Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Mary present at every Mass


Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted

Okay, I am going out on a limb here so I want someone to give me a sanity check. I am off base. I've been debating over email the following statement from an anti-catholic website with the author, Roger Oakland:

[url="http://www.understandthetimes.org/commentary/c18.shtml"]http://www.understandthetimes.org/commentary/c18.shtml[/url]

"Now stop for a moment and think about what the head of the Catholic Church endorsed. It is an invitation for the whole church to acknowledge the "presence of Mary" on the altar during mass. This is a declaration of paramount importance.

Of course such a view is foreign to the scriptures. But according to Catholic tradition, dogma is just as important as the Bible when it comes to faith. However, my Bible says faith comes by hearing the word - that is God's Word, not the pope's. And the word of God is clear – Mary is not omnipresent. "

His arguements come from JP II's encyclical on the Eucharist.

[url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/special_features/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_20030417_ecclesia_eucharistia_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/special_...aristia_en.html[/url]

Especially chapter 6 where Mary is brought in.

Note he adds the words "on the altar". They are nowhere found in the document or anywhere in Catholic teaching. That is the context of my discussion.

[b]Now in his last email he says:[/b]

Gerald,

If you will please give me an explanation why Zenit News Agency from Rome (a Roman Catholic source) would write an article on April 17, 2003 and state:

Therefore, the Pontiff concludes, "Mary is present, with the Church and as the Mother of the Church, at each of our celebrations of the Eucharist."
[url="http://www.zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=34405"]http://www.zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=34405[/url]

I realize, as you have already stated, that you say Roman Catholics do not accept that "Mary" is "present" at the Eucharistic celebration.

If you would have Zenit, clarify that "present" does not mean "present" but instead means that she is NOT PRESENT then we can discuss this further.

Other wise there is no need to send e-mails back and forth and discuss this any further. I will wait for the response from Zenit.

Blessings, in the name of Jesus,
Roger Oakland

[b]
To which I respond:[/b]



I never said that Mary is not present at the Eucharistic Celebration. The Eucharistic celebration is the Mass. I am present at the Eucharistic celebration every time I attend Mass. Does that mean I am on the altar? No. It is ridiculous to say so. You get an "understanding" in you mind based on what you think and then add the words "on the altar" to what was said.

Now I will answer what it means that Mary is present at each Eucharistic celebration. You see this as omnipresence. I do not. First of all heaven is not a place in space. For if it was space, i.e. the universe would have to have existed throughout eternity. But the physical realm is created. The spiritual is not. So we are speaking of two different realms when we speak of those in heaven and those on earth. As I said before Scott Hahn parrellels the Mass with the book of revelations. We see in the Mass the prayes in revelations and in scipture, i.e. the Holy, Holy, Holy, and the Gloria (Glory to God in the Highest". There is the opening of the scrolls and the wedding supper of the lamb which correspond to our liturgy of the word where the scriptures are read and expounded, and the liturgy of the Eucharist, the wedding supper of the lamb. The point of it is that the Mass in some sense is a portal in to the heavenly realm. Hope that doesn't offend you to baddly.

The Mass is the heavenly liturgy spoken of in Acts 5 and 8. We are participants in that liturgy which is made present to us through the prescence of Christ in the Eucharist. In some sense this heavenly liturgy can be veiwed as the center of an auditorium upon which is the throne of God and all the masses in the world are about this auditorium, the center of which is the throne of God. Thus Mary's prescence is not an omniprescence but a prescence by her position in the heavenly court. She is not on the altar but at the right hand of the King, Jesus Christ (see psalm 49).

I know this is over your head and that is why you don't understand Catholicism and so insert whatever you feel like (on the altar) to Catholic teaching. But this is the way the Pope sees it when he says that Mary is present at each Mass.

