Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted (edited)

I am taking more of the certfication classes put on by my diocese. Our first night, someone asked about Marian dogmas/doctrines and the "Sister" teaching the class responded that there were only two: the Immaculate Conception of Mary and her Assumption. I raised my hand and responded that there were 4 dogmas and one doctrine regarding our Blessed Mother: Immaculate Conception, Assumption, Mother of God, and her perpetual virginity. Since we had just finished going over the Ecumenical Councils she conceeded that Theotokos was also dogma, but insisted that her perpetual virginity was only doctrine. I promised I would look it up, as did she.

Last night I brought in my Catechism, Ott's "Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma", and my "Introduction to Mary" book from Dr. Miravalle's Mariology class... I waited until she approached me and then I showed her my books and the appropriate pages and started to explain the 3-fold nature of Mary's perpetual virginity (at which point she got very confused about Mary being a virgin "during the birth of Jesus" until I pointed her to the relevant passage in the Catechism...). I said that the dogma of perpetual virginity was confirmed by the Second Council of Constantinople (which is an Ecumenical Council) since it twice refers to Mary as "ever-virgin" and condemns Origen as a heretic-- and he denied the perpetual virginity of Our Lady. I also showed her a quote from Pope St. Martin I from the Lateran Synod where he basically declares it an article of faith. HOWEVER, she refuses to believe it to be dogma because the Catechism does not say "X is dogma" and because the Council/Synod I showed her don't say "X is dogma" and neither does the quote from Pope St. Martin I say "X is dogma". When she presented her findings to the class, however, she was just vague and sort of half conceeded that the perpetual virginity of Mary was dogma.

Later on, the gentleman who had asked the question in the first place came and found me and said he'd looked it up and that there were 4 dogmas-- all the ones I'd named, and asked me about the 5th doctrine because he'd seen some of Dr. Miravalle's sites promoting it in hopes of the Pope declaring it dogma. As I started to explain the titles for him, "Sister" interrupts because Co-Redemptrix is not in Vatican II and thus it's not doctrine and it will never be because only Jesus is our Redeemer. I affirmed what she had said and replied that it's a common misunderstanding of the Latin Co-Redemptrix which means "woman WITH the Redeemer" and does in no way claim Mary as another Redeemer, but rather acknowledges her presence and motherly consent throughout the Redemption by Jesus Christ. And she just shook her head and said, "Oh no... I don't know what they taught you... but we really just have to stick to what Vatican II said..." (in which I just had to let it go and not fly off the handle about her heretical-non-habit-wearing-"order" that promotes very scandalous ideas) and just said, "well I guess we'll have to look to the Church for her decision and just disagree on this point for now".

So, I don't know what the point of this post was (other than to vent), because I'm not sure there's much else I can do to demonstrate the dogmatic stance of Mary's perpetual virginity? I tried explaining to her that infallibility is not just limited to papal pronouncements, but she didn't believe me and insists that the perpetual virginity of Mary is not infallible nor is it dogmatic (which is sort of redundant).

Any suggestions?

Someone from my parish (who's been greatly amused/edified by my ramblings and run-ins) wants me to write a letter to the Diocesan Office about some of the inaccuracies and inconsistancies with Church teaching that I've been pointing out pretty frequently (ex., last night our presenter didn't know what Transubstantiation was, and claimed that it was the Lutherans who believed that Christ was actually present and that we only believed He was spiritually present alongside the bread and wine until I objected and insisted it was the other way around--even bringing up St. Thomas Aquinas' substance and accident). But I have a feeling my letter would not be received well and would fall on deaf ears. Should I write a letter anyway? And, should I send in my resume after I graduate? (lol, one of the attendees from another parish came up to me afterwards and said she'd like it if I taught the classes instead :lol: ). But I don't know how well it'd go with me working with "Sister" and the rest of the presenters... all of whom seem to have some struggles with Church teaching (and yet they're working for the Diocese in the Office of Religious Education and Catechesis!). Yikes.

Sorry to make you read all that. What next?

