Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted
:( I am undergoing a crisis...a BIG one.
It all started about a month ago when two things occurred in my local parish.
1. Eucharistic Adoration was held with Benediction - throughout the entire hour, people were fidgeting and blatantly disrepectful. Two ladies in front of me were having a 'housewife chit chat' :annoyed:
2. During homily after the Gospel, I have noticed out Priest tends to say things which seem dubious to me. Firstly saying that "all people and faiths are beautiful to God, all faiths give God the praise he desires" and "Jesus is the way, like Buddha and Allah are the way for others. God loves each way" .... (maybe these weren't the exact words but they were along these lines)

This, in turn, made curious little me go off and do some reading ... and I must admit I am quiet distressed by what I have found. :blink: It seems irreverence, homosexuality and outright heresy is prevalent amongst many parishes.
I must admit this shock made me quiet sympathetic to many 'traditionalist' writings by traditionalist catholics. Some of their arguements are clearly vindictive. Others, however, are quiet strong.
Yet what I have noticed is that traditionalists appear to be in schism with the Church ... so for all their preaching about sticking to the traditions and dogma of the Church, they seem to have skipped the directive that leaving the Church is schism.

I am very confused :idontknow:

I would like several questions answered, or at least a point in the right direction as to where I can get answers

my questions are:
1. Are our Popes since Vatican II rightfully Popes ... and if so (other than just saying 'yes they are') how do we know?
2. Is the New Mass filled with liturgical abuses?
3. Which societies and groups are in schism with the Church?
4. How do you reconise a Tridentine Mass that is legitimate?
5. Does transubstanation occur in the New Mass ... despite the drastic changes to the Eucharistic prayer?
6. How does one explain the rise of pedophillia, homosexuality and apostacy in the Church since Vatican II and Pope John Paul II contrary teachings, to teachings given by preceeding saints, popes etc .... the one that comes to mind is the doctrine that there is no salvation outside the catholic church v JP II admission that there is
7. And finally, someone PLEASE explain to me JP II kissing the Koran?

:( Eagerly awaiting answers and the Truth
Posted

OK, I'll do my best to answer your questions, but there are more knowledgeable people on here who will probably answer more completely after me. Hope this helps, I'm praying for ya!

[quote name='GodChild' post='1042777' date='Aug 13 2006, 08:03 PM']
1. Are our Popes since Vatican II rightfully Popes ... and if so (other than just saying 'yes they are') how do we know?[/quote]
Yes. We know because in Matt. 16:18 Jesus Christ gave the keys of the kingdom to Peter and declared "the gates of hell shall not prevail against the Church." To say that the popes since Vatican II are not rightfully popes is to say Jesus got it wrong.

[quote]2. Is the New Mass filled with liturgical abuses?[/quote]
The "new Mass" in itself is NOT filled with liturgical abuses. However, the way the Mass is celebrated in many parishes unfortunately is. When the Mass is celebrated as it should be, it is very beautiful, reverent, and pleasing to God.
[quote]3. Which societies and groups are in schism with the Church?[/quote]
The SSPX, while not technically in schism with the Church according to them, is not in full union with the Church.
[quote]4. How do you reconise a Tridentine Mass that is legitimate? [/quote]
A Tridentine Mass is legitimate if it is celebrated with the permission of the local Bishop and/or religious superior in the case of a Mass with religious priests. These are referred to as Latin Indult Masses, because an Indult (permission) was given for them to be celebrated. Generally these Masses will be listed on the website of your local diocese. Or you can go to this website that has a listing of Indult Masses: [url="http://www.ecclesiadei.org/direct00.htm"]http://www.ecclesiadei.org/direct00.htm[/url]

[quote]5. Does transubstanation occur in the New Mass ... despite the drastic changes to the Eucharistic prayer?[/quote]
Yes. The Church has legitimate authority to change the wording of the Eucharistic prayer.

