Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

King James Version


Recommended Posts

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted

+JMJ+


Why is it that Protestants are so insistant upon the King James Version of the Bible?

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

I've determined it's a sinster plot by the magesterium of protestant churches to keep the bible in the vernacular (american english) out of the hands of the people so they can be exploited and kept in bondage. ;). Just having fun. Don't mean to derail the thread. Carry on. :lol_roll:

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

[quote]+JMJ+


Why is it that Protestants are so insistant upon the King James Version of the Bible? [/quote]

My grandmother believes that its the only translation that should be followed. Because, they believe its the closest possible to the real Bible itself.

This what she has told me. I like the old english structure, but I very much dislike King James himself.

thessalonian
Posted

On the more serious side it is problematic for the Sola Scriptura side of things though I think it is an outgrowth of that. In order to say that the Bible is infallible and the sole rule of faith they have to have infallible translations. This allows them to be able to say that it can rule individual lives rather than the dreaded church hierarchy. The problem they have of course is that they have a doctrine of infallibility of men in translating scirptures that they have no biblical foundation for. This biblical translation infallibility is outside of the bible and so they violate what they are trying to justify. In a nutshell it is a convenient way of "logically" getting around problems in their theology regarding scripture that contradict logic and truth. i.e. the Bible is the sole rule of faith.

I also find it interesting that they have this KJO position and there are hundreds of other languages in the world. What is special about the KJ language? Is there a KCV (King Charles Version ) for the spanish or a KPV for the french or whoever their kings were. Of course then there is the issue of putting a man's name on the cover of the scriptures. Isn't that a form of idolatry according to their views. Of course they won't directly address these things.

It's funny I asked a KJO guy about the other languages the other day. He said that Bibles from other languages have to be translated from the original manuscripts (which really don't exist) or the KJV.

thessalonian
Posted

On the more serious side it is problematic for the Sola Scriptura side of things though I think it is an outgrowth of that. In order to say that the Bible is infallible and the sole rule of faith they have to have infallible translations. This allows them to be able to say that it can rule individual lives rather than the dreaded church hierarchy. The problem they have of course is that they have a doctrine of infallibility of men in translating scirptures that they have no biblical foundation for. This biblical translation infallibility is outside of the bible and so they violate what they are trying to justify. In a nutshell it is a convenient way of "logically" getting around problems in their theology regarding scripture that contradict logic and truth. i.e. the Bible is the sole rule of faith.

I also find it interesting that they have this KJO position and there are hundreds of other languages in the world. What is special about the KJ language? Is there a KCV (King Charles Version ) for the spanish or a KPV for the french or whoever their kings were. Of course then there is the issue of putting a man's name on the cover of the scriptures. Isn't that a form of idolatry according to their views. Of course they won't directly address these things.

It's funny I asked a KJO guy about the other languages the other day. He said that Bibles from other languages have to be translated from the original manuscripts (which really don't exist) or the KJV.

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='Fulton Sheen Warrior' post='1049678' date='Aug 24 2006, 11:07 AM']
+JMJ+
Why is it that Protestants are so insistant upon the King James Version of the Bible?
[/quote]

There's a lot of historical baggage associated with that particular translation of the bible, which was published in 1611. The KJV was translated in England during the crucible of the first century of the Protestant Reformation in the particular historical / political / religious context of the rivalry between Spain and England. It was very self-consciously a [i]Protestant[/i] bible, particularly in the sense that King James (baptized a Catholic, BTW, although raised in the Scottish court as a Protestant), as the head of the Church of England, was a "rival" to the Pope. Accordingly, in the reformed traditions, the KJV is still very self-consciously a [i]Protestant[/i] bible, and by the weight of history and tradition often afforded a special status as being "the" Word of God. It also happens to be a particularly beautiful and poetic translation of scripture, which is neither here nor there, but does speak to its enduring quality (as opposed to other documents, Shakespeare excluded, from the 17th century which are no longer commonly used).

thessalonian
Posted

On the more serious side it is problematic for the Sola Scriptura side of things though I think it is an outgrowth of that. In order to say that the Bible is infallible and the sole rule of faith they have to have infallible translations. This allows them to be able to say that it can rule individual lives rather than the dreaded church hierarchy. The problem they have of course is that they have a doctrine of infallibility of men in translating scirptures that they have no biblical foundation for. This biblical translation infallibility is outside of the bible and so they violate what they are trying to justify. In a nutshell it is a convenient way of "logically" getting around problems in their theology regarding scripture that contradict logic and truth. i.e. the Bible is the sole rule of faith.

I also find it interesting that they have this KJO position and there are hundreds of other languages in the world. What is special about the KJ language? Is there a KCV (King Charles Version ) for the spanish or a KPV for the french or whoever their kings were. Of course then there is the issue of putting a man's name on the cover of the scriptures. Isn't that a form of idolatry according to their views. Of course they won't directly address these things.

It's funny I asked a KJO guy about the other languages the other day. He said that Bibles from other languages have to be translated from the original manuscripts (which really don't exist) or the KJV.

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='Fulton Sheen Warrior' post='1049678' date='Aug 24 2006, 11:07 AM']
+JMJ+
Why is it that Protestants are so insistant upon the King James Version of the Bible?
[/quote]

There's a lot of historical baggage associated with that particular translation of the bible, which was published in 1611. The KJV was translated in England during the crucible of the first century of the Protestant Reformation in the particular historical / political / religious context of the rivalry between Spain and England. It was very self-consciously a [i]Protestant[/i] bible, particularly in the sense that King James (baptized a Catholic, BTW, although raised in the Scottish court as a Protestant), as the head of the Church of England, was a "rival" to the Pope. Accordingly, in the reformed traditions, the KJV is still very self-consciously a [i]Protestant[/i] bible, and by the weight of history and tradition often afforded a special status as being "the" Word of God. It also happens to be a particularly beautiful and poetic translation of scripture, which is neither here nor there, but does speak to its enduring quality (as opposed to other documents, Shakespeare excluded, from the 17th century which are no longer commonly used).

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted

+JMJ+

[quote]I've determined it's a sinster plot by the magesterium of protestant churches to keep the bible in the vernacular (american english) out of the hands of the people so they can be exploited and kept in bondage.[/quote]

Oh come now Thess! That's rediculous! It's obviously a Calvanist tactic used to brainwash and manipulate the masses!!!






J/K :lol_roll:



Very interesting, thankyou!

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1049685' date='Aug 24 2006, 11:20 AM']Of course then there is the issue of putting a man's name on the cover of the scriptures. Isn't that a form of idolatry according to their views. Of course they won't directly address these things.[/quote]

BTW, as an aside, the "official" name of the KJV is the "Authoris/zed Version."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...