Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Serious Questions about the Liturgy.


The Liturgy  

63 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Mitchell_b55
Posted (edited)

I have recently engaged in an argument with an extreme traditionalist, of the [i]Una Voce[/i] variety, who while accepting the legal validity of the Pauline Missal of 1969 nonetheless feels that it was a morally unacceptable action on the part of Pope Paul VI to promulgate it. I have argued this point, professing the idea of Liturgical Pluralism, which Pope Benedict XVI briefly discussed in his interview with Messori as Cardinal Ratzinger. ^_^ I believe that the Missal of 1962, which I refuse to title the [i]Traditional Mass[/i], is beneficial to those who are attached to it, and commend Pope John Paul II's Indult. However, I fully support the current Roman Rite, as any obedient Catholic should, publicly affirm this, and I have tried to create an awareness of liturgical abuse in local parishes, however unsuccessful. :blush: I have however decided to ask a number of questions which I ask to be answered.

Cardinal Ratzinger:

[quote]If it would foster devotion in many believers and encourage respect for the piety of particular Catholic groups, I would personally support a return to the ancient situation, i.e., to a certain liturgical pluralism.[/quote]

There are three prerequisites to answering these questions:

[color="#CC0000"][b]I want those in question:[/b] [/color]

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...to be baptised and catechised Catholics.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...to answer honestly all inquiries.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...answer without personal judgment or bias against either the Missal of 1962 or 1969, whether that bias exists or not.

[color="#CC0000"][b]Please provide responses for these questions:[/b][/color]

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Where in the Missal of 1969?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Where in the Missal of 1962?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Do you believe that the Mass should be said [i]ad orientem[/i], to the east?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If yes, why? - If no, why?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How often do you feel that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How would you feel if Mass was said in Latin?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Would you learn Latin for God?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Could a "liturgical pluralism" be more acceptable than "liturgical uniformity" which seems to affect both left and right wings of the argument?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism."
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Is communion in the hand a reverential as communion on the tongue?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How so?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How so?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How do liturgical abuses affect this expression?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] What do you believe are liturgical abuses?

[color="#CC0000"][b]It may interest you to note that I made the following oath:[/b][/color]

I, Mitchell Bond, unhesitatingly accept and profess also all things transmitted, defined and declared by the sacred canons and the ecumenical Councils, especially by the second most Holy Council of Vatican, and further more accept all promulgations and definitions expressed by the sovereign pontiff in regard to the celebration of the liturgy and the interaction between the true faith and all other subsequent religions. I adhere to these and all other teachings of the Church, and make no judgment on them. I accept that whatever discrepancies that I may see within them are a misunderstanding and are the result of my lack of theological knowledge and historical understanding or the intention of the promulgators. I grant that whatever is taught by my sovereign pontiff, and subsidiary authorities, however supported by him, is the truth that I, as a Catholic, must endeavor to proclaim and express. Nonetheless, I find the Missal of 1962, expressed in all it’s pomp, produces and fosters a more keen and obvious devotion in me and thus I adhere to it, not out of disobedience, but out of an understanding for liturgical plurality. However, I do not find discrepancy with the Missal promulgated in 1969, because I have seen that it can bear fruit and have merits, and because I understand that no liturgy can be ranked with another, since their sole mission is the sacrifice of Calvary and this sacrifice can not be undermined in its fundamental essence.

[Mitchell Bond, June 28 2006]

The following is quoted from "The Pauline Liturgy - A True Restoration", Appendix A, written by I.Shawn McElhinney ©2000.

[quote]The Pauline Rite is very "plain, simple, practical" too. It also in light of all that I have covered in this essay is a genuine restoration along the line of the ancient Western Mass Rites. [color="#CC0000"]This does not make it above some forms of criticism of course either in the form of abuses of the liturgy, poor pastoral directives allowed after the Revised Missal was promulgated, or areas where implementation has in practice has not worked as well as in theory.[/color] [b]These are all legitimate criticisms and one is not acting at all [color="#CC0000"]unorthodox[/color] in making them.[/b] However to call it a "lesser rite" as some pro-Tridentine groups have done is also [in light of what history and common sense reveals to us] profoundly erroneous since all approved rites are equally sacred and one is not more or less "holy" or "proper" then another one. [Provided that they are celebrated in accordance with their prescribed rubrics.] Comments to the contrary get hung up in [color="#CC0000"][b]style [/b][/color] or [color="#CC0000"][b]externals [/b][/color] and miss the whole point of the Mass which is an action of Christ Himself. In this light, all other aspects are a distant second in importance.[/quote]

An old priest that adhered strictly to rubrics said to me:

[quote]Catholicism isn’t incense, marble, and gold and Christ wasn’t crucified in a Gammarelli cassock an' a tiara, carried forth on the sedia gestatoria. Jesus Christ died stark naked on a cross of rough hewn splintering lumber, with rusty wrought iron nails, and his first Mass was offered in the upper room of an middle-class tenement with an agate cup, bread, wine and a wooden table. There was no Gregorian chant, there was no incense, and there were no high marble altars with vaulted ceilings and jewel encrusted chalices. If it was good enough for Christ, who has the gall to complain that it isn’t good enough for our corrupt materialistic world. I don’t give a beaver dam if we admit that he accepted his means, and that we now have means that are superior, the Holy See has approbated a Mass that must be accepted, unless we are given a dispensation to do other wise. Period.[/quote]

Perhaps I don’t agree with him in the extreme sense, but I accept the premise.

Cardinal Ratzinger said thus:

[quote]We do not seek a Christ whom we have invented, for only in the real communion of the Church do we encounter the real Christ.[/quote]

[color="#CC0000"][b]Please respond with the dignity and circumstance surrounding your catholicity.[/b][/color] :saint:

Edited by petrus_scholasticus
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

1. Yes
2. Yes
3. Undecided

Now for the more detailed questions:
¤ Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice? Yes. It is THE Sacrifice of Christ at Calvary.
¤ What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice? of the Tridentine or Novus Ordo?
¤ Where in the Missal of 1969? The Roman Canon (Eucharistic Prayer I) calls it a "sacrifice" specifically a couple times (at least twice), the other Eucharistic Prayers usually say "gifts"
¤ Where in the Missal of 1962? I could quote most of the Canon-- the Eucharist is constantly referred to as a Sacrifice.
¤ Do you believe that the Mass should be said ad orientem, to the east? YES!
¤ If yes, why? - If no, why? It is a sign of true unity and community in worship--we worship together (i.e., in the same direction) towards CHRIST, rather than towards one another.
¤ What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers? They are an abuse-- and have become more "ordinary" than EXTRAordinary in the vast majority of Catholic parishes
¤ How often do you feel that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition? Honestly? Never.
¤ How would you feel if Mass was said in Latin? I would be elated.
¤ Would you learn Latin for God? Yes, am currently striving to learn more.
¤ Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual? In practice or in theory? In practice I would say no, but would possibly be more lenient in theory.. I think it tries.
¤ If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular? It has the potential...
¤ Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962? Not all of its practices...
¤ Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth? Yes, but guided faithfully by the Church and the authentic liturgical documents she has provided.
¤ What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief? No part of the 1962 Missal is adverse to Catholic belief.
¤ If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it? People view it as "hidden"/"oppressing" because they don't understand Latin and because it's so different from other Christian services.
¤ Could a "liturgical pluralism" be more acceptable than "liturgical uniformity" which seems to affect both left and right wings of the argument? Perhaps...
¤ If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders? Yes.
¤ Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic? In a sense.
¤ If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react? With surprise as I don't think it possible (but if it were possible, I would be immensely happy)
¤ Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity? No...
¤ Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism." The latter.
¤ Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist? Yes.
¤ Is communion in the hand a reverential as communion on the tongue? No.
¤ How so? Communion in the hand tends to be treated and passed out like candy, and the vast majority of people do not sanitize and wash their hands before reception of the Sacred Host.
¤ Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing? Yes.
¤ How so? Kneeling is a prayerful posture of HUMILITY conveyed better by kneeling than by standing.
¤ Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice? Not as well as does the Missal of 1962, but the Novus Ordo does not lack potential provided there is a faithful and catechized priest celebrating...
¤ Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass? Not currently.
¤ How do liturgical abuses affect this expression? As Redemptionis Sacramentum states... Liturgical abuses "hinder the faithful" not only from realizing and seeing the sacredness of the Mass, but from participating fully.
¤ What do you believe are liturgical abuses? Anything that violates Sacrosanctum Concilium #22, point 3 "No one... may add, [b]change[/b], or remove anything..."