Comment, Suggest away, and tell me to stop being so judgmental.

Edited by Fides_et_Ratio
thessalonian
Posted

If anyone does not, according to the Holy Fathers, confess truly and properly that holy Mary, ever virgin and immaculate, is Mother of God, since in this latter age she conceived in true reality without human seed from the Holy Spirit, God the Word Himself, who before the ages was born of God the Father, and gave birth to Him without corruption, her virginity remaining equally inviolate after the birth, let him be condemned.

Pope Martin

Man I feel for ya. What school do you go to? Remind me not to send my kids there. It is sad that the teaching is so horrible. Surely she knows that councils are infallible?

Posted

As a Christian, you are a partaker in the divinity of Christ and share in his role as Priest, Prophet, and King. Do not hesitate to stamp out error. (Did Jesus not remain sinless when he turned over tables?) Do so pastorily. I encourage you to take documents from popes and councils that show her error. Start with Lumen Gentium paragraph 25 (she may be a big fan of VII), then introduce other pronouncements like the one thess found from Pope Martin. They exist in multitudes.

For addressing the larger issue of how the 'sister' remains in charge, I recommend the following:

Matt 18:15-18 method,

Matt 18:15
Pray for her to be won over to the fullness of the truth
Meet with her in private.
Pray with her that the class with teach truth.
Show her your evidence in humility.
Recommend how you think her class should proceed.

If verse 15 fails, find a buddy who agrees with you and move to Mt 18:16-17 which may include your parish pastor. If no success, move on up to the Bishop and beyond if necessary. They, not you, with handle Mt 18:17b.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

what phenomenal ignorance.. :twitch:

I would definitely make a stink if I were you. These people are spreading falsehoods and heresy and there is already enough of this going around. With all due respect, people of that caliber should not be teaching the faith, in fact from the sound if it they aren't teaching the faith.

My first impulse would be to speak to these people privately and very candidly. If they clearly had no intention to cure their ignorance or teach the true faith I would proceed to tattle and see where that got things.
I would have little regret in opposing their role as teacher and catechist. The people who go to them to learn the Catholic Faith deserve to get just that. I would also think that the Bishop (and/or pastor) has a right to know that there are such low caliber teachers in their fold. Pastors and Bishops have the responsibility of seeing that the Gospel is authentically proclaimed and thus they ought to know when a heretic is in their midst.
If despite your best efforts nothing is done to correct the matter you can always pray, and possibly set yourself up in some sort of catechetical capacity to compete with their heretical teachings.

Just some thoughts anyway.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I dream of the day when orthodox christians will raise up and cast out the army of heterodox insurgents who have dared to attack the Church from within.

As un-PC as it may sound, we are at war, and what is at stake is the eternal destiny of countless souls. Our enemies attack with sophistry, ignorance and deceit; we must counter attack with the truth. Too many otherwise good Catholics seem to be ashamed of the truth. The twisted lies of the so-called dissenters, liberals, progressives, must be exposed and counteracted. Anyone who has known the truth, who has been set free by the truth, has a duty to proclaim that truth at any cost, even if it should cost ones reputation, friendships or life.

That's my take in a nutshell.

thessalonian
Posted

The Church is kind of a Lebanon with hezbullah inside it's borders right now it seems.

I agree with your take.

Posted

Perhaps a tongue in cheek manner to accomplish both is to send the US bishop's letter on adult faith formation (Our Hearts Were Burning - [url="http://www.nccbuscc.org/education/ourhearts.htm)"]http://www.nccbuscc.org/education/ourhearts.htm)[/url] and suggest that Sister and other teachers who are not meeting the standard make up the first classes

Standards for catechists:

§ 150 § Catechists of adults need to be people of faith with an evangelizing spirit, a zeal for God's kingdom, and a commitment to lifelong formation. [b]They have a sound grasp of Catholic doctrine and theology[/b], an ability to access the various sources of the word of God,105 and an understanding of how to communicate this knowledge effectively to adults, drawing appropriately upon psychology and the social sciences as needed. They are first people of prayer who recognize their own need to grow in faith.

