Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is there and objective theological reason or official


Recommended Posts

Posted

Can anyone give me a link to some theological reason or Vatican/Papal teaching regarding cohabitation when the couple isn't sexually active? I'm not looking for the cohabitating couples have a higher rate of some bad thing because those studies are only relevant if done on people who don't plan on having sex and are at least devout Christians who don't believe divorce is possible. I think the results are doctored to a certain extent because most of the people who don't plan on having sex and are at least devout Christians who don't believe divorce is possible aren't cohabitating thus making the non-cohabitating side automatically better regardless of the tested factor. Unless of course both test groups have and equal number of secular humanists that are sexually active before marriage and have no really understanding of its dignity and devout Catholics who frequent the sacraments and have a extreme respect for the Church and its teachings in which case I think a 50 percent increase in the divorce rate is considerable. Plus although possibly helpful in persuading the secular mind they have no real theological backbone unless you argue that they "show" it can harm a marriage and harming a marriage is bad. My problem is it is rarely looked at outside the issue of premarital sex, the only reasons I've seen are scandal (something entirely different for each situation), the above studies, and temptation (something which is also entirely different for each situation and that I don't think would truly increase unless the couple only spent time together in public before moving in together), yet I see it I don't see it being portrayed as a discipline (as it should be if based on two subjective factors and certain psychological studies) but a doctrine implying that cohabitation is an objectively immoral life style, even though they seem allow it for couples awaiting an annulment. Unless the fact that the couple awaiting an annulment shouldn’t even act as though they are dating is relevant but it certainly isn’t in regard to the three reasons I’ve heard. Also I've only seen it addressed by individual bishops and small conferences of bishops, which I guess technically makes it magisterial teaching but not to the extent that someone could tell someone from anywhere that it is the Church's position, yet that is what I see happening. So I think there must be more to this but I can’t find it. Any help?

Posted

cohabitation (living together) is usually considered a proximate occasion of sin. As Catholics we are obliged to avoid proximate occasions of sin (those that may easily lead a person into sin), and living together is certainly such an occasion of sin.

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/search.php"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/search.php[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...