thessalonian Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 I've heard it a few times. I think its from Jack Chick Some priest is trying to convert this woman to Catholicism and she puts poison in the wine and tells him to consecrate it and drink it. Of course he runs away. Now why would they think that there would not be poison in the transubstantiated wine in the cup. Jesus did not say that the Lord's Supper could include poison which would change to his body and blood. Does putting poison in water change the poison to water? It is diluted of course but is still poison. It's a silly senario, underlaid by devious minds, seeking to twist and distort the truth.
Era Might Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 The substance of the species changes, but not the accidents. You still get drunk, for example, if you drink the precious blood to excess. If you put poison in the chalice, it would be mitigated by the wine (in the same way the drop of water is that the Priest pours), and so probably would not affect the consecration, although the accidents of that poison would still remain, and hence, you would die.
N/A Gone Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 In aristollean philosophy the idea is there is a difference in subject and predicate(there are numerous terms to use, I will use these) flesh and bones are our predicate, but our essence is our subject. I have a pen in my hand and its color and feel is predicate, but its essence is a pen. In transubsational the essence/subject changes. But the predicate stays the same. the atributes of bread and of wine stay the same. Thus in the chick example the poison, which has become an atribute of the wine, would still remain even after the parts have been concecrated. This is why the scientific testing of the wine and bread make no sense at all. Anyone with basic catechism testing knows that the atributes of the body still remain bread and the atributes of the blood still remain like wine. basically this is a common protestant flaw in understanding. I have heard it numerous times from people with good intentions that simply dont understand Aristotle. Real presence and transubstation does not mean literal attributes. Thes, you are my senior in knowledge and in experience, but this is what I would say
thessalonian Posted August 28, 2006 Author Posted August 28, 2006 (edited) Would the poison itself consecrate? I see a question in Aquinas about a spider or some other creature falling in and poisoning the wine. It says to dispose of it if it is before the consecration. To treat it reverently if it is after the consecration that it is noticed. He does not answer the question of if the poison would still be poison within the wine. I would think it would still be poison. Therefore explanations about accidents and substance aren't really neccessary in refuting them. Anyone have anything different? My purpose in raising this thread is that the standard arguement is to complex for their protestant minds and I think there is a different answer that might be more satisfying in the discussion. But maybe not. Edited August 28, 2006 by thessalonian
Mateo el Feo Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1052207' date='Aug 28 2006, 05:29 PM']Would the poison itself consecrate?[/quote]I would think not. The priest is consecrating the wine, not "whatever liquid molecules are in the cup."
thessalonian Posted August 28, 2006 Author Posted August 28, 2006 (edited) That's what I am thinking. That seems to free the arguement from what they believe vs. whether TS is true or not. Would they drink their Lord's Supper wine? No, because the poison has not become wine. Neither would it in ours. In fact the Church has rules about what can be mixed in the bread for instance that would invalidate a consecration, such as honey. It would seem likely the same would be true of adding something to wine. It might even invalidate the consecration. If a preist consecrated what had had poison added I don't think there would be a consecration. The priest could not knowingly perform such a consecration. Aquianas says to pour out the wine. Edited August 28, 2006 by thessalonian
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 [quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1052211' date='Aug 28 2006, 05:34 PM'] I would think not. The priest is consecrating the wine, not "whatever liquid molecules are in the cup." [/quote] I agree. The wine transubstantiates. The poison that happens to be there remains poison.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 The thing with the spider (or any other thing that may fall into the Chalice after consecration), is that it would contain small particles of the Precious Blood and so just tossing out the foreign object would be tossing out (possibly and most likely) small, minute amounts of the Precious Blood... and thus we would wish to avoid that by whatever means possible. So thus, yes, the poison will still remain potent and dangerous... however, if the wine has not been consecrated, I don't see why the priest would perform the consecration in the first place (referring to above example)
Era Might Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 I don't know that the poison would remain (substantially). When the Priest cleans the chalic, for example, and a few drops of blood mix with all that water, the wine is basically consumed under the water so that it is no longer truly a unique species of wine, and thus, no longer exists. I think the poison would be "swallowed" up by the precious blood as well; the accidents would remain, but there would not be any poison in there really.
thessalonian Posted August 28, 2006 Author Posted August 28, 2006 I posted a question in Q&A on this.
Aloysius Posted August 28, 2006 Posted August 28, 2006 water is different than poison, era. what is consecrated is a mix of water and wine from the start. the priest intends to consecrate a mix of water and wine. I am not sure he can consecrate the poison any more than he could consecrate pepsi, even if it was mixed with the wine prior to the consecration.
thessalonian Posted August 28, 2006 Author Posted August 28, 2006 (edited) It's kind of like trying to consecrate wonder bread if you ask me. I'm not even sure that if there were poison present that there would be a consecration. Edited August 28, 2006 by thessalonian
thessalonian Posted August 29, 2006 Author Posted August 29, 2006 Cappies answer to my question about the purity of the bread and wine. [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=56574"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=56574[/url]
Tindomiel Posted August 29, 2006 Posted August 29, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1052196' date='Aug 28 2006, 05:08 PM'] The substance of the species changes, but not the accidents. You still get drunk, for example, if you drink the precious blood to excess. If you put poison in the chalice, it would be mitigated by the wine (in the same way the drop of water is that the Priest pours), and so probably would not affect the consecration, although the accidents of that poison would still remain, and hence, you would die. [/quote] If you read the "History of the Franks" by St. Gregoray of Tours, one of the queens poisons some relation of hers- her daughter, I believe - that way.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now