Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Ok Pham, Get Writing!


Recommended Posts

Birgitta Noel
Posted (edited)

[url="http://www.statenews.com/op_article.phtml?pk=36986"]http://www.statenews.com/op_article.phtml?pk=36986[/url]

[quote]During the first trimester of the pregnancy, the fetus is merely a wad of cells. A mere wad of cells doesn't equate to a fully functioning, living human being. A wad of cells cannot make its own cognitive decisions. A wad of cells doesn't have the capability to inhale or exhale with its lungs. A wad of cells cannot survive independently, as it relies completely on its mother for all its nutriment.

So why would anyone provide a wad of cells with the outrageous status of a living human being?
...
Tapeworms are parasites that house themselves in the intestinal tracts of humans, feeding off the food the host consumes. Comparatively, a fetus is little more than a tapeworm. It is quite common for humans to annihilate parasites with medications or toxins, so why not allow for fetuses to suffer the same fate?
[/quote]

There's a link for the letter to the editor at the top.

As an MSU alumni I'm horrified.

Edited by The Little Way
Posted

That is horible! A group of LIVING cells containing HUMAN DNA is a human.

[quote]A wad of cells cannot make its own cognitive decisions. A wad of cells doesn't have the capability to inhale or exhale with its lungs. A wad of cells cannot survive independently, as it relies completely on its mother for all its nutriment.[/quote]
This guy must have never been to a hospital. Unconscious people cannot make their own cognitive decisions. Many people have devices to breath for them since they dont have the capability to inhale or exhale with their lungs. Most cannot survive independently, thats why they are in the hospital. With his "qualifications" to living humans, killings that occure in a hospital are compleatly justified since they are not human.

[quote]Humans provide pets with food, water and a habitat[/quote]
Parents provide children with food, water and a habitat. Well, he's now cut off a huge group of people under 18. I wonder if he knows that you cant kill pets in many states?

[quote]Do any of these individuals realize that according to the National Institutes of Health, 25 percent of conceived embryos perish within the first six weeks due to complications such as failure to implant to the uterus wall? That's right — a quarter of all "humans" conceived end up "dying."

It would appear that the "loving" God of these fundamentalists is many more times guilty of murder than all the human race's abortionists combined.[/quote]
That is a natural death. Did he know that 100% of humans eventualy die?

After reading that (and grabbing some ice for my hand, since my desk ocupied the space my fist was trying to go to) I can only wonder, do none of these people remember that they were once a fetus. Their egos and pride must make it hard to see such a thing. I wonder if God has concidered that piller of salt thing he did a while back?

While I would love to write in, I think my ability to controll the lingual arts would fail and I would resort to "sentence enhancers." I believe I will pray instead though I implore others in phatmass to write. God Bless.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='2xbob' post='1037148' date='Aug 3 2006, 05:22 PM']
This guy must have never been to a hospital. Unconscious people cannot make their own cognitive decisions. Many people have devices to breath for them since they dont have the capability to inhale or exhale with their lungs. Most cannot survive independently, thats why they are in the hospital. With his "qualifications" to living humans, killings that occure in a hospital are compleatly justified since they are not human.
[/quote]
It scares me to point that out to these people, though, because they'll just go with the next logical step to then kill those people, too. No one is really safe...conceit is what it is

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I sent this:

Mr. Krouse,

Your recent article on abortion is terribly illogical. Allow me to guide you through your errors. First, you state, "Are pets not considered the property of a human? Humans provide pets with food, water and a habitat, just as a mother provides a fetus a habitat inside of the womb, along with food and oxygen." Mothers provide to infants, to toddler, to teenagers, and to college students as yourself the same things they provide to animals, yet you would surely rebel from any claim by your mother that you were her property. Let's look at what else a mother provides to a fetus that she do not provide to a pet: DNA, blood cleaning service, emotional support (at least several of a woman's hormones cross the placenta into the child), etc. The fetus is undeniably human. You claim that it is not a human person, however. Well, here's the thing: humans exist in themselves. You can't have a human that isn't a person. You can have a human body which is devoid of a soul, but that is merely adjectivally human, not a human being. If you are trying to claim that fetuses are dead human tissue, then you are saying by extension that dead things can become living. This does not happen, even to a religious mind, apart from some miracle of God.