§ 151 § It is not enough for catechists to know their subjects. They also need the competence to animate a shared journey with other adults, the ability to relate authentic Catholic faith to real-life circumstances, the ability to guide them in prayer and through spiritual experiences, and the craft to integrate divergent tendencies into the full faith and life of the Church. It is essential that catechists witness in their own lives the truth of the faith they are communicating. This will require a love for people, a passion for catechesis, effective interpersonal and community-building skills, respect for different adult learning styles, the ability to communicate and explore the Gospel with others using active and engaging methods appropriate to the learners and to the content, and the flexibility to adapt to ever-changing circumstances.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Whew.

This is a much better response than I was expecting. I have really been struggling lately with seeming "too conservative" yet knowing that I cannot possibly understand certain aspects of the Church's teaching in another light. Call it pride perhaps, but my "radical ultra conservativeness" is not going anywhere any time soon. I'd stake my life on it.


Just a couple random replies in general:

These are DIOCESAN classes being put on by the [b]Department of Religious Education and Catechesis[/b] for my Diocese. The presenters all work in the Diocesan Office together and most of them are consultants for certain regions of the diocese. The classes themselves are certification courses in catechesis-- ALL Catholic school teachers in the diocese are required to take them, and catechists in CCD/PSR, RCIA and any other faith formation programs are encouraged to take them (and many do). All of these presenters have their Masters in Theology (though a lot of them through Loyola's LIMEX program which many are trying to talk me into because it's cheaper--I only pay for books, the Diocese and my parish pay the tuition).

I sincerely do want to write a letter of concern over certain responses given in the classes, but at the same time, in doing so I will have to recognize that I am only further removing myself from the job market (and that will be a HUGE sacrifice). (fyi, I am hoping for a career in catechesis as a DRE and drastically reforming and improving religious education programs... I would like to work in the Diocese, but I know that my radical and conservative demands would not be taken well... so I figure that working at the parish level, I can negotiate special permissions for my parish and hope that in the long run the reforms will come when they see that returning to a more conservative and faithful stance towards catechesis and Church teachings brings about a better and more lasting revival of the faith).

L_D,
You and I couldn't be more in agreement about being at war. The Church is under a vast and mounting attack by Satan who is using heterdox and more liberal Catholics to destroy faith and fidelity to the Magisterium... the errors of modernism are pouring from the pews and pulpits.

I have been writing in my "reviews" for the classes most of my concerns and occasionally they are addressed when they are severe (or when someone else brings them up as well).

However, just as another example: In that same class, "Sister" stated that Jesus did not know His mission and that He was not sent to die but simply "fell into the wrong hands". I grievously objected, but this went ignored and I've spent the past two nights so far in private discussions with other individuals who were concerned showing them the relevant passage from the Catechism that corrects "Sister's" erroneous view (namely, CCC 474) and reassuring them that Christ indeed came to make atonement for our sins by His innocent death and that He full well knew the plan as He mounted the Cross at Calvary. (as a side note: earlier in the summer "Sister" and I had our rounds about the knowledge of Jesus when she claimed that He "made mistakes, though without sinning" and I asked how a man with perfect knowledge for whatever His age could make a mistake because not all learning (i.e., acquiring knowledge invovles making mistakes-- this idea is erroneous)? But this basically again went unanswered).

(sorry my complaints are so long and detailed! this has been welling up since these classes started earlier this summer)

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1036498' date='Aug 2 2006, 02:49 PM']
I dream of the day when orthodox christians will raise up and cast out the army of heterodox insurgents who have dared to attack the Church from within.

As un-PC as it may sound, we are at war, and what is at stake is the eternal destiny of countless souls. Our enemies attack with sophistry, ignorance and deceit; we must counter attack with the truth. Too many otherwise good Catholics seem to be ashamed of the truth. The twisted lies of the so-called dissenters, liberals, progressives, must be exposed and counteracted. Anyone who has known the truth, who has been set free by the truth, has a duty to proclaim that truth at any cost, even if it should cost ones reputation, friendships or life.