[quote]6. How does one explain the rise of pedophillia, homosexuality and apostacy in the Church since Vatican II and Pope John Paul II contrary teachings, to teachings given by preceeding saints, popes etc .... the one that comes to mind is the doctrine that there is no salvation outside the catholic church v JP II admission that there is [/quote]
Wow, that's a lot rolled up into one question there. OK, first, the rise of general sinfulness and confusion within the Church is largely a result of misinterpretation of Vatican II and experimentation gone wrong. This is a very complex issue, I would recommend reading George Weigel's book "The Courage to Be Catholic." It's an excellent read, and very informative.

There have been no teachings or doctines of the Church that have changed before and after Vatican II, what has happened is that they are expressed differently. The no salvation outside the Church doctrine is debated often at phatmass, but JPII didn't go against this teaching. He looked at it from a different perspective. Basically he said there is no way for us to know the limits of God's grace and who is implicitly within the Church, even if they were never explicitly a member of the Catholic Church.

[quote]7. And finally, someone PLEASE explain to me JP II kissing the Koran?

:( Eagerly awaiting answers and the Truth
[/quote]
Ahh...there are so many different versions of this story it is practically mythical. I have heard many different explanations, but I don't know the validity of any of them so I will not repeat them. I'll leave that to someone more knowledgeable than myself. :)

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

First, I'd like to say that Claire did a great job in responding, and so I apologize if some of my comments seem like repeats, but it never hurts to emphasize Truth.

[quote]1. Are our Popes since Vatican II rightfully Popes ... and if so (other than just saying 'yes they are') how do we know?[/quote]

Absolutely, yes. As the visible head of the Church Militant, the Holy Father is protected by the infallibility of the Holy Ghost from officially teaching doctrinal error or heresy.

What I always find humorous about these "post-VII Popes aren't real Popes" claims is that the focus is on Vatican II. If the Second Vatican Council actually taught all the heresy that these schismatic groups argue it did, then instead of saying that the Pope isn't the real Pope, they should argue that the Magisterium isn't the real Magisterium. But when you look at it in that light, it becomes even more obvious that Christ's promise that "the gates of Hell shall never prevail against [the Church]" is incompatible with these accusations.

Either the schismatic traditionalists are wrong, or Christ is wrong, and I throw my lot in with Christ.

[quote]Is the New Mass filled with liturgical abuses?[/quote]

This isn't the right question you want to ask. You should be asking: Is the new Mass [i]necessarily[/i] filled with liturgical abuses. And the answer to that question is absolutely, unequivocally, no. The new Mass, when said as it was intended to be said, is a solemn, beautiful, mystery-filled celebration, and truly earns the name of Divine Liturgy.

This having been said, many, many priests, and even bishops, do not say the new Mass as it was intended to be said. This leads to a number of abuses, and that is deplorable. However, we ought to get rid of the abuses, not the Mass.

[quote]Which societies and groups are in schism with the Church?[/quote]

Here are some traditionalist groups that you want to stay away from. I will not comment on their precise ecclesiastical status, but rather, they are groups you should try to steer clear of if you are interested in being as orthodox as possible:

Religious Congregation of Mary Immaculate Queen (CMRI)
Society of St. Pius X (SSPX)
Society of St. Pius V (SSPV)

[quote]How do you reconise a Tridentine Mass that is legitimate?[/quote]

Just to keep proper terminology, there are two distinctions: "Valid" and "Licit." A Mass can be [i]valid[/i] without being [i]licit[/i]. Every Tridentine Mass that is said by a priest who has been validly ordained is a [i]valid[/i] Mass, and so contains the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Christ. However, not all valid Masses are [i]licit[/i]. Any Mass from the above listed groups is not a [i]licit[/i] Mass. If you are looking for a Tridentine Mass that is both licit and valid, you can either go to an indult Mass in your diocese (call your diocese and ask them about it, or go to Claire's link above) or you can attend a Mass said by the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter (FSSP) or the Society of St. John Cantius. Both are great :D:

[quote]Does transubstanation occur in the New Mass ... despite the drastic changes to the Eucharistic prayer?[/quote]

