GodChild Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 I don't know if this will make sense to people but here it goes .... Can a mentally ill person pray to God or have a relationship with him? I'm asking this not to discriminate but because I myself have recently being diagnosed with a mental illness. I used to think I had a good relationship with God and received messages from Him. He would talk to me as would 'Jesus' and 'Mary'. Then I found out its just symptoms of my illness (hearing voices and believing pretty grandious things) Now I'm lost How do the mentally ill pray? When I pray and hear a voice I immediately have to tell myself its not real - but then how can anything be real? Also in a sense, i feel like since the voices were 'Jesus' and 'Mary' I feel like I've been used as a joke by God. I feel humiliated to pray if you can understand why. I would sit there and talk to (who I though was God) but it was really my broken brain. Anyways, in sum I have just stopped praying. I don't pray cause I don;t know how to. I feel too humiliated to pray cause these 'Jesus' and 'Mary' voices told me to do things (which I did) and So how can the mentally ill pray or how can we have a relationship with God. I'm coming to accept that God screwed up badly when he created me so I'm just a deformed image of Him --> is this maybe why a normal relationship isn't possible? Would like info. P.S - I'm too embarressed to go to my priest. I told him what the voices were telling me and he actually thought i was a visionary until i found out i'm ill. Now I'm humiliated and I cant help feeling that God himself did this to me (as the voices were 'Jesus' and 'Mary') if you can understand what I mean
bmb144 Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 Hi GodChild, Firstly, I'm here if you need an ear, email, MSN, you know how to get in touch, do so! I have been praying for you and will now do so even more. [quote] I'm coming to accept that God screwed up badly when he created me so I'm just a deformed image of Him [/quote] Secondly, my Father in heaven does not screw up, no one is screwed up and please don't buy into that one. It will only help you to feel worse. Regardless of a label, (be it mental illness or any other one), you are a much loved child of God, and even in this He is still here and still listening. Please pray, not matter what you may or may not hear, it does not matter. If free prayer is a problem, the Rosary or the use of a prayer book will help. Stopping prayer will make things worse. Don't let go of the basics. Pray, read the Bible and go to Mass. There is some other stuff I need to say but will do that directly to you. Just remember here if you need me. Belinda
Theologian in Training Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 I am trying to figure something out, these voices that you heard, what would they tell you? I am not asking for specifics, just, in general? Because, I read your post about Mary, and you said that Jesus revealed to you that Mary is not an idol, which helped you to search further and to find some understanding in the Scriptures. Now, I just have a question, "would a broken brain" be able to come up with that insight? I know doctors mean well and if you tell them you are hearing voices they immediately think you are crazy, but were these voices constant? I mean, if we are children of God, is it possible that we would never hear His voice? Now, don't get me wrong, I am not trying to say that the doctors mis-diagnosed you, and you should not be hearing voices constantly, but, again, if prayer is conversation with God, and, as you seem to imply, this occurs during prayer, and you did not pray always thinking you would hear the voice, then I wonder what will happen now that they have diagnosed you, because I think that will be the true test in the end. Just my .02 God Bless
scardella Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 Obviously, the difficulty w/ mental illness is that the very instrument that is attempting to diagnose itself is flawed... However, in principle, it should be really simple, although it never works out that way. You should test everything you hear against Church teachings. If they are consistent, then, discern carefully. If they are not, then you can know they are false. It is easy to outthink yourself. I do it to myself all the time. Pray, and continue meeting with your priest. Be honest about the diagnosis with him, and if you disagree with it, let him know that. Put yourself into your priest's hands, for he is [i]in persona Christi[/i].
GodChild Posted August 25, 2006 Author Posted August 25, 2006 [quote]I am trying to figure something out, these voices that you heard, what would they tell you? I am not asking for specifics, just, in general? Because, I read your post about Mary, and you said that Jesus revealed to you that Mary is not an idol, which helped you to search further and to find some understanding in the Scriptures. Now, I just have a question, "would a broken brain" be able to come up with that insight? I know doctors mean well and if you tell them you are hearing voices they immediately think you are crazy, but were these voices constant? I mean, if we are children of God, is it possible that we would never hear His voice? Now, don't get me wrong, I am not trying to say that the doctors mis-diagnosed you, and you should not be hearing voices constantly, but, again, if prayer is conversation with God, and, as you seem to imply, this occurs during prayer, and you did not pray always thinking you would hear the voice, then I wonder what will happen now that they have diagnosed you, because I think that will be the true test in the end. Just my .02 God Bless[/quote] The voice of 'Jesus' and 'Mary' would only come when I prayed or throughout the day when I wasn't in prayer. The voices never told me anything bad {per se] but always spoke to me about virtues, love and how to love God. 'Jesus' drew me to His Mother and that I should consecrate myself wholly to her - which I did via the St Louis De'Montfort Consecration. 