Crusader_4 Posted August 24, 2006 Posted August 24, 2006 Here is a tricky one I have been trying to figure out, and I would like some expert advice on this one. I can understand completly the church's position on how a marriage is still sacremental between to validly baptised adults one Catholic and one Protestant when they chose to be married. Here is my question though there are many many anabaptist protestant denominations that do not practice a sacramental baptism. In such a case that say a baptised Catholic man wanted to marry a girl from a group like this for instance a mennonite would their marriage first be allowed by the Church, frowned upon? and most importantly in some ways sacremental? My next question is that my understanding of matrimony in the latin sense of the sacrement is that the sacrament is administered by the man and the women to each other as in contrast to the eastern church's understanding of the role of the priest who is more active as a channel of Grace (correct my understanding if i am wrong). Thus us, in the latin church, would accept for example any eastern churches marriage. However, would the eastern churches accept our marriages if it is overseen by a deacon as sacremental and for example (correct me again if I am wrong) us in the latin church would accept for example the marriage between two baptised high anglicans as sacremental, however would the eastern churches particularly the orthodox accept this seeing as how the anglican church does contain valid apostolic succession? Thus would there be a great difference in theolgoy that is contradictory and at odds with each other in such a case, and who would be correct? Particuarly between us and the Eastern churches that are in communion with the Supreme Pontiff. Thanks in Advance, Will (crusader_4)
cappie Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 Marriage between 2 [b]validly[/b] baptised persons is a sacrament. The marriage between a validly baptised person and an unbaptised person or a sect that does not have valid baptism (your example) or in the case of a Jehovah Witness or Morman is not considered a sacramental marriage but a "natural bond" 2 validly baptised persons Sacrament 1 validly baptised one not Natural Bond (no sacrament) This presumes the persons are free to marry The second part, it seems it would depend on the church. Some Orthodox churches don't recognise the marriage between say a catholic and an orthodox unless it is in an orthodox church. Maybe someone else can answer
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now