Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Concerns of a Catholic Neophyte Philosopher


Recommended Posts

Mitchell_b55
Posted

[font="Verdana"]I have examined many things in the past weeks that have led me to a conclusion, which is startling. My first question was, why do we, as Catholics, constantly estrange science from our religion? Is it a threat? Of course, our religion itself is not to blame, but it seems that many people lack the ability to make distinct connections, which could be significant, and unable to make these connections reject a relation at all. There are some that realize that they cannot stay estranged. We call them creationists, who seem to have an enlightened, Christian notion of science. But are they necessary, can they have an impact, or are they just a diversion? Some of these men have credible theories; others have created fanciful ideas that have no foundation. I have come to the conclusion that science can remain as it is, because it is not a threat, for it is not the answer. What is the answer? I believe that God cannot be justified through physical science, because God is not physical. These men are trying to justify their lack of faith in his existence. They have set their will against their intellect. It seems obvious to some who can see in the underlying order of things the hand of God, who is the creator of all. However, it is not through these trivial creations that God can be seen.

The only method that can justify God’s existence is a study of the human mind. I do not mean psychology, though it can contribute if it is applied correctly. You may think that this is a vain attempt to defend atheistic science, but it is not. We were created in the image of God, but that image is not physical, God does not have a face that we can perceive. God simply, is. He is being itself, a pure spirit. “I am, who am.” We retain an image or likeness of that spirit in our soul. The soul is unified with the body on earth, but is distinctly separate in its function. The soul controls the body, the body supports the soul. The soul is visible in our intellect, and the soul is seen through our will. Intellect and will are connected, the intellect guides the will, and the will increases the intellect. This seemingly contradictory circle of continuance is a pure expression of our likeness to God, who like this circle has no beginning and no end. We can thus depend upon our will to increase our search for knowledge and for our knowledge to justify its cause.

Speaking of causes, the cause of all things is God. Any honest scientist will admit that God exists, perhaps they disagree with the necessity for an organized religion, but they acknowledge that there is a force of reason behind the world that can only be explained by itself. Many also understand that we possess the ability to see a small sliver of that force through our soul. To understand God, we must understand ourselves. Can we understand ourselves? Not entirely, and we will never entirely understand God. What he reveals to us is the extent of our ability. We often comment on the first cause, the conscience, and the desire that justifies His existence. These are presented through philosophy, and philosophic proofs are as substantial and weighted as scientific proofs. Philosophy is a discipline comprising as its core logic, aesthetics, ethics, metaphysics, and epistemology. Logic is a science that deals with the principles and criteria of validity of inference and demonstration. Aesthetics is a branch of philosophy dealing with the nature of beauty, art, and taste and with the creation and appreciation of beauty. Ethics is the discipline dealing with what is good and bad and with moral duty and obligation. Metaphysics is a division of philosophy that is concerned with the fundamental nature of reality and being. Epistemology is the study or a theory of the nature and grounds of knowledge especially with reference to its limits and validity.

As one can clearly see the only way that God can be understood through human beings is through philosophy. We can understand through logic that our inferences and assumptions in any matter have a systematic and mathematical justification. Through aesthetics we appreciate the craftsmanship of our creator, and the order of beauty. Through ethics we see the reason for morality, the lay of the law, the rule of life. Epistemology justifies all that is above it. It is through philosophy, through the minds processes that we see the trademark of God imprinted on the fluted pedestal of our being, expressed in the curves of the statue of our existence. I don’t go to the lengths that the Greeks did in the matter. I do not see Philosophy as the salvation of the world, as an escape from the blind chaos. I don’t believe in the Stoics and their Nameless God, their blind entity, and the evil of matter. That is an incomplete philosophy which draws from the lakes of despair it putrid water. I purely wish to express that Philosophy is our clearest guide to God, who has a name, who isn’t blind, who is the salvation of the world.

