Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is it a sin...


Recommended Posts

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Sometimes when I'm really feeling bad and my prayer life stinks and life in general stinks, I go to pray and end up kinda venting at God...never like cursing or anything like that, and always clinging to the faith...but is it a sin to tell Him that we aren't happy with the way things are going or that we're not happy that we can't feel His presence? Does it disrespect God or anger Him?

I know the saints seem to say no, but it still makes me feel awful afterward.

geetarplayer
Posted

I think it's important to be honest with Him. Then again, let's not forget who's the Creator and who's the creation. :sweat:

Posted

I hope not!! Yipes, I vent to Him all the time!

let_go_let_God
Posted

From what I know, it's not. The fact that you are turning to God and saying I can't feel You near, is acknowledging that you are in need of help and are still searching for Him.

For example, have you ever seen a little kid who has seem to lost their parents? They are usually so panic stricken that they can't even move or they scream, holler and cry to find them. Once the lost child is found usually they are so happy to have found them they don't remember how they lost them and the parent doesn't care about the fuss they through, but they are glad they found their child.

God is the same way with us. He really doesn't care how much of a fuss (as long as we aren't committing a sin within the fuss) we throw as long as we are genuenly looking for Him. His arms are always open to us.

I've thrown my fair share of fusses in my life, and in my cases, it's always a way that I find that I'm looking for God more.

Hope I helped

God bless-
LGLG

matthew1618
Posted

Are you insulting him or are you saying things like "God I don't like how things are goin" or "It's too hard, and I don't like this." Cause if your saying things like "I hate how your treating me, and I hate you" or something like that, it's wrong b/c no matter what's going on in our life he still loves us and what ever happens to us will be for building us up. So I don't think you should insult him but just telling him how you feel is probably alright. :)

Posted

I am probably not the person who should be responding to this. I don't know a lot about anything. But God is God. He knows how you feel no matter whether or not you tell him. It seems to me that in those times when you do feel like that are not the times that you want to be distancing yourself from him. I think that being honest with God might actually draw you closer to him, but sitting in a corner pouting about it will certainly not. Just a thought! :idontknow:

Posted

I know what you mean Micah and I don't think it is a sin. God is there for us always. What does your best friend say to you? "I am here for you. Anytime you need to talk just let me know." God is the same way. But as long as you don't say stuff like Matthew was talking about, or thinking that God did it and you hate Him so on, (I know that you wouldn't do that) then it is fine.

God is there for us in thick and thin, in good times and in bad. He wants to hear about everything. Just make sure you give him time to reply to your frustrations. Sometimes I forget that part.

Posted

We must share with God everything. If we store things up it is not healthy for any relationship especially with the person in charge of judging us at the end of our life.

There was once a priest who held everything in and never told God his troubles, on his death bed he did and he died at peace.

Though God knows our problems we must share with him and ask that God will fix them in our life.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted (edited)

[quote name='matthew1618' post='1032835' date='Jul 28 2006, 10:29 AM']
Are you insulting him or are you saying things like "God I don't like how things are goin" or "It's too hard, and I don't like this." Cause if your saying things like "I hate how your treating me, and I hate you" or something like that, it's wrong b/c no matter what's going on in our life he still loves us and what ever happens to us will be for building us up. So I don't think you should insult him but just telling him how you feel is probably alright. :)
[/quote]
I say things like "I hate this" where "this" means "this pain God is letting me go through."

I would never tell God I hate Him, because I don't. I hate some of the pains I go through trying to love Him, though.

Sometimes it might come close to blaming Him for pain, though...although I know it's sin, not God, that causes it. You know, I'll pray, "why are you letting this happen to me?" Is that wrong?

Edited by Raphael
Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

No, I don't think so. It's a very human thing. God knows your innermost thoughts and feelings -- they aren't things we can hide from him. :sweat:

When my mother died, I said, "God, I am mad at you. I don't want to be, but I cannot help it, I am." I was completely honest and I felt an incredible sense of peace and unconditional love coming from Him at that moment. I felt that even with all his wisdom and ability to see the picture in the grand scheme of things moreso that I ever could, he understood. And it gave me great consolation and ability to submit to his will.

Part of being reverent is being completely honest, and God has perfect understanding of everything going on in our heads.

There was a story about St. Teresa of Avila, she got mad at God when she fell off her horse and into the mud, and she asked God why he was treating her so, and he said "This is how I treat all my friends" and Teresa said, "now I see why you have so few."

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Posted

He's a big guy. He can take it.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

I agree with what has been said above:

If a thing is difficult for you, acknowledge that it is difficult to God. If something is hard, tell Him that its hard. You can even complain and say "I wish it wasn't this hard" - even Christ asked the Father to take the cup of suffering away from him. Call a spade a spade and God will love you for that honesty. The only time that sin could enter is if you told God that He was wrong for letting you struggle and that "your way" is better than God's way.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

Communication is important in every relationship. Maybe not so much that we let others know how we feel, but for own benefit.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1032901' date='Jul 28 2006, 12:20 PM']
The only time that sin could enter is if you told God that He was wrong for letting you struggle and that "your way" is better than God's way.
[/quote]
That's what's bothering me. I never said God was wrong, nor was it my intention (such a thing would be pretty stupid to say, besides), but isn't it sort of implicit in complaining? When I say, "God, I don't like the way this is hurting me/the way I'm being treated (although knowing that it's not God doing evil, but it's the pain I must undergo for the sake of His plan)," it makes me feel a certain amount of guilt...perhaps because if I had said that to my parents, it would have been considered disrespectful.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Feelings are not good or bad, they just are. Share your feelings :)

God can handle it :D:

Posted

He's our Eternal Father. As with our earthly fathers, he expects us to be totally honest with him. And unlike our earthly fathers, He know when we aren't telling him how we really feel.

sidemunch88
Posted

[quote]
Sometimes when I\'m really feeling bad and my prayer life stinks and life in general stinks, I go to pray and end up kinda venting at God...never like cursing or anything like that, and always clinging to the faith...but is it a sin to tell Him that we aren\'t happy with the way things are going or that we\'re not happy that we can\'t feel His presence? Does it disrespect God or anger Him?

I know the saints seem to say no, but it still makes me feel awful afterward.
[/quote]
do you go to FUS cause yeah it sounds like it :hehehe: :hehe: :lol:

Posted

Emotions are meant to move us and to move others.

Posted

What's the point of telling God how we feel when He knows already how we feel?

Posted

[quote name='LSW' post='1033455' date='Jul 28 2006, 11:53 PM']
What's the point of telling God how we feel when He knows already how we feel?
[/quote]


good question..but sometimes its still good to get things off your chest.. just because He knows already doesn't mean you need to hold it in :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...