Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What does the Church teach


Recommended Posts

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted (edited)

+JMJ+

I think this topic has been discussed before...but, I figure it doesn't hurt to ask.

What is the Church's teaching regarding evolution?

Thanks!!

Edited by Fulton Sheen Warrior
missionseeker
Posted

it's not nessicarily contrary to genisis.
Since we God does not exist in time, it perfectly possible that it took more than 7 days to create the earth. It is perfectly possible that dinosaurs ruled the earth for a few thousand years before anything else existed.

you can take evloution too far. monkeys did not turn into men over time.

Posted

The Church has not really made any official stance on evolution, except saying that God created the universe and all that is in it.

A good resource for this topic are Cardinal Shoenborn's series of lectures he did this past year on creation and evolution.
Here's a link to his first lecture:
[url="http://www.zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=81525"]http://www.zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=81525[/url]

Posted

Another teaching is that we are biological descendants of Adam and Eve.

I'm sure a simple search of the CCC for creation would help greatly.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

A summary of definitive Catholic teaching on creation as presented in this thread and from Catholic Answers:

Monogeny, not polygeny.
Creation out of nothing.
Man's soul is specially created, though his body may be inherited from previous forms.
The universe has a finite age.

[url="http://catholic.com/library/Adam_Eve_and_Evolution.asp"]http://catholic.com/library/Adam_Eve_and_Evolution.asp[/url]

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted

+JMJ+


I see...that makes sense. Thanks!!

Posted

Thanks for posting this. I'd been wondering about the same topic myself. ^_^

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

basically, in some scientific terms (in addition to the tenets that have been mentioned above)... "micro" evolution is a plausible and permissible theological opinion one may hold (provided they retain the above tenets-- God created the world ex nihilo (from nothing), God created man with a spiritual soul, etc.). "macro" evolution (i.e., cross-over between species... like apes to human beings) is not plausible nor permissible for a Christian to adhere to.

one may also hold the theological opinion of "creationism" (i.e., a fairly strict literal interpretation of Genesis)

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1050511' date='Aug 25 2006, 03:56 PM']
basically, in some scientific terms (in addition to the tenets that have been mentioned above)... "micro" evolution is a plausible and permissible theological opinion one may hold (provided they retain the above tenets-- God created the world ex nihilo (from nothing), God created man with a spiritual soul, etc.). "macro" evolution (i.e., cross-over between species... like apes to human beings) is not plausible nor permissible for a Christian to adhere to.

one may also hold the theological opinion of "creationism" (i.e., a fairly strict literal interpretation of Genesis)
[/quote]


That has not been taught by the Church as far as I am aware. Do you have citations for that?

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted (edited)

which part? I was not intending any heresy... all 3 opinions I gave were merely theological opinions (and only 2 of which are agreeable to Christian faith).

"micro" evolution (which is what I'm guessing you were disagreeing with?) can be compatible with Christian faith, depending upon what one means-- which was why I added the qualifiers. "micro" evolution, as I understand it, is evolution within a species (as opposed to "macro" which involves cross-species evolution and is entirely disagreeable to Christian faith).
[quote]Concerning biological evolution, the Church does not have an official position on whether various life forms developed over the course of time. However, it says that, if they did develop, then they did so under the impetus and guidance of God, and their ultimate creation must be ascribed to him. [/quote]
(from the Catholic.com link..)



but perhaps my scientific understandings are mistaken and someone can correct me.

Edited by Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1050563' date='Aug 25 2006, 04:48 PM']
which part? I was not intending any heresy... all 3 opinions I gave were merely theological opinions (and only 2 of which are agreeable to Christian faith).

"micro" evolution (which is what I'm guessing you were disagreeing with?) can be compatible with Christian faith, depending upon what one means-- which was why I added the qualifiers. "micro" evolution, as I understand it, is evolution within a species (as opposed to "macro" which involves cross-species evolution and is entirely disagreeable to Christian faith).

but perhaps my scientific understandings are mistaken and someone can correct me.
[/quote]

That's how it's been explained to me also.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

The Church has actually not condemned macro-evolution.

Pius XII:
[quote]For these reasons the Teaching Authority of the Church does not forbid that, in conformity with the present state of human sciences and sacred theology, research and discussions, on the part of men experienced in both fields, take place with regard to the doctrine of evolution...
[i]Humani Generis 36[/i][/quote]
John Paul II:
[quote]In his encyclical Humani Generis (1950), my predecessor Pius XII has already affirmed that there is no conflict between evolution and the doctrine of the faith regarding man and his vocation, provided that we do not lose sight of certain fixed points.
[i]MESSAGE TO THE PONTIFICAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES: ON EVOLUTION[/i][/quote]
Personally, I'm not a big fan of evolutionary theory.

Micro-evolution is probably more commonly refered to as adaptation. Even most creationists have no problem with this.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

However, Macro-Evolution is entirely incompatible with Christian faith-- in the sense that Apes could involve into human persons. It would be "condemned" on the basis that one would necessarily "lost sight of certain fixed points", etc.

The above documents, however, could plausibly support one who wanted to adhere to Micro-Evolution.