Where am I going with this? Well let me see… Let me ask a question, is God masculine or feminine? Sacred Scripture and Divine Revelation present him as a masculine entity, a father. Sense tells us that a masculine entity doesn’t produce life. Let me put forth a third option. He is not either masculine or feminine, he is neutral. Do I here the whispers of heresy. Let me explain. God is a nonsexual—and therefore, genderless—personality. He is beyond gender. If we say God is strictly masculine or feminine we mould God to the image of His creations. We are the creations not the creator, our image is not physical, God is not male, he is not female. What is he? He just is. Pagans seem to misunderstand the Christian God, the God of Abraham, the God of Jacob, and the God of Isaac. Scripture presents him as a masculine entity, because he appeared as a masculine entity. We cannot understand the mystery of a genderless being; we can expound it, but cannot explain it. God appeared as a masculine entity, presented himself thus. That was his choice, not ours. God was incarnated a man. Why? Not because women is inferior to man, but because man was created for God. Woman was created from and for man. Imagine Adam, or any man, created singly he could survive alone, with no taint of death, but he required a companion. A woman’s body was made for birth; she has a period of menstruation every month reminding her of this. She was created with need of man, not he with need of her. I know that this offends the feminist and the pagan who worships the sacred feminine. We are all equal, we all have freewill, but woman was made as a companion to man, he has no right to abuse her, to cause her pain, but she was made for his happiness. He is equally obligated to grant her happiness, even though the woman was created for man, he must mutually love her as she loves him, and grant her happiness so that she will reciprocate.

To review, God, a genderless being, creates man, then from man and for man’s benefit creates woman. Man, without the taint of death, can exist singly, but a woman cannot exist alone, her purpose is the production of life, without man, she has no way of fulfilling this obligation. I’m not a chauvinist pig, I treat every woman with dignity, but the truth is above us, we shouldn’t ask questions. Women were made to nurture, men were made to rule, exceptions can occur, we can shift the rules, we are complex enough creatures to cause discord, but the purpose that is God given, remains standard and unchanging.

I digress though, I would like to make one last comment on the force of philosophy and the weakness of science. Can a line of meaningless bones, attributed to Portuguese Neanderthals disprove the existence of God, no they do nothing of the sort. Those bones can neither prove or disprove the existence of God. And for those who call themselves creationists, and believe that science is the only key, turn not to science, but to the Philosophers. Saint Augustine was a master of philosophy. Did he not say:

[quote name=' Augustine City of God Book XI Chapter 6 '] If we are right in finding the distinction between eternity and time in the fact that without motion and change there is no time, while in eternity there is no change, who can fail to see that there would have been no time, if there had been no creation to bring in movement and change, and that time depends on this motion and change, and is measured by the longer or shorter intervals by which things that cannot happen simultaneously succeed one another? Since God, in whose eternity there is no change at all, is the creator and director of time, I cannot see how it can be said that he created the world after a lapse of ages, unless it is asserted that there was some creation before this world existed, whose movements would make possible the course of time.
The Bible says [and the Bible never lies]: ‘In the beginning God made heaven and earth.’ It must be inferred that God had created nothing before that; in the beginning' must refer to whatever he made before all his other works. Thus there can be no doubt that the world was not created in time but with time. An event in time happens after one time and before another, after the past and before the future. But at the time of creation there could have been no past, because there was nothing created to provide the change and movement which is the condition of time.
The world was in fact made with time, if at the time of its creation change and motion came into existence. This is clearly the situation in the order of the first six or seven days, in which morning and evening are named, until God's creation was finished on the sixth day, and on the seventh day God's rest is emphasized as something conveying a mystic meaning. What kind of days these are is difficult or even impossible for us to imagine, to say nothing of describing them. [/quote]

[quote name=' Augustine Confessions Book XI Chapter 14 ']It is therefore true to say that when you had not made anything, there was no time, because time itself was of your making. And no time is co-eternal with you, because you never change; whereas, if time never changed, it would not be time. [/quote]

Augustine understood that the literal interpretation was not necessary, because the Bible is full of Metaphors, Parables, and Rhetoric. It is for the Church to advise us in Biblical matters, and she has since the question arose, assured us that theistic evolution is a possibility. I personally do not believe that we are descended from apes, but I believe that we do indeed adapt. This is the case of race, of certain physical features. I was recently reading that the Neanderthals are believed not to be a separate species, but simply a group of humans who adapted to the extreme cold of the north. There structure is not unlike a human structure, the differences, being defenses against the cold. Smaller structure, less surface area, more hair, and the like. They were not stupid as many people have said, but extremely intelligent, having a similar relation to nomadic living, which was advanced in its own respect. This lends us to think that perhaps we can adapt, if not evolve from a particle of protein in an endless sea at the beginning of time. God created us, each in our own way, and if science would see through the eyes of a philosopher they would see that their theories take a different light.

