining again. From the movie:
[quote]
Lewis Morris: "New York abstains, courteously."
Secretary: [recording vote] New York abstains.
Lewis Morris: "Courteously."
[/quote]
It became a sort of joke. I think there's actually a t-shirt you can buy that says "New York Abstains. Courteously."

So ha-ha, I vote to re-instate Brendan to non-phishy status. But New York abstains, of course.

On a side note, I believe the movie was also responsible for popularizing the insult, "Fribble." From the movie:
[quote]
John Dickinson: Mr. Jefferson, Mr. Lee, Mr. Hopkins, Dr. Franklin, why have you joined this... incendiary little man, this BOSTON radical? This demagogue, this MADMAN?
John Adams: Are you calling me a madman, you, you... you FRIBBLE!
Dr. Benjamin Franklin: Easy John.
John Adams: You cool, considerate men. You hang to the rear on every issue so that if we should go under, you'll still remain afloat!
John Dickinson: Are you calling me a coward?
John Adams: Yes... coward!
John Dickinson: Madman!
John Adams: Landlord!
John Dickinson: LAWYER!
[a brawl breaks out] [/quote]

/ Alrighty then. End thread hijack.

Edited by Lilllabettt
Posted

[quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1037104' date='Aug 3 2006, 03:49 PM']
Ever seen the movie, [i]1776[/i]? I was briefly obsessed with it in junior high. Its all about the Continental Congress, the founding of America, blah blah blah.
Anyway. The Continental Congress voted on lots of things. And every single time anything came up for vote, the representative for New York, Lewis Morris, would always abstain. Because New York was full of Patriots and Loyalists, and they were always fighting about everything, so they never sent him any instructions as to how to vote. So he was always abstaining, even when it came time to ratify the Declaration of Independence. Everyone would get really frustrated him. Like, there goes New York, abstaining again. From the movie:

It became a sort of joke. I think there's actually a t-shirt you can buy that says "New York Abstains. Courteously."[/quote]
:blink: you learn something new every day :topsy:

onlygrace08
Posted

[quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1037104' date='Aug 3 2006, 03:49 PM']
Nope, dear, it has nada to do with you.

Ever seen the movie, [i]1776[/i]? I was briefly obsessed with it in junior high. Its all about the Continental Congress, the founding of America, blah blah blah.
Anyway. The Continental Congress voted on lots of things. And every single time anything came up for vote, the representative for New York, Lewis Morris, would always abstain. Because New York was full of Patriots and Loyalists, and they were always fighting about everything, so they never sent him any instructions as to how to vote. So he was always abstaining, even when it came time to ratify the Declaration of Independence. Everyone would get really frustrated him. Like, there goes New York, abstaining again. From the movie:

It became a sort of joke. I think there's actually a t-shirt you can buy that says "New York Abstains. Courteously."

So ha-ha, I vote to re-instate Brendan to non-phishy status. But New York abstains, of course.

On a side note, I believe the movie was also responsible for popularizing the insult, "Fribble." From the movie:
/ Alrighty then. End thread hijack.
[/quote]


Very interesting!!! :)

let_go_let_God
Posted

Quick hijack, I haven't seen the movie but I loved the musical. *Starts singing*

(At the Same time)

Chorus: "Sit Down John Sit down John for heaven sake John sit down."
Someone "Can someone open up a window."
John Adams rambling in the back

End of hijack

God bless-
LGLG

memory-singer
Posted

Let's get back to de-phishphying you SOON.
:sign: :sign: :sign: :sign: :sign: :sign: :sign: :sign: :sign: :sign: :sign: :sign:

Dare

Marieteresa
Posted

I am just wondering has dUsT said anything about his de-phishing?

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I hope you get dephished soon, Brendan! :)

brendan1104
Posted

No. Dust ignores me... even though I'm very respectful... he never responded- either via this thread or e-mail. >:( :idontknow: :sadder:

[quote name='Marieteresa' post='1037599' date='Aug 4 2006, 04:10 PM']
I am just wondering has dUsT said anything about his de-phishing?
[/quote]

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Don't worry... dUSt doesn't always get around to things right away, but it will happen.

