Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 As the title suggests.. Is the "process" of Revelation defined or thoroughly examined by the Church in any document or other reliable source? For context, in a particular theology class I'm in, it was claimed that the distinction between public and private revelation was irrelevant because the distinction refers to the content, and not to the process which is what we were supposedly discussing.
Era Might Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 Do you mean the process of revelation as it was revealed (through Scripture and Tradition), or the process of fully comprehending this revelation? John Paul touches on the latter somewhat in "Ut Unum Sint": [quote]Taking up an idea expressed by Pope John XXIII at the opening of the Council, the Decree on Ecumenism mentions the way of formulating doctrine as one of the elements of a continuing reform. Here it is not a question of altering the deposit of faith, changing the meaning of dogmas, eliminating essential words from them, accommodating truth to the preferences of a particular age, or suppressing certain articles of the Creed under the false pretext that they are no longer understood today. ... Even so, doctrine needs to be presented in a way that makes it understandable to those for whom God himself intends it. In my Encyclical Epistle Slavorum Apostoli, I recalled that this was the very reason why Saints Cyril and Methodius laboured to translate the ideas of the Bible and the concepts of Greek theology in the context of very different historical experiences and ways of thinking. They wanted the one word of God to be "made accessible in each civilization's own forms of expression". ... As far as the formulation of revealed truths is concerned, the Declaration Mysterium Ecclesiae states: "Even though the truths which the Church intends to teach through her dogmatic formulas are distinct from the changeable conceptions of a given epoch and can be expressed without them, nevertheless it can sometimes happen that these truths may be enunciated by the Sacred Magisterium in terms that bear traces of such conceptions. In view of this, it must be stated that the dogmatic formulas of the Church's Magisterium were from the very beginning suitable for communicating revealed truth, and that as they are they remain for ever suitable for communicating this truth to those who interpret them correctly". In this regard, ecumenical dialogue, which prompts the parties involved to question each other, to understand each other and to explain their positions to each other, makes surprising discoveries possible. Intolerant polemics and controversies have made incompatible assertions out of what was really the result of two different ways of looking at the same reality. Nowadays we need to find the formula which, by capturing the reality in its entirety, will enable us to move beyond partial readings and eliminate false interpretations. ... In all this, it will be of great help methodologically to keep carefully in mind the distinction between the deposit of faith and the formulation in which it is expressed, as Pope John XXIII recommended in his opening address at the Second Vatican Council. ---Pope John Paul II, Encyclical Letter "Ut Unum Sint"[/quote] The distinction between "private" and "public" revelation is not at all irrelevant, because public revelation is binding on all Christians. Private revelation is not binding on anyone, either in its "content" or in its interpretation of public revelation.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 25, 2006 Author Posted August 25, 2006 Revelation itself--as being Revealed by God. I'm sifting through Dei Verbum, but am still having trouble seeing much about the "process". (which, in my limited opinion seems as though this "process" of Revelation would be different in the case of public Revelation and private)
Era Might Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 Oh ok. That's a big topic; nothing specific comes to mind. There's a lot of documents here and there that might be helpful in understanding the process of how Scripture and Tradition came to be. Here's a few: [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/PBCINTER.HTM"][u]The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church[/u][/url] [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/pius_xii/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_30091943_divino-afflante-spiritu_en.html"][u]Divino Afflante Spiritu[/u][/url] [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/leo_xiii/encyclicals/documents/hf_l-xiii_enc_18111893_providentissimus-deus_en.html"][u]Providentissimus Deus[/u][/url] The Enyclicals on Scripture are probably the best source, at least from the Magisterium, because they draw the limits. But, I don't know if there's an "official", nitty-gritty examination of the actual "process" of revelation. You'll probably have to look to theologians for that. Historical-critical method type stuff, for example, that dissects how Scripture came to be. It'd be interesting to see an historical-critical treatment of Tradition; I'm not sure if it has been done. [quote]Another characteristic feature of this synthesis is its balance and moderation. In its interpretation of the Bible, it knows how to harmonize the diachronic and the synchronic by recognizing than the two are mutually complementary and indispensable for bringing out all the truth of the text and for satisfying the legitimate demands of the modern reader. Even more importantly, Catholic exegesis does not focus its attention on only the human aspects of biblical Revelation, which is sometimes the mistake of the historico-critical method, or on only the divine aspects, as fundamentalism would have it; it strives to highlight both of them as they are united in the divine "condescension" (Dei Verbum, n. 13), which is the basis of all Scripture. --Pope John Paul II, 1993 Address to the Pontifical Biblical Commission[/quote]
Era Might Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 (edited) I'm not sure why "public" and "private" would be irrelevant distinctions. Do they mean that public revelation can continue? The Church teaches that revelation ceased with the Apostles: [quote]"The Christian economy, therefore, since it is the new and definitive Covenant, will never pass away; and no new public revelation is to be expected before the glorious manifestation of our Lord Jesus Christ." Yet even if Revelation is already complete, it has not been made completely explicit; it remains for Christian faith gradually to grasp its full significance over the course of the centuries. --CCC #66[/quote] I agree that the "process" in public and private revelation would be different. "Public" revelation was not just given, but the actual record of that revelation was formally inspired. This isn't the case with "private" revelation. Individual Saints can misunderstand what God is revealing, or they can interpret it wrong, etc. Their revelations aren't inspired, but given. Their communication of this revelation is on their own word and competence. For example, Scripture is inspired by the Holy Spirit, but St. Faustina's "Diary of a Soul" is not, even though it records revelations from Our Lord. Every word of Scripture was inspired by the Holy Spirit, whereas St. Faustina's diary is hers and hers alone, and has to be understood as her own. Edited August 25, 2006 by Era Might
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 25, 2006 Author Posted August 25, 2006 Yeah, it's all a bit sketchy right now.. I sent her a message (we have a discussion board for class that's online) and hopefully will get a more clarifying response. We are supposedly talking about "experience" in a non-emotivist/subjectivist sort of way, but it seems that we've managed just the opposite. We're reading a book published by Paulist Press called "The Experience of God" by Dermot Lane... so the background of this discussion is against this book.
Era Might Posted August 25, 2006 Posted August 25, 2006 (edited) Added to the previous post. Edited August 25, 2006 by Era Might
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 25, 2006 Author Posted August 25, 2006 Thanks for all your contributions thus far, Era Might! Perhaps a better clarification I think I will need is this: how exactly has the Church's understanding re: Revelation "changed" at Vatican II (this is a tenet of the prof and the author of the above mentioned book). It is claimed: [quote]For some, revelation appears primarily as a clear deposit of truths to be jealously guarded and defensively protected by the Church. This particular view of revelation was taken up at the Second Vatican Council and supplemented by another and more important view on revelation...[/quote] I have concerns that this passage (and others) leads to a sort of modernist thinking regarding Church doctrine and revelation that was vehemently condemned in the years immediately preceeding Vatican II. I have my doubts that Vatican II would so drastically alter some teaching of the Church as to wholly replace one understanding of doctrine.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 26, 2006 Author Posted August 26, 2006 Blah... prof is no help, basically ignored my clarification. I went back and read many of the documents the above book referenced as condemning of experience, etc. and turns out-- the author is gravely exaggerating and a very simple case can be made that holds roughly the same outlook towards experience that the author does. Yes, we experience revelation in human experience (umm, duh, we're human beings), but the Church never has condemned experience all together, only condemned those who would take experience alone.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now