Glory to God in the highest. The key to the restoration of the world is bringing to life the ancient piety, the brilliance of Catholicism, the rebirth of learning, of Philosophy and of diligent theological study, the creation of peace and the return of beauty. The key to the restoration of the world is God, may he guide us to that which we strive for.[/font] :huh:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1031286' date='Jul 26 2006, 12:55 PM'] [font="Verdana"]My first question was, why do we, as Catholics, constantly estrange science from our religion? Is it a threat?[/font][/quote]

I don't think that's a universal... In fact, if Catholicism contradicts science, then that would be a strong blow against it.

Edited by scardella
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_15101998_fides-et-ratio_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_pau...t-ratio_en.html[/url]

Posted

Interesting post. Just a few thoughts on this quote:

[quote]As one can clearly see the only way that God can be understood through human beings is through philosophy[/quote]
I think that philosophy is certainly the most obvious way, and perhaps in some senses the only way to know God, but Logic, metaphysics, ethics, etc. are all essential (working together and guided by Faith) to ensuring that [i]philosphy[/i] does not become skewed by human error and pride. And of course, philosophy is a seeking after the Truth that must necessarily base itself on observation of teh world, of humanity and attentiveness to Divine Revelation. So we do need other disciplines in order to come to know God.

Mitchell_b55
Posted

[quote]Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth; and God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truth—in a word, to know himself—so that, by knowing and loving God, men and women may also come to the fullness of truth about themselves[/quote]

Thank you, Raphael. It's nice to do as Chesterton said, and land on the coast of a land, invigorated by the emotion of a new discovery to find that it had been discovered long ago.

[quote]I don't think that's a universal... In fact, if Catholicism contradicts science, then that would be a strong blow against it.[/quote]

It was sweeping generalization, I apologize for using it. It appears through my limited experience that those that I have spoken with, seperate them and isolate them from one another. I believe that they should be isolated as they deal with different subjects, on is phyical and one is spiritual, but my observation has been that the isolation has been out of necessity, because science is a threat. I however don't believe that science is a threat to religion. I was trying to say that Philosophy is the purest expression of God and can be understood only through our minds. We can only understand God by understanding ourselves.

When I presented the question, I used the word "was". Illustrating that the question bothered me at one time, but no longer does, because I see that the estrangment has no significance. No official Church Document denies that we revolve around the sun, no Church official claims to dispute science, and I don't believe that the Church is at all opposed to it. I just believe that the Church shouldn't worry about it. Evolution doesn't disprove God, it doesn't have the weight. God's existence, should be accepted, but if it is not can only be shown through a force of reason.

[quote]I think that philosophy is certainly the most obvious way, and perhaps in some senses the only way to know God, but Logic, metaphysics, ethics, etc. are all essential (working together and guided by Faith) to ensuring that philosphy does not become skewed by human error and pride. And of course, philosophy is a seeking after the Truth that must necessarily base itself on observation of the world, of humanity and attentiveness to Divine Revelation. So we do need other disciplines in order to come to know God.[/quote]

Touché.

In response, yes, we do require other disciplines, all within the realm of reason. "Observation of the world." We will not discover God by digging at the bones a ancient mammal. We will however observe the design of creation. I use the term "science" vaguely and laxly, when I mean science I suppose that I refer to paleoanthropology, archeology, and physical sciences that trace the origin of life and the creation of the universe. Such sciences have no reason to exist, since physical properties do not lead to God.

"skewed by human error and pride." This is true, but when I speak vaguely of philosophy I speak of it as guided by Divine Revelation, Physical Observance, and thus as the only true philosophy. Faith and humility is always required in these areas, it is necessary to realize this.

Justified Saint
Posted

Sounds like you are describing theology of which philosophy is its handmaid.

Mitchell_b55
Posted (edited)

I would venture to say you are right.

[P.S. Sir, who is the man in your avatar?]

Edited by petrus_scholasticus
Justified Saint
Posted

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1031380' date='Jul 26 2006, 01:42 PM']
I would venture to say you are right.

[P.S. Sir, who is the man in your avatar?]
[/quote]

That would be the historian Christopher Dawson, a man of incredible erudition and scholarship, pondering what to eat for breakfast.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1031292' date='Jul 26 2006, 03:04 PM']
[url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_15101998_fides-et-ratio_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_pau...t-ratio_en.html[/url]
[/quote]
:annoyed:

AHEM!