Posted

Cardinal Schönborn Proposes Evolution Debate
Calls for More Science, Less Ideology

RIMINI, Italy, AUG. 25, 2006 (Zenit.org).- Cardinal Christoph Schönborn is proposing an ideology-free debate on the theory of evolution, and wants to clarify the Church's position on the topic.

The archbishop of Vienna presented his proposal Thursday to a packed auditorium at the Meeting of Friendship Among Peoples, organized by the Communion and Liberation Movement in Rimini, Italy.

At a press conference Wednesday, the cardinal, explained that the Church does not hold the position of "creationist" theories on the origin of life and man, which draw scientific consequences from biblical texts.

In fact, he added, there is "no conflict between science and religion," but, rather, a debate "between a materialist interpretation of the results of science and a metaphysical philosophical interpretation."

Cardinal Schönborn, who sparked a worldwide debate in 2005 with an article in the New York Times on the subject, called for clarification of the difference between the "theory of evolution" and "evolutionism," the latter understood as an ideology, based on scientific theory.

By way of example, the cardinal mentioned Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, who saw in the publication of Charles Darwin's "The Origin of Species," "the scientific foundation for their Marxist materialist theory. This is evolutionism, not theory of evolution."

The archbishop of Vienna warned against the application of this evolutionist ideology in fields such as economic neo-liberalism, or bioethical issues, where there is the risk of creating new eugenic theories.

More than a theory

Journalists asked the cardinal what Pope John Paul II meant in his address to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences, in Oct. 1996, when he spoke of evolution as "something more than a theory."

Cardinal Schönborn explained that the phrase meant that "the theory, as scientific theory, has been expanded with new scientific data, but of course that phrase cannot be interpreted as an 'Amen' of the Catholic Church to ideological evolutionism."

The archbishop of Vienna noted a document published by the International Theological Commission in 2004, with the approval of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, entitled "Communion and Service: The Human Person Created in the Image of God."

He said the paper clarifies the distinction between ideology and science, and "gives an answer to those who wished to interpret John Paul II's phrase in an ideological sense."

"What I desire intensely is that, also in school programs, questions be explained, at the scientific level, opened by the theory of evolution, such as the famous question of the missing rings," Cardinal Schönborn said.

The cardinal said that 150 years after Darwin's theory, "there is no evidence in the geological strata of intermediate species that should exist, according to Darwin's theory."

He continued: "He himself said in his book that this is a hole in his theory and asked that they be found.

"This should be discussed in a serene manner. If a theory is scientific and not ideological, then it can be discussed freely."
ZE06082508

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted

+JMJ+

Thanks for the article Father! Very informative.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1050563' date='Aug 25 2006, 04:48 PM']
which part? I was not intending any heresy... all 3 opinions I gave were merely theological opinions (and only 2 of which are agreeable to Christian faith).

"micro" evolution (which is what I'm guessing you were disagreeing with?) can be compatible with Christian faith, depending upon what one means-- which was why I added the qualifiers. "micro" evolution, as I understand it, is evolution within a species (as opposed to "macro" which involves cross-species evolution and is entirely disagreeable to Christian faith).

(from the Catholic.com link..)
but perhaps my scientific understandings are mistaken and someone can correct me.
[/quote]


It was actually your part about macro-evolution that I'm pretty sure the Church has not said anything about. Cross-species evolution is not inherently disagreeable to Christian faith (see cappie's article above). The theory of evolution (including macro) does not make any statements regarding the special creation of Man or creation ex nihilo. Evolutionism, the ideology does make statements regarding those things and is completely incompatible with Christian faith.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1050716' date='Aug 25 2006, 10:33 PM']
It was actually your part about macro-evolution that I'm pretty sure the Church has not said anything about. Cross-species evolution is not inherently disagreeable to Christian faith (see cappie's article above). The theory of evolution (including macro) does not make any statements regarding the special creation of Man or creation ex nihilo. Evolutionism, the ideology does make statements regarding those things and is completely incompatible with Christian faith.
[/quote]
News to me, but I've never met a macro-evolutionist or read anything on macro-evolution that didn't somehow imply or make reference to the "missing link" in the chain of man. But, so long as one holds the basic tenets of the faith regarding God's creation, I suppose macro-evolution could be a plausible theological opinion, but it would need (/demand) numerous qualifications.

Posted

I guess the difference is I don't see macro-evolution as a theological opinion at all, but merely a scientific one. It doesn't need to have any theological qualifications as such, as it is by definition limited to the natural rather than the supernatural sphere. Just as ensoulment is not covered in embryology textbooks, I wouldn't expect it to be covered in any scientific theory of evolution.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

perhaps it's not a theological opinion, but a scientific one...

however, in a certain sense-- in that it would be an opinion regarding God's action of creation-- it would be somewhat theological, though by no means merely theological.

Posted

I guess the way I see it is that the theological part is the who (God) and the what (created mankind) and the scientific part is the how (theory of evolution or whatever).

Off hand, I can't think of any purely scientific theory/observation that could ever be incongruous with God's action of creation. There are plenty who try, but they almost always have slipped some ideology into their statements.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...