Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote]There are entire sites run by ex-catholics that have learned the truth about their precious church, everything they cover up, the full extent of their greed[/quote]
Thats like going to a cheating ex-husband or wife and asking them for unbiased opinions of their cheated on spouse :pinch:

franciscanheart
Posted

Books to read: Biblical Basis for the Catholic Church -- and -- The New Anti-Catholicism: The Last Acceptable Prejudice

I think there might actually be something helpful in that second one (in the small part of it that I've read now). I'll see if I can find it for you sometime today.

heavenseeker
Posted

well im still waiting to see what his next responce is going to be, hopefuly there wont be one. I'm just praying that I was able to show him that the church isn't what he thought it was.

Posted

woo hoo my first nomination

i nominate greg (heavenseeker) for church militant

Posted

Pin him down for an example of what he is talking about. Find out if it is just an urban legend, a misunderstanding, or whether he's just mad that the Church is telling him that something he is doing is wrong. You will accomplish one of two things:

1) You will correct a misconception or show the basis for Church teaching; or
2) You will expose him for what he is

heavenseeker
Posted

[quote name='ReinnieR' post='1038184' date='Aug 5 2006, 01:05 PM']
woo hoo my first nomination

i nominate greg (heavenseeker) for church militant
[/quote]

thanks ReinnieR :D:
[quote name='Norseman82' post='1038198' date='Aug 5 2006, 01:30 PM']
Pin him down for an example of what he is talking about. Find out if it is just an urban legend, a misunderstanding, or whether he's just mad that the Church is telling him that something he is doing is wrong. You will accomplish one of two things:

1) You will correct a misconception or show the basis for Church teaching; or
2) You will expose him for what he is
[/quote]

I think it's a misunderstanding that he has picked up from others.



this really ties into the quote that I have up on my page
"Less than 100 people hate the catholic church, millions of people hate what they mistake the catholic church to be."
I'm sure he is/was in that millions that only hate what they mistake us to be.

franciscanheart
Posted

no offense but i think it will take much more than what you have provided to change his ways of thinking.

heavenseeker
Posted (edited)

[quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1038241' date='Aug 5 2006, 03:08 PM']
no offense but i think it will take much more than what you have provided to change his ways of thinking.
[/quote]

none taken, and I admit I had thought it would take more myself but i also would have expected something back from him by now too. I guess the only way to know is to wait and see.

Edited by heavenseeker
Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1038241' date='Aug 5 2006, 03:08 PM']
no offense but i think it will take much more than what you have provided to change his ways of thinking.
[/quote]
yeah it's like that.

one person i'm debating... well i've been debating this one guy for almost a year.

Posted

please ask him for those sites so we can blow them to smitherines and be done with this balderdash

heavenseeker
Posted

alright here is what he just sent me along with what i just sent him, i dont know where he is getting this stuff.


him: 1. You can think that, but they certainly don't. And what they say goes completely adverse to what you are saying. Why do you think your perception of the 'truth' is infallible?

2. Hehehe, there are many ways the catholic church doesn't follow the bible, and 'adds' to the religion beyond what is said in the bible:
i. The catholic priest's, bishop's, pope's, and whatever other high ranks there are in the church's salaries are HUGE. The pope lives in a massive mansion with every comfort you could imagine, bishops a bit less, and priest a bit less than that. They are all extremely rich. This goes directly against the bible's rules on greed, and vanity. I know you are going to spout 'they are chast, they cannot have wives or any relations, therefore they should be able to have such comfots', but does one "right"(though it really isn't a right, the rules make truly no sense, and are not taught in the bible) justify another wrong? As well as many churches themselves being incredibly unneccesarilly decorative and huge. They waste mass ammount of money on maintaining these churches, and building new ones. These churches should be museums, and the religious practice should be in simple building that do not waste money pointlessly. This is greed and vanity as i've said already, which is against the bible.
ii. Use of idols in worship. The bible says no idol should be used in worship, not just in worship of other gods, but in worship of him as well. He cursed followers of his for worshiping him through the golden calf did he not? Yet the church uses huge crosses with images of Jesus (whom they think to be part of god) in their worship, definately idolatry.
iii. All of the ceremony in the church is not in the bible, and is therefore presuming what god would have us do, which is against the bible. They should follow the bible, and nothing more, not what the pope's write, not what is in other texts. JUST the bible. And these ceremonies are certainly not included in the bible.
iv. Baptism of babies... How friggin obvious is that?
etc.. etc..

