at0m1c Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 In the comic series Y: The Last Man by Vertigo Comics, all the males in the world are wiped out by a plague. Let's say this happens in the real world. How does Apostolic Succession continue, and can women become priests?
Resurrexi Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 Women can never become priests. It's dogma. Until the end of the world there will always be Apostolic Succession. That is also dogma.
morostheos Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 Well, if all the men in the world died, I suppose the end of the human race in general wouldn't be too far off either. Besides being practically nearly impossible, it would not change whether or not women can be priests. It's not just that they aren't allowed, it's that women are physically incapable of being priests just as a man cannot bear children.
journeyman Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 George Weigel touches on this (not the death of all men) in his book The Truth of Catholicism. Quoting Francis Cardinal George of Chicago, Weigel posits that the Catholic priest is not just a "job description," a set of functions (which any bureaucracy/codifed system certainly could encourage), but serves as a sacramental image, an icon.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted August 14, 2006 Posted August 14, 2006 Allow me to retort with another questions, while simultaneously plagiarizing from a satire that I thought was histerical: If all the men and ducks were wiped out by a plague, could women become ducks?
Theoketos Posted August 14, 2006 Posted August 14, 2006 [quote name='JeffCR07' post='1043608' date='Aug 14 2006, 11:22 AM'] Allow me to retort with another questions, while simultaneously plagiarizing from a satire that I thought was histerical: If all the men and ducks were wiped out by a plague, could women become ducks? [/quote] Best question ever.
thessalonian Posted August 14, 2006 Posted August 14, 2006 Did you know that a duck can be used to see if someone is a witch.
cmotherofpirl Posted August 15, 2006 Posted August 15, 2006 If all men in the world would die, why would women want to go on living? Who would take out the garbage, wash the car??
Sojourner Posted August 15, 2006 Posted August 15, 2006 Hey, guys are good for more than just taking out garbage and washing cars. Someone also needs to open jars and get things off the top shelves in the kitchen.
thessalonian Posted August 15, 2006 Posted August 15, 2006 CROWD: A witch! A witch! [bonk] A witch! A witch! MONKS: [chanting] Pie Iesu domine... CROWD: A witch! A witch! A witch! A witch! We've found a witch! A witch! A witch! A witch! A witch! We've got a witch! A witch! A witch! Burn her! Burn her! Burn her! We've found a witch! We've found a witch! A witch! A witch! A witch! VILLAGER #1: We have found a witch. May we burn her? CROWD: Burn her! Burn! Burn her! Burn her! BEDEVERE: How do you know she is a witch? VILLAGER #2: She looks like one. CROWD: Right! Yeah! Yeah! BEDEVERE: Bring her forward. WITCH: I'm not a witch. I'm not a witch. BEDEVERE: Uh, but you are dressed as one. WITCH: They dressed me up like this. CROWD: Augh, we didn't! We didn't... WITCH: And this isn't my nose. It's a false one. BEDEVERE: Well? VILLAGER #1: Well, we did do the nose. BEDEVERE: The nose? VILLAGER #1: And the hat, but she is a witch! VILLAGER #2: Yeah! CROWD: We burn her! Right! Yeaaah! Yeaah! BEDEVERE: Did you dress her up like this? VILLAGER #1: No! VILLAGER #2 and 3: No. No. VILLAGER #2: No. VILLAGER #1: No. VILLAGERS #2 and #3: No. VILLAGER #1: Yes. VILLAGER #2: Yes. VILLAGER #1: Yes. Yeah, a bit. VILLAGER #3: A bit. VILLAGERS #1 and #2: A bit. VILLAGER #3: A bit. VILLAGER #1: She has got a wart. RANDOM: [cough] BEDEVERE: What makes you think she is a witch? VILLAGER #3: Well, she turned me into a newt. BEDEVERE: A newt? VILLAGER #3: I got better. VILLAGER #2: Burn her anyway! VILLAGER #1: Burn! CROWD: Burn her! Burn! Burn her!... BEDEVERE: Quiet! Quiet! Quiet! Quiet! There are ways of telling whether she is a witch. VILLAGER #1: Are there? VILLAGER #2: Ah? VILLAGER #1: What are they? CROWD: Tell us! Tell us!... VILLAGER #2: Do they hurt? BEDEVERE: Tell me. What do you do with witches? VILLAGER #2: Burn! VILLAGER #1: Burn! CROWD: Burn! Burn them up! Burn!... BEDEVERE: And what do you burn apart from witches? VILLAGER #1: More witches! VILLAGER #3: Shh! VILLAGER #2: Wood! BEDEVERE: So, why do witches burn? [pause] VILLAGER #3: B--... 