[/b]

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

If I were to try to argue this point via Holy Scripture, I would look to the Letter of Paul to the Hebrews, specifically with regards to the fact that he argues that Christ is the Eternal Priest, offering Himself as the perfect offering in Heaven. Now at this Heavenly Sacrifice, all the angels and Saints are present (c.f. Revelations). Holy Mass is a participation in this heavenly sacrifice of Christ. As such, Mary, and indeed all of Heaven, is present at the Mass, bowing before the Lord and Savior of the Universe, humbly singing the Sanctus before the Lamb. This does not mean that Mary, the Saints, and the Angels are "omnipresent" but rather, it means that you and I are mystically united to Heaven, where they really are, through the Mass.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

That helps. Thanks.

Does what I have said make sense though?

Edited by thessalonian
Mateo el Feo
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1039632' date='Aug 8 2006, 09:31 AM']Thus Mary's prescence is not an omniprescence but a prescence by her position in the heavenly court. She is not on the altar but at the right hand of the King, Jesus Christ (see psalm 49)[/quote]This is the first thing I thought of. The celebration of the Mass unites those in heaven (Church Triumphant) and earth (Church Militant). It is only natural that Mary, as the Queen of heaven, be present.

I think that he is stretching things a bit with his interpretation of the text.

franciscanheart
Posted

I get irritated when I see people honing in on MARY. All the angels and saints (big S and little s) are present at each and every Mass. It is as you have said, a kind of portal to the heavenly kingdom. We celebrate with all of God's kingdom at each and every Mass. So yes, Mary is there and so are Sts Christopher and Thomas, Matthew and Mark, Luke and John, Agatha, Martha, Lucy, Sebastian, Benedict, Peter, Dominic, ... ((you get my point))

I think you responded well.

phatcatholic
Posted

thess,

i can't really say it better than jeff just did. besides that, i would recommend taking out a few jabs so that your response will be better received. i also made a few spelling and grammar changes:


[quote name='thessalonian' post='1039632' date='Aug 8 2006, 08:31 AM']I never said that Mary is not present at the Eucharistic Celebration. The Eucharistic celebration is the Mass. I am present at the Eucharistic celebration every time I attend Mass. Does that mean I am on the altar? No. It is ridiculous to say so. [s]You get an "understanding" in you mind based on what you think and then add the words "on the altar" to what was said[/s].

Now I will answer what it means that Mary is present at each Eucharistic celebration. You see this as omnipresence. I do not. First of all heaven is not a place in space. For if it was space, i.e. the universe would have to have existed throughout eternity. But the physical realm is created. The spiritual is not. So we are speaking of two different realms when we speak of those in heaven and those on earth. As I said before Scott Hahn parrellels the Mass with the book of revelations. We see in the Mass the praye[b][color="#FF0000"]r[/color][/b]s in [color="#FF0000"][b]the book of[/b][/color] revelation[s]s[/s] and in scipture, i.e. the Holy, Holy, Holy, and the Gloria (Glory to God in the Highest". There is the opening of the scrolls and the wedding supper of the lamb which correspond to our liturgy of the word where the scriptures are read and expounded, and the liturgy of the Eucharist, the wedding supper of the lamb. The point of it is that the Mass in some sense is a portal into the heavenly realm. Hope that doesn't offend you to[b][color="#FF0000"]o[/color][/b] bad[s]d[/s]ly.

The Mass is the heavenly liturgy spoken of in Acts 5 and 8. We are participants in that liturgy which is made present to us through the prescence of Christ in the Eucharist. In some sense this heavenly liturgy can be veiwed as the center of an auditorium upon which is the throne of God and all the masses in the world are about this auditorium, the center of which is the throne of God. Thus Mary's prescence is not an omniprescence but a prescence by her position in the heavenly court. She is not on the altar but at the right hand of the King, Jesus Christ (see psalm 49).

