Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I delivered this today and included the text from Trent Vol VI, Alex Jones conversion story, Time Staples conversion story, and a Catholic tract. This guy, who hangs up pics of aborted babies, will not protest with other Prots who are willing to pray to Jesus with Catholics.

abridged:
[quote]Brother Mike,

I enjoy seeing you out in front of Planned Parenthood on the weekends to protest/pray for an end to abortion. I wish to discuss with you some of the items you have written in your tract, [i]Is Catholic Christian? Be born again and have a loving relationship with Jesus.[/i] You have made statements such as, “Catholics say their Bible is unreliable and trust the pope... The Catholic Church says Pius [XI] acted as God’s representative when he endorsed Hitler’s Third Reich... Catholics reject salvation by grace and seek to earn it (i.e. 7 sacraments)... ” and many more. The closing line of the tract is, “SALT Ministries invites the Catholic Church to refute these facts in a public forum.” This is my attempt at such refutation of your statements, as I find them false and misrepresenting my new faith.

You made a very interesting comment last Saturday. You observed some Baptist have stated, “I am Baptist, I was born Baptist, I will die Baptist.” You found danger in that statement, as they may be placing their church membership above the call God has for them. Like Father Abraham (Acts 7:2), we must be willing to sacrifice all that we believe and have hope in for God. This includes the church you and I attend. I said this prayer about a year ago, which placed me on a path that has lead me to the Catholic Church.

As having been a ‘bible Christian’ all my life, my relationship with Jesus has never been stronger since I joined the fullness of the Catholic Church on 20 November, 2005 at age 28. History: I can remember asking Jesus to come into my heart at age 4 in the back of my father’s car. Since then I have read the bible from cover to cover, have spoken in tongues, and have been slain in the spirit. I have been to various Pentecostal, Independent Bible, Methodist, Lutheran, Baptist, BaBtist, Episcopal, Assembly of God, Presbyterian, Evangelical, and Church of God in Christ churches just to name a few. A very wonderful and surprising thing happened about a year ago, while my wife and I were church hunting. During March, 2005, I was relocating with the military to Colorado Springs. My wife and I had battled on which church to join since we met in 2000. She was a non-believer until she ‘got saved’ in an Assembly of God church. I was High Anglican (Episcopal) at the time. I finally gave up trying to meld our church beliefs when I moved here and honestly, prayed, “God, I will go to whatever church you want for me and my family, no matter which one it is.” A few months later I was Catholic. There were many things which initially made me feel uncomfortable with the Catholic Church. To work through these issues (salvation, deuterocononical books, Mariology, Pope etc), I objectively asked what the Catholic teaches and why they hold such beliefs from Catholic sources instead of letting anti-Catholics, such as Josh McDowell, Foxe and his ‘Book of Martyrs,’ Jack Chick, Dave Hunt etc, incorrectly tell me what the church taught. One of the issues that gave me the final nudge to become Catholic was my attraction to the Catholic ban on contraception and call for marital chastity. All Churches (Catholic, Baptist, Protestant etc) banned contraception until 1930. Now the Catholics are the only one. Why do Catholics oppose contraception? There are many reasons; one of which is that the spread of contraception causes men to mistreat women. Another is that nearly all abortions are the product of failed contraception.

My wife became Catholic 20 April, 2006 as she used prayer, the bible and history to test the Catholic Church.

I grow each day as I ask Jesus to continue to change my heart to fit His desire for my life. He has done so. My newfound faith has born great fruit. I feel his grace and peace everyday as He gives site to my blind soul. I repent of sins more often and avoid sinful media that gets in the way of my relationship with God (porn). I am involved in worthy causes on a regular basis (feed hungry, clothe naked, prevent abortion).

To begin to answer your invitation to “refute these facts,” I wish to only address one issue at a time. Please respect my request, as jumping from one topic to another is a danger that could lead to us to changing subjects before we can come to any resolution. I will address your items in your paragraphs on “Grace vs. Works,” and “Losing Salvation.” Let us as family in Christ, through our baptism, slowly and carefully seek out His truth in humility.

In your tract, you wrote:

[code]Grace vs. Works
Protestants say we are, “justified by faith, apart from works” (Rom. 3:28). Catholics counter with, “Seest thou that faith did cooperate with works and by works faith was made perfect?... Do you see that by works a man is justified, and not by faith?.. faith without works is dead,” Jam 2:22-26. (&Mat. 12:36, 25:45; Rom. 2:6; 2 Cor. 5:10, Gal. 5:6, Jam 1:22, Rev. 22:12).
However, “For by grace you are saved through faith; and that not of yourselves, for it is the gift of God. Not of works, that no man may glory,” Eph 2:8-9. “For if thou confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in thy heart that God hath raised him up from the dead, though shalt be saved.” Rom. 10:9 (& Isa. 64:6, Rom. 1:17-19, 3:20-24, 4:4-6, 5:1-2, 8, 6:14, 9:30-32; Acts 16:30; Gal. 2:16, Titus 3:5).
Resolution- Protestants don’t really know what to do about the paradox; many of them say we are saved by faith alone (sola fide) and sit on the couch. Catholics reject salvation by grace and seek to earn it (i.e. 7 sacraments), as do Mormons, J. Witnesses, and all other non-Christians; but if salvation is, “by grace, it is not now by works; otherwise grace is no more grace,” Rom. 11:6. “You are made void of Christ, you are justified in the law: you are fallen from grace,” Gal. 5:4.
A simple experiment of cause and effect can dispose of the whole conflict. Blow up a balloon and tie a knot. Then yell, “bang” real loud. Do it again... and again. What did your many works achieve? Now pop the balloon. A true bang invariably results.

