Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

priests are priests because God called them to be, who are we to say because their faith is weak in a certain area that they shouldn't respond to that call?  if you can honestly say that you don't struggle with a single one of the church's teachings you either don't know the church very well, don't know yourself very well, or should definitely teach us all your secrets...

I don't think anyone said that this priest's faith is weak.

What was observed is that he appeared publicly defying a statement issued by the National Catholic Conference of Bishops. In other words, he publicly acted in a disobedient manner, which brings scandal to the Church, and gives encouragement to others with dissenting viewpoints.

Yes, we could just leave it alone because the man who made these statements is a priest, but the saints wouldn't have. Priests are human; they err. This priest erred publicly and therefore he has invited commentary on it.

Is it truly virtuous to be silent when Holy Mother Church is being misrepresented publicly? St. Catherine of Siena deliberately told popes, queens and kings how to behave....

Priests deserve our respect by virtue of their Sacrament of Holy Orders.

If one is being derelict in his duties to the Church, the Faithful needn't allow it to go unchallenged. (That's not a call to jump on the bandwagon every time a priest makes a mistake, but this is rather grave.)

I don't wanna sound prideful here, I've struggled with Church teachings in the past. But rather than run to my nearest tv or radio station, I ran to the confessional or my pastor.

Teach us your secrets? It's called Trustful Surrender to Divine Providence. His Church cannot err; we can. It's just that simple.

Pax Christi. <><

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

amen anna amen!!

ryanmeyersmusic
Posted

i'm not saying that the thing to do is sit and be silent, but i am saying that laization of a priest isn't something that we have any say in, and for good reason. there was a time in history when the church just excommunicated anyone who said anything contrary to the teaching, rather than convincing them of the truth (unless you consider torture and such a method of convincing). i hate to see us revert back to that mentality of "if you can't agree, get the heck out of here" our job is to pray for this priest, and if we're in situation where it's possible to rebuke him lovingly. not to call out for his "defrocking" on a message board.

God Conquers
Posted

Never, ever speak badly about a Priest, imagine how tough it is in our day and age. We do not need more detractors from that glorious vocation because we can't keep our mouths shut and not gossip about our priests. If they've done something bad, well they muct answer to that. But don't talk around, it just makes it worse.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Sorry, but priests and bishops are not above reproach or criticism. We are called to judge actions, God determines final destinations.

If a priest is publically sinning in anyway, he can and should be called to account. We are our brothers' keepers, even if they have a roman collar around their neck.

Posted

I don't think anyone said that this priest's faith is weak.

What was observed is that he appeared publicly defying a statement issued by the National Catholic Conference of Bishops.  In other words, he publicly acted in a disobedient manner, which brings scandal to the Church, and gives encouragement to others with dissenting viewpoints.

Yes, we could just leave it alone because the man who made these statements is a priest, but the saints wouldn't have.  Priests are human; they err.  This priest erred publicly and therefore he has invited commentary on it.

Is it truly virtuous to be silent when Holy Mother Church is being misrepresented publicly? St. Catherine of Siena deliberately told popes, queens and kings how to behave....

Priests deserve our respect by virtue of their Sacrament of Holy Orders. 

If one is being derelict in his duties to the Church, the Faithful needn't allow it to go unchallenged.  (That's not a call to jump on the bandwagon every time a priest makes a mistake, but this is rather grave.)

I don't wanna sound prideful here, I've struggled with Church teachings in the past.  But rather than run to my nearest tv or radio station, I ran to the confessional or my pastor. 

Teach us your secrets?  It's called Trustful Surrender to Divine Providence.  His Church cannot err; we can.  It's just that simple.

Pax Christi. <><

Like ryanmeyersmusic said, we are not in the position to demand that a Priest be reduced to the lay state. Find me one Saint who ever did anything remotely close to that.

Also, statments of the USCCB are far from binding. Do you agree with their statement on the Passion? (Which accuses it of being Anti-Semetic, and not of Catholic thinking).

What the Priest did do was defy a teaching of the Sacred Magesterium. Yes he was wrong (if he even did as what was said). llrddvl@stpius did after all ONLY CATCH the end of the show. Maybe what was said was taken out of context. Don't you think since we don't have ALL OF THE FACTS we should give the Priest the benefit of the doubt? The media does have ways of manipulating words, and making one thing look another.

If you have a problem with something a Priest did, (a Priest you do not know), it is not your job to go around slandering him. You should report it to his Bishop, if that gets no where, go to the Papal Nuncio, if that goes no where go to the Congregation for the Clergy. You are not in the position to pass judgement on the Priest, you are not in the position to call for him to be removed from his priestly ministry (unless you join liberal Voice of the Faithful of course :P ). And that is all that has been going on in this thread. What you should be doing is reinforcing Catholic teaching on homosexuality amoung those who watched the show. Faith, Prudence, Humility, and Charity are your best guides in this case.