Mitchell_b55
Posted (edited)

I am very pleased with this, I hope that more people respond, I want to write an essay upon concluding this study.

Edited by petrus_scholasticus
Mitchell_b55
Posted
:bump: Please respond?
Posted (edited)

1. yes
2. yes
3. no

Please provide responses for these questions:

¤ Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice? [i]Yes, just as Fides et Ratio said, the Sacrifice at Calvary[/i]
¤ What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice? [i]the "ancta sacrifícia illibáta" from the Te Igitur (Prayer for the Church), the "hoc sacrifícium laudis" from the Prayer for the Living and the whole of the the Unde et Memores (Offering of the Victim) along with the whole of the Supra Quæ (The Asking of God to Accept the Offering) [/i]
¤ Where in the Missal of 1969? [i]In the Oratre Fratres and in Eucharistic Prayer I, though not in any of the other Eucharistic prayers[/i]
¤ Where in the Missal of 1962? [i]In the Oratre Fratres and most especially in the Unde et Memores' "a Victim + which is pure, a Victim + which is holy, a Victim + which is spotless, the holy Bread + of life eternal, and the Chalice + of everlasting Salvation" part of the Canon taken out of the Novus Ordo Missae.[/i]
¤ Do you believe that the Mass should be said ad orientem, to the east? [i]Yes[/i]
¤ If yes, why? - If no, why? [i]Becuase when a priest is made to face the people he feels like he needs to entertain them, also it may be distracting for him to try to pray with people looking at him. It is also more symbolic for all the people present at the Mass to face the same direction showing that they are offering the same sacrifice[/i]
¤ What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers? I[i] think they are sacriligous and should never be used at all. I believe only priests should be allowed to touch the Sacred Eucharist except if a layperson is saving it from being profaned.[/i]
¤ How often do you feel that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition? [i]Never[/i]
¤ How would you feel if Mass was said in Latin? [i]I love both the Traditional Latin Mass and Novus Ordo in Latin.[/i]
¤ Would you learn Latin for God? [i]Of course I would, and I'd like to some day, though it isn't strictly necessary with the invention of the hand missal.[/i]
¤ Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual? [i]Not sure...[/i]
¤ If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular? [i]I don't know[/i]
¤ Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962? [i]No.[/i]
¤ Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth?[i] I'm not sure what you mean by that. I don't believe the Mass needs to grow anymore... The Old Mass was perfect the way it was and the New Mass would be fine and in no need of change (except eliminating different options so that every Mass is exactly the same) if it were said in Latin, ad orientem, with only men wearing cassocks serving, with no Extraordinary Ministers, with kneeling for Communion and with Communion on the Tounge only, with Eucharistic Prayer I [/i]
¤ What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief? [i]I think it is heretical and sacriligous to say any part is.[/i]
¤ If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it?[i] Only modernerdists who don't respect the Church and Her Sacred Traditions act viciously twards the Traditional Latin Mass.[/i]
¤ Could a "liturgical pluralism" be more acceptable than "liturgical uniformity" which seems to affect both left and right wings of the argument? [i]I think it would be great for the Novus Ordo and the Traditional Latin Mass to co-exist if that's what you mean, so long as the Novus Ordo is said in Latin, ad orientam, with only males in cassocks serving at the altar, with Eucharistic prayer I, no Extraorinary Ministers of Holy Communion, kneeling for Communion, and only Communion on the Tounge.[/i]
¤ If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders? [i]Yeah[/i]
¤ Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic? [i]Don't know...[/i]
¤ If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react? [i]I would think I were in a dream and pray God that I'd never awake.[/i]
¤ Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity? [i]No.[/i]
¤ Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism." [i]It's been replaced with modern materalism[/i]
¤ Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist? [i]Of course I believe that the bread and wine are turned into the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of God the Son at Consecration[/i]
¤ Is communion in the hand a reverential as communion on the tongue? [i]No.[/i]
¤ How so? [i]There is more oppurntunity for the Sacred Host to be profaned and it would be easier for an enemny of God to comitt sacrilige against God the Son physically present.[/i]
¤ Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing? [i]Yes[/i]
¤ How so? [i]Kneeling is a posture that signifies adoration and humility while standing does not signify either.[/i]
¤ Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice? [i]As Fides et Ratio said, not as well as the Traditional Latin Mass, but if those present are well catechised then it's just as good as fostering devotion to the sacrifice as the Traditional Mass.[/i]
¤ Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass? [i]Not nearly as much as the Traditional Latin Mass[/i]
¤ How do liturgical abuses affect this expression? [i]The completely take away the meaning and sacredness of the Mass and make it more of a protestantised get-to-gether rather than the Holy Sacrifice which the Mass is.[/i]
¤ What do you believe are liturgical abuses? [i]Liturgical abuses are anything that goes against the offocial rubrics, is sacriligous or is contrary to Tradition.[/i]

Edited by StThomasMore
Posted

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...to be baptised and catechised Catholics. Yes, I am
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...to answer honestly all inquiries. Of course
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...answer without personal judgment or bias against either the Missal of 1962 or 1969, whether that bias exists or not. I haven't read either of them, so I'm sure that won't be a problem..

[color="#CC0000"][b]Please provide responses for these questions:[/b][/color] I know I won't be able to answer all these questions, but I'll answer the ones I know...

