Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Intriguing arguments against women's ordination


Recommended Posts

Posted

I ran across this argument on [url="http://www.mirrorofjustice.com"]Mirror of Justice[/url] today:
[quote]The gist of the argument is that due to Original Sin, men are plagued with a reluctance to respect the equality of women; and, women are plagued with a tendency to expect their men to satisfy all their needs. As a result, men tend to oppress women and women tend to take it--just as described in Genesis. Christ opposes these tendencies by teaching men that love requires self-sacrificial love even to the point of death and by teaching women that only Christ is able to satisfy the deepest longings of their heart. If Christ had been a woman, her death on the Cross would have sent men the message that self-sacrificial love is a "woman's thing." It would not have altered the tendency to regard women as a resource to be managed and controlled. (Watch John Wayne's McClintock for an illustration of this prejudice.) And if Christ had been a women, women would never have known that men could love them without subordinating them and that God is the one who meets their desires for all-consuming love. For these reasons, the Gender Mission of Christ requires Christ to be a man. I then extrapolate this argument to give support to the Roman Catholic Church's decision not to ordain women priests in its Latin rite.
But since I've been warned by Lisa not to be lengthy, I can only invite those who cannot access the Godspy article or the Logos article to contemplate the mystery of an institution that sees the refusal to ordain women as a way to support sexual equality. If this seems oxymoronic, then it is because we are making various assumptions that make it so, e.g., the assumption that unless an institution refuses to distinguish between male and female gender roles, it is committed to sexual inequality. If we prescind from these assumptions, the possibility that the refusal to ordain women is prophetic becomes pressing. It may well be the case that in a few decades, the only institution that distinguishes between the work of men and women will be the Roman Catholic Church. [/quote]

homeschoolmom
Posted
:priest: :love:
That's very interesting. Good point.
Posted

She's a philosophy prof at St. Thomas ... there are definitely things I'm looking forward to about being in an academic environment ...

Posted

[quote]the Roman Catholic Church's decision not to ordain women priests in its Latin rite. [/quote]

bad wording, this "decision" is a doctrine binding on all sui juris churches within the Catholic Church.

other than that, interesting point.

Posted

[url="http://www.mirrorofjustice.com/mirrorofjustice/2006/08/more_from_lemmo_1.html"]Another post from the same woman ...[/url]
[quote]It's important to realize that the bridegroom/bride analogy as it pertains to Christ and the Church also pertains to Christ and the people of God. As such, the analogy teaches that every human being is to relate to Christ as to the bridegroom. Moreover, since Christ as the bridegroom signifies sacrificial love on the Cross and the Church as bride signifies responsive love, it is the feminine paradigm that images how every human being is to correctly relate to Christ, i.e., feminine responsiveness is the properly human response to God. Our responsiveness to Christ transforms us, especially through the Eucharist, into His image. Thus, women as well as men are called to image Christ.
Given this, it remains puzzling that the Catholic Church, in all her rites, has decided to restrict priestly ordination to heterosexual men. By so doing, the Church invites us to mediatate on heterosexuality: why is heterosexuality so important? Why did God create the human race as divided into males and females?
John Paul II in his Catechism on Genesis teaches that human beings image God best in moments of heterosexual, spousal union; because then we best image the Trinity. Could it thus be that part of the reason why the Church restricts priestly ordination to heterosexual men is to call attention to heterosexuality and the radical incompleteness of masculinity without femininity as well as the incompleteness of femininity without masculinity? Such radical incompleteness identifies the indispensability of both sexes as well as the need for each sex to relate to the other through equally reciprocated acts of self-giving love. Could it be that by restricting priestly ordination to heterosexual men, while also identifying ordained priests to be images of Christ, the Church is seeking to teach men that their masculinity achieves its highest fulfillment in a self-sacrificial love unafraid to embrace the Cross for the good of others? Could it be that men especially need this message?[/quote]

Posted

[quote]If Christ had been a woman, her death on the Cross would have sent men the message that self-sacrificial love is a "woman's thing." It would not have altered the tendency to regard women as a resource to be managed and controlled. (Watch John Wayne's McClintock for an illustration of this prejudice.) And if Christ had been a women, women would never have known that men could love them without subordinating them and that God is the one who meets their desires for all-consuming love.[/quote]

Well, guess what he was a guy and he was a guy for a reason. Anyone can play the Bible around with if's and but's to make excuses. Maybe, I could quote her in the book of 1 Timothy where it states that a woman should not hold a position over man. She is just trying bounce selected topics from the bible off of egalitarianism, so as to state that things would be better for women if Jesus was a woman.

If the church is sexist, then they have been sexist for over 2000 years. And 2000 years of church fathers stating that the role of women is important, be that if your a nun or not. But, importance doesnt mean that they can be pastors, or priests. In this day in age sexual inequality is so extreme that you cant cough on your front pourch as a lady walks by without being investigated for sexual harassment.

Posted

[quote name='Convert4888' post='1044449' date='Aug 16 2006, 09:08 AM']
Well, guess what he was a guy and he was a guy for a reason. Anyone can play the Bible around with if's and but's to make excuses. Maybe, I could quote her in the book of 1 Timothy where it states that a woman should not hold a position over man. She is just trying bounce selected topics from the bible off of egalitarianism, so as to state that things would be better for women if Jesus was a woman.

If the church is sexist, then they have been sexist for over 2000 years. And 2000 years of church fathers stating that the role of women is important, be that if your a nun or not. But, importance doesnt mean that they can be pastors, or priests. In this day in age sexual inequality is so extreme that you cant cough on your front pourch as a lady walks by without being investigated for sexual harassment.
[/quote]


Ummm, you might want to read that quote again, it is supporting a male-only priesthood... :detective:

She's talking about how it would never have worked out the right way if Jesus was a woman, not the other way around.

Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1044464' date='Aug 16 2006, 09:53 AM']
Ummm, you might want to read that quote again, it is supporting a male-only priesthood... :detective:

She's talking about how it would never have worked out the right way if Jesus was a woman, not the other way around.
[/quote]
Yeah. What she said.

Posted
:huh:












Awesome argument, though. That perspective really destroys the accusation that the Church is anti-women. :twothumbsup:
  • 6 months later...
Posted

wow this is so great!! i was just talking to someone about this. yay God :)

Posted

biggest problem when explaining this is that the majority of the protestant community does not see a difference in men and women. To speak of them as difference is viewed as sexist. That is the problem.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...