Let's examine your second claim. You state, "So why not allow the mother her innate right to decide whether or not this wad of cells will grow into a human?" If a fetus has the potential to grow into a wad of cells, what is it before then? Here we have a common fallacy of the pro-choice side of things. You like to claim that fetuses have the mere potential to become human persons. However, I ask you, what else can it be? To have potential to do one thing implies that you have potential to do other things. Therefore, it is reasonable to ask the question, what other potentiality is inherent to the fetus?

Next, you make the bold statement that "if anything, a fetus is merely a parasitical creature that uses the mother as its host." Of course, to say this is to say that the fetus of a dog is a parasite, that the fetus of a cat is a parasite, etc. Now, that would mean that every living thing ever to exist, save the first generation, is a parasite. What a cynical way to live life. Besides, if we are all parasites, and many of us are hosts, then our limited nutrition on earth would very rapidly (not to mention exponentially) be depleted. Furthermore, what would you say if the mother wants her child? Would you say that the fetus is a parasite in that case, when she willingly gives of herself? Yet you say that the fetus has no will (it follows from your argument that the fetus is not a person), and therefore it must not be the child's will, but the mother's, that keeps the child from being a parasite. Now, if the child is doing the same thing in either case, then how can its objective status be determined by the will of a person who is distinct from it? Do you really think that the human perception actually impacts reality in such a way, or vice-versa?

These thoughts should really dismiss your underlying premise that life hasn't yet begun at conception.

Now, at this point, I would give you the statistics on embryonic development, but I'm certain that you must have seen them numerous times, so I won't bother. What I will do, however, is defend my Protestant brothers and sisters. First, I am a Catholic theology student. I do not appreciate the fact that you didn't give us credit for the vigils we hold, the fasts we keep, the intercessions we pray, the abortions we prevent, etc. Second, I'm feel a little slighted at the misinformation you provided in your article, which reads as follows: "If life begins at conception, why is it that Catholics and other fundamentalist groups don't have funerals for all these dead 'babies'?" The fact of the matter is that we do have formal burials for those babies we are able to obtain. However, clinics usually incinerate the bodies and hospitals usually dispose of the bodies of the miscarried, so it is hard to obtain them. Nonetheless, my college has a tomb of the unborn children, where students may go and visit the dead (their bodies are buried there under the tombstone). We have a deep respect for the sacredness of life, something I'm sorry you haven't seen. As for your further comment ("Why not hold candlelit vigils for all who fail to implant themselves?"), the fact is that candlelight vigils are too difficult to organize for us to do it for each child, but we do pray for them frequently in our prayers, public and private, and especially in the Mass. We celebrate them on the Feast of the Holy Innocents, as well. Finally, you show that you are not thinking clearly when you state, "Or wait, better yet, why don't we supply a birth certificate to all those embryos who died shortly after conception? Why not make them legal citizens too?" Well, of course we wouldn't give them birth certificates; they aren't born. We would gladly give them life certificates, though, and legal citizenship would certainly lead to the end of legal abortion in the United States. Both seem like wonderful ideas, if only we could get enough people to go to the polls.

Finally, I will address your religious difficulty: "It would appear that the 'loving' God of these fundamentalists is many more times guilty of murder than all the human race's abortionists combined." This is simply wrong. First of all, God doesn't kill anyone. God allows people to die as a consequence of the sin in the world (not always as a direct consequence of one's own sins, but of sin in general). Sin causes all natural evils. Second, God's allowing a baby to die in the womb is no different from God's allowing your grandfather to die in his hospital bed. Both simply are a part of life, and death is only a sin when it is unjustly afflicted on another, not when it simply happens. Now, we should mention that the Catholic Church at least states that these children do not go to hell, but by the mercy of God may be saved. You see, you misunderstand how we view death. When it is a passage to eternal life, it is something to be feared only in relation to how much one is attached unduly to the world, but never something to be inflicted.

