Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='1037070' date='Aug 3 2006, 03:00 PM']
Man, if I'd known I could request replacement novels, maybe I could've gotten out of all that Hemingway.

:pinch:
[/quote]
:pinch:

Posted

hey now. lets not get carried away here. Just because a character in a book takes in specific sexual acitivity does not make the book evil. I read Flowers just like everyone else, and well.. i didnt like it because it was boring and you can see the "point" of the book miles away, but i loved brave new world.

The authors of these books didnt write in all of this sexual stuff because they were being evil and wanted to encourage others to be lustful, they did it to show points. sex is A HUGE part of our world, and a main force behind the majority of our actions and formations of society. In flowers, Charlie gains intelligence, and is just like everyone else - this ofcourse means he's now aware of the same sexual urges that are within us all. im not condoning the actions, im just saying that the author is trying to make a point there about intelligence/sex/etc.

as for brave new world.. ooooh man that catholic school knows what its doing. that book is great, its pretty much a blatent warning to society about what can happen when marraige/family/and giving birth are all destroyed. Which is exactly whats going on in the real world right now.

Look beyond the fact that theres sex, if you have to skip some paragraphs, but done give up on these books as a whole (course if you want to give up on Flowers because it's BORING - by all means lol)

The simple fact that you are disgusted by the stuff means you are "ok" to read it. If the descriptions in the book are actually encouraging your brain to be more lustful - and thus you arnt disgusted, thats when you have to worry. The authors of these books werent trying to tempt you.

Posted

I say they're good enuf for keeping warm. Theres much more useful stuff out there to be reading.

Posted

I know nothing about that "Flowers" book, but Brave New World is classic satire, and one of the most prophetic books of the 20th century. A lot of it is actually scarily close to the way society is going, and is I think even more relevant now than it was in the early '30s when it was written.

It describes an immoral future world, but does not go into any unnecessary graphic detail, and should not be morally problematic for the reader. It is literature, not porn.

[quote name='curtins' post='1036923' date='Aug 3 2006, 11:12 AM']
seriously though

why do they rate video games and movies but not books???
[/quote]
Yeah, you can see how ratings systems have really helped clean up our entertainment! <_<

Posted

ITs not about cleaning it up its about warning people whats in it.

Posted

[quote name='curtins' post='1036840' date='Aug 3 2006, 09:22 AM']
I have to read Flowers for Algernon for summer reading. I'm pretty much disgusted at the amount of graphic sexual carp thats in it. How does one read through something like this without comprimising one's purity?
[/quote]

Yuck! I totally agree with you. I had to read Flowers for Algernon in high school english class. I hated it. Pray about it. I hope you get through it.

Posted

I'm done

finally

But like even to the last 20 pages he had to stick in 2 more pages of carp

ugh

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='1037070' date='Aug 3 2006, 04:00 PM']
Man, if I'd known I could request replacement novels, maybe I could've gotten out of all that Hemingway.

:pinch:
[/quote]
I still rejoice to this day that I got out of Animal Farm.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1037228' date='Aug 3 2006, 08:52 PM']
I still rejoice to this day that I got out of Animal Farm.
[/quote]
What was wrong with Animal Farm? I mean, it was a short book, didn't take that much time.

Posted

When I had to read Flowers for Algernon for my Catholic school, we read the highly edited version in our literature textbooks...nothing racy in there. I guess it's a bit late now but you might've been able to find an edited version.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1037228' date='Aug 3 2006, 08:52 PM']
I still rejoice to this day that I got out of Animal Farm.
[/quote]
I actually liked Animal Farm. I've read it just for kicks.

Four legs good. Two legs baaaaad.

All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.

missionseeker
Posted

i was about to post that.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Wow, I am either
1. Getting old
2. In possession of a swiss coagulated milk brain

Because I remember reading Flowers for Algernon but I don't remember any overt sex in the book at all. I must have read the edited version.

Posted

yeah, I don't remember it being all that bad either. Ash, you and I must have the same problem.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Hehe, yeah I forgot to add reason number 3: both :D:

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

i had to read in 7th grade. i didn't though. but i had to see the movie.

Posted

[color=#663366][font=Comic Sans Ms][size=7]


I read 'Flowers' on my own,

and this book is about much more than Sex or Science~

It is about a man getting the chance to live beyond his 'lot' in life that society has laid upon him,

about him having the chance to live outside of the 'box'...tasting sweetness after so much pain.

and the tragic part, is having to go back to the emptiness that came before~ knowing what bliss can felt in a heart, and truly

knowing how different it can be.

Charlie had eyes to see, and loved, just like everyone, .. and then had to go back to the painful and simple life he lived before.

He accepted this though, and kept living his life without question.


This book is about far more than offensive language and vulgarity, I think the message to Trust God could be hidden inside it somewhere~ but, that is just my opinion.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1036924' date='Aug 3 2006, 10:12 AM']
I never read the book, but the play I saw made me cry. I thought it was touching.

Funny, I don't remember any sexual content. :idontknow:
[/quote]


mee too, i read it in 8th grade in a catholic school and i just remember thinking it was really sad :sadder:

huh, :huh: , i wonder if thye had an adapted version in our reader.... :detective:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...