Posted

Sodomy laws are silly and un-enforceable. perhaps I missed something, but i didn't see the openly gay part. is he keeping his vows?
Now that sodomy laws have been overturned, the law of the land is that what goes on behind closed doors is protected by the 'right of privacy.' What is there now to stop prostitution, or incest between consenting adults? Also, now we are one step closer to allowing sex with minors or minors having sex with each other.

Yes, the government should not be coming into our bedrooms and it is silly to think that a law that would require that is enforceable. If the sodomy laws were just about homosexuality, it would be silly. That issue can and should be dealt with in other ways.

I was told to say three hail marys whene'er i saw a priest mis-behave and keep my mouth closed. kinda ol' fashioned, but i like it.

That sounds like good advice. I'll take it.

However, I do wonder sometimes why more people aren't excommunicated. Not for saying an errant thing here and there, but when they are consistently claiming to be the voice of the Church and they preach in error, I would like to hear something official from the Church condemning that person's views. Attach that person's name to it, and the media is more likely to pick up on it. They are out to make money, which means they will say what the people want to hear. "Senator So-and-So Excommunicated." "Father Disident Disciplined by Rome."

Also, statements of the USCCB are far from binding. Do you agree with their statement on the Passion? (Which accuses it of being Anti-Semitic, and not of Catholic thinking).

No, in the strict sense, they are not binding. But the Bishops are the shepherds of their flock and the ordinary magisterium. We should be especially mindful of what they have to say. I think that the USCCB with regards to The Passion was not saying that it IS anti-semitic, but that it could arouse anti-semitism. That I think is certainly true. This movie could very well be more fuel for those who are already bent that way. Nevertheless, I believe it is a worthwhile endeavor and should be required viewing for all Christians. We, for our part, should be aware of the possible anti-semitism that may arise from it and respond accordingly.

Posted

Like I said, I was hoping that ABC News would update their website once the show was over but they still haven't. I am reserving judgment until I can read/watch the whole show on whether or not the priest is totally out of line.

Posted

Two things to further add heat and not much light to the conversation:

1. Even if it sounded like he was defying the teaching of the church, did they edit what he said? I have been interviewed before and with careful editing you can twist the words of even the most devout catholic.

2. Given #1 above any call for laicization is incredibly premature, the process is extremely complex and the indiviual is given numerous occasions to retract and reform what he has taught that is in violation of church teaching. We should do the same and give this priest every benefit of the doubt.

3. Hyper, I like your idea of the three hail mary's

Posted

St. Catherine of Siena, not laity, but also not clergy, told the Pope (!) to go back to Rome. We are certainly in a position to correct priests. They are not above our reproach any more than any other Catholic.

Now, I believe in being careful about pronouncing judgment. I do not believe in remaining silent about priests by virtue of their office. Nor bishops, for that matter.

I cannot imagine laicizing a priest for one such occurence. The Church typically acts carefully in these situations. Everyone strays at some point, and instant and extremely predjudicial actions are not the Church's modus operandi.

Good Friday
Posted

Let me rephrase.

IF indeed this priest is speaking against Church teaching, then he should be laicized. And yes, I do think he should be laicized, just like I think any layman speaking against Church teaching should be excommunicated if they refuse to hear what the Church is saying. It is one thing to struggle with the Church's teaching on some matter or another. I struggle with one particular teaching every day of my life. It is quite another to publically promote dissent against that teaching. This is uncalled for, especially from a priest. It causes major scandal, for Pete's sake. How many Catholics are unclear on what the Church teaches because many of the priests have abandoned Church teaching?

I find it interesting that some of the same people in this thread calling for us to stop judging priests also called him a "Catholic," with quotation marks, implying that he is not really Catholic. All I did was call for his laicization, y'all passed judgement on his faith.

hyperdulia again
Posted

The Texas Sodomy law was just about Homosexuality Luke. It out-lawed oral and anal sex between members of the same sex, but not for opposite sex relationships. Even Clarence Thomas who voted to up-hold sodomy laws called the law in Texas "uncommonly stupid" or something to that effect. If I fall off of the Chaste homosexual wagon tonight I don't need to go to jail for it.

ryanmeyersmusic
Posted

what i meant by what i said is that talking about someone on a message board like this is at best slander and gossip. it's not doing anything for the Church, or that particular believer. if you were to approach that person and correct them, or even approach their pastor or bishop to let them know about it, that would be understandable. there's no way to justify making judging comments about someone to a bunch of people that don't even know them (or even of them). i didn't mean priests were above reproach, but i did mean that EVERYONE should be protected from slander.