That's my take in a nutshell.
[/quote]


Mr. Jefferson, have you finished that draft yet . . .
Mr. Chairman, I'm working on the last part right now, how does this sound . . .

And for the support of this Declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes and our sacred Honor.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Fides,

It's time to talk to the bishop. You've confronted her and her teachings are so full of error as to be dangerous for other students. This is a greater concern than your career (not to put down your ambitions in any way). The good you want to do is being offset by her polluting the minds of young people. She may even be training someone incorrectly who will be put in a position to prevent you from realizing your ambitions. You have gone to her. You have witnesses, now take the next step and take it to the Church. I would protest vehemently with the university and with the Bishop. She needs to be removed.

Edited by thessalonian
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted (edited)

Fides, I agree about talking to her superiors, praying intensely about it, and I would also say that you should keep proclaiming in class what the Church proclaims. People are so hungry for the truth today that if they see you being a sort of confessor for the faith who is being persecuted, they will probably approach you rather than the sister for sound teaching. It sounds like one gentleman already has. You are not subject to the sister, as far as I know, so she can't shut you up. :P: Be subject to the Church.

Edited by Raphael
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Thanks for all the encouragement... one more clarification: the classes are entirely separate from the University I attend (yes, the University has its own other issues, but it's a whole 'nother problem there).


I am thinking I will probably start with a letter to the Director of the Diocesan Department of Religious Education and Catechesis... I've met her before when I first began thinking about becoming a DRE. Hopefully I can get her to just take a closer look at the classes and the presenters. If I get a funny response, I'll write the Bishop (but seeing as I've written him at least 4 times in the 2 years he's been in office (all complaints regarding priests and other Diocesan such things) I'm beginning to think my letters of concern are not having much of an effect). Of course, the new DRE at my parish was previously one of the presenters (a bit more orthodox, thankfully) and the consultant I met with when I met the Director for the Department (..blah, the rest of the title)-- I e-mailed her earlier over concerns for the videos they were showing and one of the "priests" who I knew to be a questionable fellow and she blew me off at first--e-mailing me back saying she hoped I didn't miss the point of the video's message because I was too concerned about the "priest", but then actually clicked on and read the information about him that I'd sent and e-mailed me back a quick thanks.

I just have a feeling that my orthodoxy and fight to preserve it in the Church is annoying rather than edifying... and I don't want to have the opposite effect and turn people away from the authentic teachings of the Church. Though there are people who approach me about the teachings of the Church, they've all also begun joking about me being the "troublemaker" at class (and making them last longer)... which is fine to an extent, I just don't want people to brush off the reality of the Chuch's teachings as a joke too... you know, because I'm the young college kid that thinks she knows everything and blahblahblah... I think a lot of them respect my knowledge of the Catechism, but sometimes I wonder how seriously they take my defenses (there have been comments regarding birth control about "old celibate men" and so forth, and as an unmarried woman, I just don't yet understand...) It's a give and take balance with them all.


I'm not too concerned about my career plans... I already know it will be a tough struggle because I have repeated to a few good and holy priest-friends of mine that I won't tolerate a more liberal parish (or rather, a more liberal priest) and that my liturgical concerns will dictate where I would accept a position as a DRE. My work would be completely undermined if it's not being preached and celebrated in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass (and I'm done writing liturgical letters for a while). But it's getting to the point where I'm not going to get much support in getting a job in that particular field because it's dominated by a certain mindset that I'm radically opposed to (namely, either outright embracing heretical teachings or watering down and glossing over the Church's teachings in favor of not offending (or, dare I say... "convicting") anyone... it's the "we can't step on anyone's toes" mentality).


It just gets tough when I'm the only one around questioning positions and harping on what the Catechism actually says... one priest told me that I don't have to "fight" everything all the time, and I should just pray about things, but I can't in good conscience just keep my mouth shut.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...