zwergel88 Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 Hey folks, what's up? Well, I hate to trouble you with personal problems but I figured I'd just throw one out there for you folks and the person who gives the best advice wins. Warning: This will be a long post. Actually this is kind of a serious issue. My brother who is 13 going on 14 has a myspace. Among other crude, graphic, and obscene things that are there, he happens to state that he is an Atheist. It used to say that he is an Agnostic, but I guess he changed it. Now I know that anything written on myspace should be taken with a grain of salt (for example, I stated on my myspace that I am part extraterrestrial) but the thing is that he has indicated this to me before in real life. A couple weeks ago we had a coversation that went something like this: My brother: You just gotta have fun and live in the moment because there is nothing to look forward to. Me: What about the future? Growing up, making a difference in the world, raising a family, isn't that something to look forward to? My brother: No because there is nothing after. Your family will die, you will die, and there is nothing after that, you cease to exist. Me: That's not true; death is not the end. Life is eternal. My brother: No, there is nothing. (Note: He has a phrase he likes to use to express his particular philosophy; "Life's a b*****, and then you die, so f***, the world and just get high" Whether or not he has followed his own advice I can't say) Anyway, the thing of it is, is I don't really know what to do. I hate for him to have this view because what kind of life is that to believe that life has no purpose. I told my mom about it, and she said that it is just the result of his age. I tryed to tell her that I don't think that Atheist is a "stage" that kids go through. I don't know if I should do anything, except of course pray. I used to nagg him about going to Mass on Sunday, and he ususally used to go. He was never super religious, but up untill he turned about 13, he used to go without too much of a fight, and for a while he even got into praying the Rosary. Then my mom told me to quit nagging him, becasue I was a hypocrit and me telling him to go to Mass would only make him hate religion more. My mom tells him he should go every other week (I told her that was bullcrap, but whatever), but now he hasn't been in several months, and hasn't been to Confession since he was probably about 10. I know of course to pray for his coversion, but I'm just curious if you guys have any advice for dealing with a situation like this. Should I just ignore my mom's advice at risk of being called a hyprocrit and try to engage him in coversation, and try to get him to go to Mass as much as possible. What if he is too far gone for anything but a miracle (he listens to alot of Marilyn Manson)? Have any delt with a similar issue? Alright Ready Set Advise Thanks guys, Anna
God the Father Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 There's no such thing as an atheist in a foxhole. There's no such thing as an atheist on their deathbed. The real thing you have to worry about is that he listens to a lot of Marilyn Manson. Get his ears checked.
let_go_let_God Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 There may be no such thing as an atheist in a foxhole et cetera, cetera, cetera... but you do have a ligitament reason to worry. We are talking about the immortal soul of someone you love and care about quite a bit. You do have a responsibility to 'nag' him, but in such a way not to drive him farther away. Try to be open with him, have conversations as to why you believe what you believe and why he believes what he does. Just keep letting him know that you are there and that you do care about him. That is an important first step. God bless- LGLG
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 I think if I was in the situation, I would try to set an example by living a holy life. People are attracted to holiness and will inquire why you have so much hope and joy.
MIKolbe Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 For what it's worth... if there was no God, there would be no atheists....i think Chesterton said that... As for advice...take him to Mass with you. Heck, get him off MySpace and onto PhatMass!!!! Challenge his 'reasons' for non-belief.. As for your Mom saying this is a stage, i doubt (though am unsure), she was referring to atheism, per se..but was probably talking about the random 'i know everything-ness' that many teenagers spout out unintelligently. I know, I used to do it myself... and THAT is a phase.. I only wish I was half as smart as I THOUGHT I was when I was 17!!! ..that said however, i would agree that flirting with atheism is dangerous for the soul and not to be taken lightly at any age... Hope this helps.... Kolbe
zwergel88 Posted August 27, 2006 Author Posted August 27, 2006 You folks are so smart. Keep it comin'
Anomaly Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 It's typical teenage rebellion. Use his logic. Why worry about 100 years from now? Live for today and the probablilty of tomorrow. Enjoy life to it's fullest. Unless you are being held hostage by a rabid terrorist, it's most logical and reasonable that you will wake up in the morning. The odds are we don't dissappear while we sleep. You go to school today, because your parents will make you suffer tomorrow if you don't. Live Friday for the hope of having fun on Saturday. Enjoy the moment without creating the likelihood of being miserable an hour from now so you can have hope of enjoying the moment 2 hours from now. Aetheism is just an alternative choice of principles. It has nothing to do with how you enjoy life now because it only limits consequences when you are dead, not consequences when you are alive.