Lose Salvation?
The Catholic Church damns as a heretic anyone who believes their salvation is assured (Council of Trent, Ses. VI). However, “you may know that you have eternal life: you who believe in the name of the Son of God”, 1 John 5:13 (& Eph. 4:30). We cannot earn our salvation nor can it be taken from us. Still, some worriers ask if we can forsake it (see- Rom 8:15; I Cor. 10:12; Colos. 1:23; 1 Tim. 3:6, 4:1, 16; 2 Tim. 2:10-13; 2 Pet. 2:20; Heb. 3:6, 6:4-6, & 10:26).[/code]
To begin, let us start where we agree. I, like you, affirm the resolution that sola fide is a paradox contrary to scripture. The truth lies elsewhere. Second, as with your balloon illustration, I agree simply speaking or willing an action does not make it happen. For as Jesus declares in Matt 7:21, not everyone who proclaims ‘Jesus is Lord’ will go to heaven. St. Paul, speaking to baptized Christians after they had professed their faith in Christ, further explains Jesus’ words about the requirement of action in Gal 5:21, “... those who do such things will not inherit the kingdom of God.” St. John shows the importance of keeping Jesus in our lives when he wrote to those with the faith, “(3)The way we may be sure that we know him is to be sure we keep his commandments. (4)Whoever says, “I know him,” but does not keep his commandments is a liar, and the truth is not in him... (24) Let what you heard in the beginning remain in you. If what you heard from the beginning remains in you, then you will remain in the Son and in the Father,” (1 John 2:3-4,24). More is required; we must follow his commandments. We can have faith, but if we do not act, we may be judged unworthy of the saving grace Jesus obtained on the cross for us. Not only action, but continual action especially when Jesus reminded us that,”whoever endures to the end will be saved,” (Matt. 10:22),“If you wish to enter life, keep the commandments,” (Matt 19:17). While faith is a requirement for salvation as you showed in, “Rom. 10:9 (& Isa. 64:6, Rom. 1:17-19, 3:20-24, 4:4-6, 5:1-2, 8, 6:14, 9:30-32; Acts 16:30; Gal. 2:16, Titus 3:5),” so is the requirement for following the commandments.
So what is the balance between faith and works? We agree that faith cannot exist apart from action (works). We both agree that the bible cannot contradict and the truth is in the economy of salvation which agrees with all verses in the bible. So what is the Catholic position? I plan to discuss such issues next letter.
In Him,[/quote]

toledo_jesus
Posted

I noticed a few typos :ninja:


BUT good letter. Don't count on much. His rhetoric is how he feeds his family.

Posted (edited)

[quote]Catholics reject salvation by grace and seek to earn it (i.e. 7 sacraments), [/quote]

I hope he didn't mean to write that. Is he aware that Catholics believe we can't earn salvation [u]without[/u] grace? :unsure:

Edited by DAF
Posted

Way to be, this is awesome. I especially like how you basically called him out on his challenge to a Catholic in a public forum.

Continue working and posting your responses!

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1035606' date='Aug 1 2006, 01:04 PM']
I noticed a few typos :ninja:
BUT good letter. Don't count on much. His rhetoric is how he feeds his family.
[/quote]
my typos or his? He does not have a family. He spends alot of time out there. Before he got 'saved,' he paid for his girlfriend to have an abortion.

[quote name='DAF' post='1035695' date='Aug 1 2006, 03:30 PM']
I hope he didn't mean to write that. Is he aware that Catholics believe we can't earn salvation [u]without[/u] grace? :unsure:
[/quote]
Nope, but he will be, with God's help through my pen.

[quote name='rkwright' post='1035720' date='Aug 1 2006, 03:55 PM']
Way to be, this is awesome. I especially like how you basically called him out on his challenge to a Catholic in a public forum.

Continue working and posting your responses!
[/quote]
Thank you and send me your prayers.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Ok, good news. My letter was well received. Remember, we are only discussing salvation. He read all of Keating's "Catholicism and Fundamentalism," watched the Alex Jones story "No price too High," listened to Tim Staples Conversion story, and read Trent VI. We had a great discussion. We [u]agreed[/u] together:

1. If you do not have faith in Jesus and follow his commandments, you cannot be assured of your salvation.

2. When we sin, our hearts become more prideful and sinful. This is effectively a punishment. God does fogive sins and the eternal punishment due, however we are left with the 'worldly' effect of sin in our lives and must deal with our situations.

:drool: 3. As we live in Christ, he transforms our selfish hearts of pride into hearts of gold. Before we see God in heaven face to face, our hearts will need to be fully gold without any pride. We will be prideful until the day we die. [u]Therefore, any pride remaining in us at our death will be removed between death and heaven. [/u] :drool:

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1046757' date='Aug 20 2006, 01:09 PM']
Ok, good news. My letter was well received. Remember, we are only discussing salvation. He read all of Keating's "Catholicism and Fundamentalism," watched the Alex Jones story "No price too High," listened to Tim Staples Conversion story, and read Trent VI. We had a great discussion. We [u]agreed[/u] together:

1. If you do not have faith in Jesus and follow his commandments, you cannot be assured of your salvation.

2. When we sin, our hearts become more prideful and sinful. This is effectively a punishment. God does fogive sins and the eternal punishment due, however we are left with the 'worldly' effect of sin in our lives and must deal with our situations.

:drool: 3. As we live in Christ, he transforms our selfish hearts of pride into hearts of gold. Before we see God in heaven face to face, our hearts will need to be fully gold without any pride. We will be prideful until the day we die. [u]Therefore, any pride remaining in us at our death will be removed between death and heaven. [/u] :drool:
[/quote]
:shock:

^_^

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...