Passing out [i]THAT [/i] link ought to be my job... *points to username and signature AND title* :P:

:lol:

Posted

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1031286' date='Jul 26 2006, 11:55 AM']
[font=Verdana]Where am I going with this? Well let me see… Let me ask a question, is God masculine or feminine? Sacred Scripture and Divine Revelation present him as a masculine entity, a father. Sense tells us that a masculine entity doesn’t produce life. Let me put forth a third option. He is not either masculine or feminine, he is neutral. Do I here the whispers of heresy. Let me explain. God is a nonsexual—and therefore, genderless—personality. He is beyond gender. If we say God is strictly masculine or feminine we mould God to the image of His creations. We are the creations not the creator, our image is not physical, God is not male, he is not female. What is he? He just is. :
[/quote]
While I don't think you're saying anything technically heretical here, I would qualify. While God as pure spirit technically has no gender, He [b]is[/b] truly Father. Not that He is "like a man" or "masculine," but rather in that human masculinity (in its imperfect way) mirrors the Divine Fatherhood of God. God revealing Himself as Father is not just a "choice" of His (as if He could have just as easy revealed Himself as a Mother or feminine), but reveals His actual nature in relation to His creation.

And the claim that "a masculine entity doesn’t produce life" is absurd. Do you think your father had no part in bringing about your life? A "feminine entity" would be no more intrinsically capable of bringing forth life. Of course, neither men nor women wan bring forth life ex nihilo as God does, but the image of Father is used because the male is considered the active principle in conception, and God is Pure Act.

This may all seem nit-picky, but I think it important that we think of God in "masculine terms" as a "Heavenly Father" as Christ taught us. (This is not to say that God the Father is biologically male, or biologically anything). But this is how we should think of Him; if we, with our limited human imaginations thnk of Him as "neither masculine nor feminine," the tendency is to think of Him as either somehow androgynous or bi-sexual, or as an impersonal "it." Neither would reflect the true nature of God.

Posted

Sir, I will not pretend to understand philosophy at the level you present it. In which i feel your argument and tone of dialogue are very enjoyable to read and show you have weight in your studies and conviction. I would repeat the concerns of Socrates in the idea that the male does not produce life. Speaking in moral theology we know that the role of reproduction in a marriage is the caring responsability of both husband and wife. In that shared responsability we know that each part holds part of the potential for life. A wife could not produce a life on her own, and a husband could not produce on his own. But it is a shared situation of responsability and creation.

Also, you are speaking in terms of reproduction. God as creator was not reproducing himself or any other being. He designed and created from nothing. There is nothing in human analogy that we can compare it to. But we could see that there are other measures of invention and creation that both male and female can preform. Joseph was a carpenter. he created, and built with his hands.

i would be interested in your concept of time and how it relates to God and to us in relation to him. Could you elaborate it more?

Posted

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1031330' date='Jul 26 2006, 02:40 PM']

Touché.

In response, yes, we do require other disciplines, all within the realm of reason. "Observation of the world." We will not discover God by digging at the bones a ancient mammal. We will however observe the design of creation. I use the term "science" vaguely and laxly, when I mean science I suppose that I refer to paleoanthropology, archeology, and physical sciences that trace the origin of life and the creation of the universe. Such sciences have no reason to exist, since physical properties do not lead to God.

"skewed by human error and pride." This is true, but when I speak vaguely of philosophy I speak of it as guided by Divine Revelation, Physical Observance, and thus as the only true philosophy. Faith and humility is always required in these areas, it is necessary to realize this.
[/quote]
I can't help feeling that it's a little harsh to say that physical sciences have no reason to exist. For both me and my mother the intricacies of, for example, a cell or the physical makeup of a stone are compelling proofs, or at least humble demonstrations of God's majesty.