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice? I think so. The Eucharist is the sacrifice, right?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice? symbolically represents that it is literal? I don't understand... or haven't read it
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Where in the Missal of 1969? Haven't read
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Where in the Missal of 1962? Haven't read
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Do you believe that the Mass should be said [i]ad orientem[/i], to the east? No. [color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If yes, why? - If no, why? Christ is with us everywhere. Mass should be said ad orientem to the altar, where the local sacrifice takes place, not towards some distant land where Christ was solely present 2000 years ago, when He is present in tabernacles and monstrances everywhere.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers? I wish more of them had that twinkle in their eye as they say "Body of Christ"
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How often do you feel that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition? I would say that they're extraordinary because they're administering Christ, rather than they're extraordinary because they're not supposed to be used often. However, I still think that they shouldn't be used quite as often, and that it should be more of a privledge than "WHO WANTS TO SIGN UP?"
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How would you feel if Mass was said in Latin? Latin was used because it was the people's language back in the day. Thus, I think it should be said in the local language. If, however, the question was if it should be in Greek or Hebrew, I would be less inclined to disagree, but, they're all still human languages.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Would you learn Latin for God? This is a trick question. Yes, of course I would, but I do not think that it should be neccessary.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual? Huh?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth? Should we, as Pope? I'm not the Pope, and I don't know what organic growth refers to.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief? If it's a Catholic Missal written by a council or Pope, I don't see why it would be adverse to Catholic belief, but I haven't read it.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it? Some Catholics are overzealous or are more Catholic than the Church Fathers.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Could a "liturgical pluralism" be more acceptable than "liturgical uniformity" which seems to affect both left and right wings of the argument? I dunno.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders? We should work towards both at the same time, but both require different methods of going about them.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic? These questions are very leading. It depends on the severity of the affairs primarily, but generally domestic affairs are more important.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react? I would be surprised and wonder why the heck they did that.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity? Not being materialistic does not mean not owning anything material at all. Thus said, I would say that liturgical ritual is important, and so is apostolic simplicity. It's "spirit of the law" vs "letter of the law" I think. The letter of the law is in place to make sure that the spirit of the law is not broken, so it may be acceptable to go against the letter of the law if one is still keeping with the spirit of the law.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism." I'm not sure on the difference between medieval and modern materialism.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist? Definatly.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Is communion in the hand a reverential as communion on the tongue? If your hands and teeth are both clean, yes.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How so? When you receive on the tongue, you still touch the Host. It just makes it so the EM or priest doesn't have to get your saliva all over his fingers.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing? It can be, probably, yes, by the nature of kneeling.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How so? Kneeling focuses on the divinity of Christ in the Eucharist, whereas standing would emphasize our common humanity. Recently I heard of parishes standing after the Lamb of God instead of kneeling to focus on the common humanity rather than divinity. I kinda think that both should be focused on, and perhaps standing during one time (after LoG/before receiving or while receiving Eucharist) and kneeling during the other.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice? No clue.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How do liturgical abuses affect this expression?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] What do you believe are liturgical abuses? Any intended lack of reverence for the Eucharist or display of contempt for the Mass.

Again, sorry I couldn't answer all of the questions, but I figgured you might want a point of view other than what's been offered so far.

Mitchell_b55
Posted

[b][color="#CC0000"]Response from the Poster:[/color][/b]

I believe I owe a certain explanation of the questions to you, so that they can be better understood. I will also provide my opinion in the matter, for a clarification.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice? [/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Yes, it is as has been clearly presented that it is the Sacrifice of Calvary ad infintitum, until the end of time.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] This question alone, is fairly meaningless, it was a pretext to the following questions.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Where in the Missal of 1969?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] To quote St. Thomas More, “In the Oratre Fratres and in Eucharistic Prayer I, though not in any of the other Eucharistic prayers” This is what I was looking for.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Where in the Missal of 1962?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] To once more quote St. Thomas More, “In the Oratre Fratres and most especially in the Unde et Memores' "a Victim + which is pure, a Victim + which is holy, a Victim + which is spotless, the holy Bread + of life eternal, and the Chalice + of everlasting Salvation" part of the Canon taken out of the Novus Ordo Missae.” Again, exactly what I was expecting.

I believe these are fundamental questions in the [i]Sola Missale Romanum MCMLXII [/i] [1962] vs. [i]Sola Missale Romanum MCMLXIX [/i] [1969] argument. I attempt to be a moderate in these affairs, as I see benefit in both Missals, and so should, as my opinion stands, all Catholics. One claim that many so-called “Traditional” Catholics have is that the Liturgy is no longer, in the so-called “Mainstream” Church considered a Sacrifice by the Clergy or the Laity, and that it has been expressed as, instead, a Communal Supper, like that of Protestant Denominations. I hoped through these questions to clarify that the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is still and always will be nothing more or less than exactly that.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Do you believe that the Mass should be said ad orientem, to the east? [/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Yes.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If yes, why? - If no, why?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]GIRM[/b] [299]: "The altar should be built apart from the wall, in such a way that it is possible to walk around it easily and that mass can be celebrated at it facing the people, which is desirable wherever possible. The altar, should moreover, be placed as to be truly the center toward which the attention of the whole congregation of the faithful naturally turns. The altar is usually fixed and is dedicated." This statement is authoritative, and thus must be adhered to, however, I believe that the correct translation from Latin which is “that it is desirable, whenever possible, to have a freestanding altar so that Mass can be able to be said facing the people.” This almost minute difference in conjunction with [i]Prot. No 2086/00/L[/i], from the [i]Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments [/i] seems to me to express that the Mass said [i]ad orientem [/i] is the default position. I believe that this is a tradition which is fully supported by the Second Vatican Council, and post-conciliar texts, and that this is the most reverential position that the priest can be in. I believe that the priest and the people, must pray together in the same direction, and that priest should not focus on a local sacrifice, but on the catholic [universal] and eternal sacrifice that cannot be confined to one place, and is celebrated in every part of the world. To argue that the priest should focus on the local sacrifice is ineffectual, the priest and the people should pray to God, not to each other. However, I believe that Mass said [i]versus populum[/i] is a valid position, but is not ideal. I do support the General Instruction's call for altars [i]pariete sejunctum[/i] or detached from the wall, because I believe this allows for a cleaner and less restricted architecture which could be beneficial aesthetically.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers? [/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I believe that extraordinary ministers of communion or viaticum, should be restricted to truly extraordinary occasions. We all admit that a Bishop is the only individual qualified to bestow the Sacrament of Confirmation, and yet priests given an extraordinary function can also bestow this sacrament. How often is this extraordinary function exercised? The answer is that it is very likely that you will never see it occur, and if you do it is under extreme conditions. This should be the attitude towards the infinitely greater sacrament, in fact in the Summa Theologiae III, 65, 3; Saint Thomas Aquinas addresses that “Absolutely speaking, the sacrament of the Eucharist is the greatest of all the sacraments…” If it is the greatest of all the sacraments, should it not be given greater consideration over the all the sacraments and greater respect. If in a truly extraordinary situation a layman is employed to distribute the Eucharist, then so be it, but I do believe that because it would take the priest more than an hour to distribute communion himself, that this is an extraordinary condition.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How often do you believe that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I can’t speak for every single minister, but I consider the vast majority, if not all, to act outside of extraordinary conditions.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How would you believe if Mass was said in Latin?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I would believe that this was a great step, however, unlike some I am not going to say that it is the only method. I would prefer Mass said in the universal language of the Church, but I would not ask for this if it would rupture the peaceful unity of the faithful. I believe that general consensus after the Council, after the implementation of the vernacular, proves that it can be beneficial to a better understanding. However, if this consensus is due not to a more accessible devotion, but the product of lax individuals I do not support it. Convenience breeds lukewarm souls, not devotion. When Latin was implemented as the liturgical language, it would have replaced koine Greek, both languages would have been considered the languages of scholars, languages that were not subject to the rapid evolution of idiomatic languages. They would not have been considered local languages, in fact the earliest use of Latin in Church documents stems from Northern Africa in the second century. I however believe that a return to Greek, would be make less sense, than a return to Latin, Fr. Adrian Fortescue states in his brilliant work on Liturgical History, that “Latin is naturally terse, austere compared with the rhetorical abundance of Greek. It would be natural tendency of Latin to curtail redundant phrases. And this terseness and austere simplicity are a noticeable mark of the Roman Mass.”

