peep Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 I'm not trying to be a troll. I'm just curious on peepzlz opinions. What happens after suicide? I was consdiering it a while ago, but God helped me get through it. I am no longer suicidal! I'm so glad to be alive!! I have become curious on what Catholics think. The Angel Walk... I read in a psychic book that you are not greeted by family at the pearly gates. Instead an angel greets you then takes you back down to earth as a ghost and shows you all the people you hurt by commiting suicide. The psychic said most peeps who commit suicide feel regretful. It sounded like a legiminment idea. Right before I was going to run away I had this dream that this angel showed me around my friends and family after I commit suicide an showed me how much they missed me. Then again I heard a Muslim say peeps who commit suicide go to hell. My pastor told me God is a loving god and would never hurt nobody.
franciscanheart Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 it's amazing to me how many people do not commit suicide after having visions of their family or friends - either the pain they feel in their day to day lives, the pain of the funeral or memorial, or the actual finding of the body.
Lil Red Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 i honestly don't know what happens to them. i'd like to believe (especially if the person is suffering from a mental illness) that they go to heaven, but i truly don't know.
Noel's angel Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 (edited) I'd like to see the person who voted to condemn them to Hell give a reason for their answer. I'm not going to vote on the poll because it doesn't contain the answer I would give. I don't know. Only God knows. We don't know what is going on in other peoples' heads or hearts. I say, leave the judging to God. Edited August 30, 2006 by Noel's angel
homeschoolmom Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 Whatever the person believes??? Interesting option.
brendan1104 Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 If they are sane, and know what they are doing then they would go to hell. If they're mentally ill, and don't know/partially know what they are doing then only God knows.
ardillacid Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 It is a mortal sin to commit suicide. You beaver dam yourself to hell unless you do not have control of your faculties
Ash Wednesday Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 You left out a very important option in that vote that I would have selected: "God only knows." And that goes not just for someone who has committed suicide, but anyone living or dead for that matter. We certainly have our hopes and fears about the state of someone's soul, but in the end, God only knows. P.S. I am glad that you aren't feeling suicidal. In Catholic teaching, suicide is a grave mortal sin, and yes they do risk the pains of hell BUT it is also stated in Catholic teaching that only God can judge a person's soul and certain factors would be taken into account which might lessen the culpability of the sin, so nobody but God can say for sure where their soul goes after they die for sure, but that [b]we still must pray for their soul and all souls of the dead.[/b]To commit suicide is not only an act of ultimate self-harm and grieves God deeply, it also affects so many loved ones around you -- and even people in ways we may not know. Here is a link that discusses this: [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/ANSWERS/SUICIDE.htm"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/ANSWERS/SUICIDE.htm[/url]
fearundercontrol Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 (edited) Ash Wednesday--Thank you for your response. It was very informative and gave the whole picture. Glad someone posted that! Edited August 30, 2006 by fearundercontrol
CrossCuT Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 [size=1]I think the poll is kinda rediculouse just because as Catholics we do not believe you can judge another persons soul. But of course according to what we KNOW of suicide the obviouse punishment is Hell. But what we CANT tell, however, is whether or not the person is doomed to that fate. We have no way of knowing that seconds before they died (Ex. they jumped off a building) they regretted their decision and asked for forgivness. Maybe this person had a very horrible mental problem that they no longer had real controle over what they thought or did. We dont know that God has mercy on us etc and wont judge us on this we cant controle. So I dont think there is any for sure way of knowing WHERE we go after we die. Of course we know the places we can go...but which one we cant tell 100% all the time. [/size]
Era Might Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 I know exactly what happens after you commit suicide: you get judged. Since I'm not the judge, I won't presume to speak for him.
homeschoolmom Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 No one else wants to know what "The Angel Walk" is?
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 [quote]Q. 1274. What sin is it to destroy one's own life, or commit suicide, as this act is called? A. It is a mortal sin to destroy one's own life or commit suicide, as this act is called, and persons who willfully and knowingly commit such an act die in a state of mortal sin and are deprived of Christian burial. It is also wrong to expose one's self unnecessarily to the danger of death by rash or foolhardy feats of daring.[/quote] i voted hell, only because the action is a mortal sin. but yes as Catholics we can not say "so and So is in hell".
franciscanheart Posted August 30, 2006 Posted August 30, 2006 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1053854' date='Aug 30 2006, 07:35 PM'] No one else wants to know what "The Angel Walk" is? [/quote] We've already been told. [quote name='peep' post='1053663' date='Aug 30 2006, 02:08 PM'] I'm not trying to be a troll. I'm just curious on peepzlz opinions. What happens after suicide? I was consdiering it a while ago, but God helped me get through it. I am no longer suicidal! I'm so glad to be alive!! I have become curious on what Catholics think. [b]The Angel Walk... I read in a psychic book that you are not greeted by family at the pearly gates. Instead an angel greets you then takes you back down to earth as a ghost and shows you all the people you hurt by commiting suicide. The psychic said most peeps who commit suicide feel regretful. It sounded like a legiminment idea. Right before I was going to run away I had this dream that this angel showed me around my friends and family after I commit suicide an showed me how much they missed me. [/b] Then again I heard a Muslim say peeps who commit suicide go to hell. My pastor told me God is a loving god and would never hurt nobody. [/quote](emphasis mine)
peep Posted August 31, 2006 Author Posted August 31, 2006 yeah, I never considered how much it would hurt God's feelings and it would displease the King Jesus Christ. He'd be so sad! I am partially mentally ill, battling psychosis. Sometimes I get really crazy and am likely to kill myself. But the last time I truly wanted to die I had severe depression. God is all knowing, and my counciler said He understands that depression is a disease, and he knows how truly unbearable it is. But he wants us to turn to Him, and ask for help. Thats what I did, the night before I wanted to die I went to Mary's statue and cried my heart out infront of her. I thought she hated me. I screamed "Why! Why! Why don't you help me???" I was spared at the last moment by my counciler and brought into a psychiatric hospital. It was only sometimes feeling like I was religious sometimes. I asked God to help me, and even though I wasn't really into religion after that...I do believe God has helped me to recover. He still loves me even though he didn't talk to me. The bible does say he'll be with me always. Sometimes I wonder why he gave me such a screwed up mind...and why he won't physically come down and give it some cranking, but I'm not paying attention to all the things he has blessed me with. Praise be to God in the highest!!
Mercy me Posted August 31, 2006 Posted August 31, 2006 I am with Ash and Era. I do not pretend to know how God will judge. What I do know is that He has given us a huge gift in the life that we are given. His will and actions never cease to surprise me. I wouldn't dare guess. Peep I am so glad that you are no longer considering suicide. This life that we are given is an ever changing adventure. He is with us always. Speaking for myself, I do not always see Him all the time. However, as I look back at incidents in my life I can clearly see how he has guided me. At mass we sometimes sing a Psalm that has a line "When I am in trouble and all I see is me, be with me Lord." That little prayer in that Psalm has helped me to realize that I am not alone in not sensing His presence in a time of need. Even the great psalmist understood how I feel. Perhaps it might help you.
Socrates Posted August 31, 2006 Posted August 31, 2006 (edited) Church teaching has always been that suicide is objectively a mortal sin, like murder. If one dies unrepentant in mortal sin, he goes to hell. However, she also teaches that only God can know with certainty the state of another's immortal soul after death. Factors such as severe mental illness can lessen one's culpability, and God may perhaps offer a chance at repentence right before death, but we cannot know this. However, it's best not to try to find out! Edited August 31, 2006 by Socrates
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now