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='1032384' date='Jul 27 2006, 09:13 PM']
I can't help feeling that it's a little harsh to say that physical sciences have no reason to exist. For both me and my mother the intricacies of, for example, a cell or the physical makeup of a stone are compelling proofs, or at least humble demonstrations of God's majesty.
[/quote]
indeed. that is the "divine design" argument:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/123"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/123[/url]

petrus..........have you seen the Faith and Science entry?
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/7"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/7[/url]

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

If I might offer up an admittedly simplistic response: I think you might find the philosophy and theology of St. Thomas Aquinas to be remarkably useful in answering your questions. Thomists have no fear of science and there are a number of current Thomists who very much desire to fight against the false dichotomy between science and religion that you are talking about. Thomism achieves a synthesis of science and religion that far outstrips the (in my opinion astonishingly feeble) attempts of the "creationists." Moreover, Thomism does not attempt a proof of God from physical science, but rather, emphasizes [i]a posteriori[/i] [u]metaphysical[/u] arguments. The primacy of metaphysics allows for an alternative to the mechanism of the evolutionary-determinists as well as the mechanism of the creationists.

Just some thoughts :D:

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Mitchell_b55
Posted (edited)

[font="Times New Roman"][b]EDIT:[/b] The quote function seems to be operating incorrectly. Quoted material has been put in italics.

[b]SOCRATES:[/b]

[b]Petrus Scholasticus:[/b] [i]Where am I going with this? Well let me see… Let me ask a question, is [b]God masculine or feminine[/b]? Sacred Scripture and Divine Revelation present him as a masculine entity, a father. [b][color="#CC0000"]Sense [/color] tells us that a masculine entity doesn’t produce life. Let me put forth a third option.[/b] He is not either masculine or feminine, he is neutral. Do I here the whispers of heresy. Let me explain. God is a nonsexual—and therefore, genderless—personality. He is beyond gender. If we say God is strictly masculine or feminine we mold God to the image of His creations. We are the creations not the creator, our image is not physical, God is not male, he is not female. What is he? He just is.[/i]

I apologize, I have understood what I mean, but I have difficulty presenting it. I'm not trying to prove that we should worship HIM as a genderless being, because HE has appears as a masculine entity to us. This is as you said the product of HIS nature. It is difficult to explain the separation of human experience and our understanding of biological gender, and the idea of a pure spirit. I was arguing against the pagan belief in the Sacred Feminine, which does appeal to those who believe we were born from God. A man can not give birth. When I said "sense" proves a masculine entity doesn't produce life, I meant that a masculine "creature" doesn't give "birth". It seems to make sense to us as humans. We have to go above the idea of gender though. When I argue against the pagan belief I try to first show that God is not limited by gender.

Nonetheless, the statement was bad; I realize that the statement is in the same tone as:

[b]Petrus Scholasticus:[/b] [i]If we say God is strictly masculine or feminine we [b]mold [/b] God to the image of His creations. [/i]

This shouldn't be done, since I said that a masculine entity could not produce life, I isolated God and molded Him to human experience. This wasn't what I intended to do. To correct it let me try to explain what I mean. [b]This argument only comes up when I argue with pagans about the sacred feminine.[/b] They always suppose that a masculine creature couldn't give birth to humanity. Yet they also have a different conception of creation. It is an annoying argument. The statement actually supported that I give their argument merit, which I do not. It was the product of a mis-communication. The idea I wanted to present didn't, how do you say - "Come out right."


[b]Socrates:[/b] [i]While God as pure spirit technically has no gender, He is truly Father. Not that He is "like a man" or "masculine," but rather in that human masculinity (in its imperfect way) mirrors the Divine Fatherhood of God. [/i]

I am entirely in agreement. To disagree would be heresy and I tend to avoid heresy for obvious reasons.

[b]Socrates:[/b] [i]God revealing Himself as Father is not just a "choice" of His (as if He could have just as easy revealed Himself as a Mother or feminine), but reveals His actual nature in relation to His creation.[/i]

However, we again assume that [b]God is acting like a Father[/b]. Could it not be that man inherited the qualities of God, in respect to his nature. Thus it is not him that has Fatherly qualities, but male human beings that exhibit the qualities of God. This allows that it is not God who conforms to our rules, but we to His. I said that He "presents" and that it is His choice, after reflecting, that again molds Him. I believe that it is not He that exhibits our qualities, but we that exhibit His.

[b]Socrates:[/b] [i]And the claim that "a masculine entity doesn’t produce life" is absurd. Do you think your father had no part in bringing about your life? [b]A "feminine entity" would be no more intrinsically capable of bringing forth life.[/b] Of course, neither men nor women wan bring forth life ex nihilo as God does, but the image of Father is used because the male is considered the active principle in conception, and God is Pure Act.[/i]

I already addressed this, but let me quote myself. So you can understand my position better.

