MrsFrozen Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 And I see your point as well. Just remember though that the church says that under certain circumstances that the death penenty is allowed. So in a sense we are allowed to judge when it's someones time. Hi, MP.. I heard this before.. Do you know under what circumstances? Is it in the Catechism? Thank you! God bless. :)
MrsFrozen Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 Check out Romans 13:1-5 It is pretty clear the government has full authority to the death penalty. Hi, Circle.. Like the new icon. I read it, but I have this feeling that the death penalty doesn't apply, because the whole "eye for an eye" thing was nixed by Jesus. I got the feeling that this passage was basically telling us to obey the laws. What do you think? God bless. :)
BLAZEr Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 Check out Romans 13:1-5 It is pretty clear the government has full authority to the death penalty. Tell that to Christians in China or the Sudan or the Congo or Cuba . . .
BLAZEr Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 By the way I think that the death penalty is a permissable and moral decision in some cases. I just don't want to roll over to the state which today is killing Criminals, tomorrow might be killing Christians.
Donna Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 I have a bit here, from the Denzinger, Sources of Catholic Dogma: Profession of Faith Prescribed for Durand of Osca and His Waldensian Companions [From the letter "Eius Exemplo" to the Archbishop of Terraco, Dec. 12, 1208] (Here follows numbers 420-427) 425 ....Concerning a secular power we declare that without mortal sin it is possible to exersize a judgement of blood as long as one proceeds to bring punishment not in hatred but in judgement, not in- cautiously but advisedly. (The above line was added to the profession of Faith for heretical Waldensians returning to the Church, in 1210, according to the Denzinger).
BLAZEr Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 And by the way, life in Prison isn't such a beautiful option when it means a life of Criminal Rape because our prison system can't protect its inmates from the violence they do to each other. You will have a hard time convincing me that PRISON is moral and the Death Penalty is NOT.
Donna Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 (edited) Blazer, what we're talking about is the legitimate recourse of the State to the death penalty for heinous crimes. It is a matter of justice. My opinion is that I've more hope for the conversion of a criminal facing the death penalty. We cannot expiate more than in giving our own life (even if we forfeit that by our crimes). People rail against the teaching that "God can send someone to hell for all eternity for a crime that took only minutes to commit." And the world used to be able to answer back, "the state can take the life of that same man for the crime it took him only minutes to complete." Have we lost our mind? Killing 40 people; including a Catholic priest. Killing the vulnerable sick as they looked to you, Nurse, for help and healing. The audicity of this hate-filled murderer grows strong and waxes most likely into final impenitence with the likes of this madness coming from a moral prince, should his own personal view win the secular-punishment day. It is not mercy His Excellency proposes but impotence and shameful effeminate-ness when he should be virile with the spiritual censures (if this Nurse be Catholic and show himself impenitent) and not be an aid and comfort to this enemy of Christ and mankind. Christe Eleison! Edited January 9, 2004 by Donna
Circle_Master Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 Hi, Circle.. Like the new icon. I read it, but I have this feeling that the death penalty doesn't apply, because the whole "eye for an eye" thing was nixed by Jesus. I got the feeling that this passage was basically telling us to obey the laws. What do you think? God bless. The "eye for eye, tooth for tooth" thing applies to government but not to us as Christians. When Peter goes and cuts off the guards ear that goes for Jesus, Jesus stops him and says "He who lives by the sword, dies by the sword." - He understood that if Peter killed the guard, his just punishment was death. Jesus also goes on to say "Give to Caesar what is Caesar's and give to God what is God's". This passage - It can be broken down as the following. I just did a lot of research on it last week - God Commands Obedience (Romans 13: 1a) Reason for Obeying #1 – Judgment by God (Romans 13: 1b-2) Reason for Obeying #2 – Judgment by Authority (Romans 13: 3-4) Reflection on Command (Romans 13: 5) If you notice in v4, it says the sword. There have been two interpretations of that, one as a symbol of office, and the other as a symbol of power (i.e. can give death penalty). Fortunately to make it simple, the word used for sword is always used in reference to the Roman sword for killing and never the sword of office which is another word. The government has been set up to properly punish evil