Anybody remember the time we gave him a bad time because his pregnant wife was mowing the lawn?

:hehe:

You can always offer up your frustrations for his soul. :D:

brendan1104
Posted (edited)

[b]Updated List[/b]
[i]as of August 4, 7:25 PM EST[/i]

In total 32 members agree that my phishy title be lifted- 2 regulators, 1 church scholar, 12 church militants, 16 phatmassers, and 1 lurker.

[u]Regulators:[/u]
1. Lil Red
2. Homeschoolmom

[u]Church Scholars:[/u]
1. Laudate_Dominum

[u]Church Militant:[/u]
1. Prose
2. Thedude
3. OLAM Dad
4. Peach_cube
5. Raphael
6. The Little Way
7. Dave
8. Paladin D
9. Socrates
10. Noel’s Angel
11. Let_go_let_God
12. Ash Wednesday

[u]Phatmassers:[/u]
1. Marieteresa
2. Rick777
3. Fulton Sheen Warrior
4. Anthony
5. Isilzha
6. Misereremi
7. Franimus
8. Mercy’s Child
9. Domine ut Videam
10. Matthew1618
11. MissScripture
12. Justified Saint
13. Lilllabettt
14. CatholicCid
15. Onlygrace08
16. Convert4888

Lurkers:
1. Fearundercontrol

Edited by brendan1104
Posted

[quote]Dust, moderators, and Pham:

August 16th will mark my one year anniversary on Phatmass (yeah, I know, time to plan the party). A few days later I was labelled phishy because I stated that I sympathized with/supported the SSPX. As the majority of you well know, it has been a long and interesting journey...

I am no longer a radical traditionalist, nor an SSPX supporter. I haven't been so since late March.
I haven't attended Mass/received the Sacraments (illicitly and sometimes invalidly, e.g. Confession or Marriage) as well as spiritual direction, etc. celebrated/given by SSPX/other chapels and priests without canonical recognition and faculties. I haven't been schismatic since my final decision- see the: SSPX Decision thread.)

In these past months, I have proven that I am no longer separated from the Church, nor do I have a schismatic mentality. I am so happy to be back in the Church, recognizing that the Indult isn't compromising anything but delighting in obedience to Peter's successors, that Vatican II isn't heretical but good and intriniscally orthodox, and that the Novus Ordo can be- and is- just as beautiful as the Mass of 1962, or any other Catholic rite.

I've consistently defended Magisterial and Papal acts, teachings, etc. (especially those of the past 43 years), Vatican II, and most importantly, the Missa Normativa against radical traditionalists in the Debate Table and promoted the Vatican II documents, current Code of Canon Law, and the Catechism.

I serve/participate in the "new" Mass (celebrated in various languages but especially English and Italian) each week, along with the Indult. Just yesterday I posted pictures of being in last month's Corpus Christi procession- all of this, proving that I acknowledge the validity and liceity of the new sacraments, as well as my goodwill and obedience. I've assisted contemplative Nuns by building and publishing them a website.

I think that all this- plus my conversations/messages with Dust, homeschoolmom, and others especially Eddie- catholicbandgeek- should prove that I am an obedient Catholic in good standing with the Church- and I've been told this by my confessor/spiritual director, an auxillary bishop and the ordinary bishop of my Diocese.

So, just as Paladin recommended that my 'phishy' title be lifted months ago, I now propose the same now. Many phatmassers have told me that they believe I should no longer be phishy.

All who agree, please reply with any comments you may have.

Thanks and God bless.[/quote]


I havent heard or had a disscussion with you. However, after numeous comments by the awesome members here. I think that it would be worth my time to sit down at my keyboard and have a good discussion with you and our members. You are great addition to our phorum and due to the wonderful comments given I am lead to believe that you are a wonderful role for the guys and girls here. Keep fighting the good fight!!

Congrats...In Christ

-Chris

Posted

you can add me to the list

welcome home

fearundercontrol
Posted (edited)

DEPHISHIPHY THE GUY ALREADY!!!! (And edit the list--I'm not a lurker any more!! :dance:)

Edited by fearundercontrol
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...