Posted

St. Catherine of Siena, not laity, but also not clergy, told the Pope (!) to go back to Rome. We are certainly in a position to correct priests. They are not above our reproach any more than any other Catholic.

Now, I believe in being careful about pronouncing judgment. I do not believe in remaining silent about priests by virtue of their office. Nor bishops, for that matter.

I cannot imagine laicizing a priest for one such occurence. The Church typically acts carefully in these situations. Everyone strays at some point, and instant and extremely predjudicial actions are not the Church's modus operandi.

Correcting a Priest is one thing, calling for him to removed from the clergy is something different. A decision ultimately left up to the POPE!

Posted

Firstly,

We don't even know the identity of this priest...our comments are not so much directed against this person, (at least mine aren't) but towards anyone (with or without roman collar) who publicly speaks of the Catholic Church in an unsavory manner.

Earlier this year, the television showed footage of a woman clobbering her little two year old in a Walmart parking lot. Subsequently, a (wo)man-hunt for the mother took place, her child was put in foster care, and she was charged with child abuse. If someone said, "anyone who does that needs to receive XYZ punishment," would you consider that slander or gossip?

We have NO WAY of reaching the multitudes of people who watched that program. The damage that's been done is done, and there is nothing that we can do at all, except vent a little.

True, we have no authority to censure, issue an order of silence, or laicize a priest. All that authority belongs to the Church hierarchy. So, in essence, no harm done. (imho)

I will add, however, that I am sick of dissenting priests being put in the spotlight; THAT gives our Church and our clergy a bigger black eye than us discussing (and sharing our outrage at) such an incident amongst ourselves.

Pax Christi. <><

Posted

Here's the article that ABC News wrote up on their Nightline website. But it doesn't have a video of the actual interview. And it doesn't have anywhere in there where he was disagreeing with the Church's teaching (which is the only part I saw). So judge for yourself.

Print Interview

Jake Huether
Posted

They don't really distinguish between "gay" and "homosexual". To me, "gay" refers more to someone who is living an actively gay life. Whereas "homosexual" tends to refer more to simply the orientation.

If this priest is homosexual, yet living a chaste life, then it is a whole entirely different issue. The fact that he managed to divide a church over his statements leads me to believe that he was supporting an ACTIVELY gay life, which indeed is against Church teachings.

Posted

for this priest:

In theNameoftheFatherandtheSonandtheHolySpirit

Our Father who art in Heaven, Hallowed be thy name. Thy Kingdom come, thy will be done, on earth as it is in Heaven. Give us this day our daily bread and forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us. Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil AMEN

Hail Mary, full of grace, the LORD is with thee, blessed art thou amongst women and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners, now and at the hour of our death. AMEN

Hail Mary full of grace, the LORD is with thee. Blessed art thou amongst women and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death AMEN.

Hail Mary, full of grace, the LORD is with thee. Blessed art thou amongs women, and blessed is the fruit of the womb, JESUS. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death AMEN.

Glory be to the FatherandtotheSonandtotheHolySpirt. As it was in the begining is now and ever shall be. World without end AMEN.

Oh my Jesus, forgive us our sins, save us from the fires of hell. Lead all souls to heaven, especially those in most need of thy mercy.

Oh God, some of your priests have wandered from the path of truth, LORD, help them back to the one truth in union with the Holy Father as Christ is in union with thee. Lord, help those who struggle with same sex attraction. They need strength and guidance. Through Jesus Christ we pray

Mary, watch over all priests

All saints, be their examples

may our priests serve God with unwaivering virtue and wisdom

In theNameoftheFatherandtheSonandtheHolySpirit, AMEN

Posted

I have a problem with the fact that he says he is 'gay'. There is distinction between Homosexual and Gay in my opinion. Gay means you lead an active homosexual lifestyle with no regard for Holy Mother Church or God. Homosexual means you have a same sex attraction, but do not immerse yourself in the 'lifestyle' and believe it is disorder and a cross to bear for Christ. From what I read, this Priest does not believe it is a disorder or a cross, since he said it was a 'gift'. The was some of the parishoners said he would always talk about also makes me wonder.

If I was his Bishop, I would have asked him to recant, and affirm the Church's teaching. Or, if he did mean what I said, then to clarify and never speak of it again from the pulpit (certainly is not the place). If he refused, then he would have been suspended, and then as Bishop I would go from there. I can't be in his mind so anything beyond that would require lots of prayers, lots of consultation with Roman and other American authorities, and an open and honest meeting with the Priest in question.

I am not a Bishop however, and I am glad that I am not his Bishop because this would be something difficult to deal with.

Pray for this Priest, he needs prayers. As do all Priests, but certainly the ones who seem to be straying from the faith.

Thanks for bringing the article up.

Posted

I totaly agree Credo.... like always. :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...