Great, you believe the devil exists, but if you are 'sure he exists' that is simple ignorance. There is no evidence for his existance, so don't go spouting to me that the devil is working through me, that is simply annoying and serves no purpose. Seeing how I DON'T believe in either God or the Devil..



and me:im just going to skip your first arguement because all that is is a matter of opinion that you have picked up from ex-catholics that believe nothing but lies.

There is no way what so ever that any of your second arguement is true.
i. the salaries of the priest, bishops, and pope are not huge. A priest only makes about the same amount as an elemntary teacher most likely even less. I personaly know priest and have visited them in their homes which are also the parish offices. I garentee you that they are no larger than that of a middle income families house and that the part of the mthat the priest actualy lives in is about the size of a one or two bedroom apartment and have nothing in them that you couldnt go out and buy yourself. Bishops and Archbishops are just the same as priest and recieve just about the same pay. Cardnals and the Pope are the same way as far as pay even though they probably do get a little more but it is not much. Your lie of them being rich is just that a lie, the Pope lives in the Vatican mot because he is rich but because it is the central location of the church. As far as the size of it goes it is only that big because it was built back when the church was powerful and rich, now like every parish it is maintained by donations not by the income of the priest. The reason why churches are huge
and well decorated is because they are representations of God's kingdom on earth. New churches that are built today have to be built to reach the catholics that live areas that dont have a church. These new churches are not built like the churches of the past with high cealings, huge stained glass windows and fancy statues because they cant aford them, the church isn't rich enough to have them.
ii. haveing cruxifcs (Jesus of a cross) is not idol worship it is a visual reminder of what he went through for us. If we are not to folow Jesus why did God say "this is my son with whome I am well pleased, listen to him."
iii. Im going to go a head and take it that by ceremony your talking about the mass. If that is the case them once again you are wrong, the blessing of the bread and wine turning them into the body and blood comes directly from the last supper. At every mass the priest blesses them in the same way that Jesus did.
iiii Every christian church baptises, not all do it when they are babies but they baptise. Jesus was baptised and he is the son of God, for us not to be baptised and to be folowers of him would to be saing we are better than him.


"Less than 100 people hate the catholic church, millions of people hate what they mistake the catholic church to be." You are in the millions that hate what you mistake the church to be.




I shall ask for his sorces, partly because im interested as to what they have to say.

Posted

WOW -- those guys responses are making me sick! if you look at his last response, it almost looks as if he is trying to convince & remind himself that he does not believe.

it kills me that there are people out there who don't believe in our awesome God. like... seriosuly? why can't people just surrender & accept Him...that He is real and better than Him. And though the "rules" may seem strict to them, it's because they don't see that God knows what is best for us and has the rules to protect us!

biggest example: pre-marital sex. i'm discerning a vocation to be a sister, right? and people are always liek ''you do know you'll never have sex, right?" and kids at school sleeping around and stuff...it's CRAZY! God says no to that to protect our hearts and to keep us from getting broken and hurt, ya know!? people just don't stop to think about it and be thankful that God has high expectations for us to keep us safe! it's because He LOVES us so much! We were talking about rules of the church & non-belivers and how to explain God to people... and be like "Well He 's your father! He loves you but He also has high expectaions! And sometimes our parents show us tough love so that we'll LEARN and GROW and become BETTER!"

oh man that ignorant ignorant guy has me allw orked up! i am totally going to pray for him!!!! and for you that the Lord works through you to knock some sense into him!!!!!