The baby is a baby at conception, my friend, and will not ever be anything else. It may be difficult to recognize (I admit that it is), but that "wad of cells" is a human person. Though the child may be somewhat amorphous, that is merely a matter of shape, size, and development. You see, the term "person" is relational. Your personhood shows when you are in relation with another. A baby is, from the very beginning of life, in relation to a mother. Personhood is not a quality of a human being; to be human is necessarily to be a person. You aren't endowed with personhood somewhere along the way, you simply are a person if you are human, and as I've shown, the fetus is undeniably a human.

God bless,

Micah Murphy
Franciscan University of Steubenville

Birgitta Noel
Posted

WOW! Pity he'll prob not get past the first line.

Most excellent job Micah!

I wanted to retort something about the fact that women who have miscarriages deeply mourn the loss of their children, as do women who've had abortions for that matter.

BTTT

Posted

[quote name='The Little Way' post='1037204' date='Aug 3 2006, 09:45 PM']
I wanted to retort something about the fact that women who have miscarriages deeply mourn the loss of their children, as do women who've had abortions for that matter.
[/quote]

While its important to show concern for women who find themselves in unfortunate situations, I don't think arguments based on a mother's feelings are all that convincing. After all the whole pro-life argument is based on the fact that there are some things that are absolutely true no matter what people may feel or think. That being said, I found an absolutely awesome quote on a blog the other day from a priest named Fr. Tadeusz Pacholczyk.

[quote] During my testimony, I pointed out how in the United States we have stringent federal laws that protect not only the national bird, the bald eagle, but also that eagle's eggs. If you were to chance upon some of them in a nest out in the wilderness, it would be illegal for you to destroy those eggs. By the force of law, we recognize how the egg of the bald eagle, that is to say, the embryonic eagle inside that egg, is the same creature as the glorious bird that we witness flying high overhead. Therefore we pass laws to safeguard not only the adult but also the very youngest member of that species. Even atheists can see how a bald eagle's eggs should be protected; it's really not a religious question at all. [/quote]

Birgitta Noel
Posted

[quote name='TrueImage' post='1037245' date='Aug 3 2006, 09:23 PM']
While its important to show concern for women who find themselves in unfortunate situations, I don't think arguments based on a mother's feelings are all that convincing. After all the whole pro-life argument is based on the fact that there are some things that are absolutely true no matter what people may feel or think. That being said, I found an absolutely awesome quote on a blog the other day from a priest named Fr. Tadeusz Pacholczyk.
[/quote]


1) yes, I agree, arguement from emotion isn't where it's at. The only reason I would make that comment to him is to counter his argument that if the babies were alive more people would mourn the ones lost before birth.

2) Fr. Tad rocks. He's at the National Catholic Bioethics Center as the Director of Education. He has a Ph.D. in Neuroscience from Yale University, did post-doctoral research at Massachusetts General Hospital/Harvard Medical School, and then did advanced studies in theology and in bioethics in Rome.

Here's a link to some of his stuff [url="http://www.ncbcenter.org/makingsense.asp"]http://www.ncbcenter.org/makingsense.asp[/url]

HomeTeamFamily
Posted

it may be a wad of cells, but its a wad of human cells, that is growing into a fully developed human beings

Posted

Wow. Micah. That was beautifully and kindly written.

Thank you for being an example to others what a Catholic truly should be.

Someone should send him an image of a three month old fetus (because that is the "first trimester").

melporcristo
Posted

+JMJ+

wow Micah -- you amaze me.
Great job at this letter.

Maybe we can have Professor Bessler write to this person too?

Peace,
Melissa

franciscanheart
Posted
:blink: I'm horrified. I'll work on something.
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1037196' date='Aug 3 2006, 07:17 PM']
I sent this:

Mr. Krouse,

Your recent article on abortion is terribly illogical. Allow me to guide you through your errors. First, you state, "Are pets not considered the property of a human? Humans provide pets with food, water and a habitat, just as a mother provides a fetus a habitat inside of the womb, along with food and oxygen." Mothers provide to infants, to toddler, to teenagers, and to college students as yourself the same things they provide to animals, yet you would surely rebel from any claim by your mother that you were her property. Let's look at what else a mother provides to a fetus that she do not provide to a pet: DNA, blood cleaning service, emotional support (at least several of a woman's hormones cross the placenta into the child), etc. The fetus is undeniably human. You claim that it is not a human person, however. Well, here's the thing: humans exist in themselves. You can't have a human that isn't a person. You can have a human body which is devoid of a soul, but that is merely adjectivally human, not a human being. If you are trying to claim that fetuses are dead human tissue, then you are saying by extension that dead things can become living. This does not happen, even to a religious mind, apart from some miracle of God.