'Mary' then told me I should pray the rosary every day and ask God via the Rosary for virtues to love Him more [as 'Mary' explained to me, the rosary is a direct prayer to the Holy Trinity in praise, thanksgiving, love and contemplation of the mystery of redemption God gave us and the spirit in which it came to us eg: in poverty, simplicity, love, humility, suffering]. The virtues I was told to pray for was 1. To love God 2. humility 3. purity 4. obedience to God and abandonment to His will 5. mercy, charity and preservation from all sin. 'Jesus' would tell me about his Mercy and love. And throughout the day 'Mary' and 'Jesus' would talk to me about my daily actions (for instance when someone annoyed me 'Mary' would say "remember to be charitable and not have judgemental thoughts"). I would also have 'visions' about Jesus in the Eucharist and Mary. 'Jesus' and 'Mary' would also tell me other things - like I will be a saint and that they want me to start a new congregation grandious thoughts and 'voices' from God is a typical symptom of mental illness. Therefore I think its safer to assume that I'm 'sick' rather than get puffed up with pride and say 'God talks to me'
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 Just to clarify... were you actually diagnosed by a real doctor with a specific mental condition? ...perhaps take it as a great grace you have been undeservedly given to audibly hear encouragement and support in your spiritual journey (and thus, no need to consider pride). And as long as nothing Jesus or Mary said to you was out of line with the official teaching of the Church (this is why a spiritual director/priest is good to have.. which you mentioned in your first post), I don't see anything "wrong" necessarily with paying attention to them (provided you have a spiritual director of sorts). Who's to say that God isn't using a mental illness to speak to you? Go back and tell the priest the diagnosis of the doctor and ask him to continue to help you discern the voices you hear that you might follow God all the more closely. That way, you can clear up any misunderstandings the priest might have, he can help you cope with this news, continue to help you discern the voices you hear... and even if it is a bit humiliating... humility is a virtue, and it would take a great amount of courage to go back to the priest. God does not play tricks, and He will grant you whatever graces are necessary for your salvation. And I do not think prayer would be impeded by a mental illness, but rather, in your sufferings you are enabled to unite yourself more closely with Christ and offer up those sufferings for the sanctification of your soul, and the souls of others.
fearundercontrol Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 [quote name='GodChild' post='1050579' date='Aug 25 2006, 06:13 PM'] The voice of 'Jesus' and 'Mary' would only come when I prayed or throughout the day when I wasn't in prayer. The voices never told me anything bad {per se] but always spoke to me about virtues, love and how to love God. 'Jesus' drew me to His Mother and that I should consecrate myself wholly to her - which I did via the St Louis De'Montfort Consecration. 'Mary' then told me I should pray the rosary every day and ask God via the Rosary for virtues to love Him more [as 'Mary' explained to me, the rosary is a direct prayer to the Holy Trinity in praise, thanksgiving, love and contemplation of the mystery of redemption God gave us and the spirit in which it came to us eg: in poverty, simplicity, love, humility, suffering]. The virtues I was told to pray for was 1. To love God 2. humility 3. purity 4. obedience to God and abandonment to His will 5. mercy, charity and preservation from all sin. 'Jesus' would tell me about his Mercy and love. And throughout the day 'Mary' and 'Jesus' would talk to me about my daily actions (for instance when someone annoyed me 'Mary' would say "remember to be charitable and not have judgemental thoughts"). I would also have 'visions' about Jesus in the Eucharist and Mary. 'Jesus' and 'Mary' would also tell me other things - like I will be a saint and that they want me to start a new congregation grandious thoughts and 'voices' from God is a typical symptom of mental illness. Therefore I think its safer to assume that I'm 'sick' rather than get puffed up with pride and say 'God talks to me' [/quote] Although you may have a mental illness, I don't think what you were hearing was a result of that. None of those things are things that would come from hallucinations. It is totally uncharacteristic.
GodChild Posted August 29, 2006 Author Posted August 29, 2006 I need lots of prayers please I feel very unwell - the medication i am on has made me very ill. I stopped taking it for one day only and I am sick - i have a migraine and nausea BIG TIME. Lots of prayers please!!
cmotherofpirl Posted August 29, 2006 Posted August 29, 2006 If the voices are leading you to deeper prayer and a better relationship with God does that qualify as mental illness?? Didn't many saints have conversations with the Lord or Mary? I am not saying you are a saint, and all those people we call saints would certainly not called themselves saints either, but since when does being urged toward goodness qualify as mental illness? Is it interfering with your daily activities? Are you not functioning because you are hearing voices? Forgetting to bathe or eat? Most shrinks just assume the supernatural spiritual life is automatically a sign of mental illness and could never conceive any other reality. Catholics know better. If I were you I would go talk to the priest again, and look for a Catholic psychologist. How many saints would we have if we disqualified as crazy those talking to God if we let the "shrinks" run the Church? don't stop taking your meds on a whim, consult a doctor first, but also don't assume the Lord isn't talking to you either. Much more discernment is necessary than one shrinks opinion
peep Posted September 1, 2006 Posted September 1, 2006 (edited) you'll be in my prayers tonight, Godchild. I know kind of how it feels in your boat because I too am mentally ill sometimes (attention deficit psychosis) and have a hard time talking to God.\ Our Lady of Mental Peace, pray for us. Our Lady of Mental peace pray for us. Our Lady of Mental Peace, pray for us. Edited September 1, 2006 by peep
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now