Mariam Posted July 27, 2006 Posted July 27, 2006 Hi, Two friends of mine were talking about salvation and they were arguing over how non-catholics are saved. One was saying that non-catholics whether Christian or not, if they are to be saved are saved through the Catholic Church while my other friend was saying that if they are saved it is through the mercy of our Lord and not the Catholic Church. Church teaching on this topic will be greatly appreciated as now I am a little confused. God Bless
thessalonian Posted August 4, 2006 Posted August 4, 2006 (edited) Your second friend is quite incorrect and the false dichotomy they raise is wrong. There is no distinction between salvation and the Church and Christ's mercy. The Church with it's saving truth and sacraments is Christ's mercy for the world. The CCC says "There is no salvation outside the Church.". This is dogma. Those who may be saved who are not formally and explicitly Catholic can only be saved because they have not explicitly and willfully and knowingly rejected the Church. Their religions that they hold are not salvific except when they express truths held by the Catholic faith. I suggest that you read in the CCC from paragraph 815 through 848. See link below. [url="http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p123a9p3.htm#815"]http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p123a9p3.htm#815[/url] Edited August 4, 2006 by thessalonian
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted August 4, 2006 Posted August 4, 2006 The first position is the Church's teaching. CCC 846: "...all salvation comes from Christ the Head through the Church which is his Body..."
fearundercontrol Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 (edited) My notes from my Theology of the Church class: [img]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y285/fearundercontrol/NecessityoftheChurchforSalvation.jpg[/img] Hope they helped. Edit: Sorry that was so big. And I apologize for the gaps (the "..."s). I can't always keep up with the professor and I've yet to go back over my notes while listening to my recording of the class. Sorry! Edited August 28, 2006 by fearundercontrol
DAF Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 Yeah, when we say "there is no salvation outside of the Church" we don't necessarily mean that you have to be enrolled in your local Catholic Parish to be 'saved.' (That was actually a heresy denounced by the Church. Somebody else can probably find more info about that if you're interested). I would skim through [url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20000806_dominus-iesus_en.html"]Dominus Iesus[/url], it's one of the documents that officially speaks to this topic. The Church's position can be broken down like this: --> In the Church exists the fullness of the deposit of objective Truth (as it relates to God and man) --> Consequently, churches (read 'other religions') other than the Catholic Curch, because they are not Catholic, do not enjoy this gift. --> Because they are not in communion with objective truth, their salvation is not assured (Catholics' salvation isn't assured necessarily either, but that's another topic). They do not understand reality as it is. If you don't understand reality, how can you live it? --> All people, Catholic or not, are saved through the merits of Christ's sacrifice. This just means that Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life. I.e. Buddha isn't. That's just the way reality is. --> Because the fullness of Christ's sacrifice, revelation and, by extension, His mercy reside in the Church, we can say that there "is no salvation outside the Church" (<-- there is no salvation outside of reality, which is what the Church is-Christ's sacrifice, revelation and mercy.) --> That's abotu the jist of it. The Church's teaching isn't just arrogance, as in "if you're not Catholic you're going to Hell." There are reasons for what the Church teaches. Hope I helped in Christ
kenrockthefirst Posted August 29, 2006 Posted August 29, 2006 [quote name='DAF' post='1052325' date='Aug 28 2006, 06:15 PM']--> In the Church exists the fullness of the deposit of objective Truth (as it relates to God and man) [/quote] So what is the position for other Christian denominations and religions vis-a-vis "accidental" or "incidental" truth as it relates to salvation? For example, and in particular, what is the position for Judaism insofar as it is "special" in its relation to Jesus and the Church (and here I presume that Romans and Hebrews are particularly instructive)?
hermit Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 I've often wondered about this.... I was once told, that when you die and stand before the Just Judge, that you will be given one last chance to get your ducks in a row so to speak... Any thoughts on this... This raises another interesting question, when we as Catholics, evangelize others and give to them the truths of the Catholic faith, are they then bound by those truths.... God Bless and Keep hermit
Mariam Posted August 30, 2006 Author Posted August 30, 2006 Thanks so much for that. It has made things much clearer.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 [quote name='hermit' post='1053280' date='Aug 29 2006, 11:34 PM'] I've often wondered about this.... I was once told, that when you die and stand before the Just Judge, that you will be given one last chance to get your ducks in a row so to speak... Any thoughts on this... This raises another interesting question, when we as Catholics, evangelize others and give to them the truths of the Catholic faith, are they then bound by those truths.... God Bless and Keep hermit [/quote] I don't think we get another chance after death. It would be so obvious at that point that I think it would tarnish any free will choice to follow God. I guess it depends on the amount/quality of evangelizing. If it is done poorly or anadaquately soas to justify rejecting it, I would not think so.