[b]Petrus Scholasticus:[/b] [i]Imagine Adam, or any man, created singly he could survive alone, with no taint of death, but he required a companion. A woman’s body was made for birth; she has a period of menstruation every month reminding her of this. She was created with need of man, not he with need of her. [/i]

[b]Socrates:[/b] [i]This may all seem nit-picky, but I think it important that we think of God in "masculine terms" as a "Heavenly Father" as Christ taught us. (This is not to say that God the Father is biologically male, or biologically anything). But this is how we should think of Him; if we, with our limited human imaginations think of Him as "neither masculine nor feminine," the tendency is to think of Him as either somehow androgynous or bi-sexual, or as an impersonal "it." Neither would reflect the true nature of God.[/i]

Not at all nit-picky. I pray to THE FATHER. I do not disagree at all, in fact you are correct in everyway. God should be referred to in the way that appears to us.

[b]TINDOMIEL[/b]

[b]Tindomiel:[/b] [i]I can't help feeling that it's a little harsh to say that physical sciences have no reason to exist. For both me and my mother the intricacies of, for example, a cell or the physical makeup of a stone are compelling proofs, or at least humble demonstrations of God's majesty.[/i]

[b]Petrus Scholasticus:[/b][i] ...physical sciences that trace the origin of life and the creation of the universe. Such sciences have no reason to exist, since physical properties do not lead to God. [/i]

You are right, but I was speaking of physical science that trace the origin of life and the creation of the universe. Because they are looking for an alternative to God, whom we know to be the creator of all.

[b]REVPRODEJI:[/b]

[b]Revprodeji: [/b][i]Sir, I will not pretend to understand philosophy at the level you present it. In which I feel your argument and tone of dialogue are very enjoyable to read and show you have weight in your studies and conviction. [/i]

You flatter one who does not deserve it. I try that is my only response.

[b]Revprodeji: [/b][i]I would repeat the concerns of Socrates in the idea that the male does not produce life. Speaking in moral theology we know that the role of reproduction in a marriage is the caring responsability of both husband and wife. In that shared responsability we know that each part holds part of the potential for life. A wife could not produce a life on her own, and a husband could not produce on his own. But it is a shared situation of responsability and creation.

Also, you are speaking in terms of reproduction. God as creator was not reproducing himself or any other being. [b]He designed and created from nothing.[/b] There is nothing in human analogy that we can compare it to. But we could see that there are other measures of invention and creation that both male and female can preform. Joseph was a carpenter. He created, and built with his hands.[/i]

I agree, as for Joseph "creating", I tend to side with Tolkien. He believed and I believe that man has no ability to create, however we can sub-create, by using materials provided. We do not create a desk, but simply mold wood, God's creation, into our sub-creation, the desk. Stew on that it is an interesting concept.

[b]Revprodeji: [/b][i]I would be interested in your concept of time and how it relates to God and to us in relation to him. Could you elaborate it more?[/i]

At a later date, I am at this moment required at the cafe across the street, a couple of friends invited me over for lunch so I will be ending with this.

[b]IN CONCLUSION:[/b]

As for Thomism... Creationists... feeble. I agree. Thomas' synthesis of science and religion, yes. But again I had to redefine the vague term science. I don't mean all science, nor do I mean all physical science, just a certain portion that tries to find an alternative for God. As for Tindomiel, I acknowledge subjects such as Biology, Anatomy, Chemistry, Physics to be wonderful expressions of God's hand as a creator. However, Biology can be twisted as we all know.

As for PhatCatholic, I have studied the Divine Design. It is indeed a good way to prove God's existence. For me it is a last resort, as it was for Thomas. The idea of "Cause" always seemed cut and dry. I have written a number of thesis' on it for school.

I will look at the Faith and Science theory. However I share Pope Benedict's view "creative reason." Enlightenment is wrong in it's assumption that science is the absolute. Thus fore enlightenment to be used it must be subserviant to the monotheistic revolution, or Christianity. I haven't time to elaborate. Please respond. Ciao.[/font]

Edited by petrus_scholasticus
Posted

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1034835' date='Jul 31 2006, 12:55 PM']
[font="Times New Roman"][b]EDIT:[/b] The quote function seems to be operating incorrectly. Quoted material has been put in italics.