'cause they're made of... wood? BEDEVERE: Good! Heh heh. CROWD: Oh, yeah. Oh. BEDEVERE: So, how do we tell whether she is made of wood? VILLAGER #1: Build a bridge out of her. BEDEVERE: Ah, but can you not also make bridges out of stone? VILLAGER #1: Oh, yeah. RANDOM: Oh, yeah. True. Uhh... BEDEVERE: Does wood sink in water? VILLAGER #1: No. No. VILLAGER #2: No, it floats! It floats! VILLAGER #1: Throw her into the pond! CROWD: The pond! Throw her into the pond! BEDEVERE: What also floats in water? VILLAGER #1: Bread! VILLAGER #2: Apples! VILLAGER #3: Uh, very small rocks! VILLAGER #1: Cider! VILLAGER #2: Uh, gra-- gravy! VILLAGER #1: Cherries! VILLAGER #2: Mud! VILLAGER #3: Uh, churches! Churches! VILLAGER #2: Lead! Lead! ARTHUR: A duck! CROWD: Oooh. BEDEVERE: Exactly. So, logically... VILLAGER #1: If... she... weighs... the same as a duck,... she's made of wood. BEDEVERE: And therefore? VILLAGER #2: A witch! VILLAGER #1: A witch! CROWD: A witch! A witch!... VILLAGER #4: Here is a duck. Use this duck. [quack quack quack] BEDEVERE: Very good. We shall use my largest scales. CROWD: Ohh! Ohh! Burn the witch! Burn the witch! Burn her! Burn her! Burn her! Burn her! Burn her! Burn her! Burn her! Ahh! Ahh... BEDEVERE: Right. Remove the supports! [whop] [clunk] [creak] CROWD: A witch! A witch! A witch! WITCH: It's a fair cop. VILLAGER #3: Burn her! CROWD: Burn her! Burn her! Burn her! Burn! Burn!...
fearundercontrol Posted August 16, 2006 Posted August 16, 2006 (edited) As to the question at hand, it's a moot point, just like the question of "What would you do if the Catholic Church stopped existing", because the Church is indestructable, so that would never happen. So there's really no point in discussing the matter. Edited August 16, 2006 by fearundercontrol
catholicinsd Posted August 23, 2006 Posted August 23, 2006 [quote name='at0m1c' post='1042526' date='Aug 13 2006, 08:27 AM'] In the comic series Y: The Last Man by Vertigo Comics, all the males in the world are wiped out by a plague. Let's say this happens in the real world. How does Apostolic Succession continue, and can women become priests? [/quote] Well that's about the best question ever posed on PM.
toledo_jesus Posted August 23, 2006 Posted August 23, 2006 [quote name='at0m1c' post='1042526' date='Aug 13 2006, 11:27 AM'] In the comic series Y: The Last Man by Vertigo Comics, all the males in the world are wiped out by a plague. Let's say this happens in the real world. How does Apostolic Succession continue, and can women become priests? [/quote] no. if that happens, the world is over. uh oh, the Python is loose on this thread.
chris Posted August 24, 2006 Posted August 24, 2006 (edited) [quote]In the comic series Y: The Last Man by Vertigo Comics, all the males in the world are wiped out by a plague. [/quote] ...Well not alot of comic book affairs bleed into real life... However, in retrospect if all men die there would be no way that the population would increase and thus would fall into extinction. Edited August 24, 2006 by Convert4888
at0m1c Posted September 12, 2006 Author Posted September 12, 2006 Anyway the gist of the story is that the only surviving males in the world are the main character and his pet monkey. In the comics, the highest ranking female official at the Vatican is some nun. The main character bedded some girl, and the girl has his child. So the nun and a company of women swiss guards try and see if the child is a male, using a portable ultrasound machine. Basically their logic is that they think can somehow restore apostolic succession by baptising the child and naming him as Pope. Which doesn't work, right?
Picard Posted September 12, 2006 Posted September 12, 2006 [quote name='at0m1c' post='1061215' date='Sep 12 2006, 10:34 AM'] they think can somehow restore apostolic succession by baptising the child and naming him as Pope. Which doesn't work, right? [/quote] Correct, it would not work. You need a living Bishop to pass on apostolic succession by ordaining another Bishop.
Theoketos Posted September 12, 2006 Posted September 12, 2006 Only if the other previous surving male had apostolic succession...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now