Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Lord's Supper - Metaphor only?


Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

A common arguement against the Eucharist is that Jesus was simply speaking metaphorically. He says I am the vine and yet we know he is not a vine. He said "I am the door" but yet he is not made of wood. He even says "I am the bread of life". No he is not bread either. I most definitely agree with that. When he says this he is in fact speaking metaphorically. Bread is a symbol of Christ for bread has been the primary food historically throughout history for mankind. The langauge of "I am the...." is metaphore. Up to this point I think we can agree.
But are we limited to one view of God. By this I mean that can the meaphore be the reality. In John's Gospel we see the baptism of Jesus and the Holy Spirit appears.

John.1
[32] And John bore witness, "I saw the Spirit descend as a dove from heaven, and it remained on him.
Luke.3
[22] and the Holy Spirit descended upon him in bodily form, as a dove, and a voice came from heaven, "Thou art my beloved Son; with thee I am well pleased."
Now doves have been developed in the metaphorical sense as symbols of peace and so that is the symbol that the Holy Spirit appears as. Was their a dove there? No, it was the Holy Spirit appearing as a dove. Yet I think there was physically (i.e.) bodily the Holy Spirit there, just as the man Jesus embodied the Son of God, Jesus. God can be in the physical.

Now the significance of this is that there are some passages that simply do not fit the metaphore with regard to the Lord's Supper. We are told that "unless you eat the flesh of the son of man and drink his blood you shall not have life within you". "my flesh is true food, my blood is true drink". Quite clearly this is not the language of metaphore for never anywhere else does Jesus say "this door is truly me" or this "vine is truly me". This is not the language of metaphore but reality. That he used metaphoric language above it does not mean that he is speaking metaphorically here. Neither is there a contradiction in using the metaphore of bread and then speaking the reality of what looks like bread (the metaphore) really being him. "This is my body...this is my blood". Rememberence is not symolic either. Though the symbol of bread helps us to remember that he is in fact feeding us. Feeding our souls with his flesh that he says was to be given for the LIFE OF THE WORLD. In the Old Testament the blood of the animal was considered to contain the life of the animal. With regard to Christ when we recieve his flesh and his blood his life becomes a part of our lives. We become what we eat and are restored to his image and likeness.

Blessings

Edited by thessalonian
kenrockthefirst
Posted

met·a·phor Pronunciation Key (mt-fôr, -fr)
n.

1. A figure of speech in which a word or phrase that ordinarily designates one thing is used to designate another, thus making an implicit comparison, as in “a sea of troubles” or “All the world's a stage” (Shakespeare).
2. One thing conceived as representing another; a symbol: “Hollywood has always been an irresistible, prefabricated metaphor for the crass, the materialistic, the shallow, and the craven” (Neal Gabler).

I don't think that the use of a metaphor necessarily means that what is being spoken of metaphorically is any less "true" or "real" because it has been described using a metaphor. For example, when Jesus says that he is a "door," while he is not made of wood he *is* a portal and in that sense *really* is a door; when he says that he is a "vine," while he is made of plant matter he is a source of "sap," i.e. sustenance, life, and in that sense *really* is a vine. In the definition above, a metaphor is described as a symbol. One excellent description of heard of the difference between a sign and symbol is that a sign points toward a reality while a symbol participates in the reality to which it points. Certainly, I think it's fair to say that the sacraments fall into the metaphor / symbol category. That is, participation in the sacraments is participation in something real but at a level above or apart from what we perceive in the natural world, i.e. they are [i]super[/i]natural. So while in baptism, for example, we don't *actually* experience physical death, on a metaphorical / symbolic / spiritual level, we *do* participate in Jesus' death and resurrection. It's a metaphor but no less real for being so.

My two cents,
Ken

thessalonian
Posted

Point well taken. I agree.

Posted

Another point to ponder.

The institution of the Eucharist occured at the Pasover. Jesus could have grabbed the flesh of the lamb, but grabbed the bread instead.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='jswranch' post='1049535' date='Aug 24 2006, 04:28 AM']
Another point to ponder.

The institution of the Eucharist occured at the Pasover. Jesus could have grabbed the flesh of the lamb, but grabbed the bread instead.
[/quote]


Yes, if he just wanted a symbol of himself he had one on the table already. :bigthink:

Edited by thessalonian
kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1049535' date='Aug 24 2006, 03:28 AM']
Another point to ponder.

The institution of the Eucharist occured at the Pasover. Jesus could have grabbed the flesh of the lamb, but grabbed the bread instead.
[/quote]

While the paschal or passover lamb clearly prefigures Jesus, so does manna, which Jesus specifically refers to in John 6. In addition, in that same chapter, Jesus refers to himself as the "bread of life," and declares that "whoever comes to [Him] will never hunger..."

I think the point must be that Jesus is our sustenance, our life, and that we must partake of Him in order to live.

Posted

Yes, there is no dialectic between symbol and reality necessarily.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...