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Would you learn Latin for God?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] This question is largely a trick question, simply because the main argument against Latin is a lack of understanding by the faithful. However, I would argue that the use of a Hand Missal, or even the memorization of key phrases, plus the obvious somatic and symbolic context of at least the Missal of 1962, should keep any layman happy. Unless he is a lax individual who is a minimalist. The question was targeted at those who are unwilling to do something for God.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I do not believe that the Missal of 1969 is properly suited for somatic catechesis, it lacks form and a consistent expressive nature, however I do not believe that this is necessarily a bad thing.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I consider the Missal of 1969, said in the vernacular, to be a replacement for the poor catechetical value of the Missal, however as I said an understanding via Hand Missal would also lead to an understanding of the Mass.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I believe that it did not in many aspects.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] The Liturgy, as guided by the Holy Ghost has, naturally, and organically proceeded from one point to another. This organic growth is necessary as far as I am concerned. Pope Benedict, as the then-Cardinal Ratzinger, had theorized about returning to a pre-conciliar Missal, so as to progress from that Missal organically. It may interest, St. Thomas More to know that the Missal of St. Pius V has changed slowly, little things being added or changed, while these are no where near as significant as the 1969 reform, they show a gradual change, an organic development.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I asked this question to learn how many people actually felt that it is. I assumed that no one would. Many so-called “Traditionalists” claim that so-called “Modernist” Catholics have nothing but bad things to say about the Missal of 1962.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Again in conjunction with the above question, I hoped to draw the obvious conclusion that we are not that narrow.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Could a "liturgical pluralism" be more acceptable than "liturgical uniformity" which seems to affect both left and right wings of the argument?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I believe this is ideal, and asked because I support it whole heartedly.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I was hoping that to some degree this questionnaire could alleviate tension among the so-called “Phishy” and the so called “Liberals” [a.k.a. everyone else]. Theses factions of Catholicism should not exist, Catholicism doesn’t have factions.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I agree, for once, with Franimus, “…severity of the affairs primarily, but generally domestic affairs are more important.” Oh, and of course the questions are leading I have a ulterior motive here: understanding, tolerance, and peace.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I would be ecstatic, however I would also be confused because I believe it would cause confusion and misunderstanding.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] This was a trick question. I meant the answer to be “no”, since the ritual and materials necessary for an action of God, can never be considered materialistic. Materialism being that any benefit gained from the Mass is considered to have been gained from the matter, not the spirit of the ceremony. [This does not apply to the Eucharist], but to the vessels, vestments, and other materials necessary for Mass. I was trying to show that Catholics do not believe that we gain any benefit from the materials used, but from spirit of the ceremony and the devotion that is born from the ceremony, not to mention the necessity of the “real” flesh and blood of Christ, but even then the benefits are not from the matter itself, but from the devotion evoked from it. A man can receive communion and not gain anything from it. I believe that the root of the current return to “apostolic simplicity” is because we have been charged with a worship of matter, a worship of stone, and gold, and of incense. Thus I believe that the liturgical abuses, that are very common are reactionary to this charge against Catholics. However, untrue it is.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism."[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Another trick question. Since we naturally want to provide God with the greatest physical masterpieces of our being, we will never achieve “apostolic simplicity” in-so-far as the apostolic simplicity was simple because it lacked means, as soon as we had the means we lost the simplicity. I label “Medieval Materialism” as a the charge that we worship the art we create for God, and thus we shouldn’t create art, but return to “apostolic simplicity.” I label “Modern Materialism” as the replacement, instead of offering aesthetically pleasing worship, we offer the equivalent monetarily, except it is void of elegance and aesthetics. The terrible, concrete box at Fatima, is in no way skimping, or cheap, but it lacks beauty. The same can be said of the liturgy, we often spend as much on the material components, but we produce ugly components. In other words, I feel we should return to the so-called “Medieval Materialism,” because it is more beautiful, and is equivalent in price. St. Thomas More, while you answered my question properly, I think you meant that it has not returned to simple love of God, but to a more commercial and culturally corrupt action, which I also agree with.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Of course, I do and so does any honest Catholic. This question is here for obvious reasons, since most so-called “Traditionalists” argue that we no longer believe. “Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity” You got it right, there.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Is communion in the hand as reverential as communion on the tongue?[/b]
[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How so?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I feel that it is not, because while our tongue may technically be just as clean as our hands, psychologically our hands are the tools which engage physically in most sin, thus they become images of filth, and are unworthy of touching God, but we know that we don’t just put anything in our mouth and thus our mouth is psychologically if not physically cleaner. Plus it is a Tradition that shouldn’t be disregarded. [P.S. To be very blunt, I’m not sure how long that argument can hold up, when you imagine the widespread practice of oral sex, which makes me cringe in regard to the reception of the Eucharist.]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing?[/b]
[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How so?[/b]

“Kneeling is a posture that signifies adoration and humility while standing does not signify either.” This is where my fealty lies, in this regard, however as an act of obedience and since it is local custom, I receive on the tongue, standing, making a genuflection before receiving. St. Ambrose, said something about fasting differently if in Milan or in Rome, and I believe the proverb “When in Rome…” wholeheartedly.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] The poll says:

[indent][b]Yes.[/b] [ 7 ] [33.33%]

[b]No.[/b] [ 2 ] [9.52%]

[b]Undecided.[/b] [ 12 ] [57.14%][/indent]


This is hardly definitive. Let us see, what the final outcome is.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass?[/b]
[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How do liturgical abuses affect this expression?[/b]
[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]What do you believe are liturgical abuses?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] These questions are fairly general, and I just wanted to see personal opinion.

For an understanding of liturgical abuses, go to [url="http://catholic.com/library/liturgical_abuses.asp"]Liturgical Abuses @ Catholic Answers[/url].

[color="#CC0000"][b]Also if your not having any luck locally eliminating abuses, please consider the following alternatives:[/b][/color]

[b]If your bishop isn't doing his job, contact: [/b]
Giovanni Battista Cardinal Re
Prefect, Congregation for Bishops
Piazza Pio XII, 10
00193 Vatican City, Italy, Europe

Phone: (011) 39-6-6988-4217

[b]In case of liturgical abuse, contact: [/b]
Francis Cardinal Arinze
Prefect, Congregation for Divine Worship and Sacraments
Piazza XII, 10
00193 Vatican City, Italy, Europe

Phone: (011) 39-6-6988-4368

[b][color="#CC0000"]Response from the Poster:[/color][/b]

I believe I owe a certain explanation of the questions to you, so that they can be better understood. I will also provide my opinion in the matter, for a clarification.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice? [/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Yes, it is as has been clearly presented that it is the Sacrifice of Calvary ad infintitum, until the end of time.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] This question alone, is fairly meaningless, it was a pretext to the following questions.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Where in the Missal of 1969?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] To quote St. Thomas More, “In the Oratre Fratres and in Eucharistic Prayer I, though not in any of the other Eucharistic prayers” This is what I was looking for.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Where in the Missal of 1962?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] To once more quote St. Thomas More, “In the Oratre Fratres and most especially in the Unde et Memores' "a Victim + which is pure, a Victim + which is holy, a Victim + which is spotless, the holy Bread + of life eternal, and the Chalice + of everlasting Salvation" part of the Canon taken out of the Novus Ordo Missae.” Again, exactly what I was expecting.

