Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pre-VII & Post-VII


Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted (edited)

This shall be my generic "heresies" I'm hearing in a particular class that I need to sort out my thoughts and get feedback/other perspectives on from all the wonderful knowledgeable PMers.

But today we were told that the Second Vatican Council "embraced" what the Protestant Reformers had been pushing for. This was later, upon my request, clarified to say that "[i]not everything that was adopted by the Reformers was adopted by Vatican II[/i]"... but some specific examples of this embracing supposedly include: [i]using the vernacular, the notion of the "priesthood of the faithful," communion under both species, turning the altar to face the people, a greater sense of the many presences of God in the Eucharist (the proclamation of the Word)[/i]

And aside from the fact that "Sacrosanctum Concilium" no where states to turn the altar around, I'm not so sure that the other things (excepting the Vernacular) were ever excluded from the teachings of the Church. V2 was a pastoral Council that defined nothing new. But I need some more reference material, etc. to be better prepared and able to explain myself and the authentic teachings of the Church.

HOWEVER, the underlying hardship to all of this is that the prof is very relativistic-- "you see things your way, I see them mine"-- that make pinning down any certainties rather difficult.

Edited by Fides_et_Ratio
thessalonian
Posted (edited)

what a crock. I will try to give some input later. Ott's book which I think you have comes to mind as does the Catholic encyclopedia for some of this. The Eucharist was given under both species for a long time but I believe around trent a heresy arose in which people saw the Eucharist as two sacaraments, i.e. two Christs. The vernacular was always allowed in places that had old approved translatoins. The translation is the problem more than the language. That is what Pius V's decree indicates.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

This is very simple.

Trent condemned the doctrines of the reformers.
Vatican II re-affirmed Trent, and made its doctrines its own.
Therefore, Vatican II itself condemned the doctrines of the reformers.

The Post Concilliar Church still condemns the concept of the altar as a "table", which is the real thing the Reformers were going for not just having it face the opposite direction, and specifically says that it is preferable that the altar be made of stone and not movable.

the notion of the "priesthood of the people" is from the scriptures. Vatican II and the post-concilliar Church still hold the line that there is a fundamental and substantial difference between the minsterial priesthood and the lay priesthood, and that there is an indulable mark on the soul of the consecrated priest that is not there on the lay priest (prophet, king). This no more changed our view of priests than it did our view of kings and prophets.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

"a greater sense of the many presences of God in the Eucharist (the proclamation of the Word)"

I believe this watering down of the Real Presence was condemned at some point. Hopefully somebody else knows more.

  • 4 weeks later...
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

more fun stuff...

when trying to distinguish for a fellow classmate between Revelation and revelation (i.e. public/definitive Revelation of Jesus that ended with the death of the last Apostle, and private revelation)... the prof said that the distinction was unnecessary for the class and that we were focusing on the "act of revelation" and the process of it, rather than its contents.

however, I am hesitant to concede that the process of Revelation was/is is the same as the process of revelation. One involves the person of Jesus Christ Himself (for it is He who was revealed to us), and the other involves our understanding of the former. am I making sense?

Posted

[quote][i]using the vernacular[/quote]
This is not a Protestant invention. The vernacular was the original norm for both East and West, and has always remained the norm for the East, Catholic and Orthodox. The Eastern theology of Liturgy actually was a heavy influence on the Council Fathers, rather than Protestantism. The Eastern Church, of course, has a rich foundation in the Fathers, which was the whole purpose of the Council, to go back to the sources and rejuvenate what had come after by strengthening that foundation.

[quote]the notion of the "priesthood of the faithful,"[/quote]
As Aloysius pointed out, this is a doctrine from Scripture, and has always been part of Catholic theology. The Second Vatican Council did not "discover" this, but expanded on it. Really, it was just completing what was begun at the First Vatican Council, where the Papacy was dealt with. With Vatican II, the Fathers addressed the rest of the people of God, first the college of Bishops, then Priests (there's a whole document dedicated to Priests), and of course, the laity.

[quote]communion under both species[/quote]
This, also, is not a Protestant invention, but has always been the practice of the East, which administers communion by intinction. It was restricted in the West after Utraquists took it too far, and tried to say it was necessary to receive under both species, when in fact, it is not.

[quote]turning the altar to face the people[/quote]
Again, as you noted, this was not something that came from the Council, but post-conciliar legislation. This was more a concession to modernity than to Protestantism. It was intended to make the action at the altar more visible. It had nothing to do with devaluing the Church's firm theology of the Eucharist.

[quote]a greater sense of the many presences of God in the Eucharist (the proclamation of the Word)[/quote]
Well, the increase in Scripture readings was about a more general appreciation of Scripture that had started long before the Council, with Pope Leo XIII and subsequent Popes who devoted Encyclicals to the study of Scripture. The current form in the Roman Liturgy is actually identical to the early Church, which St. Justin Martyr tells us included readings from the Old Testament, from the Prophets and Apostles, and also from the Psalms. The many presences of God in no way devalues the unique presence of Christ in the Eucharist. Sacrosanctum Concilium is very clear on this, and on the sacrificial nature of the Mass. Rather, the purpose in pointing out God's other presences is to help us appreciate the Mass as a whole. When we listen to Scripture, we encounter God there. When we exhange the sign of peace, we encouter God in our neighbor. But all these presences are subordinate to the supreme and indescribable presence of the Eucharist, and point to it as the focal point of the mass.

I don't think it would be incorrect to say the Fathers had Protestant Christians in mind. But their decrees were hardly concessions to Protestantism. If anything, the Council's main influence was the East, from the opening up of the Liturgy to the great emphasis on episcopal communion. The Protestant reformers would be aghast at the Second Vatican Council just as they were aghast at the Council of Trent, because the same Catholic faith is presented.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...