JesusIPray Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 [quote]Have any delt with a similar issue?[/quote] I'm dealing with a very similar, or possibly worse, situation right now. So all of this advice is helping me too!
peach_cube Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 Definitely challenge his logic. Try Pascal's wager or something else that's rather simple to start with. Show miracles and ask his explanation of them, anything to get him thinking. The biggest thing with teenage athiests is that they hear one arguement for this position and then adopt it. They never really analyze it further. If you show him just a few things to get him thinking it might trigger something that makes sense to him and puts doubt on the athiest position.
Ash Wednesday Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 I will pray for your brother. He is blessed to have a good sister like you. I agree with peach cube's suggestion about Pascal's wager. Atheism has no logic to it. If there was no God or life after death, then what we do on this earth would really be pointless. Pointless. To me, the logic of atheism would mean that someone like Hitler really had nobody to answer to, especially after he died, and some of the gravest acts of humanity really in the end wouldn't matter. I cannot think of a more depressing way to live life.
Claudine Posted August 27, 2006 Posted August 27, 2006 I had tons of this problem, i was a youth minister, so here is the best way that i found.... # 1. Prayer and fasting, never hurts! offer it up for your bro! maye a Novena! # 2. He needs to be able to trust you before he asks you about anything to do with God. # 3. What kind of stuff is he interested in? Get him to teach you something or show you something he cares about. Take interest in what he does. These 3 important things need 2 be done b4 moving on to the next steps. He needs to meet Jesus and you will guide him. Any youth thing going on in your parish? Do you have a youth minister? any Youth Rallys going on? find out, dont mention it, you sign up to go, and post a little something about the youth rally on the fridge, let him come 2 you, dont talk about it.... he will ask you about it. About My Space thing....... leave it alone. Chao4 now
Cow of Shame Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1051533' date='Aug 27 2006, 11:04 AM']Live Friday for the hope of having fun on Saturday. Enjoy the moment without creating the likelihood of being miserable an hour from now so you can have hope of enjoying the moment 2 hours from now. [b]Aetheism is just an alternative choice of principles. It has nothing to do with how you enjoy life now because it only limits consequences when you are dead, not consequences when you are alive.[/b] [/quote] I find your 'logic' highly faulted. Aetheism can easily impact life consequences. Keep working on your brother.....and keep in mind that he might not change for 10 years, or ever.
tojo Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 [quote name='thedude' post='1051234' date='Aug 26 2006, 09:41 PM'] I think if I was in the situation, I would try to set an example by living a holy life. People are attracted to holiness and will inquire why you have so much hope and joy. [/quote] While there is good thoughts behind that, I must say that manz people, especially rebellious 13-year old boys, aren#t attracted to holiness. My advice is of course to pray, and to find the most awesome Catholic youth ministry in your area, and to try to get him to go to that. If they have lots of teens, espüecially lots of teens guys, then obviously they must be doing something 7 have something that draws them in, and perhaps it will work on your brother. I think the most important thing is to get him to meet and fall in love with Jesus, get him to the place where it's most likely to happen, where other guys his age are experiencing that.
CrossCuT Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 [size=1]I think you should sit down and talk (if he is open enough) and try to pin point exactally what is throwing him off. There has to be something...then work from there. [/size]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now