I believe these are fundamental questions in the [i]Sola Missale Romanum MCMLXII [/i] [1962] vs. [i]Sola Missale Romanum MCMLXIX [/i] [1969] argument. I attempt to be a moderate in these affairs, as I see benefit in both Missals, and so should, as my opinion stands, all Catholics. One claim that many so-called “Traditional” Catholics have is that the Liturgy is no longer, in the so-called “Mainstream” Church considered a Sacrifice by the Clergy or the Laity, and that it has been expressed as, instead, a Communal Supper, like that of Protestant Denominations. I hoped through these questions to clarify that the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is still and always will be nothing more or less than exactly that.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Do you believe that the Mass should be said ad orientem, to the east? [/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Yes.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If yes, why? - If no, why?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]GIRM[/b] [299]: "The altar should be built apart from the wall, in such a way that it is possible to walk around it easily and that mass can be celebrated at it facing the people, which is desirable wherever possible. The altar, should moreover, be placed as to be truly the center toward which the attention of the whole congregation of the faithful naturally turns. The altar is usually fixed and is dedicated." This statement is authoritative, and thus must be adhered to, however, I believe that the correct translation from Latin which is “that it is desirable, whenever possible, to have a freestanding altar so that Mass can be able to be said facing the people.” This almost minute difference in conjunction with [i]Prot. No 2086/00/L[/i], from the [i]Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments [/i] seems to me to express that the Mass said [i]ad orientem [/i] is the default position. I believe that this is a tradition which is fully supported by the Second Vatican Council, and post-conciliar texts, and that this is the most reverential position that the priest can be in. I believe that the priest and the people, must pray together in the same direction, and that priest should not focus on a local sacrifice, but on the catholic [universal] and eternal sacrifice that cannot be confined to one place, and is celebrated in every part of the world. To argue that the priest should focus on the local sacrifice is ineffectual, the priest and the people should pray to God, not to each other. However, I believe that Mass said [i]versus populum[/i] is a valid position, but is not ideal. I do support the General Instruction's call for altars [i]pariete sejunctum[/i] or detached from the wall, because I believe this allows for a cleaner and less restricted architecture which could be beneficial aesthetically.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers? [/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I believe that extraordinary ministers of communion or viaticum, should be restricted to truly extraordinary occasions. We all admit that a Bishop is the only individual qualified to bestow the Sacrament of Confirmation, and yet priests given an extraordinary function can also bestow this sacrament. How often is this extraordinary function exercised? The answer is that it is very likely that you will never see it occur, and if you do it is under extreme conditions. This should be the attitude towards the infinitely greater sacrament, in fact in the Summa Theologiae III, 65, 3; Saint Thomas Aquinas addresses that “Absolutely speaking, the sacrament of the Eucharist is the greatest of all the sacraments…” If it is the greatest of all the sacraments, should it not be given greater consideration over the all the sacraments and greater respect. If in a truly extraordinary situation a layman is employed to distribute the Eucharist, then so be it, but I do believe that because it would take the priest more than an hour to distribute communion himself, that this is an extraordinary condition.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How often do you believe that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I can’t speak for every single minister, but I consider the vast majority, if not all, to act outside of extraordinary conditions.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How would you believe if Mass was said in Latin?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I would believe that this was a great step, however, unlike some I am not going to say that it is the only method. I would prefer Mass said in the universal language of the Church, but I would not ask for this if it would rupture the peaceful unity of the faithful. I believe that general consensus after the Council, after the implementation of the vernacular, proves that it can be beneficial to a better understanding. However, if this consensus is due not to a more accessible devotion, but the product of lax individuals I do not support it. Convenience breeds lukewarm souls, not devotion. When Latin was implemented as the liturgical language, it would have replaced koine Greek, both languages would have been considered the languages of scholars, languages that were not subject to the rapid evolution of idiomatic languages. They would not have been considered local languages, in fact the earliest use of Latin in Church documents stems from Northern Africa in the second century. I however believe that a return to Greek, would be make less sense, than a return to Latin, Fr. Adrian Fortescue states in his brilliant work on Liturgical History, that “Latin is naturally terse, austere compared with the rhetorical abundance of Greek. It would be natural tendency of Latin to curtail redundant phrases. And this terseness and austere simplicity are a noticeable mark of the Roman Mass.”

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Would you learn Latin for God?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] This question is largely a trick question, simply because the main argument against Latin is a lack of understanding by the faithful. However, I would argue that the use of a Hand Missal, or even the memorization of key phrases, plus the obvious somatic and symbolic context of at least the Missal of 1962, should keep any layman happy. Unless he is a lax individual who is a minimalist. The question was targeted at those who are unwilling to do something for God.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I do not believe that the Missal of 1969 is properly suited for somatic catechesis, it lacks form and a consistent expressive nature, however I do not believe that this is necessarily a bad thing.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I consider the Missal of 1969, said in the vernacular, to be a replacement for the poor catechetical value of the Missal, however as I said an understanding via Hand Missal would also lead to an understanding of the Mass.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I believe that it did not in many aspects.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] The Liturgy, as guided by the Holy Ghost has, naturally, and organically proceeded from one point to another. This organic growth is necessary as far as I am concerned. Pope Benedict, as the then-Cardinal Ratzinger, had theorized about returning to a pre-conciliar Missal, so as to progress from that Missal organically. It may interest, St. Thomas More to know that the Missal of St. Pius V has changed slowly, little things being added or changed, while these are no where near as significant as the 1969 reform, they show a gradual change, an organic development.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I asked this question to learn how many people actually felt that it is. I assumed that no one would. Many so-called “Traditionalists” claim that so-called “Modernist” Catholics have nothing but bad things to say about the Missal of 1962.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Again in conjunction with the above question, I hoped to draw the obvious conclusion that we are not that narrow.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Could a "liturgical pluralism" be more acceptable than "liturgical uniformity" which seems to affect both left and right wings of the argument?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I believe this is ideal, and asked because I support it whole heartedly.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I was hoping that to some degree this questionnaire could alleviate tension among the so-called “Phishy” and the so called “Liberals” [a.k.a. everyone else]. Theses factions of Catholicism should not exist, Catholicism doesn’t have factions.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I agree, for once, with Franimus, “…severity of the affairs primarily, but generally domestic affairs are more important.” Oh, and of course the questions are leading I have a ulterior motive here: understanding, tolerance, and peace.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I would be ecstatic, however I would also be confused because I believe it would cause confusion and misunderstanding.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] This was a trick question. I meant the answer to be “no”, since the ritual and materials necessary for an action of God, can never be considered materialistic. Materialism being that any benefit gained from the Mass is considered to have been gained from the matter, not the spirit of the ceremony. [This does not apply to the Eucharist], but to the vessels, vestments, and other materials necessary for Mass. I was trying to show that Catholics do not believe that we gain any benefit from the materials used, but from spirit of the ceremony and the devotion that is born from the ceremony, not to mention the necessity of the “real” flesh and blood of Christ, but even then the benefits are not from the matter itself, but from the devotion evoked from it. A man can receive communion and not gain anything from it. I believe that the root of the current return to “apostolic simplicity” is because we have been charged with a worship of matter, a worship of stone, and gold, and of incense. Thus I believe that the liturgical abuses, that are very common are reactionary to this charge against Catholics. However, untrue it is.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism."[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Another trick question. Since we naturally want to provide God with the greatest physical masterpieces of our being, we will never achieve “apostolic simplicity” in-so-far as the apostolic simplicity was simple because it lacked means, as soon as we had the means we lost the simplicity. I label “Medieval Materialism” as a the charge that we worship the art we create for God, and thus we shouldn’t create art, but return to “apostolic simplicity.” I label “Modern Materialism” as the replacement, instead of offering aesthetically pleasing worship, we offer the equivalent monetarily, except it is void of elegance and aesthetics. The terrible, concrete box at Fatima, is in no way skimping, or cheap, but it lacks beauty. The same can be said of the liturgy, we often spend as much on the material components, but we produce ugly components. In other words, I feel we should return to the so-called “Medieval Materialism,” because it is more beautiful, and is equivalent in price. St. Thomas More, while you answered my question properly, I think you meant that it has not returned to simple love of God, but to a more commercial and culturally corrupt action, which I also agree with.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] Of course, I do and so does any honest Catholic. This question is here for obvious reasons, since most so-called “Traditionalists” argue that we no longer believe. “Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity” You got it right, there.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Is communion in the hand as reverential as communion on the tongue?[/b]
[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How so?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] I feel that it is not, because while our tongue may technically be just as clean as our hands, psychologically our hands are the tools which engage physically in most sin, thus they become images of filth, and are unworthy of touching God, but we know that we don’t just put anything in our mouth and thus our mouth is psychologically if not physically cleaner. Plus it is a Tradition that shouldn’t be disregarded. [P.S. To be very blunt, I’m not sure how long that argument can hold up, when you imagine the widespread practice of oral sex, which makes me cringe in regard to the reception of the Eucharist.]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing?[/b]
[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How so?[/b]