Aloysius Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 for every non-Catholic you attempt to place in heaven, you're likely placing a Catholic whose task it was to evangelize them in hell. God's justice is broad and all-seeing. immediately upon death you leave time as we know it, and either ascend into purgatorial time wherein your good can be built upon and refined as through fire, or into eternity where no change can happen. if you die in a state of mortal sin, including but not limited to the mortal sin of rejecting Christ and His Church, you hit eternity like a ton of bricks. if you die with venial sins needed to be worked out but no mortal sins, only then do you get an extension on time and only in the sense of your saved soul being purified. if you die in a state of grace you pass go, collect $200, and get into heaven. without time change cannot occur. therefore, you cannot change your mind after death. anyway, nobody is saved without the Catholic Church. and nobody in heaven is non-Catholic. Christ made one Church and it is the only way to heaven, because that Church is Christ's body-- mystically it is Christ Himself. Nobody gets to heaven without Christ, and if you are without Christ's Church you are without Christ. If you reject Christ's Apostles you reject Christ. No other religion saves. At all. The special relationship of Judaism to Christianity is fundamentally a historical one, and only drawing from that is it slightly spiritual because of our acknolwedgement of the same God. But today's Judaism is not the Judaism of the Old Testament, there is no longer an Abraham's Bosom for them to go to after death, their religion saves nobody. If someone is a Jew who never had a chance to join the Church through no fault of their own (i.e. it wasn't through the stubbornness of their own heart but because something outside of themselves forced them away from Christ), then the following of their conscience as they see it to be God's will may be deemed sufficient by God. Since they base their moral code off of the Old Testament in many ways, there is another spiritual connection. A Jew following his conscience formed slightly by old testament morality is more likely to be following God's will than a Buddhist following his conscience. Someone in Judaism who was to be saved in spite of their invincible inculpable ignorance, then, is more likely to be saved than someone in a pagan baby-sacrificing religion. The Jew need only be deemed inculpable for the sin of not being Catholics and perhaps a few other sins he had no chance of knowing were sins. The baby-sacrificing pagan has to be deemed inculpable not only for the sin of not being Catholic, but for the numerous evils that he carried out as being completely outside of God's revelealed moral teaching. That's my best explanation of such things as the 'special relationship' to the jews or to the muslims. They are less likely to have extra mortal sins to account for aside from not being Catholic than people of religions that did not stem off the same historical line of moral teaching.
kenrockthefirst Posted August 31, 2006 Posted August 31, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1053768' date='Aug 30 2006, 04:27 PM']anyway, nobody is saved without the Catholic Church. and nobody in heaven is non-Catholic. Christ made one Church and it is the only way to heaven, because that Church is Christ's body-- mystically it is Christ Himself. Nobody gets to heaven without Christ, and if you are without Christ's Church you are without Christ. If you reject Christ's Apostles you reject Christ. No other religion saves. At all. The special relationship of Judaism to Christianity is fundamentally a historical one, and only drawing from that is it slightly spiritual because of our acknolwedgement of the same God. But today's Judaism is not the Judaism of the Old Testament, there is no longer an Abraham's Bosom for them to go to after death, their religion saves nobody. If someone is a Jew who never had a chance to join the Church through no fault of their own (i.e. it wasn't through the stubbornness of their own heart but because something outside of themselves forced them away from Christ), then the following of their conscience as they see it to be God's will may be deemed sufficient by God. Since they base their moral code off of the Old Testament in many ways, there is another spiritual connection. A Jew following his conscience formed slightly by old testament morality is more likely to be following God's will than a Buddhist following his conscience. Someone in Judaism who was to be saved in spite of their invincible inculpable ignorance, then, is more likely to be saved than someone in a pagan baby-sacrificing religion. The Jew need only be deemed inculpable for the sin of not being Catholics and perhaps a few other sins he had no chance of knowing were sins. The baby-sacrificing pagan has to be deemed inculpable not only for the sin of not being Catholic, but for the numerous evils that he carried out as being completely outside of God's revelealed moral teaching. That's my best explanation of such things as the 'special relationship' to the jews or to the muslims. They are less likely to have extra mortal sins to account for aside from not being Catholic than people of religions that did not stem off the same historical line of moral teaching.[/quote] Thank you for your response and clarification. I find your above statement particularly profound. I realize that the Church is mystically Christ's body but never extrapolated that to the issue of salvation, i.e. that unless you were part of His body you couldn't be saved. Presumably your comments on Judaism apply to other Christian denominations (sects) as well, i.e. the sin of not being Catholic but otherwise having some access to grace / the teachings of the Church?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now