[b]SOCRATES:[/b]

[b]Petrus Scholasticus:[/b] [i]Where am I going with this? Well let me see… Let me ask a question, is [b]God masculine or feminine[/b]? Sacred Scripture and Divine Revelation present him as a masculine entity, a father. [b][color="#CC0000"]Sense [/color] tells us that a masculine entity doesn’t produce life. Let me put forth a third option.[/b] He is not either masculine or feminine, he is neutral. Do I here the whispers of heresy. Let me explain. God is a nonsexual—and therefore, genderless—personality. He is beyond gender. If we say God is strictly masculine or feminine we mold God to the image of His creations. We are the creations not the creator, our image is not physical, God is not male, he is not female. What is he? He just is.[/i]

I apologize, I have understood what I mean, but I have difficulty presenting it. I'm not trying to prove that we should worship HIM as a genderless being, because HE has appears as a masculine entity to us. This is as you said the product of HIS nature. It is difficult to explain the separation of human experience and our understanding of biological gender, and the idea of a pure spirit. I was arguing against the pagan belief in the Sacred Feminine, which does appeal to those who believe we were born from God. A man can not give birth. When I said "sense" proves a masculine entity doesn't produce life, I meant that a masculine "creature" doesn't give "birth". It seems to make sense to us as humans. We have to go above the idea of gender though. When I argue against the pagan belief I try to first show that God is not limited by gender.

Nonetheless, the statement was bad; I realize that the statement is in the same tone as:

[b]Petrus Scholasticus:[/b] [i]If we say God is strictly masculine or feminine we [b]mold [/b] God to the image of His creations. [/i]

This shouldn't be done, since I said that a masculine entity could not produce life, I isolated God and molded Him to human experience. This wasn't what I intended to do. To correct it let me try to explain what I mean. [b]This argument only comes up when I argue with pagans about the sacred feminine.[/b] They always suppose that a masculine creature couldn't give birth to humanity. Yet they also have a different conception of creation. It is an annoying argument. The statement actually supported that I give their argument merit, which I do not. It was the product of a mis-communication. The idea I wanted to present didn't, how do you say - "Come out right."
[b]Socrates:[/b] [i]While God as pure spirit technically has no gender, He is truly Father. Not that He is "like a man" or "masculine," but rather in that human masculinity (in its imperfect way) mirrors the Divine Fatherhood of God. [/i]

I am entirely in agreement. To disagree would be heresy and I tend to avoid heresy for obvious reasons.

[b]Socrates:[/b] [i]God revealing Himself as Father is not just a "choice" of His (as if He could have just as easy revealed Himself as a Mother or feminine), but reveals His actual nature in relation to His creation.[/i]

However, we again assume that [b]God is acting like a Father[/b]. Could it not be that man inherited the qualities of God, in respect to his nature. Thus it is not him that has Fatherly qualities, but male human beings that exhibit the qualities of God. This allows that it is not God who conforms to our rules, but we to His. I said that He "presents" and that it is His choice, after reflecting, that again molds Him. I believe that it is not He that exhibits our qualities, but we that exhibit His.

[b]Socrates:[/b] [i]And the claim that "a masculine entity doesn’t produce life" is absurd. Do you think your father had no part in bringing about your life? [b]A "feminine entity" would be no more intrinsically capable of bringing forth life.[/b] Of course, neither men nor women wan bring forth life ex nihilo as God does, but the image of Father is used because the male is considered the active principle in conception, and God is Pure Act.[/i]

I already addressed this, but let me quote myself. So you can understand my position better.

[b]Petrus Scholasticus:[/b] [i]Imagine Adam, or any man, created singly he could survive alone, with no taint of death, but he required a companion. A woman’s body was made for birth; she has a period of menstruation every month reminding her of this. She was created with need of man, not he with need of her. [/i]

[b]Socrates:[/b] [i]This may all seem nit-picky, but I think it important that we think of God in "masculine terms" as a "Heavenly Father" as Christ taught us. (This is not to say that God the Father is biologically male, or biologically anything). But this is how we should think of Him; if we, with our limited human imaginations think of Him as "neither masculine nor feminine," the tendency is to think of Him as either somehow androgynous or bi-sexual, or as an impersonal "it." Neither would reflect the true nature of God.[/i]

Not at all nit-picky. I pray to THE FATHER. I do not disagree at all, in fact you are correct in everyway. God should be referred to in the way that appears to us.