and to promote good. You see good through the nobel peace prize and other awards given (although it could be a lot greater!). The evil side is punishable by death (decapitation by sword by that time period) and must hold sin in bay. This is ironic considering the message of love by Christ and how we are to turn the other cheek. It seems however that government has been instituted to preserve the world - not to expand salvation. You see right before this passage it is speaking of "do not judge, lest ye be judged" - this is referring to the judgment by the actual government. It is a common misconception that the judging is by God, but it is instead done by God's agent that He has established (13:1). I.E. - You judge someone a sinner and so thus he deserves death - if you kill him then your punishment will be death as well by the governmental authorities. (eye for eye etc.) This also applies to one who has had his father murdered or something similar - instead of seeking vengeance on your own as was common in the middle ages, you were to seek justice by the Government as we are not to do that judging. I hope that helps a little -peace
Donna Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 Please clarify, Circle Master. Are you saying that God does not wish or endow the State to spread "salvation" (the gospel, the church, as you understand it)?
Circle_Master Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 I would agree - that is the churches responsibility. The governments responsibility from this passage is order in the form of punishment and reward.
Richard Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 I think that we should learn to forgive and not resort to a primitive retribution response. While I agree that it is not always (or often the case), imprisonment should be abot reform and re-education of criminals to make them valuable members of society again. The failure of this is a failure of those running the system and not the system itself. I also agree that it's very easy to have a knee-jerk reaction to some crimes and say "hanging's too good for them" etc. I do this myself too! However, I believe that we should aspire to a higher reaction; forgiveness takes great strength! Part of the Church's job is to teach us this strength and humility. If through a Judge's education and religious upbringing, they can become this strong, then yes the Church can influence whether the death penalty is used or not. God bless
Sojourner Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 A couple of points: 1) Prisons/jails are not that great a place to spend any amount of time. I've never been incarcerated, but I've visited a prison and a jail, and it's no picnic in the park -- especially the kind of prison you'd be sent to if you committed a crime of the magnitude we're talking about here. 2) Speaking to an argument early in the thread about limiting the number of appeals you could get in order to cut down on the legal costs -- if I were facing the death penalty, I'd sure as hell want as many appeals as I could get, and I'm sure you would too. 3) Harsher sentences/harsher settings: Maybe, but consider the fact that our jails are already overcrowded and we're not able to afford to run them as well as we should. Harsher sentences don't serve as a deterrent, at least not from what I've seen. It's a Class A felony, punishable by 20 years, to deal cocaine of a certain weight in Indiana, but people still do it -- a lot of people. What ends up happening is you get more people in prison, at a higher cost to taxpayers. 4) The way in which we as a society treat those we don't find socially acceptable -- including criminals -- speaks volumes about us and our humanity. That's why we have "civil rights" -- a codified way in which we agree to respect one another as human beings. Just because someone has broken the law (which in this country is really nothing more than a statement of rules we all agree to live by) doesn't mean that he or she is less of a human being. I'm not advocating no punishment, but perhaps a move away from an "us" and "them" mentality. 5) There is a part of me, deep in my gut, that believes that there are crimes truly deserving death. I'm a reporter, and in the years that I've covered the court system, I've read and seen some truly horrific things. But while I think there is a lot of good in the way we administer justice in America, it is done imperfectly. If we were able to perfectly administer justice, with the confidence that every person whose life we took for a heinous crime was justly and rightly convicted of that crime, I think the case for the death penalty would be much stronger than it is. But we're not in that situation. Innocent people are accused and convicted far too often for me to be comfortable with administering the death penalty.
Norseman82 Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 The failure of this is a failure of those running the system and not the system itself. Or maybe there are some criminals that are just pure evil and unrehabilitatable???
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now