“Kneeling is a posture that signifies adoration and humility while standing does not signify either.” This is where my fealty lies, in this regard, however as an act of obedience and since it is local custom, I receive on the tongue, standing, making a genuflection before receiving. St. Ambrose, said something about fasting differently if in Milan or in Rome, and I believe the proverb “When in Rome…” wholeheartedly.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] The poll says:

[indent][b]Yes.[/b] [ 7 ] [33.33%]

[b]No.[/b] [ 2 ] [9.52%]

[b]Undecided.[/b] [ 12 ] [57.14%][/indent]


This is hardly definitive. Let us see, what the final outcome is.

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass?[/b]
[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]How do liturgical abuses affect this expression?[/b]
[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] [b]What do you believe are liturgical abuses?[/b]

[color="#CC0000"]¤ [/color] These questions are fairly general, and I just wanted to see personal opinion.

For an understanding of liturgical abuses, go to [url="http://catholic.com/library/liturgical_abuses.asp"]Liturgical Abuses @ Catholic Answers[/url].

[color="#CC0000"][b]Also if your not having any luck locally eliminating abuses, please consider the following alternatives:[/b][/color]

[b]If your bishop isn't doing his job, contact: [/b]
Giovanni Battista Cardinal Re
Prefect, Congregation for Bishops
Piazza Pio XII, 10
00193 Vatican City, Italy, Europe

Phone: (011) 39-6-6988-4217

[b]In case of liturgical abuse, contact: [/b]
Francis Cardinal Arinze
Prefect, Congregation for Divine Worship and Sacraments
Piazza XII, 10
00193 Vatican City, Italy, Europe

Phone: (011) 39-6-6988-4368

Posted (edited)

¤ Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice?

Yes

¤ What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice?

The Consecration, 'See the Victim'

¤ Where in the Missal of 1969?

See above answer

¤ Where in the Missal of 1962?

The majority of the prayers, ceremonies, the presumed intentions and attitude of the celebrant

¤ Do you believe that the Mass should be said ad orientem, to the east?

Yes. But if it's facing the people, it's just as traditional.

¤ If yes, why? - If no, why?

Traditional and Apostolic.

¤ What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers?

One of the biggest mistakes ever made in liturgical history.

¤ How often do you feel that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition?

Never. For me a real extraordinary minister is the deacon.

¤ How would you feel if Mass was said in Latin?

My preference. My favorite liturgical- and most proper, next to Greek- langauge.

¤ Would you learn Latin for God?

Re-phrase the question. I already understand, write and speak most of it- especially ecclesiastical, and relating to the Liturgy.

¤ Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual?

Not as well as the older Missals- but then again if you didn't understand it, what difference did it make? Not much. The majority of it doesn't properly catechise- and as Cardinal George admitted last month there was the effort- and the success in eliminating sacrificial language.

¤ If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular?

No.

¤ Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962?

No. Even ask EWTN host Fr. Levis.

¤ Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth?

I'm not sure. Maybe- but present this reform as just another Western/Latin Catholic rite, e.g. along with the Tridentine, Dominican, Ambrosian, etc.

¤ What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief?

None.

¤ If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it?

Because they don't know any better and they're radical/extreme liberals/modernists, brainwashed against the older rites.

¤ Could a "liturgical pluralism" be more acceptable than "liturgical uniformity" which seems to affect
both left and right wings of the argument?

Perhaps...

¤ If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders?

Most definitely.

¤ Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic?

Depends.

¤ If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react?

As much as I love it- concerned.

¤ Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity?

No. That's condemned by Trent.

¤ Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism."

Modern materialism- see World Youth Day/John Paul II liturgies, as well as 'Catholic' Masses for children...

¤ Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist?

Yes.

¤ Is communion in the hand a reverential as communion on the tongue?

Absolutely not.

¤ How so?

It automatically guarantees sacrilege, irreverence, and can lead to heresy (as do 'Eucharistic Ministers')

¤ Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing?

Yes

¤ How so?

You stand with your equals- you kneel to those superior- to kings and to God.

¤ Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice?

Not really, especially with the ICEL edition...

¤ Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass?

See above.

¤ How do liturgical abuses affect this expression?

Well, it makes it worse...

¤ What do you believe are liturgical abuses?

Any female 'ministry', changing/ignoring prayers and ceremonies/rituals, Communion in the hand/Eucharistic ministers, the lack of a paten, proper vestments, etc. I could go on..

Remember that I acknowledge the validity of the Novus Ordo Missae, and am not schismatic.

Edited by brendan1104
kenrockthefirst
Posted

Quite frankly, I don't feel qualified to intelligently respond to all of these questions. However, let me respond to some of these by asking a few questions of my own.

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Do you believe that the Mass should be said [i]ad orientem[/i], to the east?

What's special about the east? Because it points toward Jerusalem? What if we're east of Jerusalem? I don't mean to be facetious, I really don't know. However, this kind of thing smacks of "magical thinking," IMHO. The Mass is, in part, a celebration, and it seems odd that the celebrant wouldn't make eye contact with his co-celebrants, so to speak.

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How would you feel if Mass was said in Latin?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Would you learn Latin for God?