Let's examine your second claim. You state, "So why not allow the mother her innate right to decide whether or not this wad of cells will grow into a human?" If a fetus has the potential to grow into a wad of cells, what is it before then? Here we have a common fallacy of the pro-choice side of things. You like to claim that fetuses have the mere potential to become human persons. However, I ask you, what else can it be? To have potential to do one thing implies that you have potential to do other things. Therefore, it is reasonable to ask the question, what other potentiality is inherent to the fetus?

Next, you make the bold statement that "if anything, a fetus is merely a parasitical creature that uses the mother as its host." Of course, to say this is to say that the fetus of a dog is a parasite, that the fetus of a cat is a parasite, etc. Now, that would mean that every living thing ever to exist, save the first generation, is a parasite. What a cynical way to live life. Besides, if we are all parasites, and many of us are hosts, then our limited nutrition on earth would very rapidly (not to mention exponentially) be depleted. Furthermore, what would you say if the mother wants her child? Would you say that the fetus is a parasite in that case, when she willingly gives of herself? Yet you say that the fetus has no will (it follows from your argument that the fetus is not a person), and therefore it must not be the child's will, but the mother's, that keeps the child from being a parasite. Now, if the child is doing the same thing in either case, then how can its objective status be determined by the will of a person who is distinct from it? Do you really think that the human perception actually impacts reality in such a way, or vice-versa?

These thoughts should really dismiss your underlying premise that life hasn't yet begun at conception.

Now, at this point, I would give you the statistics on embryonic development, but I'm certain that you must have seen them numerous times, so I won't bother. What I will do, however, is defend my Protestant brothers and sisters. First, I am a Catholic theology student. I do not appreciate the fact that you didn't give us credit for the vigils we hold, the fasts we keep, the intercessions we pray, the abortions we prevent, etc. Second, I'm feel a little slighted at the misinformation you provided in your article, which reads as follows: "If life begins at conception, why is it that Catholics and other fundamentalist groups don't have funerals for all these dead 'babies'?" The fact of the matter is that we do have formal burials for those babies we are able to obtain. However, clinics usually incinerate the bodies and hospitals usually dispose of the bodies of the miscarried, so it is hard to obtain them. Nonetheless, my college has a tomb of the unborn children, where students may go and visit the dead (their bodies are buried there under the tombstone). We have a deep respect for the sacredness of life, something I'm sorry you haven't seen. As for your further comment ("Why not hold candlelit vigils for all who fail to implant themselves?"), the fact is that candlelight vigils are too difficult to organize for us to do it for each child, but we do pray for them frequently in our prayers, public and private, and especially in the Mass. We celebrate them on the Feast of the Holy Innocents, as well. Finally, you show that you are not thinking clearly when you state, "Or wait, better yet, why don't we supply a birth certificate to all those embryos who died shortly after conception? Why not make them legal citizens too?" Well, of course we wouldn't give them birth certificates; they aren't born. We would gladly give them life certificates, though, and legal citizenship would certainly lead to the end of legal abortion in the United States. Both seem like wonderful ideas, if only we could get enough people to go to the polls.

Finally, I will address your religious difficulty: "It would appear that the 'loving' God of these fundamentalists is many more times guilty of murder than all the human race's abortionists combined." This is simply wrong. First of all, God doesn't kill anyone. God allows people to die as a consequence of the sin in the world (not always as a direct consequence of one's own sins, but of sin in general). Sin causes all natural evils. Second, God's allowing a baby to die in the womb is no different from God's allowing your grandfather to die in his hospital bed. Both simply are a part of life, and death is only a sin when it is unjustly afflicted on another, not when it simply happens. Now, we should mention that the Catholic Church at least states that these children do not go to hell, but by the mercy of God may be saved. You see, you misunderstand how we view death. When it is a passage to eternal life, it is something to be feared only in relation to how much one is attached unduly to the world, but never something to be inflicted.

