Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Circle_Master
Posted

i like it. that's a rather smart baptist too (i've seen him speaking at several different large conventions - currently the shepherds conference with John MacArthur and R.C.Sproul)

Posted

Circle, may I ask, how did you find out about phatmass.com?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

A Baptist perspective on Tolkien

Very interesting

Tolkein

Of course, he left out what Tolkien said was the most important part of his life- recieving the daily Eucharist at Mass, or the fact that when Tolkien was editing he set out to make it a consciously Catholic story.

Posted

Shhh, C-Mom, don't say it too loud . . . they might notice and decide they don't like it. It just might be the source of conversion for many many souls.

Circle_Master
Posted

Circle, may I ask, how did you find out about phatmass.com?

musturde visited a board I participated on sometimes and told me to bring it to phatmass and I would be destroyed and smacked down. I decided to visit, and now I am here.

PyroPenguinX07
Posted

I read an article in the St. Anthony Messenger about the Lord of the rings but that was about the catholic point of view

Posted

Of course, he left out what Tolkien said was the most important part of his life- recieving the daily Eucharist at Mass, or the fact that when Tolkien was editing he set out to make it a consciously Catholic story.

Ditto Cmom. On the extended versions of the DVD's there are commentators on Tolkien and his works, especially with comments on his friendships with other writers, such as CS Lewis. but I haven't finished watching yet.....I should go watch it now..... :rolling:

I liked St. Anthony's messengers article......as well as EWTN's. ^_^

Circle_Master
Posted

Ditto Cmom. On the extended versions of the DVD's there are commentators on Tolkien and his works, especially with comments on his friendships with other writers, such as CS Lewis. but I haven't finished watching yet.....I should go watch it now..... :rolling:

I liked St. Anthony's messengers article......as well as EWTN's. ^_^

the commentary's are very interesting. i watched through all of them and was unhappy when they ended

Posted

the commentary's are very interesting. i watched through all of them and was unhappy when they ended

:sadder: me too.......

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Of course, he left out what Tolkien said was the most important part of his life- recieving the daily Eucharist at Mass, or the fact that when Tolkien was editing he set out to make it a consciously Catholic story.

I wanna be like Tolkien if I ever grow up. :)

Posted

The review was quite good. I was glad that they mentioned that he was a devout Catholic, because Tolkien himself admitted that he could not separate his Catholicism from his writings.

Posted

I just saw The Return of the King last night. It's an incredible film. I haven't read the books yet - has the director done justice to them do you think? He has reportedly insisted that he stick to the story as closely as possible. It was very interesting to hear people discussing the film as they left the cinema. I thought it was impossible not to see the influence of Christianity in it!

Circle_Master
Posted

Peter Jackson has done a very good job with accuracy to the books. A few things were changed - but it follows the book storyline for 95% of it.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Circle what did you think about his decision to leave out the scourging of the shire?(ignoer the time constraints)

cmotherofpirl
Posted

musturde visited a board I participated on sometimes and told me to bring it to phatmass and I would be destroyed and smacked down. I decided to visit, and now I am here.

I think it was a good review, it just struck me as funny that they leave stuff like that out.

CatholicAndFanatical
Posted

This Saturday were having another Frasatti Society meeting, our special guest is Joseph Pearce, he is going to talk about Tolkien and Jackson. Should be pretty interesting to hear.

I havent seen the Lord of the Rings yet, in fact I havent seen any of them. When it first came out I viewed it like another Harry Potter junk, but recently heard it was a Catholic view film, now my interest is peaked and I need to rent the first parts, then head to the movies to see the current one. One saturday I'll go rent em and spent 6 hours watching them.

CatholicAndFanatical

Circle_Master
Posted (edited)

Circle what did you think about his decision to leave out the scourging of the shire?(ignoer the time constraints)

I was looking forward to that through the entire movie :(. So you can understand I was disappointed. I wanted to see some hobbits in action!

Edited by Circle_Master
Circle_Master
Posted

One saturday I'll go rent em and spent 6 hours watching them.

6?

The first is around 3.5 hours, the second around 3.5, the third around 3.5

You'll have around 10 hours of movies if you watch all the Lord of the Rings ones. Haha

cmotherofpirl
Posted

and if you watch all the extra stuff. plan on sitting still for the ENTIRE weekend.

Frodo lives!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...