[s]I know this is over your head and that is why you don't understand Catholicism and so insert whatever you feel like (on the altar) to Catholic teaching. But[/s] [b][color="#FF0000"]T[/color][/b]his is the way the Pope sees it when he says that Mary is present at each Mass.[/quote]

also, you may want to avoid the conversation at the beginning of your response about heaven as a place that takes up space. in many ways, its a mystery. afterall, it can hardly be located anywhere, but at the same time, the bodies of mary and jesus are present there so there must be at least some sense in which it is in fact a place.

anyway, i hope that helps

pax christi,
phatcatholic

franciscanheart
Posted

i just realized that i said what jeff said only in a sort of ignorant-sounding way. whoops. :blush:

thessalonian
Posted

Thx folks. I've incorporated all your suggestions. Phat I always run emails through spell checker. But thx. ;)

Guest JeffCR07
Posted (edited)

[quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1039959' date='Aug 8 2006, 07:21 PM']
i just realized that i said what jeff said only in a sort of ignorant-sounding way. whoops. :blush:
[/quote]

I like the way you said it better, you included St. Dominic in your response ;) :D:

And phat's post is really important as well. Its often very easy to turn derogatory towards those who criticise us, but the only way souls will be converted is through charity and love. So by all means, show them why they are wrong, and do so clearly, succinctly, and definitively, but never leave aside love and compassion when you do it.

Edited by JeffCR07
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I think a lot of the misunderstanding comes from our differing views of worship. Protestants (forgive my generalizing) tend to see worship as our offering back to God-- something of us. Catholics, on the other hand, view Mass as God's great gift to us: the celebration and remembrance of Christ's self-donation of Himself on the Cross in the Eucharistic Sacrifice.

We're looking at things from two different directions. Protestants are on earth looking up ("man comes to meet God"), and Catholics are mystically united to Heaven during the Liturgy by the great grace and mercy of God (i.e., "God comes to meet man"). The Protestant view isn't necessarily bad, it's just a radically different perspective (which also lacks the fullness of worship--the Eucharist).

The Saints in Heaven (especially our Blessed Mother) are present at each and every Mass simply because the Mass is not an isolated act of worship, but one that is done in union with the entire Church (/Body of Christ)-- and Jeff and Hughey's post captured this aspect well, I think.

Posted

I read the original post and started to think about it too and got bit confused. I mean with the thing as if Our Mother would be omnipresent but yet she [i]is[/i] at the Mass. I know she was there today ;) But thanks for clearing it out! Debates sometimes get me really tangled. ^_^ I had a confusing debate with an unbeliever few days ago, so now it's relieving to hear apologetics!

Posted

I recently read a talk given by the late Cardinal O'Connor in which he mentioned how, in a way, Mary is present in the Eucharist. That really threw me for a loop for awhile, but it was explained to me that since in Heaven, one is intimately in union with Christ. Mary as Queen of Heaven would, of course, be intimately united with Jesus, so that Christ's presence in the Eucharist would mean Mary (and all the saints) would be present in a way as well.

thessalonian
Posted

Oh my. I just recieved a rather nasty email from the raido host (who I copied on my email to her guest) who had Mr. Oakland on, telling me not to email her guests with rants about Catholicism and how blind I was. Not sure where she thinks she has the authority to prevent me from writing to publically available emails.

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1043988' date='Aug 15 2006, 07:37 AM']
Oh my. I just recieved a rather nasty email from the raido host (who I copied on my email to her guest) who had Mr. Oakland on, telling me not to email her guests with rants about Catholicism and how blind I was. Not sure where she thinks she has the authority to prevent me from writing to publically available emails.
[/quote]
eek :blink:

Posted (edited)

[quote]Oh my. I just recieved a rather nasty email from the raido host (who I copied on my email to her guest) who had Mr. Oakland on, telling me not to email her guests with rants about Catholicism and how blind I was. Not sure where she thinks she has the authority to prevent me from writing to publically available emails.
[/quote]

Sounds to me like some of that good ol' Christian Vengance. The kind of vengance that Christ askes us not to have with each other, but people do it anyway.

Plus, Sounds to me like she's afraid of a small debate if she harassing you like that. (If you consider it harassment.)

Edited by Convert4888

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...