Posted

Oooooh, I can't think of much worse then trying to defend the church on myspace. You're much braver than I am. :(

heavenseeker
Posted

Ok im no longer going to post my responces to this guy because I dont need to prove to you guys what i believe but i will (at least for a little while) continue to post his arguements. If you guys and gals can think of something that I can tell this guy feel free to post it. I was asked to see if I could get from him his "reliable" sorces so if and when i get those they will also be up here.

any ways at this time i now post his newist responce

1. You obviously don't know jacks*** about catholic executive salaries. Lmao.

2. Wrong, idolatry is making any graven image to be used in worship in any way, and making any graven image of a god.

3. Nope, not talking about that. Well acually, they are not supposed to do it every mass, or even more than once a year, but oh well. There are many other catholic ceremonies, including the complex initiations of priests, bishops, archbishops, and the pope.. and baptism, etc. They do them in strict ways that are not set down in the bible, and many of the ceremonies aren't mentioned in the least in the bible.

4. It is impossible to truly baptise a baby. Baptism is a choice the individual makes. Baptising a baby is not only a disgusting violation of the babies rights, but it is against the bible as well. Noone is to be baptised except by their own choice, and acceptance of god.. I'm quite certain a baby can't do either.


And i've another one. You pray to saints, or 'through them', including 'virgin mary'. That is quite obviously against the bible, which says to only pray to god, through Jesus..



Like I said if anything pops out at you that you can give me extra insite about then tell me and I will happly try to work it into my next defence.

Posted

i can't decide if this guy is an athiest or a calvinist......

hey on the bright side, at least he sensored his swear word!!

heavenseeker
Posted

he is an athiest and i sensored that out

Pontifite 7 of 10
Posted

Is it just me or is this dude's makeing you laugh and feel really sorry for him at the same time?
Man this dude is lost.
He should say hi to Charlie and Kate for me. :lol_roll:
Ok not a time to joke.
HS props on talking to this dude. I can tell your really trying.
One problum with your preaching though This:
"At every mass the priest blesses them in the same way that Jesus did."
The priest actually concencrates the bread and wine turning them into The Body and Blood.


that is all

heavenseeker
Posted

[quote name='Pontifite 7 of 10' post='1039819' date='Aug 8 2006, 03:45 PM']
Is it just me or is this dude's makeing you laugh and feel really sorry for him at the same time?
Man this dude is lost.
He should say hi to Charlie and Kate for me. :lol_roll:
Ok not a time to joke.
HS props on talking to this dude. I can tell your really trying.
One problum with your preaching though This:
"At every mass the priest blesses them in the same way that Jesus did."
The priest actually concencrates the bread and wine turning them into The Body and Blood.
that is all
[/quote]


I guess that I did forget to say that part, but I don't think it would have made any diff.

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

[quote name='heavenseeker' post='1039425' date='Aug 7 2006, 09:23 PM']

And i've another one. You pray to saints, or 'through them', including 'virgin mary'. That is quite obviously against the bible, which says to only pray to god, through Jesus.. [/quote]

Okay, one thing here: Jesus is God. We pray to Him, not through Him. What's wrong with asking a friend to pray for you? He obviously seems to know some of the Bible... Even St. Paul asks his fellow Christians to imitate him as he imitates Christ... (I believe it is in one of his letters... Corinthians/Thessalonians maybe?) I'm just kinda spurting thoughts here with out much connection, sorry.

Next time you should tell him to ask the next Cardinal he sees how much he makes... What priests' own, they share with the community they are part of, either it be the parish community or a religious community.

Another thing, he is obviously an sola scriptura atheist/whatever he is... The 'ceremonies' he speaks of were all in practice... Holy Orders is seen where the apostle lay their hands to ordain other men to their ministry. ALL of our sacraments are very much Scriptural. I'm not good with quoting Bible verses for these all, but this is usually the point you need phatcatholic to lend a hand ;)

I could go on some more with the little I know, but I need to get to bed very soon. God bless you abundantly in your mission. May the Holy Spirit give you the wisdom you need and that he may soften some hearts for you ;)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...