Quite frankly, I'm puzzled about all the fuss over Latin. The Old Testament was written in Hebrew, the New Testament in Greek. The Vulgate, a translation of the original NT Greek manuscripts and the Septuagint, a Greek translation of the Old Testament, happened to be written in Latin because that was the language of the Roman Empire. Indeed, Vulgate, derived from [i]vulgar[/i], simply refers to the common, everyday spoken language. What makes Latin any more special or reverent or holy than English, French, Spanish, Russian, German, etc.?

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Is communion in the hand a reverential as communion on the tongue?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How so?

I'm not sure on this score. Certainly, the chance for accidental slippage of the host from one's hand is greater than from the tongue. Still, objections to receipt of communion in the hand based on the fact that our hands are "more sinful" than our tongues seems a bit far-fetched. Our hands are flesh, muscle and bone, while our tongues are simple muscle. Sin exists in the heart (and I don't mean that muscular organ that pumps our blood). That's the whole point of declaring our sinfulness and asking forgiveness during Mass, and declaring our unworthiness to receive Christ, who nonetheless makes Himself available to us in the Eucharist [i]precisely because[/i] we are sinners.

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing?
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color] How so?

This may be a cultural thing. If I'm not mistaken, in the Eastern Orthodox traditions, the participants stand throughout the entire ritual. Of course, even in Western tradition, it is a sign of respect to stand when someone enters the room. I think that a case can be made that standing is equally a sign of respect as kneeling. Having said that, I think that there are other issues to get more exercised about than whether one kneels or stands to receive communion.

The above answers are made with every good faith intention and I welcome answers to / feedback on same.

Regards,
Ken

Posted

"Ad Orientum" literally means "towards the east" and most churches have always been built so that they faced the literal east, but more importantly it refers to the "liturgical east", meaning that the priest and congregation both face the same way. This is most easily accomplished (and of course shows more unity) if every Church throughout the world has the priest and people face the same way. It's not "towards Jerusalem" though. Christ Himself said He would return from the east, it's a great symbolic direction to face. The more important thing is that the priest and people face the same way (what the untrained eye sees as 'the priest turning his back on the people') because the priest is offering the sacrifice on behalf of the people to God. The symbolism of the priest facing the people is still [i]supposed[/i] to reflect this, but if you're honest with yourself you'll admit it didn't reflect this to you. Why? Because the positioning is confusing. The liturgical east to which everyone is supposed to be looking is the Altar; but since you see the priest's eyes you are looking at the priest and the priest is looking at you; the altar is just in the middle. The only way to make this work better is to put a giant crucifix in between the congregation and the priest, IMHO. And that crucifix should be large enough to distract your sight away from looking at the priest and be looking at the same thing that the priest is looking at. Otherwise, the position versus populum should just be abolished. the priest and people are supposed to be facing the same direction, in ad orientum and versus populum. ad orientum is just the least problematic.

Just as a note: when churches in the past which were built with an altar facing the west like St. Peter's, the priest would say the mass behind the altar facing the people and at the consecration the entire congregation would turn around so that everyone was facing the direction Christ said He would return from together to greet him.

Personally, the few times I still attend a Novus Ordo Missae, I kind of sneak my neck around to face behind me (as unnoticably as possible) as a symbol of my greeting Christ as He returns from the Liturgical East to become present in the Eucharist. Only once did someone notice me doing this and gave me a funny look :ninja:

As regards the long list of questions: I feel they have been adequately answered by Fides, St Thomas More, and Petrus and would not disagree with any of those answers.

Mitchell_b55
Posted

haven't time to respond to the other questions posed by Kenrockthefirst, but I will. I feel that in response to his questions on ad orientem, Aloysius has answered sufficiently. I will mention that these questions, while seeming trivial, are important since worship is so integral the form of worship is also integral, not to mention that these things were not-so-trivial that great men have argued over their significance. Ha, I just noticed I posted the same message twice in the same post, LOL I always type long messages in word and then post them, I must have hit paste twice, and then the Phorum died, and I couldn't check it. I thank everyone for their responses.

By the way, who doesn't believe in the literal sacrafice, I asked ONLY Catholics to post.

Posted

1. Yes
2. Yes
3. Undecided

Now for the more detailed questions:

¤ Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice? Yes.

¤ What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice? i dont udnerstand the question..

¤ Where in the Missal of 1969? The Roman Canon (Eucharistic Prayer 1)
¤ Where in the Missal of 1962? the Eucharist is constantly referred to as a Sacrifice.
¤ Do you believe that the Mass should be said ad orientem, to the east? YES!
¤ If yes, why? - If no, why? We are all facing God! Not each other.
¤ What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers? I never really liked the idea..I like recieving from a Priest. There have been a lot of abuses surrounding the EM's.
¤ How often do you feel that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition? Honestly? not much..
¤ How would you feel if Mass was said in Latin? Everywhere? I would love it. i go to a Latin Novus Ordo Missae.
¤ Would you learn Latin for God? Yes! of course. I love Latin anyhow.
¤ Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual? In practice or in theory? It has in some places, hasnt in others. In practice and theory.
¤ If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular? I dunno..
¤ Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962? Not all of its practices...no.
¤ Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth? Yes if that is what the holder of the keys wishes.
¤ What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief? None.
¤ If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it? People often hate what they dont understand. They often hate what they fear as well.
¤ If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders? Of course.
¤ Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic? In a sense.
¤ If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react? With great joy, actually.
¤ Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity? No..
¤ Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism." A little bit of both.
¤ Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist? Yes.
¤ Is communion in the hand as reverential as communion on the tongue? No. i recieve by intinction.
¤ How so? I've seen kids play with the host, Ive seen people attempt to steal the host..things like that.
¤ Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing? Yes.
¤ How so? when we kneel at mass, we are showing adoration.
¤ Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice? It does, but now adays its very hard to find.
¤ Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass? In some places. Its hard to find.
¤ How do liturgical abuses affect this expression? They distort the mass and hinder the faithful.
¤ What do you believe are liturgical abuses? various add ons and removals, music and actions that do not belong at mass...

Posted

Pauline Missal of 1969

Forgive my limits of studying. But, I am not familiar with the Pauline Missal...

Posted

That's the one which is in use now, also popularly referred to as the "Novus Ordo Missae". It is the current Missa Normativa of the Roman Rite of the Church. You probably hear it in English every week.

The 1962 missal is in essence the same missal as the Tridentine (from the Council of Trent) codification of the Mass with a few minor alterations over the centuries.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1045494' date='Aug 17 2006, 04:11 PM']There are three prerequisites to answering these questions:

[color="#CC0000"][b]I want those in question:[/b] [/color]

[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...to be baptised and catechised Catholics.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...to answer honestly all inquiries.
[color="#CC0000"]¤[/color]...answer without personal judgment or bias against either the Missal of 1962 or 1969, whether that bias exists or not.
[/quote]

Wow, I'm almost glad I don't qualify to answer these questions. I'd be here all night! :) But props to ya for wanting to go in depth.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

I'll answer the questions I feel I can answer without going and researching stuff.
For the first three I answered
Yes,
Yes,
and Yes. I didn't know whether to put Yes or Undecided at first, but foster has to do with feeding what is already there. If someone already has "devotion and understanding of this sacrifice", how could going to Mass [i]not[/i] foster that? (unless, of course, the Mass were treated as a joke)


[b]¤ Do you believe that the Mass is a literal sacrifice?[/b]
Yes

[b]¤ What part of the Canon symbolically represents, clearly and obviously, that it is a literal sacrifice?[/b]
[b]¤ Where in the Missal of 1969?[/b]
[b]¤ Where in the Missal of 1962?[/b]
I don't know the Canon by heart (well, not all of it, anyway). I know (mostly from debates) that both contain direct references, but that they are far more plentiful in the Missal of 1962.
There are clear references in Eucharistic Prayer I.