The baby is a baby at conception, my friend, and will not ever be anything else. It may be difficult to recognize (I admit that it is), but that "wad of cells" is a human person. Though the child may be somewhat amorphous, that is merely a matter of shape, size, and development. You see, the term "person" is relational. Your personhood shows when you are in relation with another. A baby is, from the very beginning of life, in relation to a mother. Personhood is not a quality of a human being; to be human is necessarily to be a person. You aren't endowed with personhood somewhere along the way, you simply are a person if you are human, and as I've shown, the fetus is undeniably a human.

God bless,

Micah Murphy
Franciscan University of Steubenville
[/quote]


did you get a response?

Posted

Well, I remember a group that didnt consider Jews humans...So they killed them...They were known as Nazi's

If we are being BOLD enought JUDGE what is HUMAN and NOT HUMAN
Then they are just as bad a Hitler who believed that he WAS BOLD ENOUGH TO MAKE SUCH A JUDGEMENT...I dont care what reasearch was made...I have take several chem classes and 75% of lab reseach is oppinion. Thus, this "wad of cells" (which has also gone under various names before, therefore proving its oppinonated value.) merely falls under the 75% oppinion category....Nazi? Who here would be bold enough to stand up and not consider even the smallest living organism living...Was it not the smallest living living in their theory of evolution that spawned the fellow man? Is it the smallest living organism in their structure of the earth that cause the so called Big Bang?

If fetues are unliving then in their interpretation of life and evolution...None of use are...

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='ReinnieR' post='1037677' date='Aug 4 2006, 08:55 PM']
did you get a response?
[/quote]
Yes; the response made little to no sense and smacked of arrogance. Pray for this young man; he has been brainwashed by the pro-abortion forces in the world and can't see through the smog it has created in his mind.

Here it is (complete with the confusion he had over my gender):

"Ms. Murphy,

Prior to reading your invalid religious opinion, I noticed you were a
Franciscan student. Unfortunately, I knew this message would use ignorant
religion and be completely void of any intelligence. So, I will thank you
for verifying my assumption by being a typical fundamentalist.

I loved the sentence that described how you would explain embroyology to me,
only to find you would save me the trouble of reading something I know much
about. First of all, this makes me assume you know little-to-nothing about
human biology, as you covered this fact by assuming we know it. Secondly,
thanks for assuming I know my human physiology. Though I am educated in the
subject, I thank you for basically telling me my column is valid, which
would be the case if I should know the stats on embryos. Thus, if my stance
is valid, you really have no basis to argue it? Right?

Now, I shall conclude this very reply with this final argument. You entirely
lost all hopes of persuading me when you moronically stated, "Well, of
course we wouldn't give them birth certificates; they aren't born." It
appears you as a fundamentalist, agree with a rationalist. Unbelievable. You
ruined your entire message and lost any hope of being taken seriously. If
you do not believe this fetus is born, then it is not alive, therefore, your
entire argument is gravely flawed. Thanks for wasting our time. Good luck
with your theology major. You'll be needing it, if you do not think that the
fetus is a born human. Take care, and be sure not to take any courses that
may potentially challenge your intelligence."

franciscanheart
Posted

I don't think it's confusing. I understand what he's SAYING just not his LOGIC. It's obviously way off but I get what he's saying.

His biggest problem is that he thinks BIRTH is what declares something as LIVING. What about babies they have to take prematurely? What about when they try someone for TWO deaths instead of one when they kill a pregnant woman? Obviously the child is LIVING before it is BORN. It's not like the vagina folds breathe 'life' into the baby. MISCARRIAGE is the DEATH of a BABY. That's miscarriage at all stages!

The man needs many prayers...

Posted (edited)

The surest way to spot a moron is to look for the person who skips the argument and goes right for the poster or sender. ReinnieR sent a long message full of points, the response was an angry sarcastic and condisending attack on ReinnieR.

Edited by 2xbob

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...