[b]TINDOMIEL[/b]

[b]Tindomiel:[/b] [i]I can't help feeling that it's a little harsh to say that physical sciences have no reason to exist. For both me and my mother the intricacies of, for example, a cell or the physical makeup of a stone are compelling proofs, or at least humble demonstrations of God's majesty.[/i]

[b]Petrus Scholasticus:[/b][i] ...physical sciences that trace the origin of life and the creation of the universe. Such sciences have no reason to exist, since physical properties do not lead to God. [/i]

You are right, but I was speaking of physical science that trace the origin of life and the creation of the universe. Because they are looking for an alternative to God, whom we know to be the creator of all.

[b]REVPRODEJI:[/b]

[b]Revprodeji: [/b][i]Sir, I will not pretend to understand philosophy at the level you present it. In which I feel your argument and tone of dialogue are very enjoyable to read and show you have weight in your studies and conviction. [/i]

You flatter one who does not deserve it. I try that is my only response.

[b]Revprodeji: [/b][i]I would repeat the concerns of Socrates in the idea that the male does not produce life. Speaking in moral theology we know that the role of reproduction in a marriage is the caring responsability of both husband and wife. In that shared responsability we know that each part holds part of the potential for life. A wife could not produce a life on her own, and a husband could not produce on his own. But it is a shared situation of responsability and creation.

Also, you are speaking in terms of reproduction. God as creator was not reproducing himself or any other being. [b]He designed and created from nothing.[/b] There is nothing in human analogy that we can compare it to. But we could see that there are other measures of invention and creation that both male and female can preform. Joseph was a carpenter. He created, and built with his hands.[/i]

I agree, as for Joseph "creating", I tend to side with Tolkien. He believed and I believe that man has no ability to create, however we can sub-create, by using materials provided. We do not create a desk, but simply mold wood, God's creation, into our sub-creation, the desk. Stew on that it is an interesting concept.

[b]Revprodeji: [/b][i]I would be interested in your concept of time and how it relates to God and to us in relation to him. Could you elaborate it more?[/i]

At a later date, I am at this moment required at the cafe across the street, a couple of friends invited me over for lunch so I will be ending with this.

[b]IN CONCLUSION:[/b]

As for Thomism... Creationists... feeble. I agree. Thomas' synthesis of science and religion, yes. But again I had to redefine the vague term science. I don't mean all science, nor do I mean all physical science, just a certain portion that tries to find an alternative for God. As for Tindomiel, I acknowledge subjects such as Biology, Anatomy, Chemistry, Physics to be wonderful expressions of God's hand as a creator. However, Biology can be twisted as we all know.

As for PhatCatholic, I have studied the Divine Design. It is indeed a good way to prove God's existence. For me it is a last resort, as it was for Thomas. The idea of "Cause" always seemed cut and dry. I have written a number of thesis' on it for school.

I will look at the Faith and Science theory. However I share Pope Benedict's view "creative reason." Enlightenment is wrong in it's assumption that science is the absolute. Thus fore enlightenment to be used it must be subserviant to the monotheistic revolution, or Christianity. I haven't time to elaborate. Please respond. Ciao.[/font]
[/quote]
Thank you for the clarification.

  • 1 month later...
Posted

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1034835' date='Jul 31 2006, 02:55 PM']
[font="Times New Roman"][b]EDIT:[/b] The quote function seems to be operating incorrectly. Quoted material has been put in italics.

[b]REVPRODEJI:[/b]

[b]Revprodeji: [/b][i]Sir, I will not pretend to understand philosophy at the level you present it. In which I feel your argument and tone of dialogue are very enjoyable to read and show you have weight in your studies and conviction. [/i]

You flatter one who does not deserve it. I try that is my only response.


[b]Revprodeji: [/b][i]I would be interested in your concept of time and how it relates to God and to us in relation to him. Could you elaborate it more?[/i]

[color="#FF0000"]At a later date[/color], I am at this moment required at the cafe across the street, a couple of friends invited me over for lunch so I will be ending with this.

I haven't time to elaborate. Please respond. Ciao.[/font]
[/quote]


sir...
Did you have time to give you ur take on time?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...