[b]¤ Do you believe that the Mass should be said ad orientem, to the east?[/b]
[b]¤ If yes, why? - If no, why?[/b]
I like the symbolism of it, but I don't know that I'd actually like it, or whether it would in fact help me to pray or not.

[b]¤ What is your opinion of extraordinary ministers?[/b]
They should be extraodinary, well trained, and everyone should know that they're extraordinary.

[b]¤ How often do you feel that they are actually acting in an extraordinary condition?[/b]
Not often enough. Too often the people organizing things don't take into account that they should be extraordinary, and once a parish is used to doing things a certain way, it takes a courageous and wise priest to successfully implement change.

[b]¤ How would you feel if Mass was said in Latin?[/b]
I don't know. I like using some Latin, and while I don't know Latin, I can sometimes sort of understand what's being said, even if I don't know the words (at least, I can when it's the Mass, which I am familiar with).

[b]¤ Would you learn Latin for God?[/b]
I hope so. Learn it how well? with what priority? I like languages & learning about them, but I don't like learning them. It just doesn't seem to me to be something that ought to be very high priority (learning Latin well, that is: learning enough to be familiar with the Mass in Latin or some chants might have a little more priority).

[b]¤ Does the Missal of 1969 properly catechise through the somatic components of the ritual?[/b]
meaning through what the members of the congregation do? or see the priest do? I'm not terribly familiar with the word somatic. But in any case, I don't think the Missal of 1969 catechises all that well. No comment as to how it compares with the Mass pre-VII. The priest did more stuff that I like, the congregetion did less, and the catechises could have come from the nuns as opposed to the Mass.

[b]¤ If not, is this lack of symbolism replaced by a better catechesis via language, i.e. the vernacular?[/b]
Again, I really don't know enough to compare.

[b]¤ Did the Missal of 1969 evolve organically from the Missal of 1962?[/b]
Whatever developing organically is, the Missal of 1969 didn't do it.

[b]¤ Should we, as Pope Benedict XVI, recommends return to a "reform the reform" and allow a more organic growth?[/b]
I haven't read his book, and I don't know what he means by a "reform the reform", but I hear it's good. Some stuff needs to change. It would then be more consistent with the Missal of 1962, but I don't know how much the changes themselves would be organic.

[b]¤ What part of the Missal of 1962 is adverse to Catholic belief?[/b]
Somehow I don't think any part is.

[b]¤ If there is nothing adverse to Catholic belief, why do so many Catholics act viciously towards it?[/b]
Perhaps they (the older ones) feel an attachment to the Missal of 1969 as 'their' Mass. Perhaps some of them have bad memories associated with the Mass according to the Missal of 1962. And if they associate the 'new' Mass with the revolution during the 60's, and identify themselves with that, then I suppose they might be very protective of it.
Perhaps they feel that the richness and ornateness of the Missal of 1962 hides the simplicity and humility of God.
Perhaps some of them feel that it is objectionable because riches are spent on the church while the poor and homeless suffer, and when we neglect them, we neglect God. I.e., we care too much about the liturgy, and not enough about God in the disguise of those suffering around us. (I desire mercy and not sacrifice + whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me type of stuff)
I can think of other reasons for a simple personal preference, but not for responding viciously.

[b]¤ Could a "liturgical pluralism" be more acceptable than "liturgical uniformity" which seems to affect both left and right wings of the argument?[/b]
Liturgical uniformity seems to affect both sides???? I know I like some variety, as long as nothing is kooky. I like being able to go to a more solemn, closer-to-the-Missal-of-1962 Mass (as should be found in Cathedrals and basilicas) but also be able to go to a less formal Mass at, say, the family camp I go to which, while still reverent (probably the most reverent Masses I have assisted at have been in that chapel), might have clapping during the recessional and be otherwise influenced in non-kooky ways by the charismatic movement, with music closer to what is associated with Life Teen (at least, the Life Teen parish in Ottawa). But those are also the Masses where we use the most Latin, and some people will kneel for Communion, and it's not weird or holier-than-thou. And then there are the Masses at my parish, which are more stressful because we're in charge of so much, and that have all sorts of things that need changing, but it's home.
Also, I'd love to go to a Divine Liturgy, and when you go to Mass in French, stuff hits you in a new way.

[b]¤ If we are so concerned with ecumenism and world peace, should we not first find peace within our own borders?[/b]
Don't both need to be worked on at the same time?

[b]¤ Thus stated, are foreign affairs more integral than domestic?[/b]
Aren't they both?

[b]¤ If the Missal of 1962 were implemented tomorrow, and the Missal of 1969 withdrawn how would you react?[/b]
with shock. That would be an insane move, pastorally. How many priests know it, or even Latin? And completely changing what a parish does at Sunday Mass wasn't a good idea then and it isn't now.

[b]¤ Is the Missal of 1962's preoccupation with liturgical ritual more materialistic than the Missal of 1969's preoccupation with a return to apostolic simplicity?[/b]
The Missal of 1962 attempts to have a wealth of symbolism, the Missal of 1962 attempts to be simple. They suit different temperments and even different situations and moods.

[b]¤ Has this "apostolic simplicity" been achieved or has the so-called "medieval materialism" been replaced with so-called "modern materialism."[/b]
That would depend from priest to priest, parish to parish, diocese to diocese.

[b]¤ Do you believe that the host transubstantiates during the consecration of the Eucharist?[/b]
Of course

[b]¤ Is communion in the hand a reverential as communion on the tongue?[/b]
It can be.

[b]¤ How so?[/b]
Some would find receiving on the tongue especially meaningful, for others receiving in the hand is especially meaningful.
Besides, while the body reflects and affects the spirit, doing something in a certain way doesn't guarantee an interior disposition.

[b]¤ Is communion received kneeling a more reverential position than that of standing?[/b]
It can be. It can also be used hypocritically.

[b]¤ How so?[/b]
I already said that the body reflects and affects the spirit, and while I probably didn't say that in the best of ways, you get the point.


[b]¤ Does the Pauline Missal of 1969 foster devotion and understanding of this sacrifice?[/b]
Yes (see what I wrote at the top)

[b]¤ Does it clearly express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass?[/b]
I doubt I've ever been at a Mass that was said exactly according to the Missal of 1969. Maybe at the Legionnaries...
In any case, I certainly have been at Masses according to the Missal of 1969 that did express the meaning and sacredness of the Mass.
You also have to be aware that if people are used to seeing that meaning and sacredness expressed using certain specific actions, ect., then they might have trouble recognizing it without those specific actions, etc.

[b]¤ How do liturgical abuses affect this expression?[/b]
Variously: they can damage it, damage it seriously, damage it to the point where it's almost invisible, not affect it, and, in some circumstances, add to it.
That's defining abuses as anything that isn't exactly how the Missal specifies.

[b]¤ What do you believe are liturgical abuses?[/b]
Well, my definition is just above.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...