Yes, transubstantiation absolutely does occur in the New Mass, as long as the words of consecration that the Magisterium have promulgated are used. If the question were (as many schismatic traditionalists would have it be) simply one of certain precise words, then all of the Liturgies and Sacraments in the Eastern Rite Catholic Churches would not be valid Sacraments, but that is clearly not the case. Compare the western and eastern prayers of absolution:

God, the Father of mercies, through the death and resurrection of His Son
has reconciled the world to Himself and sent the Holy Spirit among us
for the forgiveness of sins;
Through the ministry of the Church may God give you pardon and peace,
and I absolve you from your sins in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen

and

May the same God, who through the Prophet Nathan forgave David when he confessed his sins, who forgave Peter when he wept bitterly, the prostitute when she washed his feet with her tears, the publican, and the prodigal son, through me, a sinner, forgive you both in this life and in the next and enable you to appear before his awe-inspiring tribunal without condemnation, he who is blessed for ever and ever. Amen.

What matters is whether or not the legitimate Church authority deems the wording to be sufficient for the sacrament to be made valid. The rite of the new Mas was legitimately promulgated by the magisterium of the Church, and thus its validity cannot be questioned.

[quote]How does one explain the rise of pedophillia, homosexuality and apostacy in the Church since Vatican II and Pope John Paul II contrary teachings, to teachings given by preceeding saints, popes etc .... the one that comes to mind is the doctrine that there is no salvation outside the catholic church v JP II admission that there is[/quote]

This is two questions so I will break it down.

How does one explain the rise of pedophilia, homosexuality, and apostacy in the Church since Vatican II?

The same way that one explains the occurrence of pedophilia, homosexuality, and apostacy that have occurred in every other age of the Church: Satan and Sin. The corruptor is good at what he does, and he hates priests especially, because they bear the indelible mark of the One who defeated him. Fault Satan and the sin of weak individuals, not the Church.

That last point should be stressed. There is nothing Satan could want more than for Catholics to blame a Church Council for his evil.

Did John Paul II contradict the teaching [i]extra ecclesium nulla salus[/i]?

No, he didn't. for proof, read [i]Dominus Iesus[/i] which was promulgated by JPII. This having been said, we must understand that the schismatic traditionalists seem to like very much the negative formulation of the doctrine, but not the positive formulation of the doctrine, which, while logically identical, shows their strict interpretation to be too strong. The fact is "Outside the Church there is no salvation" means exactly the same as "All salvation comes from the Church." This is what JPII stressed. If anyone who is not a member of the visible Catholic Church can attain heaven, it is only because that person was, by the Grace of God, somehow united to the Church in an invisible way. There isn't a way into heaven without the Church.

[quote]And finally, someone PLEASE explain to me JP II kissing the Koran?[/quote]

The explanation of this that makes the most sense is this:

For people of middle-eastern culture, when one receives a gift, it is proper to kiss the gift, whatever it is and whether you like it or not, as a sign that you respect the giver. JPII was given the Koran as a gift and, as a sign of respect for the [i]giver[/i] - not the gift itself - he kissed it. We ought not to publicly speculate as to whether this was a wise decision prudentially, but it is clearly not the case that the Pope was secretly a Muslim. :P:

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

thessalonian
Posted

Be not afraid is all that I can add to the excellent answers so far. The gates of hell shall not prevail, but they will try even from within.

Scandal is nothing new in God's people. Hophni and Phineous were having relations with virgins in the doorway of the tent of the meeting. David and Bethsheeba, you know the story. The Jewish leaders sacrificed children to pagan gods. See 1 Cor 5 and rev 3&4, not to mention that 11 out of 12 apostles abandoned Jesus at the cross. The Church is truly a hospital for sinners more than it is a hotel for saints. We are all in need of redemption.

Posted
:) Thankyou to all who have replied .... your words have bought me alot of relief.
Posted

Glad to be of help! :) Let us know if you have any other questions.

phatcatholic
Posted

good work everyone :thumbsup:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...