Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

At Mass today it was a priest that I haven't seen too often. Before the prayer that goes "which earth has given and human hands have made" the priest poured the wine into three different chalices. Then at the part where he is supposed to put water in the wine, he put water only in his own chalice. Is that ok? I didn't know if all the wine is supposed to have water in it. I have always just seen priests put water in the wine [/i]then[i] pour it into chalices. Anyway, making sure the consecration was still valid and everything.

Posted

The norms are not very precise on this question. It appears that this is the preferred option and the one that best corresponds to the tradition that water be added to the wine used for consecration. Yet, this is not specifically mandated.

Several liturgists suggest that adding water to the principal chalice alone sufficiently fulfills the symbolic meaning of the rite and the liturgical norms. They argue that the several chalices are in an analogous situation to that of the small hosts present in additional ciboria and adding water to one is symbolically adding it to all.

Both options are probably legitimate unless the Holy See states otherwise.

Preparing extra chalices may be done in several ways. If only one or two extra chalices are needed, they may be prepared in the usual way at the altar during the preparation of the gifts. If more are needed, they may be prepared at this time at the credence table by a deacon and brought to the altar.

In situations were a rather large number of chalices are required, or due to some other circumstance such as a shortage of proper ministers, then chalices with wine (and water) may be prepared before Mass at the credence table and brought to the altar during the preparation of gifts.

This is the usual practice at large papal concelebrations.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...